How to Trade In Your Car When You Owe Money On It | NerdWallet

Trust Channel
6 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 6, 2025
If you’re still paying off your current car, but a new one has caught your eye, you do still have some trade-in options. Let’s talk about how to trade in your car when you still owe money on it.
Confession time. One of my favorite things to do this time of year is to stalk car blogs and
magazines and check out all the latest changes and models, and then I like to mentally purchase
like five or ten of them. If you're still paying off your current car but something new and shiny
has caught your eye, you do have some options. Let's talk about how to trade in your car when
you still owe money on it. Hey, welcome back to NerdWallet. Before we get into it, you should
know that in general, cars have been more expensive the past couple of years due to some
supply chain issues. As of July of this year, the average price of a new vehicle was up 11.9 percent
from July of 2021. That said, if you do want to trade in your car while you still owe money on it,
the dealer will subtract the value of your old car from the price of the new car. The dealer will
take over the loan on the old vehicle and you'll only be on the hook for the new vehicle price,
less the amount of your trade-in value. When talking about trading in a vehicle that you
still owe money on, we're looking at one of two scenarios. You either, one, have positive equity,
meaning you owe less than your car is worth, or two, you have negative equity and your car is
worth less than what you owe. Obviously, the first scenario is a little easier to tackle because the
positive equity means you will have extra money to put towards your new vehicle. If you have
negative equity, you'll have to pay the difference between the loan balance and the trade-in value.
Now, before you start picturing yourself driving through the countryside with your windows down
and the music up, your first step needs to be contacting your current lender and figuring out
exactly what you owe. You really need to make an informed decision before you purchase something
new and understanding your payoff amount will help. The payoff amount your lender provides
will usually be slightly higher than the remaining balance you see on your billing statement. Once you
know the payoff amount, pop over to an online pricing guide like Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds
to determine your vehicle's trade-in value. Subtract the payoff amount from your vehicle's
trade-in value to get an idea of whether you have positive or negative equity. You can also get
trade-in values from online car buyers like Carvana. Just know that trade-in values can be
negotiated at dealerships, but not with most online car retailers. If you have positive equity, you're in
great shape for getting the new car. Let's break down what this could look like. Say you owe $3,000
on your car and it's worth $5,000 if you were to trade it in. This would mean you have $2,000
of positive equity that you could apply to the purchase of your next car. Keep in mind that you
will still need to provide either cash or financing for the remaining balance of the new car's purchase
price. The value of the trade-in will be listed on the contract and should reflect the price you
negotiated. And just like with any other car purchase, you can still make a down payment to
reduce the overall balance of the new car loan. A quick pro tip, get the best price possible for
your trade-in and the new vehicle by negotiating them separately. Do your research and come to
negotiations armed with knowledge gained from the online guides I mentioned earlier. Now, if you have
negative equity, also known as being upside down on your loan, it really is ideal to postpone your
new car purchase. Try to either pay off that loan or at least pay it enough that you have positive
equity. But if your current payments are really high and you're struggling to pay off the vehicle,
downsizing to a less expensive car or even an inexpensive used car could provide some relief.
If this is the case, you'll need to give the dealer your trade-in plus the amount of negative
equity owed on the loan. Let me break it down a little with an example. Let's say you owe $5,000
and your car's worth $3,000. The trade-in credit would cover most of the loan and you would pay
the dealer the $2,000 difference. Make sense? Your dealer will likely suggest that you just
roll that negative equity into your new loan, which I know sounds tempting, but this is actually
going to mean that you're going to be immediately upside down on your new loan and you'd be creating
a larger loan for yourself and would likely result in paying more interest. So unless you're really
in a pinch and don't have the funds to pay off that negative equity, it's best to avoid rolling
the balance into the new loan. The actual steps of trading in the car once you've done your research
is actually pretty simple. You'll just need to bring the following items to the dealership.
First, you'll need your car loan information. This should include the payoff amount along with the
account number. You'll need your vehicle registration and proof of insurance. You'll
need all the keys and remotes for the vehicle. You'll need a printout of your current vehicle's
trade-in value and of course you'll need your driver's license. Once you've negotiated the deal,
review the contract carefully and pay extra attention to cost amounts to ensure the prices
listed match the prices you negotiated. Double check all the numbers with your own calculator
before you sign. A few weeks after you've completed the deal, the lender should send you
documentation in the mail confirming that your loan from the vehicle that you traded in has been
settled. The most important thing to keep in mind regardless of if you have positive or negative
equity is that you, you should be the one controlling the transaction, not the dealer.
That means you have to have a good handle on your vehicle's trade-in value and what you're willing
to pay for the new vehicle. If the dealer just insists on offering you less than you know the
vehicle is valued at, you may want to look at just selling the car privately instead.
And if you're setting up a new loan, try not to extend the loan term for more than 60 months
if you're buying a new car or more than 36 months if you're buying used. Ultimately, we all like the
idea of a shiny new car in the driveway, but remember that a new car is a big financial
undertaking. Avoid making the decision strictly based on emotion and really crunch the numbers
to decide if trading in now makes smart financial sense for you or if it would be better to wait
until your current loan is paid off. Thanks so much for stopping by. If you like this video, be
sure to give it a thumbs up and if you want to see all kinds of cool future videos from us, be sure
to subscribe to our channel. Until next time, bye!
