Produite, réalisée et écrite par le Québécois Mathieu Côté-Desjardins, cette websérie documentaire de 2010 (sélectionnée aux Prix Gémeaux comme finaliste en 2011) suit le créateur de la série étant nouvel enseignant fraîchement sorti de l'université. Dès les premiers jours de classe, il s'est demandé comment on pouvait offrir si peu de qualité aux jeunes. Puisant dans ses quelques expériences en cinéma et son maigre salaire de nouveau prof (et d'un emprunt bancaire de plusieurs dizaines de milliers de dollars), il décide de s'acheter une caméra vidéo, ce qu'il faut pour faire du montage et se met à filmer divers entretiens divers intervenants du système scolaire (et d'autres nullement liés à ce domaine). « Suis-je fou de penser que le système scolaire n'a aucun sens » ? Exutoire et thérapie sous format documentaire qui fut le premier pan dans sa quête de percer le mystère de la véritable éducation. La saison 2, intitulée LA RÉÉDUCATION, se trouve également sur cette même chaîne.
I didn't think about going to school at home, I thought it was a little crazy the first time I saw people do that.
The first ones I met who went to school at home were actually a family of teachers.
They had four children and they didn't send one to school.
What is that?
So you're asking questions.
And then I met some of them, they were high school teachers, if I'm not mistaken.
And when they decided to have children, they said, no, yes, we don't put them in the system.
So that made me wonder why teachers say, no, my children won't go through that.
Because, let's face it, there are some who are comfortable and send them to good schools.
And again, a school is a school, OK?
But there are still schools that will fit better.
Or they all end up with very anti-children.
OK?
But the majority of Quebeckers go through the torture of the regular.
You know?
What is there to depress anyone?
There are some who will get by despite the school.
School commissions are very powerful.
It's political.
They don't write you.
They don't answer in writing.
They don't want to get involved.
It's really a language of wood.
I mean, a jump dialogue.
They tell us, you explain the whole situation.
Yes, but we're not going to change the law on that.
You know?
I said, I have a law degree.
I said, listen, the law is not that.
They know how to read you.
They don't know how to read.
And in fact, they don't want to get involved at the political level.
They don't want to write that a young person has the right to.
In fact, they want to put sticks in our wheels until the end.
You have to fight.
And there are parents who don't want to fight.
You know, it takes a lot of energy.
And it takes a lot of energy to educate these children.
It's not for everyone.
It's easier in elementary school.
It's more vital in high school.
You know, when I started school at home, my husband trusted me.
And he said, listen, I see that you want to do this.
You know, we started the adventure by saying, we're going to do it again.
We're going to do it again.
The school board is always doubting you.
You always have to prove that you're teaching your children.
At some point, they stop you from learning.
Because the evaluation...
I think the kids are evaluated to death.
And the teachers are like this with the evaluations.
And at some point, you don't learn when you're always evaluated.
The evaluation reassures the adult.
That's all it does.
And again, it's not for the benefit of the child.
When you go to the library,
and you've found what you're interested in,
you're taking out some books,
do they sit you down on the way out to test you?
To make sure you learned everything you were supposed to in the library?
Well, of course not.
Because they assume you're somebody who's a learner
and you want to learn something.
Why shouldn't all of our education be like that?
But it's certain that at some point,
if you pass the D.E.S. exams,
you have to jump into their net.
Okay?
That's very clear.
It's not a matter of life and death.
Look, when I'm 15,
I think it's positive that my son is preparing for the exams.
Before that, no, not at all.
At 15, to say,
listen, the requirements are going up,
and now there's a year to pass the exams.
Okay?
It's a year to pass the exams.
It's not the content that's the problem.
Okay?
He knows more than the program.
He's more independent, he's more open,
he has more scientific knowledge.
But he has to jump into their net,
in their own way, at their moment.
It's good that he's measuring himself, too.
You see?
To others...
Me, he passed,
my son, at 14,
he passed the French D.E. exam.
He was the only one.
He had 10 hours of exams,
divided into two days.
Okay?
The person who gave him that,
at Claudel High School,
said, he deserves his D.E. just for that.
The others are all weighted,
and all that,
and they only have three exams.
He had six,
because the others are in continuous evaluation.
There was that in French,
in Mathematics,
in Science and Life on Earth,
in Physics,
and in Geography and History.
Okay?
And in Italian.
He didn't even study Italian during the year.
He didn't pass the exam.
There's a child's book
that really struck me.
I was telling this to some kids,
it was in English,
you know,
The Late Bloomer.
It was a baby tiger.
And the dad was looking at him
and telling his wife,
he said, listen,
the elephant, wait,
I'm under him.
And one day, he wrote,
and he's eating his piece of iron,
and look at him,
it's total chaos,
it's a disaster.
And his wife said,
no, no,
it's just a late bloomer.
He said,
you'll see.
And the dad looked at him,
and he didn't see any change.
