*Affiliate Links Generate Revenue for the Channel*
Disclaimer: This video is not intended to provide diagnosis, treatment, or medical advice. Content provided in this video is for educational purposes only. Please consult with a physician regarding any health-related diagnosis or treatment. Video is not sponsored but the Doctorly team does consult for Qure on product development on occasion.
00:00 Intro 00:45 Dr. Shah's Personal Story 02:40 The Science 06:35 How to Treat Harsh Water 07:42 Water Filter from QURE 09:06 Tip #2: Use a Dedicated Face Towel 10:00 Tip #3: Travel With Your Own Pillowcase 10:32 Conclusion
What's up everyone, we're back.
I'm Dr. Shah, Dr. Maxfield,
and welcome back to our channel, Dr. Lee,
where we talk about all things skincare and dermatology.
Today might be one of the most important videos
we've ever done.
And you think he's kidding, but he is not.
I don't think I have ever heard him be so worked up
about a skincare topic to date, not even a frame.
So I've been thinking about this day and night,
and every time I wash my skin, I think about this concept,
and I just can't seem to let it go.
My goal is to convince Dr. Maxfield
that my hypothesis is true,
and I'm gonna convince all of you in this video.
The question is, is water ruining your skin?
Here we go.
I think with this story,
we have to start at the genesis point.
Throughout my entire life, my skin did pretty good.
Wasn't too irritated, would never get overabundantly dry.
Kind of like combo, maybe a little bit on the dry side.
All was good.
I was living in Wilmington.
Skin was great, tremendous, glowing.
Some may say, okay?
Some people say.
Then I go to Kentucky.
All is good.
Skin is good.
Wash my hair, my skin, all is good.
Move to Charlotte.
And every week that I would go to Charlotte,
my skin would get really irritated,
especially after I cleansed.
And it would just burn, and it was dry,
and it was more irritated than ever before.
And even my hair wouldn't cooperate.
So I started to become convinced with this idea
that the water that I was being exposed to,
that I was washing my face with twice a day,
was actually making my skin worse.
Because nothing in my skincare routine had changed.
And so I started to do a deep dive
on whether or not water has actually been studied
to affect the quality of the skin.
Okay, so I'm getting this from all angles.
Dr. Schott is not the only one bringing this up to me.
And it actually goes both ways.
We have a huge amount of people moving to this area
where I live.
Even the small towns and surrounding areas,
tons of people coming in.
I hear multiple times a day.
To the point where I'm kind of annoyed
that the water here sucks.
People tell me in the context of their skin.
They move here, they're showering,
their skin has never broken out before.
They are just having to break out
because the quality of their skin isn't doing well.
And I can relate to this to some extent with hair.
Maybe my skin's a little more resilient, who knows.
But I do notice when I go on vacation somewhere,
your hair reacts differently.
Like it doesn't have the same volume,
it doesn't have the same this, it doesn't have that.
I am 100% convinced water contributes to that.
So now Dr. Schott is going to build the case
for how water affects your skin.
Right.
To double down on this,
I even started to carry my own shampoos,
my own body washes, everything with me.
So that I could have the same routine across the board.
To prove that Charlotte was the problem,
that this was causing my skin issues.
So I do this deep dive.
I start combing through all the papers
and it turns out that there's actually
an overwhelming amount of data
on the fact that the water hardness specifically
could affect your skin.
So there was really two hypotheses.
One, people thought that it was the water hardness.
So specifically looking at different minerals
like calcium carbonate and magnesium affecting the skin
and then chlorine affecting the skin.
So a lot of people pointed to chlorine being the problem.
So when we look at these studies
and they've looked at population-based cohort studies.
So you're talking about entire populations.
They looked at a Danish database.
They've looked at a British database
and they've shown that in areas
where the water has increased hardness,
increased specifically of calcium carbonate,
that there's higher incidences of atopic dermatitis
or eczema and sensitive skin.
So to look at this a little bit further,
they also looked at chlorine
and what they actually found interestingly
was that chlorine didn't nearly have as much of an effect.
And so what they found in all these studies
across the board was that
if you had high levels of calcium carbonate,
that it increased transepidermal water loss,
so increased dryness of the skin,
it increased irritation of the skin
and it also increased the risk of developing eczema
and atopic dermatitis in populations
where the water hardness was increased.
