Install Raid for Free :white_check_mark: Mobile and PC: https://clik.cc/qJLzi and get a special starter pack :boom: Available only for the next 30 days :boom:
When Caesar died on the Ides of March, he closed the door on many ambitious plans which would have significantly altered the trajectory of the Roman Empire and of our history. Thus far in our alternate history scenario we have sought to explore the case where Julius Caesar survived with a discussion of his Dacian Campaign, an interbellum period in Rome, a precursor invasion of Armenia, and now the final climactic assault upon the Parthian Empire.
Considering how far out we have departed from real history we now take a branching approach to our narrative to consider several potential outcomes of this Parthian War. What do you think would have happened to Julius Caesar?
Credits: Research = Chris Das Neves Script = Invicta Narration = Invicta Artwork = Penta Limited
When Julius Caesar was suddenly assassinated on the Ides of March in 44 BC,
he left behind many unfinished plans, which could have had a dramatic impact on history.
Among the most ambitious of these was the summoning of a vast army to wage war against
the Parthian Empire. In our previous episodes, we laid the groundwork for this event, which began
with a campaign into Dacia, an interbellum period of consolidation in Rome, and a precursor invasion
of Armenia. Now, we shall endeavor to bring this great expedition to life, and attempt to read the
tea leaves regarding the ultimate fate of Julius Caesar, as well as the fallout of this alternate
timeline. Exploring alternate history timelines can be a fascinating mental exercise, but all
this hypothesizing from the general's armchair can leave you craving action. And what better
way to get that rush than to build a team from over 600 champions to fight epic bosses or explore
mysterious dungeons? You can find all this adventure and more through our sponsor Raid
Shadow Legends, available on mobile and PC. The game offers a ton of ways to play, with my top
three themed champions being the following, Sir Nicholas for his insane tankiness and buffs,
Cleopteryx for her awesome model and hybrid role, and Norag for his sheer brutality.
Having this amount of options is one of my favorite game features. Test your mettle in this
month's schedule of special events and activities, including Forge Pass Season 3. These come with
amazing rewards such as a limited edition artifact set. In addition, Madam Ceres is getting
new skins, while Death Knight finally ascends to the status of Legendary Champion. There's never
been a better time to get started, so new players, use my link or scan the QR code right here and get
a free starter pack worth almost $30, the free champion Aina, and also this added in-game loot.
You'll find your rewards here in your inbox for the next 30 days only. Enjoy!
Our narrative thus far has followed a single alternate history timeline, whose trajectory was
based on the following two inputs. One, reports of Caesar's plans prior to his assassination,
as recorded by the first century historians Appian, Plutarch, and Suetonius, and two, the
outcome of similar historical events from the era such as Trajan's Dacian War and Antony's Parthian
Campaign. This approach presented a fairly reasonable reconstruction of an alternate
timeline. Naturally, however, the further we stray from actual history, the more our uncertainty
builds. At this point, we have made it to the middle of 43 BC, a year and three months past
the Ides of March. In doing so, I would say that we have waded to the end of the shallows of our
imagination and are now looking out into the deep. But rather than get in over our heads
with speculation, it will now be more appropriate to split our single alternate timeline into
several branches which will diverge based on the potential outcome of key events.
With this framework in mind, let us now proceed.
Our narrative had left off in the middle of 43 BC. Caesar had taken control of Armenia,
but was significantly delayed in the process. As he set about securing his holdings and preparing
his next moves, it would be the Parthians who seized the initiative with a counterattack
against Syria. This offensive is based on a real event which took place in 39 BC when
Prince Bacchurus led an invasion to capitalize on Roman distractions following Caesar's death.
For our exercise, we can consider what various degrees of success or failure might mean in the
context of this key event. On one end of the spectrum will be the critical success of Bacchurus.
Historically, this is what happened at the outset of the campaign when the prince led forces to
take virtually the whole of the Levant. In doing so, he defeated Roman garrisons and the armies
of Herodian Judea which attempted to offer resistance. Should this same feat be achieved
in our scenario, it would have dealt a crippling blow to Caesar's supply lines. The general would
now be stranded in Armenia and forced to double back to deal with the threat. Doing so would have
been quite dangerous with the Parthian king who remained on his flank. As the Roman columns stretch
out across Armenia, they would only expose themselves to more raids and counterattacks
by the mobile Easterners. Were Caesar to be killed in any of these actions, then the fallout would
certainly be quite tumultuous. For now, we'll avoid opening that can of worms. Instead, we can
consider the case where Caesar remains alive, but the Parthians are able to hold the line and take
ground through the end of the campaigning season. Though at a stalemate, this stalling of the
invincible Imperator's momentum would be seen as a sign of weakness which others might now seek to
exploit. The Dacians, for instance, who had only ever been arm-wrestled into a truce, might take
this chance to reclaim the lands they had lost by sweeping across the Danube and into Thrace.
