Lecture 45-Short Story and Novel II

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 10, 2025
Good morning and welcome back to the lecture series. We are discussing the short story and
novel, a comparative understanding of these two genres.
So, we will begin with Rust Hills and his understanding of the key features of a short
story. According to Rust Hills, the short story tells us about something that happened to someone
which makes it different from the sketch. So, we have to understand that we also have a
very similar form to short story which is the sketch. However, short story and the sketch
unlike what many readers fathom are not quite the same.
So, the sketch comprises the description of a character. The described character remains
constant throughout the sketch. So, the description is meant to illustrate rather than
develop a character in a sketch. So, a sketch in other words is an example of a character's
behavior and not an account of incidents that move or alter the character's position.
In a short story, the plot is moving. It is not static. It is a dynamic plot and the characters
are moved from their original position, from the way they are, the way they think from the
beginning to the end, a journey albeit a short one has taken place. So, the character on whom
the story leaves consequences is the moved character. At the end of the narration, his or
her position will shift emotionally, socially or in any other way. So, more than most of other forms,
a short story maintains a harmonious relationship of all its aspects.
And this however, is not a characteristic of a good novel. A good novel is expected to function
based on minimal description and leave a lot of open ends to be filled up, to be imagined
and recreated through the reader's creativity, creative reading.
And then while the development of character in short story is similar to the novel, we see that
the novel has time and space for a number of effects, artistic effects, let us say through
subplots and so the novel can experiment with stylistic devices and narrative style.
This entire scope of becoming, of developing is not available in the case of the short story.
So, the short story is driven by an inherent paradoxical situation to restrict
itself to limited dimensions of time that the genre entails and yet to convey
an atemporal theme through the plot, a theme that transcends the bounds of time and temporality.
I would quickly before proceeding go through the basic premises that
Rust-Hills proposes as key features of the short story. One is that unlike the sketch,
the short story also looks at the development of a character, the characters are moving
through the plot. It is not only the description, a static description that
the sketch is all about and then the harmonious relationship of all aspects where
the whole emerges even before the parts. Then Hill also talks about the greatest scope of
playing with the stylistic devices that the novel has, which the short story lacks.
The short story writer does not elaborate or rather cannot elaborate the secondary characters
and does not mess too much with the subplots because messing too much would mean he or she
cannot restore these subplots or the secondary characters within the limited time and space.
Due to the same reason, the short story does not have too much scope to play around with
perspectives. Usually, there is a single point of view to retain focus on the plot.
Short stories usually focus on one problem only, that is the maximum one can resolve within the
bounds of the short story, getting into the heart of one problem and trying to deal with that.
In terms of language, multiple use of sounds and words make the short story comparable with
lyric poetry. So, like in T.S. Eliot and Ezra Pound's poetry, there are intricate systems of
poetic metaphor and imageries drawn from fable, myth and fairy tales, which inform the short
story. And these poetic metaphors and influences from folk tales, from ballads, myths, to the
extent that some of the short stories can actually be read as an extended poem.
A language of a short story apart from fulfilling the need of narration, also promptly connects with
the theme, mood and actions. So, all of these aspects need to be bound together.
The theme of the short story, its mood, its actions and language becomes vital in setting up
the author's tone and style, which in turn contributes to the characterisation
and the point of view of the short story. In a typical successful short story,
all the different aspects, the tonality, the actions, the theme, the characters,
all of them should work in tandem and each feature, each aspect should enhance and interrelate
with the other feature. Short story should reflect an inseparable and synchronised composed
economy thereby. So, Clare Hansen notes that short story as a form mediates between the lyric
and the novel. It has in parts qualities, features of the lyric and then that of the novel too.
And yet, through experimentation, one also sees that short story is coming up with new genres,
new possibilities, new avatars, if we may. That is when short stories are created through
interacting with essay, with letter, cinema, photography, painting and visual arts.
Critics note that short story has split allegiance to the narrative and the lyric.
