Lucy in the Sky with a Stuck Solar Panel

Tech Boss
138 followers
7 Video Views·Dec 7, 2022
NASA's Lucy spacecraft is on its way to explore the Trojan asteroids after launching from Cape
Canaveral on October 16. The Trojan asteroids are thought to be an undisturbed population
of fossils left over from the formation of our solar system. That's why the Lucy spacecraft
was named after the famed hominid fossil discovered in Ethiopia in 1974. Just as Lucy
the fossil advanced our understanding of human evolution, Lucy the spacecraft aims to advance
our understanding of the solar system's evolution. To that end, Lucy will fly past seven of the
Trojan asteroids, which are trapped in Jupiter's Lagrange points. Along its way out to the Trojans,
Lucy will pass a small asteroid in the main belt between Mars and Jupiter. That makes for a
more than any spacecraft has attempted before. At least, that's the plan. But shortly after it
separated from its rocket on October 16, one of Lucy's two solar arrays failed to deploy
and latch into place. The arrays are designed to unfurl like a pair of Chinese fans.
Controllers got a confirmation signal that the first array fully deployed and latched,
but they never received a similar confirmation about the second array.
NASA said in a statement that it looks like the second array only partially unfurled,
but it's otherwise generating almost as much power as the fully deployed wing.
So the good news is that the spacecraft is safe and it's getting all the power it needs
for the moment. Because Lucy is drifting further away from Earth each day,
it needs to be able to autonomously point its solar arrays toward the Sun.
So the spacecraft was transitioned from its initial safe mode into its cruise mode.
But Lucy will need to fire its main engine several more times over the course of its mission
in order to stay on a very complex flight path. So naturally, the mission team would like to get
that array fully deployed and locked before Lucy begins any of its main maneuvers.
At this point, you might be wondering, well, why didn't they just use a radioisotope
thermoelectric generator like they did for the Cassini mission at Saturn and New Horizons at
Pluto? Well, the Lucy mission was originally conceived as being powered by RTGs. But RTGs
are dangerous, and NASA would rather not take a chance on a rocket exploding in the atmosphere
and scattering toxic plutonium everywhere if they could avoid it. Fortunately, solar panel
technology has come a long way. Juno demonstrated that a solar powered spacecraft can operate as
far as Jupiter's orbit. As for Lucy, chances are they'll command it to redeploy its second wing
and see if it latches into place. Right now though, mission controllers are still analyzing
the telemetry to verify that they fully understand just exactly what the problem is before they take
any further action. So while they're figuring that out, I thought we'd take a closer look at
the Lucy mission, learn about the Trojan asteroids, and understand how this solar array problem may or
may not impact the mission. But first, I'd like to thank Magellan TV, who are very kindly sponsoring
today's video. We are at the forefront of a modern day gold rush, and asteroids could hold the key
for private companies to launch into deep space. Asteroids, A New Horizon is a two-part documentary
that dives into the science and engineering behind the companies who are leading that race.
It's one of many documentaries available on Magellan TV, which features more than 3,000 titles
on history, nature, science, and technology. New documentaries are added every week. Best of all,
Magellan are offering my viewers a full month of their award-winning content absolutely free.
Please make sure to use the link in the description of this video. Our solar system is
Most of them orbit the Sun in the main belt between Mars and Jupiter. We started to explore
some of these asteroids up close in 1991 when the Galileo spacecraft flew past two of them
on its way to Jupiter. Since then, spacecraft have visited 15 other asteroids and comets in the main
belt. Among them are JAXA's Hayabusa 2 mission to Ryugu and NASA's OSIRIS-REx mission to Bennu.
Both of these missions are bringing samples back to Earth. But no mission has ever explored the
Trojan asteroids. These are two giant swarms that are clustered around Jupiter's L4 and L5
Lagrange points. Lagrangian points are the gravitational balance points that exist between
any two large bodies, like the Sun and a planet. So if a small body, such as an asteroid, were
placed at any of these points, the gravitational forces between the two larger bodies will cancel
each other in a way that fixes the body into the same relative position as the system orbits.
