Did Europeans get Curved Swords WRONG?

Ancient Swords
6 followers
16 Video Views·Feb 7, 2026
The shape of a curved sword blade is not as simple as some people think, and while Persian, Indian and Turkish blades really perfected the style, many European curved swords got it wrong!
AI Generated·May contain errors
So it's often said that curved blades are superior cutters and certainly really curved blades can
look really really awesome. Sometimes a curved blade can be a little bit silly. So here we're
going to look at why is this curved blade less effective than that curved blade and it's actually
more complicated than you might realize. Hi folks, Matt Easton here, Scholar Gladiatoria and Eastern
Antique Arms. Now I'm going to be handling a mixture of both antique and modern replica blades
here. But the key factor between them is that they have all got curved blades and we're not
just looking at slightly curved blades, we're looking at really curved blades and how curved
blades have to be curved to perform in the way that they're supposed to perform. But first of all
we need to explain why have a really curved blade. So the first thing that people always say
is that curved blades cut more effectively than straight blades. Is this fundamentally true?
Not exactly. Straight blades can bisect things just as well as curved blades but curved blades
do have some cutting advantages. These essentially come down to three factors. The first factor is
that if you are hitting a target with a very curved blade like this it means that the edge
bevel is meeting the target at an oblique or slanted angle. That means that say for example
we had a 40 degree edge bevel here, if that is angled at 45 degrees, that is diagonally,
then it's as if the edge angle was only 20 degrees. It's like walking diagonally up a hill
instead of straight up a hill. The second big advantage to this is if the entirety of the
upper part of the blade here, we'll get to that in a second, is curved then not only have you
hit the target here but as it passes into or through or past the target the edge becomes
even more angled and even more slanting as you go along which means that the edge angle becomes
effectively even smaller. Number one and number two it means that the blade naturally draws a
cross and out of the target which of course is famously a huge advantage on horseback when you
might be moving at speed and you're hitting the target in such a way while your horse is still
moving on that the blade will draw through and out of the target instead of getting stuck on it.
And of course this also increases the length of the wound it might not increase the depth of the
wound and there's a big difference between a straight blade and a curved blade as straight
blade might go through the target or it might stop in the target whereas a curved blade will
cut into the target and draw in and out so it creates generally speaking not always generally
speaking a longer channel whereas the straight blade will very often create a deeper channel.
There's another other big advantage the third big advantage to curved blades and that is to do
with indexing quite simply a bit like a weather vane or if even an axe or anything like that where
you have an asymmetry in the plane of or rather the direction in which you are holding the object
so as I move this around because not everything is in a straight line from the grip and up through
the blade it curves off it's much like like a weather vane or a flag you can feel the direction
in which that is pointing that means that naturally when you swing the thing it will point
in the right direction that means that the edge will be perfectly aligned or very close to perfectly
aligned with the thing that you're hitting relative to the movement of the actual weapon itself which
increases your chances of ensuring good edge alignment with a straight blade and particularly
with narrow blades like rapiers or side swords very often it's easy or easier to mess up the
edge alignment and of course if the edge is not perfectly aligned with the direction of motion
you're not going to cut maybe at all or certainly you're not going to cut as well if the edge is
perfectly aligned you're more likely to go into and potentially through or at least slice across
the target now before we will go into what makes a really good curvature in a very curved sword or a
not so good a less a less effective curvature in a very curved sword just a couple of other
advantages given that we've just reeled through the other main advantages of very curved swords
and they are to do with wearing and access of the sword so one of the things is that curved swords
because they curve up and around like this particularly very curved swords if they're worn
edge down this wouldn't apply if they were worn edge up incidentally but if they're worn edge down
that means that when you're wearing the thing the point comes up and away from either the ground or
the horse that you might be riding in fact if you tilt the blade in towards you here it comes around
your body that has a couple of well it has several really big advantages it means that for the length
of the blade it occupies less kind of horizontal or lateral space so it's less likely to bang
against the side of the horse it's less likely to bang against the ground when you're walking
it's less likely to hit things like your stirrups or your spurs when you're getting on and off horses