Such offensives could trigger others to do the same across Rome's frontiers and could very well
destabilize much of the empire. Ultimately, this would undercut the Caesarian government's promises
of stability and cause internal unrest that his political rivals could then exploit.
In this branch of alternate history, the threats against Caesar will have been greatly multiplied.
While he certainly might be able to negotiate these dangers, it's not hard to imagine things
spiraling out of control. Loss in battle might mean an immediate death, while even survival
could leave him mortally wounded in a political sense. But now let us consider another branching
of history. What if the Parthian attack was a critical failure? This would be similar to what
happened at the tail end of the actual invasion, when the Roman commander Huvlis Ventidius Bassus
turned the tide on the Parthians and managed to kill Prince Bacchus at the Battle of Mount
Gandaras. In our alternate timeline, such a feat might be replicated by Caesar himself or one of
his various lieutenants operating out of Syria. As happened historically, the loss of the crown
prince caused a succession crisis as the grief-stricken Parthian king Arodes II relinquished
the throne to his other son, Frates IV, who in short order conducted a bloody purge of the royal
family to consolidate power. Such a situation would have been mercilessly exploited by Caesar,
who was a master at driving wedges between factions within the opposition. Doing so against
the Parthians may have meant that his armies could more easily descend into Upper Mesopotamia.
From here, he might make a play for the capital through outright conquest or could negotiate with
disaffected Parthian nobles to strike a deal that might have them placed on the throne in exchange
for concessions to the Romans. Back home, this would all have been good news for Caesar's
administration, which could continue to consolidate its power without the distractions of the critical
success scenario we previously explored. In terms of our ongoing narrative for this video, we can
plot a theoretical course somewhere between these two ends of the spectrum. This would mean that
while the Parthian invasion met some success, it was only ever a temporary delay that kept the
Romans at bay for at most a year without significant losses to either side's military, economic, or
political ability to wage war. Caesar will still have been eager to press forward with his planned
campaign and might have used this time to better prepare for such an attack.
Thus, in March of 42 BC, his armies would begin their invasion. The exact route of this campaign
is subject to interpretation. Contemporary accounts of Caesar's plans are vague on this
front and anything documented would have been subject to change given the outcomes we've assumed
thus far. That being said, the most straightforward approach would have been to descend from the
Armenian highlands in one or more prongs with the aim of securing the region of northern Mesopotamia.
This would have been similar to the later campaigns of Trajan who took the area with
overwhelming force and the methodical construction of forts to secure his rear lines. The emperor
took time to make his advances, securing the new frontier in his first year before pushing south
the following year. Caesar may have taken a similar approach, but given his preference for
aggressive, decisive action, it is likely that he would have wished to make it to the Parthian
capital of Ctesiphon as soon as possible. To this end, his vast army which consisted of 16 legions
now backed by 20,000 Armenians would have first forced the submission of the kingdom of Austerine
to secure their back line. Surely the diplomatic groundwork was laid for this move which would
have meant a near immediate surrender of this most exposed territory within a few weeks or at most a
few months. Some forces were left behind to secure the area and reinforce the southern approaches
along the Euphrates. The remaining Roman force meanwhile would then have swung east towards the
Tigris where they might advance with the relative safety of the mountainous region on their flank.
Here, legions would likely have split into several divisions to take strategic objectives
along the invasion route. This included the prominent cities of Nisibis, Zingara, and Arbella.
