Breaking Student Loan News_ Federal Court May End SAVE Plan & All Forgiveness Programs
3 Video Views·Nov 5, 2024
The SAVE Plan and Income Driven Repayment programs face their biggest threat yet. A groundbreaking court case in the Eighth Circuit isn't just challenging the newest student loan forgiveness program - it's questioning whether the Department of Education ever had the authority to forgive loans at all. This unprecedented legal battle could erase 30 years of repayment options, affecting millions of borrowers.
Last week, a federal courtroom in the 8th Circuit became the battleground for an unprecedented
challenge to student loan relief. At stake? Not just the Biden administration's SAVE plan,
but potentially the government's very authority to offer loan forgiveness through repayment
programs. For 30 years, as student debt spiraled from billions to trillions,
administrations responded the same way, with increasingly generous repayment plans.
What started under Clinton as simple payment extensions evolved into complex,
income-driven programs, each trying to keep pace with mounting debt and economic pressures.
But now, for the first time, states are questioning the legal foundation of these
programs themselves. Missouri's lawsuit against the SAVE plan isn't just challenging another
policy. It's challenging whether the Department of Education has the power to offer loan forgiveness
at all. In this video, we'll break down the groundbreaking arguments from last week's court
hearing, examine why states are targeting this specific plan, and explore how this case could
reshape the future of student loan relief in America. To understand the legal arguments at
play, we need to first grasp how federal student loan repayment works.
The government offers a whole suite of repayment options, and they fall into two main categories.
First, you've got your traditional plans. There's the standard plan, typically 10 years of fixed
payments, though it can go longer if you consolidate. Then there's the extended plan,
which stretches payments out to 25 years, to make your payments more manageable. Then there's
a graduated plan, where your payments start low and increase over time. But the real innovation
came with income-driven repayment plans, or IDR for short. Think of IDR as a family of plans that
all share one basic idea. Your monthly payments should be based on what you can actually afford
to pay. It all started with income contingent repayment, or ICR. That was the first plan to
tie payments to a borrower's income. From there, more IDR plans followed. There's income-based
repayment, or IBR. Your payments are capped at either 10 or 15 percent of your discretionary
income, with forgiveness after 20 to 25 years. Then came pay-as-you-earn, or PAY for short.
It caps your payments at 10 percent of your discretionary income, with forgiveness after 20
years. Next was revised pay-as-you-earn, or REPAY. Before it ended, REPAY was similar to PAY,
but it included your spouse's income, even if you filed taxes separately. Like the other plans,
REPAY promised loan forgiveness after 20 or 25 years. And now we have the newest addition,
the SAVE plan. It's the most generous yet. This plan changes not only how we calculate income,
but it also offers some borrowers a faster path to forgiveness, as early as 10 years if
you borrow $12,000 or less. This whole system, and I mean the whole thing, from the traditional plans
to the IDR options, is built on the Higher Education Act of 1965. And now, for the first time,
states are challenging whether the Department of Education has gone too far with these plans.
Missouri is leading the charge, but before we dive into their arguments, let's talk about
something called standing. To bring a case to court, you'll have to prove you'll be harmed.
Missouri's argument? They say the SAVE plan will hurt Mojila, that's their state's loan authority,
by cutting into the fees they collect from servicing student loans. Here's how their
attorney explained it. Now, this sparked an interesting debate in the 8th Circuit courtroom
with Judge Raymond Grunder of heavyweight and conservative legal circles. Appointed by George
Bush in 2004, Grunder was later shortlisted by President Trump as a potential Supreme Court
nominee. When the Department of Education suggested Mojila might actually benefit from the plan,
Judge Grunder pushed back with a crucial question. This question goes to the heart of whether Missouri
even has the right to bring this lawsuit in the first place. Before the court can consider the
substance of Missouri's challenge to the SAVE plan, Missouri must first prove that it has standing to
suit. In this case, Missouri is claiming that it will be financially harmed because the SAVE plan
will cause Mojila to lose revenue. Judge Grunder's skepticism suggests that he may not be convinced
that Missouri has suffered a sufficient injury to give it standing. If the court ultimately rules
that Missouri lacks standing, the case will be dismissed and the court won't even need to address
the larger legal questions about the SAVE plan. But if Missouri clears this initial hurdle and
convinces the court that it has standing, then the case gets even more interesting.
