Are Spadroons the Sidesword of the 18th Century?

Rune Slicer
2 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 27, 2026
Comparing two cut and thrust swords from two different eras.
Hi and welcome back to the Academy of Historical Fencing. So a question that comes up reasonably
often I would say, particularly on the Spadroona group on Facebook, which is a little bit of a
plug. If you like spadroons or you don't know what they are or, I don't know, you just fancy
the memes because there are plenty of memes about them, come and join us on the Spadroona group on
Facebook because we're all about spadroons and having a bit of fun. But yeah, this question
that comes up quite often is, is the spadroon the sidesword of the 18th century and 19th century?
So before we go into evaluating basically that statement, let's just look at exactly what we're
dealing with first. So anybody that's watching the channel that doesn't or isn't particularly
familiar with the term sidesword of spadroon, very quick overview to what they exactly are.
So the term sidesword is a very, very modern term and what it basically refers to is an early rapier,
so the kind of sword that was in use around about 1500 up to the end of the 16th century,
and they look like the cross between a traditional kind of cruciform arming sword,
this is the sort of standard medieval sword, and the later rapier. Now rapiers are known for being
very, very long and for having very highly developed or complex guards, whereas sideswords,
because they're a kind of early form of rapier, they tend to have simpler guards. So you'll
usually just find they've got these forward rings that allow you to put the index finger over,
and some have a knuckle bow like this and some don't. It's a complete mix. They can be as simple
as just having one forward ring and otherwise looking like a, you know, an old school medieval
arming sword. But the characteristic of the sidesword really is that they're usually a bit
longer in the blade length than the old arming swords and a little bit more agile, but not always.
But yeah, they're usually a little bit larger and they, by agile I mean essentially they're
a little bit better suited to thrust work as in they're a bit more agile and nimble at the tip,
but not always because you can find some really beefy sideswords. So there's a huge spectrum on
these, I mean they're not pattern regulated swords, it's just that it's the in-between
sword between medieval arming sword and the full rapier. And as far as how the terminology was used
let's say in Britain in the 16th century, because the term sidesword didn't exist, this would have
been called a rapier. So the term rapier in the 16th century was applied to any basically Italian
or Spanish style sword of this type, which basically means it has forward rings that allow
this grip and usually quite a long blade. So they might have called this for example a short rapier
or just rapier, and then the longer ones that we know from say the kind of golden era of the rapier
of the say the 1600 period, the very long very complex silk, they might call that the long rapier.
But anyway, you could legitimately call this a short rapier or early rapier, but in a
modern context we tend to call it a sidesword. So there you go, early rapier of a kind. Now a spadroon
is, as we know it, this is the classic 1796 pattern spadroon, a sergeant's version in this case.
The spadroon is the cut and thrust sword of the 18th and early 19th century. Now they were actually
coming into use in the 17th century, but they just didn't have the term spadroon yet, they were
being called shearing swords. But approximately this kind of sword was in use from the mid-17th
century until the early to mid-19th, and even a little bit more than that if you include things
like the USNCO 1840 model sword. But there you go, so this sword was for sergeants and officers
and earlier on actually was for the common soldier to some degree as well.
So now let's compare these and actually see, ask the question, are they much the same thing or not?
So for a start, this is an antique and this is not. Unsurprisingly I don't have a 16th century
side sword, you know, antique, but I have lots of 18th century swords. And what are the comparisons
we can make immediately? Because this is quite a good replica, this is by Malleus Swords, make
really high quality training swords. Well, first of all, this is designed to be a double-edged
sword, okay, and this is single-edged. But spadroons can be single or double and even the
single-edged examples can be sharpened in the last few inches off the back of the blade. So in that
regard, there's nothing to really compare because, okay, they usually have a single-edged blade on
this, but not always, and a side sword is usually double-edged and yet you can find a single-edged
side sword, so essentially a back sword blade on a side sword. So nothing to really compare there,
particularly as I said, if it's got a sharpened back, there's nothing to really compare them on
or contrast them on. Okay, so the really major defining qualities to compare would be blade
length and what's going on with this guard here. So side swords, as we know them, typically have
blade lengths of, and again, this is not a pattern sword, so massive variety, but you're talking
about the shortest ones would normally be around the 34-inch blade. That would be fairly short for
a side sword and you'll still find the odd one a bit shorter, but as a rule about 34-inch blade
length ranging up to about 38-inch and sometimes even pushing up to things like 40-inch blades.