The short story to progress, there has to be disruption from the regular familiar everyday
encounters and so, there has to be a break away from the routine, from the pre-meditated
kind of pre-programmed actions, fixed actions. The extraordinary, the oddity, the paranormal,
all these traits constitute the plot, the torque for the short story. The shock, the jolt make up
the propelling force for the short story. While the fixed action enhances characterisation,
an incident that leads to a break away from fixed action introduces the potential plot
for the short story. The disruption from the normal, the routine, the everyday elicits
actions from the characters, something that is one-off, that is spontaneous and non-repetitive,
non-regular, an action that is unfamiliar thereby, which drives the plot forward.
So, fixed actions are a preliminary part, it sets the stage for the short story,
the background of the short story, even before the short story has begun. If it is a story,
once it enters within the premise of the story, it has to cut off from the mundane. If we can
understand how a narrative happens through the lens of different structuralist thinkers.
So, for example, Algirdas, Julian Rimas notes that the perception of oppositions,
of any form of conflict followed by resolution or sometimes not followed by resolution,
underlies the structure of any signification, any meaning that a narrative tries to posit,
tries to hold. Meaning in a narrative takes shape through the reader's perception of these
conflicts, these differences. And so, the structure, Rimas is talking about
something that he terms as the enunciation spectacle, the structure of the enunciation
spectacle, which is the fundamental structure of language or grammar and this remains the same
for all the stories, for any form of narration. The manifestation, the performance of this
enunciation spectacle changes depending on the actants or the different themes
embodying and performing it. This is very similar to Lange's relation with Perrault,
where all stories are springing from the same grammar, just like Perrault's are individual
dialects, individual performance of the self-same Lange. Here, we see that enunciation spectacle
is like the common repository and the different actants and themes, the stock characters,
it could be a motive that keeps coming back, a motive that manifests through different characters
and it is the individual performance of the enunciation spectacle, which still remains the
same for all types of narrations across time and space. This is what Rimas has to say.
Similarly, Tiservet and Todorov points out that any narrative comprises a series of
propositions or events that holds true regardless of whether we are talking about
the epic, the novel, the short story, this holds true both of what Rimas and Todorov say hold
true for all the genres. So, Todorov talks about propositions or events
that could be related to each other in terms of time, so temporarily, spatially or logically.
And then how is one proposition made? Each proposition is a combination of a noun,
meaning a character with either an adjective or a verb. So, the character has a certain attribute
or the character does something, an action of the character. This is what constitutes an event
and a series of such events centering time, space or causality makes up
any narration. This is what Tiservet and Todorov has to say.
According to John Gerlach, there can be a number of narrative clausural categories for short
stories. One of the ways of closing a short story could be through solution of central problem,
which is the most common way of concluding. And this trait of tying the loose end is a typical
and unique to short story that does not always happen in novels. In novels, like I have already
said, there can be certain open ends, certain problems that are not resolved till the end.
So, going back to Gerlach's different clausural categories, the first one,
solution of the central problem, either a goal is achieved or if unachievable,
a certain completion, coherence or stability is attained towards the end.
Next, Gerlach talks about the second possibility of closure, which is natural termination of the
story, meaning that completion of an action takes place with a predictable end. Next is completion
of antithesis. So, the story ends with an opposition often characterized by irony,
which may indicate polarized extremities on a given subject or circularity by returning
to an aspect mentioned at the beginning through verbal or situational echo.
So, the entire story tries to posit a thesis, tries to
shape a thesis and the end is an opposition. It is a subversion of that entire thesis.
So, the story is formed through polarized extremities on a given subject where the
subject was being dealt with from a certain angle till a different angle was adopted in the end.
Or there could be a circularity where the narrator or the author returns to the
self-same aspect that was mentioned at the very beginning or through verbal or situational echo.
Then we have manifestation of a moral. This is another possibility of closing the short story
through manifestation of a moral. It draws on the genre of parable where an example is set
at the end, a lesson is taught, it has didactic purpose. A theme emerges towards the end
whose effect is similar to the moral in the exemplum tradition.