repeatedly and indeed if you're something like a horse archer and you're operating a bow of whatever
length it is whether it's a short Turkish bow or a longer Japanese or Manchu bow or whatever
you're operating a bow or you're using pole arms like spears or glaives two-handed from horseback
it means that the sword takes up less space for its amount of length of blade by bending that
blade you occupy less space and therefore it's easier to wear in all sorts of ways finally
accessing a curved blade because when you draw a sword it naturally moves in an arc of movement
a curved sword is easier not necessarily the sheath as you saw there but it is easier to access
quickly and remember there's a big virtue of swords is that they're side arms and worn at the side and
they are very often backup weapons to something like a bow or a lance or a glaive or pole axe or
whatever so if you're using that primary weapon but in the moment in which your primary weapon
for example a bow you come into close combat and someone attacks you with a hand weapon well the
bow can't defend you then or indeed if you're using a lance bam and it goes into someone and
gets stuck and you lose it out of your hand in that moment you have to access the sword quickly
a curved sword comes out super quick because it follows the arc of movement of the arm so at the
beginning of the video I mentioned that some curved swords are rather silly and less effective
than they could be if they'd been curved in a certain other way and this is where we get into
the nitty-gritty of what makes a good very curved sword or a not so good or in some cases even bad
very curved sword now before we explain that just to set some context most of the swords that we
describe as curved swords and that you'll see on this channel are only slightly curved most cavalry
sabers are only slightly curved like this anglo-indian cavalry saber here or indeed if I
grab this indian talwar here most indian talwars despite the fact that everyone would think of
them as a curved sword are only really slightly curved similar to a typical european cavalry
saber and with the very slightly curved swords and i would put katana and tachi and wakasashi
into that category or indeed most chinese dao as well with the only slightly curved swords you only
get a little bit of the advantage of the very curved swords but also you only get a little bit
of the disadvantage of the very curved swords as well so what you're doing with a very slightly
curved sword is a little bit of the advantage a little bit of the disadvantage and therefore also
some of the advantages of straight swords you can still relatively easily use the point because
they're still relatively in line with the hand so to put those aside we're going to come back
to the very curved swords so what i'm holding here is a type of sword called a shamshir
now this is commonly thought of as a arabic or a middle eastern type of sword in fact the
shamshir is actually particular to persia and later to india so we regard this as an indo-persian
weapon in fact in the arabic countries they more often used what's called a safe which is the arabic
word for sword which tends to be a little bit more talwar shapes tends to be a little bit less
curved than this the very curved form of shamshir here which is comes from the word for a lion's
tail is actually associated with persia although as mentioned it spread to india and it spread to
the rest of the ottoman empire and indeed the arabic countries it spread out to places like
egypt and syria and so on so forth so this type of sword was very popular even in areas where they
had other forms of sword like the safe or the kilich for example this sword was also very
popular and of course it was popular in europe used by high-ranking european officers particularly
after the egyptian campaign during the napoleonic wars so this form of sword this is an indian one
incidentally but it's very similar to the to the persian original ones so the curvature of the
blade so this is what we're particularly looking at now a lot of people when they make replicas of
these or indeed europeans in the 19th century who were making swords with very curved blades
that thought that they were making a shamshir style blade get something really important wrong
if you look at the curvature it is not simply the edge of a circle it's actually more complicated
than that the first half of the blade if i isolate it there is actually almost straight so what we
actually have in this a very similar idea with the ottoman pala or kilich as well so if we look
at the grip here it comes in a straight line along here and it comes in a straight line to my hand
so what you're achieving there is essentially reach okay now reach with the sword is very
important because if you don't have extra reach with a sword you may as well use a knife or a
dagger okay so one of the reasons that swords have long blades yes it's to do with leverage but
it's also very importantly to do with reach so you are creating reach with that first part of
the blade that's essentially in a straight line from the hilt or grip here but after that we then
have the arc of a circle so rather than this being a full arc of a circle it is instead part
of an arc of a circle about let's say an eight a quarter or a fifth of a circle here attached to
an approximately straight first portion of the blade why do you do this well again it comes back