These points are labeled L1 through L5. You might be wondering, if Jupiter has five Lagrange points,
why are the Trojans only found at two of them? Well, it turns out that the first three Lagrange
points are very unstable. If an asteroid were placed there, it would quickly fall out of place
unless it were perfectly positioned at the Lagrange point. It's like trying to get a marble
to sit precisely on top of a saddle without rolling off. By contrast, the L4 and L5 points
are more like the gravitational equivalent of large hilltops on the edge of a giant merry-go-round.
If an asteroid starts to wander out of this region, the Coriolis force comes into play
and effectively pushes the asteroid back into a stable orbit. The practical upshot is that the
Trojans orbit around these two Lagrange points. But how did the Trojans get there in the first
place? Well, it turns out their colors offer a clue. Trojans range in color from gray to red.
Gray Trojans are similar in color to the Centaur asteroids that orbit between Jupiter and Neptune,
while the red Trojans resemble those of distant objects in the Kuiper belt.
So, it's widely thought that these asteroids initially formed in different regions of the
outer solar system. After the giant planets formed, they migrated and scattered the asteroids in
pretty much every direction. Some of them got caught in Jupiter's L4 and L5 points and have
been stuck there ever since. That's the prevailing hypothesis, but in order to know for sure,
we need to explore the Trojans up close. That's why Lucy will visit several different Trojans
and compare them to each other. But to reach the Trojans, Lucy must embark on the craziest
trajectory of any spacecraft in history. Lucy launched on October 16 into an orbit that more
or less follows Earth's. A year from now, it will approach Earth to get a gravity assist,
followed by a second one in December 2024. These maneuvers will propel Lucy toward Jupiter's orbit.
Along the way, Lucy will pass by the main belt asteroid Donald Johanson in April 2025.
This asteroid is fittingly named after the anthropologist who discovered the Lucy fossil
in 1974. This initial flyby will serve as a kind of dress rehearsal for the Trojan encounters.
Lucy will enter the leading group of Trojans a couple of years later in the summer of 2027.
It will first fly past Eurobates and its satellite Queda. Eurobates is thought to be
the largest surviving chunk of a massive collision several million years ago. It's also a C-type or
carbonaceous asteroid. C-type asteroids are the most common type of asteroid in the main belt,
but they're relatively rare among Trojans. So naturally that raises the question,
how did a C-type asteroid like Eurobates end up getting mixed up with the Trojans?
About a month later, in September 2027, Lucy flies past its second target, asteroid Polymeli.
This is one of the smaller targets, so they'll have to take as many pictures as quickly as
possible. Then it's on to another small asteroid, Lacutius, for another photo frenzy,
and then about seven months later, its final L4 flyby of asteroid Orus.
Now by this time, Lucy is falling back into the inner solar system.
In December 2030, it encounters Earth for its third and final gravity assist. This sends Lucy
back to Jupiter's orbit, but this time into the L5 swarm for its final encounter. In March 2033,
Lucy will pass a large binary pair of asteroids called Petroclus and Minotius. These are two
asteroids of similar size orbiting a common barycenter. Now that's particularly interesting,
because binary asteroids in the main belt are rare. The closest you'll typically find is a
relatively large asteroid with a tiny companion satellite. But large binary asteroids are quite
common in the outer Kuiper belt, so it's possible that the Petroclus binary formed in the Kuiper
belt and got flung into Jupiter's orbit. Now to visit these asteroids, Lucy takes a trajectory
that's unlike anything we've ever seen before. To see what I mean, take a look at this comparison.
We're hovering over the Sun and letting everything orbit. Lucy's trajectory seems
relatively straightforward, doesn't it? But let's take a look at it from Jupiter's frame of
reference. Here we're rotating the camera to keep Jupiter and the Trojans in the same position of
the frame. In this view, the complexity of Lucy's trajectory becomes apparent as it visits one swarm
of asteroids, and then the other. In this perspective, it's as if Lucy is flying an
figure 8 pattern as it crisscrosses the solar system. The trajectory is at once complex and
elegant. The thing about the Trojans is that their orbits are very highly inclined to the
ecliptic plane. So the fact that Lucy can intercept so many of them by being at just the right place
at just the right time is amazing. And you might be wondering, if Lucy is going to be in Jupiter's
L4 swarm, why not use the giant planet itself as a gravity assist instead of Earth? Well,
the fact is that illustrations like these fail to capture just how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly
big space is. The reality is that the closest Lucy will ever get to Jupiter is right after
its first gravity assist at Earth. During its flybys, Lucy is traveling fast, between 6 and 9
kilometers a second. Despite taking 12 years to complete its mission, the total amount of time
Lucy will spend collecting flyby data amounts to less than one day. So each encounter will
have to be carefully planned to ensure it gets the maximum amount of science every time. That's
why Lucy is packing a suite of proven instruments that have been adapted from other missions.