Such moves would have been closely monitored by the Parthians who took every opportunity to harry
them along the way. However, it is debatable whether they would yet risk a pitched battle at
this point. Better to let the invaders stretch themselves thin and wait for a slip-up before
striking a decisive blow. Caesar, however, was a veteran of many campaigns and would not present
many such opportunities by keeping his forces tightly controlled and well informed of their
surroundings. Sensing the enemy's timidity in this stance, he would have continued the thrust
towards Ctesiphon which would force them to contest his move. By this point, the timeline will have
advanced to at least midway through the campaign season. Our next key event will involve the Battle
of Ctesiphon. It's impossible to know where this may have taken place. Perhaps the Parthians wish
to fight the Romans in the more open fields beyond the capital or perhaps they would rather strike
them with a hammer blow while closer to the anvil of the capital's defenses. In a long history of
warfare between the Romans and the Parthians and Sassanids, there are countless battle sites
littered across Mesopotamia to choose from. With regards to Ctesiphon itself, the city played host
to many showdowns, being directly threatened more than a dozen times and actually taken by force six
times. We can now attempt to play out a couple options for Caesar's timeline. On the critical
failure end of the spectrum would be a total defeat prior to even touching the walls. This
might occur in a similar manner to Emperor Severus' campaign in 233 AD, when his army was crippled
with indiscipline and disease before eventually being surrounded. Here is how Herodian puts it,
quote, Ardashir attacked the Roman army unexpectedly with his entire force and trapped
them like fish in a net. The outnumbered Romans were unable to stem the attack of the Persian
horde. They used their shields to protect those parts of their bodies exposed to the Persian
arrows. Content merely to protect themselves, they offered no resistance. As a result, all the Romans
were driven into one spot, where they made a wall with their shields and fought like an army under
siege. Hit and wounded from every side, they held out bravely as long as they could, but in the end
all were killed. In this timeline, such a loss could easily claim Caesar's life through a battlefield
wound, some disease, or perhaps some mutinous element within his own ranks. Even if he did
survive, he would then have to make the arduous retreat back to upper Mesopotamia and then spend
many months attempting to hold on to his gains before even thinking of retaking the offensive.
I wouldn't put a comeback past him at this point, but as with our earlier divergence, any major
military setback would risk a spiraling situation across the empire that might ultimately doom him.
On the other end of the spectrum will be the critical success. Again, we can turn to the
example of historical campaigns of Emperor Trajan and Julian for reference. In both cases, they
advanced upon Ctesiphon with a large support fleet, with various canals being dug to facilitate their
approach. In both cases, the enemy encamped on the opposite bank, resisting their advances and making
any direct attack difficult. Thus it was that the Romans had to make a forced crossing to establish
a beachhead which eventually precipitated a pitched battle. Here is how the historian Ammianus
Marcellinus describes Julian's experiences which might have been comparable to our hypothetical
Caesar. Quote, he unloaded the stronger ships of those which carried provisions and artillery and
manned them each with 800 armed soldiers. In the first quiet of night, he sent one part with orders
speedily to cross the river and take possession of the enemy's side of the stream. But no sooner had
they reached the opposite bank than they were assailed so persistently with firebrands and every
kind of inflammable material that ships and soldiers would have been consumed had not the
emperor, carried away by the keen vigor of his spirit, cried out that our soldiers had, as directed,
raised the signal that they were already in possession of the shore and ordered the entire
fleet to hasten to the spot with all speed of their oars. The result was that the ships were
saved uninjured and the surviving soldiers, although assailed from above with stones and every kind of
unyieldingly. The Persians opposed to us serried bands of male-clad horsemen in such close order
that the gleam of moving bodies covered with densely fitting plates of iron dazzled the eyes
of those who looked upon them, while the whole throng of horse was protected by coverings of
leather. The cavalry was backed by companies of infantry who, protected by oblong curved shields
covered with wicker wick and raw hides, advanced in very close order. Hereupon the emperor,
following Homeric tactics, filled the space between the lines with the weakest of the infantry.
When both sides were near enough to look each other in the face, the Romans gleaming in their
crested helmets and swinging their shields, as if to the rhythm of the anapastic foot,
advanced slowly and the light-armed skirmishers opened the battle by hurling their javelins
while the earth everywhere was turned to dust by both sides and swept away in a swift whirlwind.
And when the battle cry was raised in the usual manner by both sides and the trumpet's
blare increased the ardor of the men, here and there they fought hand to hand with spears and
swords, and the soldiers were freer from the danger of the arrows the more quickly they forced
their way into the enemy's ranks. Meanwhile the emperor was busily engaged in giving support to
those who gave way and in spurring on the laggards, playing the part both of a valiant fellow soldier
and of a commander. Finally the first battle line of the Persians began to waver, and at first slowly,
then at quick step, turned back and made for the neighboring city with their armor well heated up.
