Addiction & Recovery Special, Gabor Maté & David Fuller

Rebel Wisdom
9 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 15, 2023
This is a particularly personal piece. It's a conversation we hosted
in the digital campfire with the addictions expert Gabor Mate.
And it's personal because it's sparked by a Substack piece that I wrote
about my relationship with my mother and her recovery from addiction.
The piece went out on Substack a few weeks ago. If you haven't read it,
I would suggest maybe you stop this and read it. I'm going to put the link in the show notes below.
It touches on many of the issues that come up with addiction.
How much are we able to help versus how much must the addict help themselves?
The nature of self-deception and delusion, what obligations we have to our parents,
and all the other moral dilemmas we have to deal with with the topic of addiction.
And the piece really seemed to strike a chord with a lot of people who've been
suffering with addiction or had family members who've been suffering with addiction,
which is why it felt right to share and also to host this conversation with Gabor Mate.
And I'm putting this out on the channel now after I've checked in with all the people who
have featured in it to just check that they are okay with their personal sharing being
shared more widely. So I hope you find this useful.
So yeah, welcome everybody to a really special Thursday evening session on the topic of
addiction and recovery. And I guess everyone here has read the piece that I wrote
last week about my journey with it, which is the first time I've shared that publicly.
So yeah, Gabor, thank you so much. I reached out to you. I can't think of anyone I'd rather
have here. And I'm so privileged that I had your email address and when I messaged you,
you were available at this late notice. So thank you so much for being here.
Well, thank you for inviting me.
I think your framing of addiction is in a way not the problem for the addict,
addiction is the solution.
In a temporary sense. It becomes a problem, but it starts off as a solution. Yes.
Could you say more about that?
Well, whenever I give a talk on addiction, I will give my definition of addiction. So I'll
do so now. And an addiction is manifested in any behavior in which a person finds temporary
pleasure or relief, and therefore praise, but sustains negative consequences in the long term,
and cannot give it up despite those negative consequences. So that's an addiction.
Craving pleasure relief in the short term, harm in the long term to oneself and others,
and inability or refusal to give it up, or difficulty giving up. That's an addiction.
Now, let's just do an experiment here. Those of you that based on that, by the way, notice that
I said nothing about substances. So the addiction could be to drugs or alcohol or nicotine,
caffeine, heroin, of course, whatever. It could also be to sex, gambling, shopping, eating,
pornography, internet gaming, the internet itself, work, any human activity. The issue is not the
external target, but the internal relationship. If there's pleasure, relief and craving in the
short term, harm in the long term, difficulty giving up, I don't care what the behavior is,
you've got an addiction. So that's my definition. So what I'll ask is, what I often do is,
when I give this talk, just people that who are listening on this talk, if you recognize that one
time or another, you've had an addictive pattern in your life, and I don't care what it is, I'm
not going to ask you, but if you had any kind of an addictive pattern in your life, just raise your
if you recognize it in yourself. Okay, now, usually we have
most people put their hands up and then there's a few liars who don't, you know, but that's how it
works. So now, what I'm going to ask you is not what you're addicted to, but when, or when,
or for how long, I don't care. But whatever it was, what did it do for you in the short term?
Is the chat line open? Yes, the chat box is open.
Just some people wrote in, what did it do for you in the short term that you liked? What did
you appreciate about your addiction? I don't mean, I know that was harm. Okay, it relieved
uncomfortable emotions, somebody said. What else? Relief, again. Relief, it relieved the pain.
Escape. When do people need escape? It's when they're suffering.
Pain is suffering. Escapism, again. Access to happiness. Disconnect from life. Okay, good.
Takes the edge off. Let's stop here because I have enough here. Take the edge off what? Take
the edge off your suffering. Why would you need to escape life when life is unbearable? In other
words, people's trauma. And in my view, well, not just in my view, according to every reasonable
piece of evidence, that trauma is usually incurred in childhood, whether people know that or not.
So what I'm saying is that addictions are like pain relief, is that a good thing or a bad thing?
Happiness, good thing or bad thing? Connection with other people, is that a good thing or a bad
thing? Inner peace, stress relief, are they good or bad? They're wonderful. We all want them.
That's how we, we just want to be normal human beings. So the addictive drive is really an
attempt to regulate unbearable emotions. And those unbearable emotions are rooted in childhood
experience. So the addiction is not the primary problem. The addiction is the attempt to solve
a problem. And the source of that problem resides in people's life experience.
Before we go to the breakouts, Gabor, I want to ask your thoughts on the dynamic that I noticed
coming up again and again in the relationship with addiction that I wrote about is this
relationship to the ego and the sense of the belief that we've got this, that we can cope
seems to be one of the major blocks. And I guess that's why it's at the core of the
12-step program of kind of like the first step is recognizing that we don't have control over it.
That feels like a deeply kind of spiritual, deeply religious
perspective of kind of recognizing our limitations and giving ourselves up to a higher power.
Could you reflect on that? What is that dynamic?