And Gerlach is talking about one more possibility for ending the short story,
which is through encapsulation. Encapsulation meaning that the story has a concluding passage
that distances the reader either by altering the point of view or through summarizing a passage
of time. So, some time has elapsed since the whole problem of the plot occurred.
And through this summarizing or through telling us in the end that some time has elapsed,
there is a kind of relief which enables the reader to distance herself from the core plot.
These closureal strategies can also be applied. These closureal signals or strategies can also be
applied. They can also occur in poems, in novels and in drama.
So, as a shorter fiction closure of a short story is structurally very important to it.
In approaching a character from the position of a short story writer,
one can treat the character either as an individual or as a subject.
So, there can be two ways of looking at the characters of a given short story. One could
look at them as an individual in their individual capacity through their ordinary acts or as a
what they stand for. There is a larger meaning associated with them and where their ordinary
acts become less important and overriding meaning is something that means to,
that informs the short story. So, the realistic approach, the individual approach looks at a
short story in the context of its similarity with the real world. This is like I said,
the realistic approach. And then the other approach, which is also
something I have mentioned just now, it is to treat the structure of the story plot as a scheme
or a code, story as a code that needs to be decoded, that needs to be deciphered. And here
the characters are not in their individual capacities, but as archetypes. And they are
by virtue of the position that they hold in the larger schema. This reading is called the
allegorical or metaphorical approach. Peter Brooks, however, says that the metaphor
that lies in eventual totalisation and which is understood only in retrospect,
draws meaning from as well as lends meaning to the realist sequence of events.
So, in other words, the metaphoric and the realistic aspects reflect on one another.
We begin our readings generally through the realistic approach, where characters are
individual. Still we have journeyed to a certain point in the story and we realise that the
characters represent and stand for some larger concepts. And that goes also, the realistic
reading goes on to become a metaphorical reading. Once we start deciphering this code, this scheme
through our journey with the narrator. And this second style of reading, this second
mode of reading or analysis generally comes in hindsight, in retrospect.
Owing to its shortness of form, short story lacks a social framework and it draws greatly
on its provenance in myth and focuses on a basic sense of mystery. Mystery, paranormal,
desire, odd and extraordinary. According to Robert Langbaum, the author's endless
introspection of who am I, this is also introspection, an existential question that
plods the novelist. And this question, the short story writer's question of who am I,
is answered through the author donning a mask and stepping into the story,
within the frame of the story. Where at the level of experience, events
eventually fall into a pattern and the author's will in the due course is unravelled and
objectified. So, in other words, through the making of the story, the author is answering
to this existential question of who I am, maybe God as one of the characters, the author's will
is eventually revealed. So, the question of epiphany, the revelation,
the realisation, the realisation of the characters within the bounds, within the frame of the story
is not only a fictional realisation, it could also be the author's realisation in her real life.
Through the necessity of the story, the author discovers his or her identity and what he or she
aspires for, something that has hitherto remained besides the conscious state of mind. The practice
of writing, it is therapeutic and it is a way of disinterring the unconscious, the unconscious
desire and aspirations of the writer. So, in this schematic, conventionalised
structure of short story, the character becomes an automated like figure who serves his or her
place in the larger schema. This is the conventional structure of short story.
The allegorical character having a code bound nature is driven by a given central obsession.
The only way to approach an allegorical character is through referencing to its position
in and as a pre-existing code. So, unless we read the character, some of the stories entail
this reading where individual reading does not make too much of meaning, does not make
a lot of sense unless we read the characters as symbols, as standing for something else,
a larger concept, for example. So, characters as code, the story as a scheme and such characters,
such plots defy realistic analysis. When realistically analysed, the obsession of
the character is explored without. So, when we are doing the realistic analysis, we are
studying the characters from or on the outside. Whereas, allegorical characters analysis
entail looking at their inner journey, their inner universe.