Our soldiers pursued them, weary though they also were after fighting on the scorching plains from
sunrise to the end of the day, and falling close at their heels and hacking at their legs and backs
drove the whole force in headlong flight to the very walls of Ctesiphon. In this scenario Caesar
may have been able to ride the momentum of victory to take the Parthian capital without a drawn-out
and bloody siege. Such an event would be excellent fodder for his propaganda where he might now be
able to play the part of the triumphant but benevolent liberator. As he paraded through the
streets of Ctesiphon he would surely have been thinking of the similar entry that his hero
Alexander the Great had made into Babylon 289 years before. But as was the case with the
Macedonians, merely taking control of Mesopotamia would not be enough to defeat the masters of the
east. Vast lands yet extended out to the borders of India from which the enemy might yet still mount
a defense. The challenge would certainly have excited Caesar, who previously at the age of 31
had once bemoaned that he had achieved so little when compared to Alexander the Great.
Now would be his chance to not just follow in the footsteps of the hero but to perhaps even
surpass him and in so doing achieve everlasting fame. But that timeline is not one we will further
explore. Instead let us consider once more the middle path between critical success and critical
failure. Admittedly there are many timelines to choose from within this range. We will consider
the case where Caesar is able to leverage his army's vast size and engineering skills to drive
a wedge between the Parthian army and Ctesiphon, eventually managing to strangle it into submission
as had been done at Alicia. In this case he is able to take the city after a grueling effort
but not to outright defeat the enemy's main army. Thus he will be able to claim a symbolic victory
and win-turn Ctesiphon at the end of 42 BC. At this point however his forces very likely will
have been ground down and in need of fresh supplies and manpower. Any efforts to bring
these to Caesar though would have been intercepted by the mobile Parthians and only the largest of
relief forces, perhaps commanded by one of Caesar's trusted lieutenants, could make the journey.
Whatever the case, history shows that it would have been quite difficult for the Romans to
establish a lasting presence in this region. Even for Caesar, matters of logistics and issues on
other frontiers would eventually force a withdrawal. But whether this might take place immediately
or over a matter of months, years or decades is again debatable. Likely Caesar would have found
a way to consolidate his gains in northern Mesopotamia and engage in diplomacy to secure
the new eastern frontier. This might have involved deals with local kingdoms, intermarriages between
prominent figures, and all sorts of geopolitical arrangements. Certainly new provinces would be
formed whose governance could be doled out by Caesar to leverage even more control over the
politicians back at home. Perhaps his would-be assassins might now be brought into the fold of
the administration with eastern postings and invitations to participate in future campaigns.
At the same time, Cleopatra and her son by Caesar, Caesarion, might also be a key piece of the puzzle.
After all, the breadbasket of Egypt would be a key strategic center for supporting activities in the
east and the Ptolemies had deep roots in the region which might be leaned upon for the restructuring of
the region's balance of power. On a macro level, it's interesting to consider what this eastern
focus would have meant for the Roman Empire. After all, this was always a highly prosperous region in
terms of spoils and taxation which promised far greater return on investment than expeditions
into distant Germania and Britannia. Perhaps now that a toehold had been established in the east,
the Roman army would see more sustained deployment in this area of the world.
This in turn might mean no disaster of Teutoburg and no costly Germanic or Britannic wars.
Thus, the trajectory of the Roman Empire might significantly be altered to have an eastern focus
earlier on. The downstream effects that this might have not only on the fate of neighboring
civilizations of the period but also the future emergence of Christianity and Islam in the region
is mind-blowing to even think about. But perhaps the greatest point to consider in this alternate
timeline is what is the eventual fate of Julius Caesar? Having achieved so much and accumulated
untold amounts of power, how does that power get transferred to the next generation?
This was a question which had bedeviled the Romans ever since the real-life assassination
of Caesar. Initially, it took a renewed civil war for Augustus to claim the throne and in so doing
to reforge the Republic into an empire. Even then, the ideas of succession were ever-changing
and turbulent with frequent bouts of fighting. It's hard to guess exactly what direction Caesar
would have steered the realm. However, power, once concentrated, is very difficult to pry free of an
iron fist. Thus, I think that an aging Julius Caesar would have done much the same as Augustus
by slowly repurposing Republican institutions to serve his purposes. His partisans, meanwhile,
would continue to be promoted and his heirs would have been strategically positioned to
maintain the new power structure. In the end, I also find it likely that the transition to
imperialism would have been a natural one given the practicalities of governing such
an expansive domain from Rome. We could go on and on with speculation, but at some point,
Julius Caesar will have perished from injuries, illness, or old age, but what circumstances led
to this event or would lead from it shall have to be left to the oracles of the past.
In any case, I hope you enjoyed our exploration of what if Caesar was not assassinated.
Let me know what other topics you'd like to see us cover next.
A huge thanks to the patrons for funding the channel and to the researchers, writers,
and artists for making this episode possible. Be sure to like and subscribe for more history
and check out these other related episodes. See you in the next one.