What they also found was that chlorine
didn't have nearly as much of an effect on the skin.
And this makes sense because so for anytime I hear data,
new data, old data, just someone talking to me
as I'm walking down the road,
it goes through a filter.
And in this filter, right now, he's got me at,
if something damaged, let's just say
if anything damaged your skin barrier early on in life,
which I completely agree,
this harsh water can definitely damage your skin
on a daily basis, it's gonna impact everything
you're doing with your skincare.
But if you damage your skin earlier on,
can that increase your risk of atopic dermatitis, eczema?
Absolutely, we know this across the board
with studies in other contexts.
If you have healthy skin barrier habits,
they even have studies like if you apply moisturizer
earlier on in life, it's gonna decrease the incidence
of atopic dermatitis later
because allergens can't get through
that intact barrier of the skin.
So okay, okay, I buy all this
because this all makes sense in the setting
of everything else we know about dermatology and skin.
Okay, so I want to read the conclusion
of this one article that I read
because this to me just confirmed everything
that I believed.
And when I read this, this comes from 2018
Journal of Investigative Dermatology.
And the statement is,
the skin of each participant was washed
with sodium lauryl sulfate in water
of varying hardness levels and chlorine concentration.
Rinse and covered with chambers
to determine the effect of the surfactant residue.
Sites washed with hard water, calcium carbonate,
had significantly increased sodium lauryl sulfate deposits.
These deposits increased transepidermal water loss
and caused irritation,
particularly in people with atopic dermatitis.
A clear effect of chlorine was not observed.
Water softening can mitigate the negative effects
of hard water.
Barrier impairment resulting from interaction
between hard water and surfactants
is a contributory factor to the development
of atopic dermatitis.
Installation of a water softener early in life
may be able to prevent atopic dermatitis,
but an interventional study is required
to confirm this hypothesis.
I don't know.
It's like, what questions do you have after that?
So I do agree that all of this physiologically makes sense.
And actually what I think is a really important thing
is how perhaps blind we are to this daily routine
because this is something you do every day.
Actually, every time you wash your face,
your cleanser is mixing with the water you're using.
Your active ingredients are coming in contact
with the water you're using.
All of this has this very complex interplay.
Sodium lauryl sulfate is probably a good marker
of how, if you improperly wash,
your skin's be more damaged
and it's gonna lead to this cascade of events
that things are gonna be less effective.
So, I mean, I don't have like a real critique
for you at this point.
I don't think I intended to
because I think I understood where this was gonna go.
But yeah, I'm on board so far.
I don't know what else you have.
All right, so the next question is,
and I'm actually very curious about this.
So I definitely need to see in the comments
whether or not any of you believe
that there is anywhere that you either lived
or traveled to where your skin became suddenly worse
or suddenly better based on where you were.
I am gonna confirm further hypothesis off of this,
but I wanna see in the comments below.
The next question I think that everyone's gonna have,
including myself is,
if your water is ruining your skin,
what can you do about it?
Well, you could move.
That could be an option.
But if you can't move,
how do you remove the things
that are causing the issues with your skin?
What I started to look at was,
how do I get a filter for my faucet
in order to improve this issue?
So I looked into this.
Most of the filters were advertising
that they were removing chlorine from the water,
which the data suggests that maybe it causes issues,
but not nearly as much as calcium carbonate.
So basically that's the answer,
is you wanna look for something
that's gonna remove both calcium carbonate,
specifically that's the most important thing,
and then probably you wanna remove
chlorine as well from the water.
And so that's how you're gonna solve this issue.
So this is interesting to me
because I think this is kind of a novel territory.
It's not like this hasn't always been present.
This is like an unfamiliar ingredient, right?
So basically we need a filter.
A filter is something you would attach to your sink.
This would just be a part of your lifestyle routine.
And there are a few options out there.
So what I started to do for a little while
was I got a Brita filter and I said,
okay, I'm gonna pour this
and I'm gonna use this to wash my face,
only when I'm in Charlotte.
I was basically washing myself with like filtered water
or sometimes even bottled water, which is slightly insane,
but I became more and more convinced.