Missouri's main argument against the SAVE plan centers on a legal principle known as the Major
Questions Doctrine. Think of it as a legal speed bump for big government decisions.
Extraordinary assertions of authority like that one require exceedingly clear statements
by Congress. Essentially, the doctrine says that when a government agency like the Department of
Education takes an action that could have huge economic and political consequences,
it needs to have very specific permission from Congress to do so. Missouri argues that Congress
never explicitly authorized widespread student loan forgiveness under the ICR statute. They point
to the fact that the law focuses on repayment plans and doesn't directly mention the possibility
of large-scale loan forgiveness.
To support their argument, Missouri points to other loan forgiveness programs where Congress
did include clear language authorizing forgiveness. For example, Congress was very specific when it
created the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program. Missouri says that the existence of
these other programs where Congress clearly said yes to loan forgiveness shows that Congress didn't
want the Department of Education to forgive loans under the ICR program without explicit permission.
To illustrate their point, Missouri's attorney drew a parallel to a recent case.
Finally, Missouri highlights concerns about the accuracy of the cost estimates provided by the
Department of Education for the SAVE plan. They point to evidence suggesting that the
department significantly underestimated the plan's cost, potentially by hundreds of billions of
dollars, which could have misled Congress when considering its implications. These concerns
seem to resonate with the judges. During oral arguments, Judge Grunger zeroed in on a fundamental
question. What exactly does repayment mean? After all, can you call in a repayment plan if many
borrowers won't actually repay their loans? The exchange that followed cuts straight to
the heart of the case. Let's talk a little bit about that. Prior to the ICR statute,
I think you said 1993. Is it true that the standard repayment was 10 years?
So prior to the ICR, the standard repayment plan was adopted at the same time as ICR.
Congress provided multiple payment options for borrowers under the direct loan program.
One was the standard plan. Another was income contingent repayment.
Were all of those other terms less than 25 years?
The standard payment plan can be no more than 10 years. There's an extended payment plan that can be
no more than 25 years. So tell me why I'm reading this statute wrong. It talks about a variety of
repayment, variety of plans for repayment, not forgiveness, repayment, including principal and
interest on the loan, which sounds like you got to repay all the principal and all the interest.
And then it goes on to talk about the borrower may choose an income contingent repayment plan
with varying annual repayments amounts based on income paid over an extended period of time not to
exceed 25 years. It seems to me, and correct me, but that that's basically saying if you don't
have enough income, the secretary can lower the amounts and extend it, but it still all needs to
be repaid in 25 years instead of the 10 years. Why isn't that the intent of Congress here?
In that clip, you heard the judges appear to be skeptical of the Department of Education's position,
particularly when it comes to calling something a repayment plan, if it's designed to end in
forgiveness. They kept coming back to one key point. If Congress wanted to allow forgiveness,
why didn't they say so explicitly? What made matters worse for the department,
their attorneys seemed unfamiliar with some existing repayment options, like the extended
repayment plan, which already lets borrowers stretch payments over 25 years. They didn't
distinguish that from the different income-driven repayment plans that promised forgiveness.
Basically, this didn't help their argument that forgiveness is necessary for flexibility.
So where does this leave us? The court has several options on the table.
They could block the entire save plan, sending everyone back to square one. They could also
tell the lower court to stop specific parts of the plan, like the shorter path to forgiveness.
Or they might take a more surgical approach, keeping some pieces of the save plan while
striking down others. The stakes, though, couldn't be higher. Millions of borrowers are
watching, waiting to see if this latest attempt at student loan relief will survive its day in court.
Remember that detailed exchange I played for you earlier about repayment plans means?
While judges debate legal definitions, millions of Americans are trying to navigate what is arguably
the most complex consumer loan product ever created. This isn't like a mortgage or a car loan.