to reach it means that the portion of the blade that you're cutting with which isn't down here
it's up here the portion of the blade that you're cutting with the section of the circle the arc
is connected to your straight bit so essentially it's a bit like an axe this is the shaft of the
axe this is the blade of the axe it means that the part of the blade that needs to be curved is
curved but the part of the blade that wants to give you the greatest reach is more or less or
very close to being straight i'll just put the uh antique down carefully for a second and i'll pick
up this replica which has been very well done by lk chen which does exactly that same thing that's
how you tell that this is a good replica of a shamshir because the first portion of the blade
exactly like that antique i just showed is almost straight in line with the grip so we achieve the
reach of the sword with the first part and very much this is important on horseback of course
because it's harder to reach things on horseback they're further away and then we have the section
of the circle this one's not quite as curved as the antique i showed but the section of the circle
is the end bit here so in other words when we're on horseback or on foot when we're cutting out we
achieve the reach with the first let's say 18 inches of the blade and then the second uh approximately
10 to 12 inches of the blade is curved and that's the part that's meeting the target cutting it
drawing through drawing past if you don't have those two things if you have the curvature too
soon you rob yourself of reach now i mentioned bad replicas as i mentioned in the 19th century
particularly although this does also go back to the even the 17th and 18th centuries in some cases
but in the 19th century europeans often tried to copy eastern style swords okay so if we're looking
at north africa and the middle east in those areas where the shamshir was used um they knew how to
make those blades and over hundreds of years they had developed that type of blade to work very well
but the europeans weren't as au fait to use a french expression with the curvature of the sword
now what is this sword this is a highly unusual and very rare spanish sword so i'll see i don't
know if you'll be able to see on screen but i will attempt to help you do so you can see there that
this was made in toledo and so this is a toledo made very curved sword this was made in 1878 at
the royal artillery factory in fact and this is one of a pair of swords i'll show you it's got the
arms of castile and leon there so it's got the spanish coat of arms and it's got really nice
etched and formerly gilded you can see some gilding remaining in the recesses there so this
is a really cool sword probably a presentation sword in fact i have a pair of them that came
together they have been sharpened um service sharpened who were they made for why were they
made like this i don't know but they're not the only very curved swords that we get from europe
you also find what some people refer to as flank officer sabers which they're not really they're
just a form of napoleonic um usually often rifles actually or infantry officers swords that have
similarly curved scimitar blades as they referred to them scimitar is a derivation of the word
chamshir and you will notice that the curvature is wrong and this is very often the case with
european swords which were mimicking and trying to allude to the persian or indo-persian chamshir
and the curvature on these blades is subtly but importantly different okay the europeans
often got this wrong so you will notice that look at the grip here the curvature actually starts
way too soon now i'm not saying that this it couldn't be used as an effective sword
of course you could absolutely use this as an effective sword it would still cut well
and it would still have most of the advantages of a very curved sword but because they didn't
have the culture of very curved swords in this case in spain in some cases britain italy france
wherever germany they curved the blade too soon and what that does is it robs you of reach
because we'd have all of the advantages of this curved cutting blade here if this portion of the
blade was straighter like it would be in a chamshir or an ottoman pala or kilich but we'd have greater
reach so what they've done here is they've created what's actually quite a long piece of steel and
they have bent it so far around that we've rubbed ourselves of huge amounts of reach with no real
advantage because we don't need the curvature down here where we need the curvature is up here
because this is the portion of the blade that we're actually cutting with so there we go it is
actually a slightly more complicated subject than most people think hopefully i've outlined the main
advantages of curved swords but also how the people the cultures that had really refined the
use of extremely curved swords like this chamshir here really understood how and where to put the
curvature in the blade which europeans in this case like the spanish didn't always really
understand anyway i hope that's been educational for some of you please make sure you're subscribed
i have been matt easton i will of course continue to be and i hope i'll see you back on the channel
again really soon cheers folks thanks for watching we've got extra videos on patreon
please give our facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already cheers folks