So then anyway, this is what ends up happening.
Cure, who we've talked about in the past,
they have an incredible LED mask.
They reach out to us and they tell us
that they're developing a water filter.
And I said, water filter?
I need this water filter.
But I said, if you're gonna develop a water filter,
you better make sure that this thing
removes calcium carbonate, not just chlorine.
So they said, okay, fine,
we will develop it to remove calcium carbonate for the skin.
And ultimately I believe it was developed for me.
There are other water filters out there.
And I think some of them are now claiming
that they can also remove calcium carbonate.
That being said, I haven't tried the other ones.
I'm sure that they do what they claim to do.
This is the only one that I personally tried
and it's incredible.
So in addition to being able to remove calcium carbonate
as well as chlorine and anything else
that's gonna make your water hard and harsh for your skin,
they did do studies on this,
taking a look at how effective it is.
So you can have confidence that this is going to help
what you're doing for your skincare routine.
And in addition to that, they can help personalize this.
So I like this.
I'm a big fan of personalization.
You can type in your zip code
and they will actually be able to tell you
the hardness of the water
and the composition of the water in your area,
which may not matter.
Actually, as I'm thinking about it,
cause it's still like, this is like a filter.
It's not like you're gonna change the filter
for your location,
but maybe that's nice to know.
You're gonna have a little bit more information
about your area, your locale.
I like that they put a lot of R&D into their products.
Maybe we annoy them a lot,
but ultimately I think they care a lot
about the products they're putting out.
So I'm super excited about this.
I do think this is just the tip of the iceberg
on this whole topic.
So here's some complimenting tips,
I think when it comes to either the water
or even some of the bacteria on your skin.
So let's say your water is now clean.
Let's say your skincare routine is great.
And let's say you're doing something I've done
for a large portion of life.
You grab your body bath towel
and you dry your face off with it.
Or you have your hand towel
that who knows who else is using
and you're drying your face off with it.
This is something that harbors bacteria.
So one thing you can do,
you can have a dedicated face towel.
I like this option.
It's just every three days you have a dedicated face towel.
You just change it out.
I actually have a little washcloth on my counter
for this very purpose.
Or you can do the Clean Skin Club.
They have the reusable towels.
There's biocompostable, biocompostable,
compostable, biocompatible, biodegradable, biodegradable.
They're biodegradable
so they try to minimize the ecologic impact.
That's a really nice way you can do that as well.
Other things we've talked about,
life hacks to minimize bacteria
and damage to your skin that goes unseen.
Pillowcase, they do have pillowcases.
I actually took one on my trip with me recently
and I really enjoyed it.
I don't know why I haven't been traveling
with pillowcases before.
Maybe I can't bring a pillow, you can bring that.
So there's just some other simple hacks,
simple tips to minimize bacteria, inflammation,
irritants on your skin that you may not be thinking about.
I like silk pillowcases personally.
They also have maybe some antimicrobial properties as well.
So that could be a good option for you.
But simple hygiene changes in your life
can also make a difference to your skin as well.
Let us know in the comments
if any of you have experienced issues with your skin
related to the water concentrations in your homes.
Also make sure to check
what the hardness level is in your area.
There are other options out there.
We'll probably try to get some more
so that we can try them out for you.
But ultimately, if you think it's affecting your skin,
it may be worth investing in something like this
because you're doing all the other things right,
but maybe your environment is working against you.
From the questions and answers you've given me,
you're probably spending $100, $200 a month
on your skincare routine.
And if water is a contributing factor,
it might be the easiest thing in the world
to help fix that first
and then everything else will fall in line afterwards.
So it's just a thought, check it out.
But I do wanna hear from you.
What has your experience been with this?
All right, so did I convince you?
You convinced me to try it.
Yeah, I experienced this with my hair.
I don't have much hair.
I still notice a big difference when I go to a new place.
So I think it's very meaningful.
The data is certainly behind it.
It could be a very easy lifestyle intervention
that you could incorporate.
So yeah, I'm gonna be doing this.
All right, well, there we go.
Thank you all so much for tuning in.
Please like, comment and subscribe
and we'll see you in the next video.
See you next time.