And his wife said,
do you understand English?
Yes.
And his wife said,
a watch,
late bloomer,
never blooms.
It really struck me,
because it's true,
if you put a child
under a magnifying glass,
they freeze.
At some point,
you have to,
there's no child like that.
I only have five.
Imagine in a classroom.
I only have five.
There's not one
who learned to read
the same way.
You know?
There's not one
who learned to read
the same way.
There's not one
who had the same sequence
of development,
who had the same challenges,
or the same strengths.
Why do we have children?
You have to have the space
to discuss these things.
We don't have a community anymore.
People are looking for it.
They volunteer.
You know,
they're in their volunteer circle,
the SCORE circle.
It's not necessarily
that we're always
talking about that,
but the parents,
or people are looking
for an affiliation
somewhere.
Before,
it was the church
here in Quebec.
A long time ago,
it was,
you know,
we would meet
at church services,
and we would talk about it.
You know?
What are we talking about?
We're rich,
and we think
we don't need anyone,
and in the end...
We have a big house.
Yes,
we have a big house.
We have to pay for it.
We're tired.
Oh, shit,
I'm going to watch TV.
You know,
instead of doing something.
The poorer you are,
in the end,
or the less wealth you have,
the more you go
into the community.
So,
in the end,
those are richer.
The richer you are,
the more you think
you can get out of it.
The biggest challenge
as a parent,
I would say,
is to find,
for my children,
other significant adults
for my children.
I am a parent
who is significant
for other children.
OK?
In my home school group,
I had a group
of 23 teenagers this year
that I took
on a long history
through the great museums.
OK?
I got attached
to each of these young people.
I know them.
I know their families.
It's been a long time.
Some of them were new.
Some of them
I've known for a long time.
You know?
And for me,
they're not numbers.
For example,
we could spend
three hours
in writing.
And it goes like that.
And no one complains.
OK?
Because they make sense.
When a young person
makes sense of something,
he's happy.
For me,
it always impresses me
when I ask them
to write
and they start writing.
I have parents
who call me
who have never
considered
going to school at home.
But there is a child
who is in great
school difficulty
for some reason,
X or Y.
And there is one,
well,
he wanted the child
to be in Italian,
but she says
it's for what?
So that he doesn't disturb
the teacher?
So the mother,
I remember,
was very nervous.
She left
a whole group of
child support
who had problems
with attention deficit
at that point.
She took him out
and she did it.
She had the trouble
at the beginning.
You see?
But she did it.
She did it for her son
because she didn't know
how to drug him like that.
You know?
I have some too.
He had spent
half the year
in the corridor
the third year.
He was disturbing.
He was bored in class.
She took him out.
She didn't have his
5th grade.
She didn't even speak
French correctly.
She was English.
She took care of him.
She put him in two
hockey teams.
He wanted to do that.
The young man
collected his money
for his hockey equipment.
He was 10 years old.
She was looking
for a curriculum
and a French tutor
because it was his...
And she educated
her two boys
like that at home.
Society says
if you don't have
a diploma, you're nothing.
But I'm against that.
You know?
A young man comes to me
and says,
I'm 97 in English.
I say, 97 is nothing.
It's in the sense that
the grade given at school
is not worth much.
It's very relative.
It's taken at a given moment.
And learning
continues.
We learn all our lives.
That's it.
I educate my children
outside the walls.
I don't put them
in a box.
They're outside the walls
in the sense that
we learn in everyday life.
We learn all our lives.
We learn on Saturdays.
We learn at 7 in the morning.
We learn at 10 in the evening.
We seize the opportunity.
We're curious.
The children speak
three languages
because we're used to
being in Italy,
so they speak three languages.
The fact that I'm
open to that,
the fact that I
became Italian,
at some point
the children
imitate you.
It's openness.
So the role of a parent
is the attitude
in relation to
education
or learning.
Whether at school
or not at school.
It's my mother
who teaches me.
Then it's me
who decides
what I want to do.
Then my mother
helps me realize it.
For example,
I want to do
herbalistry.
So my mother
helped me
find courses
in English
and organizations
to help me
learn that.
For example,
alchemy.
I mean chemistry.
Alchemy too.
Chemistry.
Then my mother
bought me
a science kit.
I can do that
at home.
Also,
I do archery
because I wanted
to do that.
Otherwise,
I do a lot of other
things.
One of my
great passions
is archery.
I love archery.
One of my
great passions
is history.
So I have a lot
of manuals on that.
I often
look at Wikipedia.
There,
in general,
history in general.
I went to New York
recently.
Also,
for my birthday,
we went on a trip
to Washington.
So I went to see
some beautiful
museums in Washington.
You see
he's at home
in the museums.
He's been frequent
since he was little.
Everywhere we go,
we travel a lot.
We hang out a lot.
From the smallest
museums
to the biggest ones.
But you're talking
about the museums.
Yes.