Well, the ego is not who we are. The ego is something that we come to identify with as being
who we are. But the ego for the most part represents our coping mechanisms and our
desperation to be in charge. Why do we have that desperation to be in charge? Because when we
are very small, we suffer. So the ego is largely a response to suffering and it wants to be in
control. And even when it's destroying you, it still wants to believe that it's in control
and that you don't have a problem. So the essence of ego is denial and denial of its own,
denial of the pain that gave rise to it. Now, of course, as any spiritual tradition,
whether Eastern or Western, Southern or Northern, will tell you, we are not the little ego.
We're not that little self isolated from the universe. We're actually connected and part of a
much greater whole. In fact, the big whole, W-H-O-L-E, that's what we're a part of and a
manifestation and representation of. But for the ego to recognize that is to give up its own
legitimacy and its own existence. So the ego fights that spiritual realization.
So when people go through these spiritual experiences, through meditation or
spiritual practices, Sufi, whirling, or through psychedelics, Christian contemplation,
the dark night of the soul, St. John of the Cross, you know, the ego suffers an ego death.
It goes through this little death. But because the ego has identified itself with us,
we're afraid that if the ego dies, we die. So
recognizing that we're powerless is actually a spiritual step.
It says, yeah, you know what? I get it. My little ego is just not sufficient
to answer my life dilemma. And I need to appeal to a higher power.
However you wish to define that. Now, the cluster groups traditionally have identified it with
the Christian derived God being, which is fine if it works for you, but it doesn't have to be that.
But generally, recognizing that higher power does mean a humbling
of the ego. So the ego is put in its place. I don't mean in a negative sense, but in a positive
sense. Oh, yeah. Okay. I'm not in charge. And if I want to move forward, I have to align
with something that's beyond, which is a, itself is a spiritual step, whether the person
experiences it or defines it as spiritual. That's what it is.
So I'd love to, yeah, I'd love to open this conversation up. So I'd like to open up the
breakout rooms. Awesome. I think we're all back. So yeah, I'd love to hear if anyone feels
that they want to share anything that they shared, that they shared or any sort of common themes
that came up in their breakout rooms. Yeah. Let's, let's begin a sort of more open conversation.
And please, please, yeah, use the chat as well for something you want to share.
But if you want to raise your hand, the raise hand function is probably in the
reactions tab at the bottom of your screen. So Leilani, would you like to share first?
You're muted. Leilani. Leilani, you're muted. Sorry. Okay. Thank you. I just wanted to say,
I was really, first of all, David, I was really touched by your, what you wrote and very
appreciative. And my own experience is to speak to that for a moment is that especially the most
important part is that my two daughters, youngest daughters are recovering addicts. And my youngest
daughter was actually in prison for a while because of her addiction as a result of her
addiction. And it was in prison that she received the most intensive therapy. We did family therapy
there. We did, she did individual therapy. We did group therapy. And it was in that process that she
started to do her recovery and it stayed clean and sober since then. And I don't think I would
have ever said that being in prison would be a good thing to happen. And it was, to me, it was
the best thing that ever happened for her and for us, because it was the path to healing that started
to take place for the trauma that she experienced and that I experienced as well. Wow. Thank you
for sharing that, Leilani. Yeah, it's amazing, this topic. I mean, you've been part of our
community for an awfully long time. I've never heard that story. It's amazing that this topic
can bring up some real, yeah, we can really connect with each other in this space. Thank you.
Thank you. Mark. Hi, thanks. So first of all, just to say, David, also, I read your piece and
thank you for that. I really appreciated it. I suppose my question was just touching on something
that Gabor was saying beforehand. We were talking about the 12 steps and particularly step one and
two, the powerlessness and then the higher power. I mean, I have to say, I really struggled with
those, particularly the powerlessness idea. I don't feel powerless at all. And I totally accept
that I can't impact everything, you know, I'm not, but to use a Viveki line, you know, I am an agent
in the arena. I can do things. And similarly, you know, as regards to the higher power,
I totally accept that there are things that are out of my control and there's sort of society,
etc. around it. But I'm an atheist, I don't believe in God and all of that sort of side
of things I find difficult. But particularly step one, there's this powerless society. We're not
powerless, it's just not correct. So I'd just be interested in, which is not to say that we're
all powerful either. Mark, are you open to a conversation about this? Yeah, yeah, of course.
Okay, good. So first of all, thank you. I get what you're saying. And of course, ultimately,
we're not powerless. If you were, you might as well not do the 12 steps or do anything, right?
So I agree with you. However, I'm not sure that's what the 12 step statement indicates.
They're talking about the addicted state. In that addicted state, are you freely choosing
to engage in your addiction, whether it's a substance or behavior,
or are you being driven to it by some internal dynamics? Which is it for you?
If you're distinguishing between the addicted state, the moment when I do do something
that I kind of wish I wasn't doing, which for me is largely overeating.
Yeah, in that moment, that is true. That's something I don't want to do.
So if we're defining it in that narrow sense, yes.
That's what they're talking about. I believe that's what they're talking about, number one.
Number two, the resistance to this idea of powerlessness itself is interesting.