L-Ralph is actually two instruments in one. Its MVIC color camera and LISA spectrometer will pick
up the subtle color variations in the visible and near-infrared parts of the spectrum. And that will
indicate where things like water and carbon compounds are concentrated on the asteroid
surfaces. L-LORRI is Lucy's main telescope that takes high-resolution black and white images.
It'll be used to count up the number of small versus large craters on the asteroid surfaces,
and that reveals the history of impacts. It'll also be used to carry out a search for satellites
and possibly even ring systems that are too close to be seen with any ground-based telescope.
These two are based on the Ralph and LORRI instruments that New Horizons used during
its flybys of Pluto and Arrokoth. L-TESS is Lucy's third science instrument. It measures
the infrared radiation coming off the asteroids. In particular, L-TESS will compare the heat coming
off both the sunlit and the shadowed parts of the asteroid's surface. The difference in
temperature between these regions will indicate how dense or fluffy the surface material is.
L-TESS is a direct copy of the O-TESS instrument used on OSIRIS-REx,
which used it to map the temperature of asteroid Bennu. In addition to these three science
instruments, Lucy makes use of two of its own spacecraft subsystems to gather science data as
well. The terminal tracking cameras are normally used for navigation, but they'll also take images
of the asteroids during the flybys. Lucy's high gain antenna is normally used for communication,
but during the flybys, the asteroid's gravity will exert very subtle accelerations on the spacecraft.
Those accelerations will change Lucy's velocity by just a few millimeters per second. That'll
introduce a very subtle Doppler shift into the antenna's signal. Those Doppler shifts will be
analyzed and allow the science team to directly measure the density and mass of the asteroids.
Well that's the plan at least. Right now though, they need to figure out what the nature of the
solar panel problem really is and what impact, if any, it'll have on the mission. This design has
been used on spacecraft like the Cygnus cargo ships that visit the International Space Station
and on Mars landers such as Phoenix and InSight. But because Lucy is going to the Trojan asteroids,
it'll become the most distant solar powered mission ever flown. That's why its panels are
each 7.3 meters in diameter. Near Earth, they generate something like 18 kilowatts of power,
but at its farthest distance, their power output will fall to just 500 watts. Believe it or not,
that's actually more power than the spacecraft will need at that point. The panels were designed
to be bigger than required in order to withstand small micrometeorite impacts and still provide
enough power to the spacecraft. It's likely that even if the second panel cannot be fully opened,
there will still be enough power generated to fly the mission more or less planned. If not,
then NASA will just do what it's always done. They'll figure out a workaround.
Remember the Galileo mission we talked about earlier? It was supposed to open a 4.8 meter
high gain antenna like a gigantic umbrella. The antenna would have transmitted at 134,000
bits per second. That's very high bandwidth coming all the way from Jupiter. However,
some of the ribs of the umbrella jammed. Despite all attempts at freeing it, the high gain antenna
simply wouldn't open. Rather than give up, the entire mission was redesigned mid-flight to use
Galileo's low gain antenna. The mission went on to become a huge success, transmitting the highest
resolution images of Jupiter's moons at a rate of just 10 bits per second. Lucy's solar panel
problem isn't great news, but there's a solution and NASA will find it. By the way, Lucy's namesake
fossil was named after the song Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds that was written by the Beatles,
and then vastly improved upon by William Shatner. It turns out that Lucy's LTS instrument uses a
beam splitter made of manufactured diamond. Coincidence? Yeah, it is, but a really good one,
so we'll take it. A big thanks to my patrons for supporting Launch Pad Astronomy, and I'd like to
welcome John Rockefeller and Rudy Yazzie as my newest sponsors. If you'd like to follow me on
this journey through this incredible universe of ours, well please make sure you subscribe and
ring that notification bell so that you don't miss out on any new videos. Until next time, stay curious my friend.
