In this video, Professor Walter explores the general principles of law in international law. We go beyond definitions to see how these principles operate, their theoretical debates, and their role in preventing gaps in the legal system.
What you’ll learn in this video: • The definition of general principles of law and how to understand them • Their key functions: filling gaps, preventing legal vacuums, and guiding courts when no applicable law exists • Scholarly debates and theoretical divisions on general principles of law • How these principles function across domestic, regional, and international levels • Principles that are unique to international law • Their operation in international law, including recognition by the International Court of Justice • Criticisms and limits of general principles in the international legal system
This lecture provides a comprehensive understanding of general principles as a core source of international law, showing how they guide justice and fill gaps when other sources are insufficient.
👉 Join IntlLaw Academy on this journey step by step. Don’t forget to subscribe, like, and share to help expand our community of international law learners!
0:00 Intro 0:18 Professor Walter's first monologue 00:58 Definition of General Principles of Law in International Law 02:37 The role of General Principles of Law in international law 03:54 The philosophy of General Principles of Law in international law 06:20 Types of General Principles of Law 09:35 Operation of General Principles of Law in International Law 12:17 Criticisms and limitations of the General Principles of Law 13:29 Professor Walter's last monologue
Hello my friend. Whether you have clicked on our videos for the first time or you are a companion
of our academy's journey, you are interested in international law and that's wonderful.
My name is Walter and I have the honour to represent Intel Law Academy lectures
about sources of international law. We have covered studying the first two primary sources
of international law. If you want you can find the videos about those in the playlist mentioned
And now we are moving on to the last primary source of international law,
general principles of law. So if you are eager to join us, let's begin.
My friends, having walked together through treaties and custom, we come now to the third
pillar found in Article 38 of the Statute of the International Court of Justice,
the general principles of law recognized by civilized nations. These principles are quieter
than treaties, less visible than customs, but no less essential. They are the fail-safes of the
international legal system, the rules we turn to when the written instruments and the habits of
states leave a gap. So what do we mean by general principles of law? At bottom, these are fundamental
rules of legal reasoning and justice that recur across the world's municipal legal systems.
Think of them as the common grammar of law, concepts like good faith, the binding force
of agreements, pacta sunt servanda, estoppel, res judicata, due process, and the prohibition of
retroactive penal legislation. They are not invented ad hoc by international judges, rather
they are distilled from the patterns of legal institutions and doctrines that most national
systems share. There is a useful way to understand the source of these principles.
Where custom draws on repeated state practice plus legal belief, and treaty is the express
will of states on paper, general principles are drawn from comparative law, the common rules,
methods, and logical structures found in domestic courts, legislation, and legal doctrine.
International tribunals, when stymied by the absence of treaty text or clear custom,
look downwards into municipal law and ask, what rule or principle is so widely accepted and so
fundamental that it can be relied upon as international law? General principles perform
several essential functions. First, gap filling. They prevent a vacuum. When international law is
silent on a particular issue, general principles provide a lawful basis for a decision. Second,
interpretation. They guide how treaties and customs should be understood and applied,
often supplying background norms that make the text sensible. Third, legitimacy and fairness.
These principles root international decisions in widely recognized notions of justice,
preventing arbitrary outcomes. Finally, they can limit or moderate the application of other sources,
for example, insisting that treaty obligations be performed in good faith.
Another vital role of general principles is their function in preventing a non-liquid,
a situation where a court or tribunal might claim, the law is silent and we cannot decide.
In international law, such silence would threaten the authority of the legal system itself.
General principles step in to fill the gap, ensuring that justice is not denied.
They provide a safety net, guaranteeing that the International Court of Justice and other tribunals
can always deliver a decision, even when treaties and customary law are unclear or incomplete.
Scholars have long debated the exact character of general principles. Some are cautious and
positivist. They argue that a principle qualifies only if it is demonstrably common to a substantial
number of domestic systems. For them, comparative evidence, court decisions, statutes, legal doctrine
is the key. Others adopt a more normative or natural law posture. They see general principles
as reflecting deeper moral or rational foundations of law, what some traditions call the conscience.
From that view, the principles are not merely descriptive of municipal systems,
but express a shared legal morality upon which international order depends.
This theoretical divergence matters in practice. A narrow, evidence-based approach guards against
importing one legal tradition's rules into the international plane. A broader, conscience-based
approach allows tribunals greater flexibility to appeal to universal ideas of justice.
Most modern international lawyers and most courts adopt a pragmatic middle course.
They require some demonstrable municipal resonance for a principle, but are not blind to moral
legitimacy where comparative evidence supports a rule's universality.
Let me give you concrete examples to make this less abstract.
The principle of pacta sunt servanda, that agreements must be kept, underpins the whole
law of treaties and qualifies as a general principle because the binding force of contracts
is recognized in virtually all domestic systems. Good faith operates as a general principle in the
Estoppel prevents a party from insisting on a right if it previously acted in a way that
led another to rely to its detriment. You will find Estoppel-like doctrines in many national laws.
Res judicata, the finality of judgments, is another classic.
International tribunals will not lightly reopen matters already conclusively decided.
Even procedural principles, such as the right to be heard, have been imported from municipal
practice because they secure fundamental fairness. In short, general principles are
the stitching that holds the fabric of international law together when the larger,
more visible threads are absent or frayed. They are a pragmatic instrument, comparative,
principled, and cautious, and they play an indispensable role in keeping the international
legal system coherent, fair, and operable. Now that we have defined and introduced the
principles of law, let us turn to their different kinds and levels of operation.