So let's say an average side sword is about a 36-inch blade approximately, which is about what
this one is, and the spadroon, well the spadroon in later life was regulated to be 32-inch and
actually most examples that exist before the regulation and during are all around about 32-inch.
They drop down to about 31 at the lowest and up to about 33, occasionally pushing to 34, but when
they get to about 34 you'd usually call them more a broad sword because they tend to have a bit more
mass in them. So yeah, about a 32-inch blade compared to a side sword that is typically more
like 36, so that's one key difference already. And then what's going on with this guard here? Well,
you've got this guard with these forward loops that allow this spacey finger to wrap over the
quillen. The quillen is the straight cross guard there and this is a form of grip that actually
was in use way before they even had forward rings. It's a reason that the rings developed,
but you can go back into sort of medieval artwork and see this being done with old sort of crusader
swords when they're wearing male gloves and stuff like that. So this grip was in use for hundreds
of years before this sword came into use and what it really does is it gives you a nice bit of
leverage over the sword. It stops it from easily slipping from the hand and significantly when
you've got a sword that is very long or fairly heavy in the blade or fairly cumbersome, so like
long rapier for example, it allows you to get a lot of dexterity and a lot of grip and a lot of
leverage on it. And one of the questions that people always post to me is, why does the spidrun
not have these rings? Well, they were already long gone by the time of the spidrun, so small swords
did have rings called amulets, but they were purely aesthetic by that point. They were kept
for tradition because the old rapiers had them, but they weren't actually used to put the finger
through. So yeah, those finger rings were basically gone, I mean there were a few exceptions to the
rule, but basically gone by the time of the spidrun. And in my experience, because I use spidruns and I
use side swords and I use long rapiers, in my experience I found that the finger rings are
not at all needed when you've got a sword that has a blade length of about 34 inch or less.
Over 34 inch, and again this is not exact because there's a bit of variety here depending on
the blade mass distribution and stuff like that, and also of course the size of the user. So I'm
five foot seven, obviously if you're a six footer that might be slightly different, but let's say
averaging over 34 inch, these rings become really useful to be able to control the blade length.
But under 34 inch and particularly where it's not got a huge amount of mass in the blade, they're
just not needed. Although curiously the grip looks something similar, so the spidrun is normally gripped
with something like a handshake or thumb on the back, whereas when you then hold a side sword
the grip wrapping over the quill and actually doesn't look that different, it can actually end
up looking fairly similar. So yeah, the finger rings are not necessary on a sword this short,
and particularly with this little mass in the tip, and therefore they're just not needed. Okay,
what else have we got? Well in terms of level of protection, spidruns can have anything from
just a knuckle bow, to a single loop on the side, to double shells, which is very common.
They can also have more, they can have additional bars that almost get to the level of a basket
hilt, almost. And a side sword can be anything from just a quill and a loop there, ranging up
to like a full swept hilt rapier as we would call them, which is very complex. And therefore the
levels of protection you can find on a side sword and a spidrun are kind of equivalent, because I
And if you added extra bars to this and you made this a full swept hilt,
you'd also end up with roughly equivalent levels of protection. So that then takes us to
what are they like in handling? Well remember again, side sword is not regulated in any way,
not patterned sword. So this is a fairly light bladed example, quite a sportive blade if you
like. You can find a whole wide range of them, but overall you're talking a sword like this
and a spidrun of this kind is more in the kind of 700 gram range. But remember it is smaller
and the guard is smaller, so it is going to be a bit lighter. Now what's the handling like
comparing a spidrun to a side sword? Again, let's take in sort of the reasonably typical
examples of side swords and typical examples of spidruns. I will say they are very similar.
