"Imagine a world where the SAVE plan is struck down by the courts, taking various income-driven repayment (IDR) plans with it and leaving millions of borrowers scrambling. This worst-case scenario could block hundreds of thousands from accessing Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) and introduce massive complications for those on IDR plans. But don’t worry, I’ll break down this doomsday scenario, discuss its implications, and offer strategies for how you can best prepare.
In today’s episode: 00:00 Introduction 02:37 Tougher eligibility for PSLF and income-driven repayment 06:33 Key tax strategies (reducing AGI, filing separately, and community property considerations) 09:36 Why I’m not overly concerned just yet 16:51 How to make sure you can still get a spot on the IBR plan"
Hey y'all and welcome to another episode of the Student Loan Planner Podcast.
It's your fearless host Travis and I am going to talk about something that is a doozy today.
So I have got a nice beverage to share with you the worst case scenario for the save plan lawsuits
and what it means for you. So this worst case scenario I think is best described as the
following. Imagine a world where the save plan gets struck down and you know by striking it down
they also strike down a lot of the ICR statute which stops them from doing the repay plan,
stops them from doing the pay plan and then makes it so that only people can sign up for IBR.
So if that were to occur that worst case scenario would probably also involve
hundreds of thousands of borrowers that could have gotten public service loan forgiveness and
private sector loan forgiveness that will be blocked from it because of the rules of IBR
surrounding partial financial hardships and being eligible to sign up for that plan.
So let me explain what I mean by that because that's a pretty scary thing
and let me tell you that this is not what I'm predicting. This is what I am letting you know
is a worst case scenario and I'm saying this so that you can know that there's a lot of strategies
and loopholes and things you can do to protect yourself against this worst case scenario and
it's something that we're going to be actively thinking about at SLP to try to protect our
community, our clients, our financial planning clients, consult clients, etc. Tax clients of
course as well. Now again what is this worst case scenario? How do we arrive at it? So the worst
case scenario is the save plan lawsuits. They're targeting the save plan and the way they're
trying to do this is for the kitchen sink and the ICR statute is the law that was used to create the
save plan. The ICR statute says you know Secretary of Education can make a IDR plan that is up to 20%
of income up to 25 years until forgiveness and the save plan you know being way more generous
than that technically does fit into that allowable range right and so the people
suing over this plan are thinking well maybe if we take down the ICR statute it'll take out the
save plan it'll take out everything that we don't like and maybe it even takes out more than the
save plan and would they have a problem with that? Probably not. So the worst case scenario is that
the 8th circuit makes this really extreme ruling against appeal to the Supreme Court and the
Supreme Court's like Congress didn't intend all this with the ICR statute so you know the only
option that's allowed is ICR for parent plus borrowers and IBR for everybody else and then
if that were the case I want you guys to think for a moment about the current state of student loans
and what everybody's payments are really based on right because if you really think about it you're
either a borrower that's graduated you know since the pandemic started in which case you applied
with maybe more recent income or you're a borrower that had a payment from before the pandemic and
that payment has been very low for a very long time based on a very low tax return from years
ago so think about this most people when the pandemic started were certified with their IDR
plan on a 2018 tax return I have no idea what I made in 2018 do you? I don't remember I remember
maybe ballpark but it was just like that's a long time ago right and so if you think about like
2018 tax returns that people are certified with IDR on what's happened is a lot of folks were
involuntarily switched to the SAVE plan or voluntarily right and then with the SAVE plan
you know payments a lot of people 9 million people are put into the SAVE plan for parents
and so if that plan was struck down everybody would have to apply for a new plan everybody
would have to recertify their income to a new plan and the only plan in this worst case scenario
environment and you know could be IBR and so if that's the case if it really is IBR and that's it
then people would have to not be able to do they would not be able to potentially sign up so if
people needed to sign up for IBR en masse they would have to do so with a more recent income and
how recent would that income be 2024 tax returns for the most part right so if we had 9 million
people that were enrolled in the same plan that suddenly needed to switch off of it and sign up
for IBR do you have a partial financial hardship if you don't have a partial financial hardship
you do not qualify and what partial financial hardship does not mean that you're experiencing
hardship it's actually a very technical definition what it means is that your calculated payment on
the IBR plan either old IBR or new IBR is below the standard 10-year plan amount so for example
if you have 200,000 of loans a rough rule to say is one percent of your balance is the standard 10-year
plan so if you have 200,000 of loans one percent of that's two thousand dollars a month so that
would be roughly your standard 10-year payment and for you to sign up for the IBR plan your required
payment would have to be below that under IBR so you'd have to have any IBR payment as long as it's
below $2,000 a month that would qualify you to switch on to IBR and the real problem here is
let's say you're a resident physician and let's say you've done your training and you're now an
attending physician but your income is still based off of back when you were resident well