To understand this, we must look at how principles function within domestic systems,
within regional groupings, and in the international legal order as a whole.
At the domestic level, every legal system has its own set of fundamental principles,
for example, principles such as the presumption of innocence in criminal law,
the requirement of good faith in contracts, or the prohibition of unjust enrichment.
These are foundational rules that guide courts and legislators within a particular national
framework. While they may vary in form or detail, they are recognised as essential
within that legal system. The next level is the regional sphere.
Here, principles may be shared across a group of states bound by geography,
culture, or regional legal integration. For instance, the principle of solidarity and
subsidiarity in the European Union, or the principle of non-intervention in regional
organisations like the African Union or the Organisation of American States.
These regional principles may reflect shared traditions or institutional arrangements,
but they are not automatically principles of universal international law.
They remain regional general principles, binding only on the states of that particular community.
And finally, the international level. This is where the statute of the International
Court of Justice directs us. Only those principles which are so widely accepted
across domestic legal systems and cultures that they can be called universal may be applied as
general principles of international law. In other words, the international community
accepts only those principles that are common to all or nearly all legal systems.
Principles that transcend legal families, religions, and regions.
Examples here include pacta sunt servanda, res judicata, and the prohibition of retroactive
criminal punishment. These rules are not regional or cultural artefacts.
They are near-universal pillars of legal reasoning. But international law also recognises that there
are some principles that are uniquely international in character, arising not from domestic practice,
but from the nature of the international system itself. For example, the principle of sovereign
equality of states, or the principle that no one can be judge in their own cause,
nemo judex in causa sua, when it comes to international adjudication. These are not
borrowed directly from domestic law, but are necessary to make the system of international
law coherent. So, to summarise, at the domestic level, principles guide national law. At the
regional level, they may reflect cultural or institutional consensus among a group of states.
But at the international level, only those principles which are either truly universal
across domestic systems, or necessary to the very structure of international law itself,
qualify as general principles of law. These are the ones that international judges and
scholars rely upon as the third great source of international law. Let us finally look at how
they operate in international law itself. This is where theory meets practice. The Statute of the
International Court of Justice, Article 38, gives general principles of law their formal status as
one of the three primary sources of international law, alongside treaties and custom. The Court has
repeatedly relied upon them when treaties and custom leave gaps, ensuring that the international
system remains functional and coherent. For example, the ICJ and its predecessor,
the Permanent Court of International Justice, have invoked principles such as good faith, equity,
and the prohibition of abuse of rights. These principles act as safeguards against injustice
and arbitrariness in the absence of written or customary rules. Recognition by the ICJ follows
a careful methodology. Judges look across the world's major legal systems to see if a principle
is shared, regardless of legal tradition, religion, or region. If it appears consistently across these
domestic systems, it may be elevated to the international level. This comparative approach
ensures legitimacy, universality, and fairness in selecting general principles. General principles
of law are not all of one kind. Some of them are derived directly from domestic legal systems,
transplanted into international law because they are recognised everywhere.
Principles such as good faith, estoppel, or responsibility for wrongful acts belong to this
category. On the other hand, there are general principles that are not borrowed from domestic
systems but arise within the international legal order itself. Think of the sovereign equality of
These are not simply domestic analogies but foundational principles of the international
community. This duality helps us understand both the richness and the complexity of general
principles of law. There is an important debate about whether general principles of law must be
truly universal. Some scholars argue that only principles found across all legal systems in the
can qualify as sources of international law. Others, however, believe that strong regional
principles, for example, principles developed within European Union law or within Islamic or
African legal traditions, may also influence the formation of international law if they reflect
a consistent and deeply held consensus. This debate reveals the tension between universality
and diversity, and it challenges us to think carefully about whose legal traditions shape
the rules of our shared international community. General principles of law are not without
criticism. Some argue that they are vague, that their identification lacks clear methodology,
and that they allow judges too much freedom to pick and choose principles that fit the outcome
they prefer. This creates a risk of selectivity or even manipulation. Others counter that without
general principles, international law would be incomplete and fragile. Thus, the legitimacy of
this source of law depends heavily on transparency and careful reasoning in how courts and scholars
identify and apply them. There are also limits. General principles cannot be stretched to justify
completely new obligations that states have never consented to. They are meant to fill gaps and
provide coherence, not to replace the hard law of treaties or custom. Still, their flexibility
makes them invaluable. For instance, the principle of res judicata, that a dispute once settled by a
judgment cannot be reopened, is essential to international adjudication, even though no
treaty explicitly requires it in all cases. Similarly, the principle of equity has been
used to achieve fairness in maritime boundary cases. My friends, we have now travelled together
through the three primary sources of international law, treaties, custom, and general principles of
law. Thanks to your attentive listening, we have completed this essential stage of our journey,
understanding the pillars that uphold the international legal system.
In our next session, we will turn our attention to the other sources of international law,
the secondary, supplementary materials that, while not primary, still guide and shape the
behaviour of states and international actors. I sincerely thank you for accompanying me so far.
Your curiosity and engagement have made this exploration meaningful.
Keep following the journey, for there is still more to uncover about the fascinating world
of international law. Until we meet again, stay curious, stay thoughtful, and continue exploring
with the Interlaw Academy.