So obviously the side sword is that little bit longer and that wrapped finger around the quill
and then allows you to handle that little bit of extra length, but overall they're incredibly
similar. And basically let's look at their use. So these kind of side swords developed out of
arming swords in large part because there was an increase in use of swords for civilians,
because this was used both as a civilian and a military weapon. So it would be a side arm in war
and also then worn in civilian life. And when you are carrying a sword in daily life and when
armour is decreasing, which it was through the 16th century, a blade that is a bit more agile
and a bit longer and better suited to basically quick cuts at distance and point work is much
better than a shorter, beefier blade in many ways. And the spidrun was in a period where armour was
all but gone and again therefore is quite well suited to what it's being used for.
So both of these are intended as cut and thrust basically swords. Now, in fact, most swords are
designed for cut and thrust, but they usually emphasise one thing over another. So let's say
an 18th century sabre is emphasising the cut very heavily and most say Basquiat broad swords are
emphasising the cut. They tend to have heavier blades that are suited to it and grips that are
quite restricted to not being quite so well suited to thrust work. And you get into the 19th
century and sabres tend to then mix it up and try and go in between. But yeah, you tend to end up
with a slight focus on one element more than the other. Whereas the spidrun and the side sword were
very much intended to be a split cut and thrust sword. And obviously when you go with a 50-50
split, in itself is a compromise because every change you make on a sword is a compromise. So
when you go for a split cut and thrust sword, you will lose a little bit of cutting capacity,
but you'll make it agile and particularly allow it to have a lot of reach. And that's an important
point because the spidrun, so people often look at the spidrun as a fairly short sword,
but in its time it wasn't. It's only short when you compare it to basically 19th century swords
that followed it. Actually, in the 18th and very early 19th century, the spidrun was,
in some regards, a cavalry length. So the light cavalry sabre that everybody thinks of for the
and the spidrun is a 32, so quite long. Whereas a lot of infantry swords were a good bit shorter.
And therefore, let's get down to it. The spidrun is typically a good bit lighter than the side
sword, but considering the side sword's length and guard weight, they are roughly in proportion.
And therefore, if you actually get them out and swing with them and fight with them,
they feel very similar to one another. The level of protection is very similar. The way you grip it,
even though you wrap this finger, isn't hugely different. And the way they move in the fight
is very similar. And if you want to talk about striking power and things like that, well, again,
you've got to compare individual examples, but you will find a lot of similarity between a lot
of the agile side swords and spidruns. So is the spidrun the side sword of the 18th and early 19th
century? In many regards, yes. It would be wrong to say that they are the same sword. They absolutely
are not the same sword. But there are huge amounts of similarities between the two. So
in many ways, yes. It wouldn't necessarily be helpful to start calling it a side sword,
so I wouldn't recommend doing that. But just as a fun comparison to see how swords evolve,
how they change over time, are these doing the same job in their equivalent time periods? Are
they much the same weapon? Yeah, in many ways, they really actually are. And that will be quite
an interesting eye-opener for some people, because, of course, over the years, the spidrun
gets loads of a bad rep, and the side sword gets a lot of love, although that's, in many ways,
even quite a recent thing. So yeah, side sword, spidrun, are they quite similar? In many regards,
yes. They are both that kind of medium length, medium hand protection, split cut and thrust
blade that emphasises agility and speed to deliver quick cuts and thrusts. So they absolutely are
kind of going along the same ideas and the same sort of concepts of what is important in a fight,
and so there are a huge amount of similarities between the two. So yeah, I hope you enjoyed the
video, and that does answer the question of, is the spidrun the side sword of the 18th century?
Well, yeah, kind of is. I hope you enjoyed the video. Please do subscribe, and thanks for watching!
