In this video, examine the exceptional Mughal carpets—the only two objects at the Frick made in India—with Deputy Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator Xavier F. Salomon. These incredibly luxurious carpets were likely created during the reign of Shah Jahan, one of the greatest Mughal emperors and the builder of the Taj Mahal. Rarely on view, they will be on display at Frick Madison in early 2021. This week’s complementary cocktail is a Chai Martini.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Xavier Salomon of the Frick Collection examines two rare 17th-century Mughal carpets from India. Once treated as functional furniture, these silk and pashmina masterpieces are now recognized as high-art fragments. The discussion covers their imperial origins, the restoration process that revealed their true nature, and the correction of historical myths regarding their provenance.
Before we begin, I would like to invite you to join us for the Frick's first ever virtual gala,
Frick on the Move, which will take place on Monday, October 19. As part of the evening's
festivities, I will be hosting a special new episode of Cocktails with a Curator. I hope you
will all attend and to learn more about the event, please click the link in the pinned comment below.
Good evening, I'm Xavier Salomon, the Deputy Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator
at the Frick Collection in New York. Welcome to this episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
When we think of the Frick, we always think, of course, of European art from about 1200 to 1900,
which is the scope of the collection as we know it. But there are some exceptions in the collection,
and we do have a few objects that were created outside of Europe. In particular, this evening,
I would like to talk about these two carpets, which are the only two objects in the entire
collection that were made in India. And these are, in themselves, extraordinary and very important
objects. Carpets, of course, were hugely expensive objects to produce, especially of this quality,
These were created in the early 17th century, the one on the left probably in the 1630s,
the one on the right in the 1650s, in northern India. They're made out of silk and pashmina
wool, which is the typical wool that comes from goats in the Himalayas, in Tibet,
that was used to make especially famous Kashmir shawls. And this wool was also used in India
to create these kinds of carpets, which were then dyed with a number of vegetable and animal
dyes, in particular the very recognisable dark, beautiful red, which was made out of black.
I am particularly fond of these two objects because when I first came to the Frick as an
Andrew W. Mellon Curatorial Fellow in 2004, one of the first projects I worked on was this
exhibition, Gardens of Eternal Spring, which was about these two carpets which had just been
restored between 2001 and 2005 at the Metropolitan Museum across Fifth Avenue by the renowned
textile conservator Nobuko Kajitani. And I was given this project to spearhead as a young fellow.
And so this was really my beginning as a curator. It was one of the very first exhibitions I helped
curating. Here is a younger version of myself with Susan Galassi, our former senior curator
at the Frick, as we are supervising the installation of the carpets in the Oval Room.
And here I am with the team of people who were really responsible for this wonderful
installation. The restorer in the middle, Nobuko Kajitani, and on the left, Stephen Seitas, who
was the designer of the exhibition. In fact, Stephen has been the designer of most exhibitions
at the Frick, at least every single exhibition since I have been at the Frick in 2004 to today.
So all the beautiful designs you would have seen of every exhibition at the Frick Collection in
the last 15 years and more are the fruit of Stephen's work. And we're currently working
with the rest of the curatorial team, with Stephen again, over the installation at Frick
Madison in the Breuer Building. And we're obviously having a lot of fun with that.
To pair the carpets, I chose a slightly Indian-flavoured cocktail. This is a chai
martini. It's made out with iced chai latte, so iced chai tea with milk, and vodka. And I would
like to raise a glass and dedicate this episode to Stephen in memory of this exhibition 15 years ago.
The carpets were then displayed in 2006 in the Oval Room. But these were carpets that were designed
and used all the way until that date on a floor. And this is one of the reasons why, except from
experts in carpets and rugs and a few people who know more about the history of these objects,
usually carpets are dismissed as objects of everyday use. And in fact, both of these objects
were bought by Henry Clay Frick as objects for everyday use. And it was really only in
the early 2000s, with the Restoration Project and then this display, that people realized how
important these carpets are and how they are works of art in themselves, and how they deserve to be
displayed as a painting, as a great masterpiece. Both carpets were acquired by Frick in early 1918.
By March of 1918, he owned them. The one on the left, with a series of decorations of trees,
was destined for the Enamels Room, and it was on the floor of the Enamels Room
through most of the twentieth century. The one on the right, with a floral pattern,
the slightly later one of the two, instead was destined for the library.
