Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/knf775 • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
If your private student loans are in default, you're not out of options. Go to whyrefi.com
slash Ramsey. My mom co-signed a lease with my brother about four years ago, and he's in
and out of jobs. He doesn't like working in corporate, even though he had the opportunity
to do so. And now he can't afford it. And he wanted to get it repoed, which she said no.
So she's been asking for help to pay bills. And so now the car's just kind of sitting,
being used. But we had asked her to sell it. I mean, my other siblings and I. But she doesn't
want to sell it. Why? She's kind of on the water. So even if she does sell it,
she won't get much for it. Okay. How much do you guys, well, let me say,
how much does the mom and the brother owe on it? About 20 grand left on it.
Okay. What's it worth if they sold it? You kind of ruined it. Sorry?
You said somebody ruined it. She ruined it or he ruined it?
He ruined it when he was using it. Just wrecking it?
He just didn't take care of it. Maintenance. Yeah, it's been wrecked a couple times as well.
Oh, why are you calling? Interior is terrible.
Because mom has asked him to help out. And brother, because brother won't.
He was in an accident last year as well. She was?
So we've been taking care of her while she's been going through rehab and physio and stuff like that.
Understood. What could she sell the car for today?
Maybe five grand, honestly. Oh gosh.
If she's lucky. Okay.
Well, this is, first of all, this, your brother is in a season of life where he is impersonating
a deadbeat and so deadbeats only wake up when they're forced to wake up. But the problem is
mom's name is on this and she refuses to help herself. Correct?
Kind of. The main reason she doesn't want to necessarily take it back to the bank or maybe
just get it repoed, which I've heard is not an option. Repo is not an option. And we can talk
to you about that, why that is, but continue on. Yeah. So eventually she says she wants to
get a house soon enough, which I personally think she can't afford. So the biggest thing for me
is just continuing to help feels like enabling. I don't know how to approach her in a sense like,
okay, in as much as we've been helping this entire time, there's a couple of things she could do.
What else have you been doing to help? Because it sounds like you've already been down that road.
It's mostly just bills and rent and stuff like that. I still live at home,
but I just got married, so I'm moving out. Is that because of the accident or that's
just always been ongoing? It's been ongoing, but more so after the accident.
And who's we? I thought I heard you say we've been helping.
My siblings and I. I have a younger brother and then I'm older.
Are your siblings that have been helping with the bills, are they all in the same opinion of you
that you just said, which is, I feel like I'm helping and it's enabling. Do they have the same
feeling? Somewhat. My older sister, yes. My younger brother, not too sure. He doesn't pay much.
Listen, you asked a question and I'm going to answer the question that I heard and that is,
how do I approach her on this? How do I handle this? And this is you going, mom, I can't do
this anymore. Here's what you should do. If I were you, this is what I would do. And you lay it out
and say, I'd sell the car because every day that she doesn't sell the car, there's another calamity
that's probably going to happen to this. And I feel like this entire car represents a lot of
the calamity that your brother creates and no one is willing to do anything about it.
And so if I'm you, I go to mom and I go, mom, sell the car today because we've got to at least
get five grand for it. And that at least lessens the debt by 5,000. And then we have a $15,000
problem. You've got all these other financial problems that are more important than this stupid
car. So mom, here's how I'm going to help going forward. I can't help you financially anymore.
I've got to move on. I suspect that you don't have the finances and the margin to be able to
keep helping her anyway, without hurting you. True or false? True. True. So that's the conversation.
Mom, I can't. Even if I wanted to, I can't. So here's how I can help. I'll be willing to
list the car, sell the car. I'll be willing to have a conversation with younger brother
and grab him by the nap of the neck. And just absolutely as only a brother can lay into his
Very well done, Jade. And use both hands, clap him on both ears. Okay. Now here's the deal.
And that's a lay it out and move on and say, you got to help mom. And I think all the siblings
should unite on an intervention. Outside of that, Jade, that's what I'm thinking of. What else did
I leave off the table? What would you do here? There's a part that can help relationally. I
think early on, if it's possible, you said mom co-signed for brother, which makes me think mom
has better credit. I wonder if she can refinance this and get him off of it. So that at least
you're separating that relational tie. And then from there on, she can make whatever choices she's
going to make with the car separate from the brother. That might un-muddy the waters just a
as she decides what she's going to do next. But other than that, Ken, I think Ken is exactly spot
on. I have nothing to add. This is tough. So selling the car would be private sale?
Yeah. You're going to get the most money. Yeah. Okay. And what she can do, and you can advise
her of this, if her credit's all right, in the process of getting him off the loan,
when you're in there, you can say, here's what we want to do. We need a loan for the difference
because ultimately we're going to sell this thing. So we need to get him off of the loan
in the process. And then we're transferring it to a personal loan. And when she does that,
if she wants to add a little something to it to get something in cash, that's fine. But I think
because of the nature of how much she owes on it, she's probably, you know, she would end up
basically back in $20,000 of debt. So I think the bigger part here is to get the brother off of it.
And then maybe, and I don't know what your lifestyle is, but maybe that's a way you
can help her out, which is, hey, while you're saving up for your next vehicle,
I can help if you need a ride, you know, in between the Ubers that in the bus rides
that you'll be taking, I can help with that. Maybe that's something you can offer.
Yeah. And then we need to caution mom. You're nowhere near buying a house,
not even close. Are you renting? Is she renting now where you've been living with her?
Yes.
Yeah. No, she is not thinking about buying anything. We got to get her healthy. Do you
feel like her long-term physical prognosis is good or she can get back to work?
It's been better. She's going to extend a little bit because she's still in some pain. So maybe by
July, maybe she'll be-
What is she living off of? Is there some type of a disability or insurance
that she's getting? What's going on there?
Yes. She had gotten a disability for a little bit, and then she was pulling
some out of her insurance. I think life insurance.
From?
That she borrowed against that.
Oh my gosh, mom.
Wow. Okay. Yeah, this is tough. Tell me, and you can be vague, but the nature of her injuries,
how serious is this? And how old is she? Because I want to know really honestly what she's going
to be able to get back to doing work-wise.
It was pretty bad. She got rear-ended while she was stopped at a light. And then she's around
mid-fifties, so it's pretty slow progress for recovery.
What was she doing beforehand? What was her job and what was she earning?
She was doing a bunch of different things, but at that time she was doing Uber as a side gig.
The ways that you can help her are as following. Help her get brother off the loan. That's thing
one. Thing two is I want you to help her with the career side of things. We're going to give you
Ken's Find the Work You're Wired to Do assessment. It's a book that'll help you, and there's an
assessment inside. Help her go through that because it sounds like she needs to create
stability in her career or create a career so that she can create stability in her finances
going forward. I hope she's well, and I hope she recovers very, very quickly.
I would just add, you siblings need to get together and essentially fire this brother
from her life for a while.
YREFI refinances defaulted private student loans for struggling borrowers.
Learn more at Y-R-E-F-Y dot com slash Ramsey.