When these allegorical narratives are written, the source of obsession is positioned inside
of the character psyche. So, the possibility of this obsession lies within and cannot be
identified through the external behaviour. Example is Edgar Allan Poe's writing. So,
Poe's focus is on the perverse neurotic side of the human nature.
His characters are mostly obsessive, compulsive, they have their own psychosis, their own quirks
and this behaviour that they posit, that they betray is beyond any common sense, any reason,
rationality and can even flout their own best interests, the best interests of their own
survival. Such mysterious obsessive characters that can be best read through the allegorical
lens of reading are found in Nathaniel Hawthorne's Wakefield, Young Goodman Brown,
and then Melville's Bartleby of course, Courtesan's Axolotl and so forth.
Such an allegorical character, as I mentioned, flows out of social, historical and cultural
contexts. They cannot be contained within the parameters of real coordinates, cannot hold them
amply, sufficiently. They constantly flow out of the social, historical and cultural contexts.
Rather than a character that is obsessed, in these cases, they are themselves an epitome of
obsession. They are not a character obsessed, but an epitome of obsession.
In a short story, the different components are tied to each other through an inseparable web,
in which one component has no reality when decoupled from the entirety, the entire
organization. The reader can grasp comprehensively only when understanding this
organized whole, this entirety. So, unity of effect, techniques of plot compression,
lyricism are some of the defining features of short stories.
So, according to Thomas Galison, the unity of effect that Hawthorne emphasizes
comes from two things. According to Galison, these two things are distillation and telescoping.
So, what are these things that render the unity to the short story? Distillation refers to the
reader's skill of reading the metaphorical and archetypal meanings, but distillation also means
steering clear of unnecessary details, too many subplots that cannot be justified within the
frame of a short story. So, a distilled short story shows the design, shows the pattern
in a clearer, in a more distinct fashion. And then telescoping, telescoping referring to
focusing on where focus needs to be, the necessary details.
So, these two features actually speak to each other. Only when we are distilling,
we are getting rid of the extraneous, unnecessary information that can remain undiscussed,
that can be avoided, one arrives at telescoping, at focusing at the right spot of the story.
The story has slots where various elements may be inserted. These slots and elements
maintain a perceivable coherence in their interrelationships.
So, a successful story, to conclude this entire discussion, we can summarize that a successful
story is complete, such that any addition or omission would destroy its aesthetic wholeness,
its inner organization and thereby its narrative harmony. Due to fewer narrative elements and
structural plots, in the modern short story, the impressionist components are more visible.
So, this is also something that hearkens back Kundera's notion of the apodictic message.
The message, you know, are a glimpse of the soul of the heart of the short story at once.
So, that is the impression that is formed at once, not by and by, not through and through,
eventually, but it is there and there throughout. So, the apodictic message,
and this happens through brevity, a practice of restraining oneself as an author,
in the position of author, from giving too much description, from bringing in too many characters
and subplots. So, that tends to blur our vision, take us away from the apodictic
message, the pit, the core of the narrative. So, in order for that to be there at once,
the narrative has to be paired off, there has to be a minimal treatment.
Impressionist movement, as we know, is a tradition whose forerunner was Flaubert himself,
and defined fiction in the late 19th century and early 20th century. We are talking about
the way we see an impression as a complete form in itself and there at once. This is also something
that is understood as desirable in the modern short story.
As Cassirel describes the short story's singleness of effect as, I quote Cassirel,
the isolated occurrence of an impression is separation from the totality of ordinary
commonplace experience, producing not only a tremendous intensification, but also the highest
degree of condensation. Here also we are getting two words, one is intensification and the other
is condensation, they speak to each other. And so, how strongly we can drive home the
central message, that is possible only when we get rid of the extraneous, something
that can be gotten rid of. So, the short story does not take up
any extra burden that it cannot justify, that it cannot do justice with. With this, I am going to
conclude today's lecture and let us meet again with another round of discussions
in our following lectures. Thank you.