And Frick had acquired a whole number of carpets, but most of them, for the decoration of the house,
were Persian. And in the nineteenth and early twentieth century, when people thought of the
great carpets of the world, people thought of Persian carpets. Carpets, of course, were made
all over the Eastern world, the continent of Asia, from Turkey to Persia, at this point,
of course, to India to China. But Persian carpets, especially of this type, from the sixteenth
century, were considered, in the nineteenth century and twentieth century in America and
in the Western world, among the most important. This is a Herat carpet, but Frick bought a number
of other carpets from both northern and southern Persia, most of them of designs usually associated
with the area around Isfahan. And some of these carpets are still on the floor at the Frick,
some of them, and of course they're now protected by barriers, but some of them
are so fragile and so precious that we now have to, unfortunately, keep them in storage
and can only be displayed occasionally. They're very light-sensitive and, of course,
they can only be displayed on a wall rather than on the floor. So Frick buys these two carpets
from the dealer Duveen, and in fact they don't come as single works of art. They come as part
of a much larger group of objects that Frick is acquiring, furniture, porcelain, carpets, that he's
buying to decorate the house at 170th Street. We're about a year, a couple of years, before
Frick's death in 1919, at the end of 1919, and these were sold by Duveen. And Duveen had them,
at least this carpet, in stock for quite a while, for several years before he sold it, and he
actually sold them at a slight loss. But this doesn't mean that these were cheap material and
cheap objects. When we think about how much Frick bought them for, this one was more than $30,000,
about $35,000. The other one was $19,000. He actually paid more for these two carpets than
he did around the same time for the Manet and the Renoir in the collection. So these were always
identified and always considered luxury goods. They were created in India as luxury goods,
and they were always sold and acquired as such. This carpet is decorated with a series of
depictions of trees on top of this wonderful red background. And the trees are not all identifiable,
but of course we can see the cypresses at the bottom. And some of the other trees are
beech-like or plum-like trees. And there are these very peculiar fantasy trees that were created
in carpets in India, were depicted in carpets in India, which have leaves that are similar to
sycamore leaves, but the flowers look like lilies. And these, of course, are not real plants that exist,
but they were often depicted on rural carpets. And here you see another detail with one of those
trees more or less in the middle, the cypresses at the bottom. And here you see also the beautiful
border with these floral decorations. The second carpet instead is decorated primarily with flowers,
and there are a number of flowers, lily-like, carnations, different types of flowers more or less
naturalistically depicted. And you have the flowers in the central field against the red,
and then the flowers around the border against the blue. When the carpets came to the Frick,
they were associated with these two other carpets. And in fact, one of the carpets was
originally described as a Persian carpet, and the other one was described as Indo-Persian,
and their provenance wasn't exactly well-defined. But they were associated with these two carpets
that are still to this day known as the Ardabil carpets. These were originally two identical carpets
that were made in Persia for the shrine of one of the rulers of Persia, of Sheikh Safi al-Din,
in the town of Ardabil. Later on, this shrine by Europeans was misunderstood as a mosque,
and so often these objects are described as coming from the mosque of Ardabil. But in fact,
this was a Sufi shrine. And these two large carpets, identical carpets, were woven in Persia
in the sixteenth century for this shrine. They reached Europe at least in the end of the nineteenth
century, and after a number of restorations which made it so that one carpet retained its
largest scale, because actually pieces of the minor carpet, the smaller carpet, were used to
restore the larger one. And this was sold at the end of the nineteenth century, the one on the left,
to the Victoria and Albert Museum in London, with the idea that it was this unique,
very important Persian carpet. Only later, the same dealer sold the second one to a number
of collectors, and eventually the one on the right ended up at LACMA in Los Angeles.
So they're both very important. We have to imagine there would have been identical carpets to begin
with. But these belonged to the same dealer who owned the Frick tree carpet. And so the idea that
the Frick tree carpet also came from Ardabil reached the scholarship in the early twentieth
century. And this carpet, until very recently, until new research that was carried out in the
early two thousands, was believed to come from Ardabil. So it was also known as the Ardabil
carpet. And the idea was that it may have been a gift from one of the Mughal rulers of India
to a Persian ruler, and that's how it had ended up in Ardabil. You can see from this photograph
that this carpet is actually made out of fragments. And so the legend also came about that
time that this carpet was considered a sacred object in this mosque, and pilgrims would steal
parts of the carpet, and that's why the carpet was in pieces. In fact, we now know this is not true
at all. The confusion with Ardabil is simply due to the fact that the two Ardabil carpets
were described in the same volume as this carpet, but there was no mention in the late nineteenth
century that this also came from Ardabil, so we don't know that. This is clearly not a Persian
rug. It was made in India. And the fact that it is in fragments is due to the wear and tear
of the past four hundred years rather than any pilgrims or religious reasons.
This was a very different carpet to begin with, and by looking at it carefully in the early 2000s,
the conservators and curators at the time and the experts in Indian carpets worked out that,
in fact, this is a puzzle. It's a finished, almost, carpet made out of many, many fragments
that came from a much larger carpet. And on the left, you see this wonderful map that was
reconstructed at the time, which shows you, more or less, where all the various fragments of this
carpet, plus a few other fragments that survive in a number of public and private collections that
came from the same rug, where they came from from the original carpet. And this is what the original
carpet in a digital reconstruction on the left would have looked like. So, very long and narrow
carpet, much, much larger than the already very large carpet that we have at the Frick.