if your income let's say is $250,000 and you have $150,000 in medical school loans
and you were in the same plan forbearance then if you go to sign up for IBR because everything
gets struck down by the courts you will not have a partial financial hardship because your
calculated IBR payment in that case would be higher than the standard 10-year plan and if
they block ICR which these new regulations did and they also block pay and reap you know all
these other things then in a world where you know Republicans win these lawsuits in a big way and
Democrats tighten down access to a lot of these other plans with new regulations and IBR is the
only option there are people with eight years of PSLF credit in this scenario that potentially
might not be able to sign up for PSLF at the very end because you have to have 10 years worth of
qualifying payments so if you cannot physically sign up for an income driven repayment amount
at all because you're not eligible for IBR because you don't have a partial financial hardship
you could be at year 8 or even year 9 of PSLF and have no way to get to year 10 to cross the
finish line now some people listening to this might be alarmed now and that's not my intent
I want to make it clear that this is not something that has come to pass or that I'm actually
probably even expecting to pass but it is a possibility and I thought it would be worthwhile
to do a podcast on the possibility that this could occur so that people are thinking about it
and you know what would you do in that scenario in this like doomsday scenario where a lot of people
that were able to get forgiveness are not even able to get forgiveness at all anymore
so you know what you would have to do is be super intentional about what tax return am I going to
use to apply and when what is my taxable income and when how am I going to use that income am I
filing taxes married filing jointly or married filing separately do I do AGI reduction to the
maximum extent possible do I make sure that I've got you know the income split the right way if I'm
in a community property state when I've got all these really crazy complexities that come along
with that you know such as you know schedule C splitting or you know investment splitting
or like you know that you're taking advantage of really complex write-offs like QBI deduction
right qualified business income if you're an S corporation you know if you are a professional
if you're doing an S corporation are you staying below the threshold for specified trade and
business I don't need to get into all that but what I'm saying is is that the 2024 tax year
is going to be critical absolutely critical because if in this worst case scenario that
this occurs where stuff gets repealed then like if you planned ahead and filed your taxes separately
kept your AGI as low as possible with solo 401ks or 401ks or 403bs or whatever pre-tax stuff that
you can do to make sure that you've got that partial financial hardship just in case so that
you could qualify to sign up for the IBR plan just in case that's literally preserving your
opportunity to get forgiveness instead of not get forgiveness and that is really critical for a
physician or a dentist or you know a lawyer somebody like that who's so close to loan forgiveness
yet you know could be so far away and so I just am thinking about this more and more lately
because there's two scenarios right Trump wins or Kamala Harris wins the presidency and then if
you know depending on those scenarios if Trump wins and there's an extreme 8th circuit ruling
they might just let it stand which could cause this worst case scenario to happen because they
don't appeal it to the supreme court which I know y'all might think that's crazy to say that that
would be the supreme court would be not the same but but they actually might not the reason for
that is the 8th circuit has one democratic justice out of a democratic appointed justice I should say
out of like 10 or 11 judges total and then the supreme court has three and then six republican
appointed judge justices total right so just the the balance of of of who appointed what judge is
even more republican leaning on the 8th circuit than it is on the supreme court and so for that
reason actually if you had a Kamala Harris win and she would of course appeal any adverse ruling
from the 8th circuit supreme court she might actually or what might actually occur is they
might take a more moderate position that would still maybe strike down the save plan but it would
probably allow maybe some pre-covid type of plans to exist I would think something like pay or repay
maybe unblock the ICR plan and that would give us a lot more tools to work with the people whose
income is above the cap so that they would still be able to get forgiveness right and so I mean you
know in terms of all these different scenarios one thing that would be interesting is if something
like this were to occur one reason why I'm not extremely worried about this scenario is this is
a scenario where I actually very much believe that congress would be forced to act to do something
right so if you think about the power of something like American Medical Association or those sorts
of lobbies they got like Kaiser Permanente completely reclassified as a qualifying
PSLF employer purely through lobbying efforts right um you know combination of AMA California
Association of Hospitals etc right so like there's power there and if a lot of physicians had PSLF
yanked away from them in year nine because of something like this I guarantee you there would
be a massive effort to pass some sort of rule in congress to maybe make the repay plan an option
which repay would be great because you do not have to have a partial financial hardship to apply for
repay it's just 10 percent of your income period and so if you're slightly above the cap it doesn't
matter you're still qualifying for an IDR plan so you could still get actual payment credit towards
whatever 10-year payment count you would need or you know 20 or 25-year payment count if you're
going for private sector forgiveness now how would this whole thing potentially affect the math of
forgiveness in the first place so people you know would still mostly go for forgiveness if you have
