Incredibly Rare Set of Scottish Coasters

Antique Collection
23 followers
2 Video Views·Feb 26, 2026
All valuations were correct at the time of broadcast. These engraved Scottish coasters were made in Edinburgh in 1801 by James Dempster, and it's very rare to find six in such good condition. Hugh Scully and the experts from Antiques Roadshow take a look at some fantastic antiques and the history and stories surrounding them. This clip was filmed in Lincoln in 1989.
Well sir, you have here a really wonderful set of six decanter or bottle casters.
What do you know about them? Let's start with you.
Well very little other than that we bought them in 1976 in Scotland.
That's about all.
They're very typically Scottish in that they are this very severe,
they're very very plain with a nice gadrooned rim, turned mahogany bases
and they're engraved with absolutely typical Scottish crests here.
The motto goes over the top of the crest which is always Scottish.
They are made in fact in Edinburgh in 1801 by Mr James Dempster
and I have in fact discovered that the crests are that of a family called
Hamilton Dalrymple of North Berwick.
I think North Berwick but they're baronets.
The family's extinct now which is no doubt why at some point they came on the market.
What's very interesting you know is you see sets of four,
obviously pairs of casters quite often, sets of four and sets of six, sometimes even more.
But what is so difficult is to find more than a pair of decanters.
Sets of six decanters almost don't exist.
So I often wonder if whether so many decanters have been broken
or in fact these were more often used for bottles
because sets of six decanters are incredibly rare, incredibly rare.
But those are absolutely lovely, lovely casters.
How much would you guess?
Well they're insured for around about the 1500.
Right.
I wouldn't like to guess because I've never seen a set of six.
No, no.
Well I certainly have seen sets of six and I think a set of six
really, really plain super Edinburgh casters today would fetch around about
six to eight thousand pounds.
Really?
Yes.
I'll just take a deep breath.
Yes.
They're marvellous.
Shocked me.
So oh dear, oh dear.
Do you find it fun?
No, I think it's quite a...
ugly thing.
I've never looked at it with a great deal of pleasure.
So it's not anything you treasure at home at all?
No, it hasn't really.
It's been in various places such as under the stairs and different places
and it's never been a thing that I would...
oh that is nice, I'd like to keep it.
That's awful because to me it's got so much charm.
It's sort of a cartoon-like quality I find
which so many of this sort of figure tend to represent.
It's so appealing.
It's the work of a potter known as, lovely name, Obadiah Sherratt.
He was working in Staffordshire in the 1820s
and his groups are very typified by these high school bases
and the marvellous mixed-up scale of his portraiture.
We've got little tiny sheep and the figures are completely dwarfing the
castle which they're supposed to be standing beside.
I know of a couple of versions of this model.
One misses out the sheep altogether
but they always have a tower on both sides of the figure
and here rather amusingly the second tower broke off during the making
but rather than scrap the piece they went ahead and just cut it down
painted over it and glazed it and so you wouldn't know and it's no longer there.
So you presumably don't think it's a terribly valuable piece?
Well no, I've never really thought of it as anything, it's just been there.
Recently some incredibly high prices have been paid in sales for the work of Sherratt.
His quick groups of circus performers and local social history of Staffordshire
which many of these pieces represent are seriously sought by collectors nowadays
and I can probably find several collectors will be quite willing to pay £2,000 for this work.
Oh golly Moses, I can hardly believe that.
Well when you think how I've looked at it and never even had any pleasure from looking at it
I find it difficult to...
It's a primitive sort of pleasure that honestly to me I see it very differently to you
but I hope perhaps you'll now after realising this you'll look at it in a new light.
I should cherish it, I should think of it now almost.