But we have to understand, both of these, the floral carpet comes from a very similar
context, would have been much larger, much grander objects, which later, in the nineteenth century in
Europe, were restored, effectively reconstructed in what now look like finished objects. But they
are produced with fragments of a much larger and more important whole. The carpets are known as
Mughal carpets because these sort of carpets were produced during the Mughal empire in India,
especially in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. The Mughal emperors arrived in India
in the 1520s. Babur was the first of the Mughal rulers of India, of the Indian subcontinent,
which included areas of India, but also of what we today know as Bangladesh, Pakistan, and
Afghanistan. And many of these rulers were great patrons of the arts, like Akbar
and his successors. They were of Turkish-Mongolian origins. They're descendants of Timur,
the great ruler of Central Asia. But, of course, they were also often intermarried with other
dynasties from Asia. So they were also partly Persian and they intermarried, of course, with
local Indian families as well, ruling families. The Mughal emperors ruled in name India all the
way to the 1850s. Of course, by that point the power shift had changed quite dramatically and,
of course, England was effectively ruling the country. But there was still a Mughal emperor
in Delhi all the way to the 1850s. These two carpets at the Frick were produced around 1630,
1650, and these are both probably produced during the reign of Shah Jahan, who was the emperor
exactly at that point, from the late 1620s to the late 1650s. Here you see Shah Jahan on the left
in Mughal miniature, showing him as the emperor of the Indian subcontinent. And on the right,
I just put it out of interest for us, but this is a drawing of Shah Jahan by Rembrandt. And,
of course, Rembrandt never went to India, never met Shah Jahan, but Rembrandt was particularly
fond of Mughal miniatures, and he did a series of copies of Mughal miniatures. This is one of them.
So he happened to own or see a miniature of Shah Jahan and he copied it. And this is Rembrandt's
drawing now in the Lugt collection at the Fondation Custodia in Paris. There was a
Of course, Shah Jahan is one of the great emperors of Mughal India, one of the great patrons of the
arts. He is, of course, remembered by all of us as the builder of the Taj Mahal in Agra. But it is
very likely that carpets like the two at the Frick were produced for the royal family, for the imperial
family. Carpets of this kind, of this size, of these materials, again I remind you these are
made out of silk and very precious wool, pashmina wool, would have only been produced by the state
manufactories that worked for the imperial family. So we don't know if these were made specifically
for Shah Jahan or if they were made for another member of the royal family. We don't know if they
were made for a palace, a fort, or for a religious site. And we don't know how effectively both of
those carpets reached the United States and Europe before that. They could have remained in
India until the nineteenth century, and maybe they reached London and Paris, where they were first
documented, but directly from India. The carpet on the right belonged to Maurice de Rothschild
in Paris before Duveen bought it. The one on the left, instead, belonged to an English collector.
It is also likely that maybe they did come from Persia, and it is possible that when Nadir Shah,
the Persian ruler, sacked and conquered Delhi in 1739, he could have brought these as war loot
to Persia. And so maybe the link with Ardabil and the Ardabil carpets is that these were also
acquired in Persia, but we don't really know. So it's equally possible that their provenance is
from Persia, as they could have been in India from when they were created, all the way until
the nineteenth century. So the history of these two objects, really before the end of the nineteenth
century, is still shrouded in mystery. We don't know exactly who they were made for and where
they came from. But we do know that they were made for one of the rulers of India, or someone
very close to the ruler in his family. So the objects are now, as I mentioned, framed and
displayed for conservation reasons in these cases, vertically rather than on the floor.
They're very large in size, and you can see them here in the Oval Room next to our Ingres,
as they were displayed in 2006. In fact, between the early 2000s and today, they were only displayed
in the Oval Room twice. There are issues with light sensitivity, so these are objects that
cannot be displayed in light places for a very long time. And so we display them on occasional
terms whenever we can. But you can also see how large they are here in the Oval Room. And if you
imagine that these are fragments of carpets that would have been four or five times the size in
terms of length, you can understand really how grandiose and unbelievable these objects are.
I'm talking to you about them because one of the decisions is to display the carpets at Frick
Madison. So when we open there early next year, these carpets will have a space dedicated to them,
and you'll be able to see them, as you haven't for many years now. So I hope that this will give
people an opportunity to think about the richness of the holdings at the Frick, the wealth of
materials. Over these cocktails and travels, we've talked about paintings and sculpture and
furniture and porcelain. But carpets are also part of the story and very important and beautiful
objects. And I hope you will all be able to come and see them and look at all the details,
the wonderful details of the plants and the flowers. And even though many of the trees,
for example, on the tree carpet appear similar, you realize as you look closely that they're all
absolutely different. And you have to imagine the team of people who worked on the looms
to create these absolute masterpieces. And to me, these are as important, if not more,
than many of our paintings in the collection. Overall, we know that carpets of this quality
were produced in the Mughal Empire for about 200 years, but only about 500 of them survive,
and most of them are still in India. So it is really wonderful for us to be able to display
them and show something to do with Indian culture, Indian heritage, Indian art at the
Frick Collection for the public who comes and visits us. Thank you for joining me this evening,
and I look forward to seeing you next week. Good evening.