Federal student loans are uniquely complicated, a web of overlapping programs,
shifting requirements, and interconnected rules that can drastically impact your monthly payments
and forgiveness eligibility. What other loan product requires you to understand the difference
between FEDL and direct loans, consolidation implications, or how your spouse's income
might affect your payment calculations? The human cost of this uncertainty is staggering.
Borrowers are getting different answers from their loan servicers every time they call.
Some are watching their progress toward forgiveness freeze while they wait for answers.
Others face impossible choices. Turn down a promotion because it might push their income
too high under save? Get divorced to qualify for lower payments? These aren't theoretical
problems. They are kitchen table discussions affecting real families right now.
Behind every page of legal briefs lies a family's financial future.
When borrowers choose their careers, plan their families, or decide where to live,
they did so believing in a simple promise. Make payments based on your income and your loans,
they'll eventually be forgiven. Now that promise hangs in the balance.
In a federal courthouse in the Midwest, judges aren't just weighing the save plan,
they're questioning whether the Department of Education ever had the power to offer loan
forgiveness through repayment programs at all. And here's a twist that many borrowers might not
expect. Changing who's in the White House won't necessarily fix this. Whether Trump or Harris
wins in November, they'll face the same fundamental question. Can any president authorize widespread
loan forgiveness through repayment programs without Congress explicitly saying so?
If courts decide the answer is no, then only Congress can restore these programs through
new legislation, and that's going to be a tall order in today's political climate.
If judges decide the Department of Education never had the authority to offer forgiveness
through repayment plans, three decades of promise could vanish overnight.
For borrowers who built their lives around these programs, the path forward may depend
not on who wins the next election, but whether Congress can finally address the student debt
crisis head on. As a student loan lawyer, I've watched countless cases unfold in federal courts,
but this one's different. While everyone's focused on the oral arguments, the reality
is that the deck was likely stacked against the Department of Education before anyone
stepped into their courtroom. And if the Nebraska case taught us anything,
that's the one from earlier that originally struck down Biden's first debt relief plan,
the Supreme Court probably won't be any more sympathetic to this plan.
The shorter forgiveness timeline in SAVE is particularly vulnerable.
For three decades, the deal has been clear, 20 to 25 years of payments before forgiveness.
While Missouri's Attorney General argues that early income-sensitive repayment plans
never promised forgiveness, we know some borrowers did receive it through ICR and other programs.
But changing that timeline to 10 years? That's likely a bridge too far for this court.
Here's what's truly alarming. Judges questioned whether these plans were ever meant to offer
forgiveness at all. It's crazy when you think about it, because when you look back on the
newspapers from 30 years ago and see it plain as day, everyone understood these programs,
these IDR plans, would end in loan forgiveness. That was the promise trumpeted by Democratic
administration, by Republican administration, by president after president, doesn't matter
across political spectrum. And yet some of you will sit here and rely on your master promissory
note and you'll say, well, my note says this. But here's the catch most of you don't realize.
The Department of Education has always reserved the right to change these programs' terms.
They even admitted it last year when they were producing the regulations
eliminating other repayment plans. And they're saying, no, we have the right to change plans
whenever. That's the same power that could be used to restrict forgiveness here.
So what should you do right now? If you're already in save or have a pending application,
there's no value in making payments during this forbearance period. You won't get credit toward
public service loan forgiveness, and you're not gaining anything except perhaps peace of mind
because you feel like you're doing something. I would caution against that, but hey,
do what you want. And if you're someone who's thinking about switching plans,
the uncertainty in the system combined with massive service or backlogs means you might
want to stay put for now, because even if you turn in an application, ain't no telling when
it's going to get processed. Here's the deal. We're in uncharted territory. The legal foundations
that borrowers have relied on for decades are being questioned in ways that simply don't align
with 30 years of practice and promises. Whether these programs survive in their current form,
they ultimately depend not on the strength of legal arguments, but on how far courts are willing
to go in re-imagining what Congress intended back in 1993. I know this sounds like doom and gloom,
but I promise you we will get through it because we always have. And if you ever need help getting
through it, feel free to reach out to me and my team. We're here to support you. Have a wonderful
day. Talk to you next video. Peace.

