Produite, réalisée et écrite par le Québécois Mathieu Côté-Desjardins, cette websérie documentaire de 2010 (sélectionnée aux Prix Gémeaux comme finaliste en 2011) suit le créateur de la série étant nouvel enseignant fraîchement sorti de l'université. Dès les premiers jours de classe, il s'est demandé comment on pouvait offrir si peu de qualité aux jeunes. Puisant dans ses quelques expériences en cinéma et son maigre salaire de nouveau prof (et d'un emprunt bancaire de plusieurs dizaines de milliers de dollars), il décide de s'acheter une caméra vidéo, ce qu'il faut pour faire du montage et se met à filmer divers entretiens divers intervenants du système scolaire (et d'autres nullement liés à ce domaine). « Suis-je fou de penser que le système scolaire n'a aucun sens » ? Exutoire et thérapie sous format documentaire qui fut le premier pan dans sa quête de percer le mystère de la véritable éducation. Une saison 2, intitulée, LA RÉÉDUCATION, est aussi disponible sur Gan Jing World dans cette chaîne.
I had a student who gave me the image,
and he wasn't talking about the Ministry of Education,
he was talking about the mystery of education.
Because he couldn't understand how a Ministry of Education
could impose a school reform from the top,
when it's the teachers who are in classes with real young people
who know the evolution of the needs of young people.
Thirty years ago, my daughter-in-law, at the time,
was used to saying,
the school is not neutral, it is too neutral,
it follows the path of the system that created it.
And that says exactly what it says.
The school, in other words, is very ideological,
contrary to what we claim.
Terms that were used for the Ministry of Education.
In 1964, it was the Ministry of Education.
In 1985, we changed it to the Ministry of Higher Education,
Science and Technology.
In 1985, it also became the Ministry of Higher Education and Science.
Then, in 1993, the Ministry of Education and Science.
In 1994, we changed it again to the Ministry of Education.
And finally, in 2005,
it became the Ministry of Education, Leisure and Sport.
The title of the Ministry of Education, Leisure and Sport,
already shows that with education,
we don't have enough to take care of.
We need to add leisure and sport.
When we talk about the Ministry of Industry and Commerce,
it deserves to be clear.
The Ministry doesn't make a lot of effort
to promote the teaching staff in general.
They give themselves good awareness once a year
by organizing the Teacher's Week.
For example, last year,
students were called to write a text about their teacher.
And the winner of that was a figure in the TV novel Virginie.
It's also a bit of an ambiguous message.
Is the Ministry trying to reveal what's going on in Virginie?
Or to say,
Virginie is the only image of a modern teacher.
I always find that a bit suspicious.
It's the same as the Secretaries' Week.
This week, we have to thank our secretary
and buy her flowers.
But it won't increase her salary and recognition.
It's just a moment where we say,
bravo, thank you for being there
and thank you for doing everything I ask you to do.
It's almost a way of infantilizing teachers.
Working with people from the Ministry of Education,
I realize that there is a huge political weight
around education.
In recent years,
there has been a parade of ministers of education.
We are behind compared to Ontario.
We are behind compared to the United States.
How are we behind?
In terms of money.
Over there, students pay more.
And so,
universities are better financed.
If they are better financed,
they provide better quality services.
And so, we in Quebec,
we are underfinanced because students don't pay as much
as Ontarians and Americans.
Etc.
And they add, without laughing,
there is no proof
that paying more for your studies
reduces your access to the university.
No.
No correlation.
Whereas any bear,
any orignal,
you tell it,
you will pay twice as much for your studies,
and half of these bears and orignals
will understand that they can't afford to pay for their studies.
Twice as much,
they can pay half as much,
but not twice as much.
And they forget in this report
that Ontario paid a high price.
A 40% drop in access to Ontarian universities
since the government of Mike Harris.
The first question we have to ask
when we say we have to abolish the school commissions
is what we are going to replace them with.
And what we are going to replace them with
is a certain number of very important decisions.
That is, if you remove the school commissions,
the schools at that time
will depend directly on Quebec
and the civil servants.
But the civil servants who are in Quebec
are very far from Montreal
and from any region of Quebec
that you want.
And they are special people.
We just have to see how they are distributed
in general elections.
They are very close to them.
If you remove all the commissioners in Quebec,
they are people of goodwill
in most cases.
In a number of non-negligible cases,
they are people who are only there
to progress elsewhere.
That is, they show up at the school
because they consider it the least important level.
After that, they will show up at the municipal level
because it is better paid, not bad.
Because a school commissioner is not paid.
Well, it's paid, but like that,
it's tiny.
Yet it generates big budgets.
But people show up at the municipal level
and after that they leave.
It's as if people had a political career profile.
Which I find quite catastrophic.
Because deep down,
when I was a commissioner, I was 13 years old,
people asked me,
why don't you become a politician?
And I said, I am a politician.
I am even at the level of the government
or the most important level of the gang,
excuse the expression.
It's the school, it's our children.
There is nothing more important than that.
But people don't consider it important.
Because, first of all,
we don't know what the powers of a school commissioner are.
And I would say that the powers of the time
when I was there,
they were immense.
But most of Quebec's commissioners
didn't know the powers.
Most of the commissioners let the general director
do the work.
The general director would say,
we can't do this or that,
and then all the commissioners would collapse.
Any decision, pedagogical,
construction,
anything you can imagine,
personnel, anything,
it's the commissioners who have the power.
A bank next to the ministry,
it guaranteed that I would never,
in the attempts to limit the scammers,
say to the government,
well, it's time to educate people
so that they become people
who will cooperate together,
who will work together to get by,
because there are no other methods.