So it's a source
of learning
and pleasure,
of discovery
that we use a lot.
The houses of culture
as well.
The libraries.
We go to the National
Library
twice a week.
Even though
Dad has to go
look for other books
because he's
going to work
and we don't even
have time
to go to the library.
That's right.
Yes.
Yes,
I go to the
National Library
a lot.
Yes,
I read a lot.
It's one of my
great passions.
He gets information
from a lot of
different sources.
And with all the
information he gets,
at some point
he makes up
his own opinion.
Yes.
And today,
at 14,
on a lot of
subjects,
Loïc knows
a lot more
than I do.
Because he's
very independent
and these are
subjects
that he's passionate about
and that interest him
a lot.
He focuses a lot
more than I do.
By the way,
it's funny
because I'm sure
there are parents
and even teachers
in high school
who encourage
teenagers
to be interested
in politics,
to be interested
in reading
newspapers,
to listen to
the news.
For me,
it's rather
the opposite.
At some point,
I say to Loïc,
Loïc,
that's enough,
I think,
the news.
But he responds
to me with,
I don't know,
Mom,
propaganda
and the real news.
Because for me,
it's the government's
propaganda
that worries me a little.
But no,
I think that
he's actually
quite an independent
citizen,
able to
forge his own way.
I didn't buy
a class book
before the third year.
The third year,
I said,
what are the others doing?
I went to see them
and I did
a full manual
in French
for the first time
with my third,
because she
had more difficulties.
She was in Italy,
there were three languages
at some point,
you know.
So she,
I remember,
she was 8 or 9 years old.
Sincerely,
I'm going to say it,
on the screen,
I don't use
any resources
in French
from Quebec
at the ministry level.
Period.
OK?
It's my privilege
to choose my material.
I have some
in several languages.
I have some
from different countries.
And I wanted something
that,
I learned French
with the French
of my children.
I mean,
I learned things,
yes,
but I didn't go to school
at all,
and I was
in a private school.
What is positive
about Quebec,
I really like
is that we do science.
Not necessarily
in the classroom books,
it's not
worse than anywhere else.
At the internet level,
at the creativity level
in Quebec,
in science,
maybe because
the school gives it
so little importance
and we want to
give it
importance
in science.
There was,
I think there was
a surge
in science.
I think it's unique
right now
in Quebec.
It's fabulous.
I use it a lot.
But science,
sincerely,
I took the bull
by the horns
and I set up
science camps.
I mean,
every year,
it's going to be
the fourth year,
the fifth,
the fourth year,
I bring together
forty,
fifty children
with their parents.
Everyone is committed.
Everyone is there.
I don't take,
there's no one
who gives me a little.
No one.
You come because
you have to take care
of everyone.
For a family
from a home school,
I find the reform,
the beautiful intersections
and the SAA,
I have time
to do it at home.
At school,
there's no time.
Well, listen,
there are beautiful projects.
I would like
there to be beautiful
projects like that
in science,
but you have to
go on the Internet
and there are
other things.
There are beautiful projects.
At school,
it's just very difficult
to put it in place.
They have to block
three-hour blocks,
classes skip.
We set up
three-hour blocks
at school.
They were 12 to 16 years old.
And I had the two little guys,
9 years old,
who played the two
little surfers.
Listen,
we didn't have to blow.
It was fabulous.
I tried with the school
director to get
them to play at school,
you know,
to go do it.
And she was super interested.
She said,
well,
secondary 1, 2, 3,
it's useless,
they won't be able
to do that.
And she said,
secondary 4 and 5
are scattered,
that is to say
that the groups
are breaking up
to go into the options.
I take the kids
out of school,
I take them to the CNA.
There's a teacher
for $5,
who offers money,
$5 to go listen
to an opera
for a kid.
OK?
There's not a Quebecer
in 1,200 seats.
Quebecers aren't
interested in opera.
We saw
Le Barbier Civil,
Les Noces de Figaro,
Don Juan,
Othello,
Macbeth.
OK?
And there's one
for young audiences
that's free.
You just have to
sign up in time.
You know,
the little red ribbon,
the little red ribbon
in opera.
There's no Quebecer.
And in the Parc de la Gatineau,
there are free workshops
in terms of nature.
They're absolutely fabulous.
It's extraordinary
the resources they have.
And she told me,
we went this year,
she said,
there aren't any
Quebecer classes.
They all come from
Ontario.
And when I talk to
the teacher,
because I met her
for the evaluation,
she said,
we can't.
She said,
we're so taken
by the evaluation.
She said,
we can't lose
any more classes.
For them,
it's a waste
of class time.
The Quebecers
go to the book fair.
It's chaos.
It's all they do.
It's the only
outing they do
each year.
There was a time
when they went
to museums.
They don't do that anymore.
And for me,
in Outaouais,
museums are
absolutely extraordinary.
I don't know
if you've been there.
I mean,
it's a must.