debt that's larger than your income and and in some cases even if the debt's smaller than your
income you would still be able to go for forgiveness even if all this stuff was repealed in the worst
case scenario happened and the reason for that is the IVR plan is basically the same thing as pay
if you borrowed after 2014 for the first time and so when you look at that pay plan it's very generous
it is something that makes it a no-brainer to go for forgiveness for the most part if your income
is is lower than your debt amount and you would just need to do the same sorts of things that we
do now for folks which is help figure out the married filing separate decision help look at the
pros and cons of that loan savings versus higher tax costs potentially and we just got done with
our full first tax season and we learned a whole lot from that tax season so one thing that's kind
of interesting is some people filing separately have huge costs associated with it and some people
filing separately don't have huge costs associated with it also we had some cases where people did
some turbo tax work that our team checked and we found errors as large as like fifteen thousand
dollars of extra taxes people paid because they did their own taxes in turbo tax this is often
usually because the community property splits people living in community property splits sometimes
don't do that split correctly and it costs people four or five figures in extra taxes because you're
supposed to file form 8958 and split the income and people don't do it um and you know i also i
think we we learned a whole lot about just how important taxes are going to be in tax strategy
is going to be for the future of student loans so if we really think about what loopholes are
available the government really really wants to move the student loan system to more and more and
more of an income tax and when you do that it makes your tax return and your tax strategies
critical and super important so things like should you file an extension for your taxes
should you file separately you know how do you reduce your agi you know one thing that's wild
to me is and this is something that we do with with idr sensitive portfolios construction
uh is people don't think about the impact that student loan borrowers marginal tax rate has on
investment returns and how much you should work so in surveys we've done burnout is a massive
problem among people in our audience people are are stressed out they are tired a lot of uh surveys
we see for example show that people are are expecting to work a lot fewer hours than they
actually end up working post-graduation because of increased demands on especially medical
professions and that's leading to a lot of of life satisfaction issues and work satisfaction issues
and i think that if people knew what they're actually earning for that last you know shift
you take at the hospital fewer people would work as much as they do and the reason for that is
you've got federal state uh local in some cases social security medicare fica basically uh and
then any other miscellaneous taxes and then also 10 for idr if you're on pay or you know save or
uh the new ibr or 15 if you're on old ibr which is anybody in this worst case scenario planning
would be anybody for their first loan before uh before 2014 so that's pretty much anybody in their
you know mid-20s or beyond probably would be on that old version of ibr and so if you think about
this in terms of a marginal tax rate if the old ibr plan was the only game in town you know you
might have 15 ibr 32 federal so let's see if i can do math that's 47 and then you know seven and
a half fika so that's like 55 and then throw on like um gosh throw on like state so let's say it's
five that's 60 maybe 65 if you're in california so we're up to people paying 60 to 65 percent
of that marginal dollar they're earning because of the high rate of that student borrowers get hit
with taxes and like that's massive right so in the words if you just like made a more frugal
choice on your vehicle you could probably afford to work four days a week instead of five days a
week and be financially the exact same this is like for somebody making you know like 120k type
of income you know versus somebody obviously making way way more than that it wouldn't be
the same math and you'd maybe be in a low lower tax rate blah blah blah right but the general idea
is pretty accurate that people are not paying attention to their marginal tax rates and the
decisions that that that could have the impact that that should have on your decisions of how
much you should work people aren't thinking about how to reduce their agi enough i think people are
kind of just setting out on autopilot and making a lot of mistakes there and i think people are
making a ton of mistakes with how they file their taxes that's certainly something that we've seen
from our first year starting in tax business we just finished up this first full tax year which
ends you know basically october 15th is the extension deadline so that's you know that's
what i'm why i'm saying that and i think that just tax strategy in general is just absolutely
critical it's absolutely critical so whether you're getting kind of like the high level from
like a student loan planner consult or you're going into more like tax planning with like an slp wealth
financial planner or you're getting into like the how do i do this and do it for me kind of
conversations that we have with slp wealth tax team i really hope you pay attention to your 2024 taxes
and just you know since we're not done with the 2024 calendar year yet what kind of pre-tax
contributions can you be making or maximizing or you know a lot of times if you're way behind on
your 401k you can make your next you know four paychecks or two paychecks like 100 percent of
your paycheck going to your 401k with the payroll withholding change to make sure you get to the max
on that paycheck and the reason is just because the agi stuff's going to matter it's going to be
critically important because like i said in this worst case scenario where courts strike down
absolutely everything but ibr which is possible it's more probable with the trump victory than
it is with the harris victory but it's still possible with the harris victory too so if this
were to occur if they repeal absolutely everything but the ibr plan you know you want to make sure you
can still get onto that plan meaning filing separately for taxes if you need to minimizing
agi looking into whether or not you should file for an extension so that you can use a tax return
and that's a lower income for a longer period of time there's all kinds of stuff to be paying
attention to during this time so that was the worst case scenario i probably could do the best
case scenario in a very short episode basically the best case scenario would be save is untouched
would shocks the world and a lot more people millions more people can get forgiveness and
nurses and uh you know ma's and um you know lower paid workers right teaching assistants could
actually get pslf for a change which is like kind of ridiculous to think about this program that was
made for public servants and they always talk about you know when they're ever talking about
they always talk about teachers firefighters but the formula pre-save plan makes it so hard for
those folks to get forgiveness because you know if you have a modest amount of debt you tend to
just pay that off in full anyway because your balance is so small it's just like even a small
payment would pay the loan off with the formula that they used that was pre-save plan right which
is why they tried to make it more generous to help more people get forgiveness same thing for private
sector forgiveness you know they tried to make it so that people could get forgiveness much faster
you know than 20 years if they have very small balances so if you have you know a very small
balance you can get it in as little as 10 years for until forgiveness so if i was going to take
the middle of the road approach to what i think will happen not the worst case scenario i think
that maybe the middle approach and which would be kind of a middle middle positive approach would be
that they get rid of the 10-year forgiveness they get rid of the five percent of income for
undergrads but they keep everything else with the save plan that's actually possible i actually think
that that maybe would be the most likely outcome with a harris victory plus it going to the supreme
court and them ruling on that so that would be the thought process there is you know maybe that
would occur with the current iteration of the supreme court if if harris were to win but it's
really hard to say right so we will know more in the coming weeks obviously the election is going
to be really important to know uh who wins so we can go into the scenario planning for that
and the you know per like what what this the 8th circuit wants to do with all these uh rulings is
going to set the tone for how the supreme court rules probably because they're going to at least
look into the reasoning the 8th circuit used and how they make their decision probably so that's
another thing we'll be following super closely but remember that that the worst case scenario
can be protected against somewhat by really good advanced planning especially tax planning
which is why we started a tax business as painful as it's been i'm going to tell you that i never
never ever wanted to do or start a tax business because it's just it's a lot of work you know and
i'm not a cpa so going through the the you know the difficult part of just starting a tax business
why did we do it it's because i knew we needed it i knew we needed to have this so that we could
learn a ton of the actual nuts and bolts of how do you actually like how do you actually turn the
widgets in the right you know direction and position to get it locked in place to the get
the savings that we need to get for people because it's gonna be like absolutely going to battle for
borrowers if this worst case scenario occurs because i've got some other loophole ideas we
could use to combat even the situation where somebody's doesn't have a partial financial
hardship so you know for example how would you like to go to your boss and say i need to take
an unpaid one month leave of absence so that i can go and contact my idr application go do that
and say i no longer have a taxable income which would technically be true for that month and then
you could sign up for ibr with a zero dollar a month payment and then the next time you certify
your idr ibr payment your payment would get capped at the standard 10-year amount but at least you
would have gotten back on to the ibr plan so i've got a lot of strategies for if we do have to deal
the worst case scenario that we will absolutely go to battle over and help you implement but
obviously there's a lot of easier strategies like filing extensions filing separately amendments
you know community property splitting 88 uh 89 58 just paying attention to your agi maximizing
all available pre-tax accounts maxing solo 401ks if your business owner setting up one
which is a big problem a lot of business owners haven't even set one up before um you know not
over contributing to roth accounts when you really should be looking at pre-tax hsa's
dependent care fsa's if you got kids in daycare i could go on and on right getting i'm getting
worked up guys i'm getting excited so many savings that people are not thinking about
that's one reason i love doing this and why i've done it for eight years is because usually i just
it's like you see something and it's usually always somebody's missing at least one thing
that could be a game changer right there's usually always at least one massive opportunity that
that can save them a boatload of money if you're a student loan borrower so that's what's kept this
fun and interesting for me and thank you for being interested in this because you could be listening
to true crime right now and instead you're listening to the uh nuclear apocalypse of
student loans so i hope i made it as entertaining as i possibly can be for you if you need a consult
go to studentloanplanner.com book and if we um have space available in our tax business
we will share that information with folks on the email list uh in in the future in the upcoming
weeks so have a great week and thank you guys for listening to the student loan player podcast