Because here's my guess. It's not my guess. It's an educated opinion.
With myself or with any other addicted person I've ever met, there was a time when one was
really powerless and suffering as a result of that powerlessness. Because things happen to one
to hurt us. Yeah.
Over which we have no power. So therefore, the variety of powerlessness
emotionally resonates with that helpless, suffering state.
So again, that I'm powerless, that refers to the addicted state. It's not an overall
true statement about any human being. I agree with you. But it is very specific to that state,
number one. Number two, the fear of acknowledging is itself a marker of trauma, is what I'm saying.
I think it's probably fair to say that I had some sort of traumatic events in my past,
and I kind of accept that. And I think the way you framed it is a useful way of thinking about it.
But then I would say, we need to rephrase step one of the 12 steps to make it a bit clearer.
Well, fair enough. I mean, I think there's a lot of things about the 12 steps that I'd
love to reframe. In fact, in my book on addiction, I have created an appendix
where I reframe the 12 steps in language that makes sense to me. And I think we can all do
that for ourselves. Okay, thank you. That's very helpful. Thank you. Thank you. Robin Cressman.
Yes, thank you. Our small breakout group was just so enlightening. And it's what's heartening
to know is just how many different ways addiction touches people's lives through
our own experience, through family experience, and how many different shades of addiction
there are, whether that's substance or behavior. And I, yeah, I'm just, I, I've been in 12 step
programs myself many times for many different, many different rooms. And there is something
so powerful about the circle, about sharing, about hearing other people's stories, about
sharing your own story that is fortifying. But one question to float to Gabor, as you say, you've
gone through having to work through a lot of this type of emotional entanglement with your wife.
I'm curious if you and your wife enlisted an outside therapist, or if this was just
internal work that you both were committed to, that's helped you walk through that and, or?
Both actually. I mean, there was a time when we saw a very good family therapist.
They both had therapy individually, because it's all about as much as about the relationship,
it's also about ourselves as undifferentiated people. I've done a lot of work on that. I've
also worked with psychedelics, both as a provider, but also as a participant. And,
and then I'm married to a woman with whom we just do a lot of deep conversation,
sometimes at the most difficult time. Because I hate to tell you, but we always
poke up with somebody exactly at the same level of trauma as we're at.
So, so it's always two people at the same level of trauma in a relationship.
That means that the relationship itself can be a wonderful training ground and a ground for growth,
or it can be a shipwreck, depending on how people relate to the trauma that they bring
into the relationship. We've been fortunate that way. So that's our story. Great, thank you.
Yeah, thank you. Yossarian. Hi. Hi, before you ask a question, can I ask you something?
Sure. Were you named after a character in Cash 22? Yes, I was. Isn't that something? Okay, thank you.
Yeah, I was a little touched by your article, David. My mom was deep in alcoholism and has
been sober for 11 years now. She just lost her husband this past year. And it made me,
I'm almost crying right now, just really proud of her that she didn't relapse into addiction
when she lost her husband and just kind of shows how much work she's done.
And I too have had bouts, long bouts with addiction and did a number of years of weekly
therapy, somatic work, energy work, breath work, and then drinking ayahuasca in the jungles of
Peru, I think where your daughter has worked, Gabor, at the Temple of Way of Light.
Former daughter-in-law. Former daughter-in-law, I apologize.
And yeah, I mean, just interesting, you know, when I first quit doing hard drugs,
2008 was actually right when my father, my birth father passed. And so that was at least the first,
you know, longer bout with quitting. But what I brought up in the group, and I guess is part of
the question for me, was that, you know, it's felt to me being interested in this
subject quite a bit, both personally and tons of friends and just seeing how much suffering
is in the world. And we know kind of the statistics on what, how effective AA is,
which is not super effective. And maybe it's due to those, you know, how we interpret
being powerless, et cetera. But I felt like Gabor, you've been at the cutting edge of what
addiction really is about. And there's a number of modalities that you can, tools that you can use to
face recovery. And I've mentioned some of those, but it still feels to me like the vast majority of
recovery treatment are not at that cutting edge level. And I guess I'm curious if you'd speak a
little bit about how well you see these different modalities being adopted from somatic type of work
and kind of trauma related work and, you know, ayahuasca and dealing with some of those things.
So that's, I guess, my question. Yeah, well, thank you. Well, look, if you took your car to
a mechanic that didn't understand how a car works, you wouldn't expect too many good results.
And most addiction programs don't understand addiction. They see it either as a choice that
somebody makes, or more likely, they see it as a disease of the brain that somebody inherited
largely, or for some reason developed. They don't get that it's all rooted in trauma. Now,
if you don't deal with the trauma, you're not dealing with fundamental causes, you're dealing
with effects. So addiction is an effect. It's a symptom. It also generates more symptoms.
But at heart, as I was saying earlier, it's an attempted solution to the problem of human
suffering, which itself is rooted in trauma. Therefore, if you're doing this trauma,
you're just not going to get anywhere. And this is where the 12 Steps founder,
they're great, the 12 Steps. As I was saying, in a small group, everybody in the world could
benefit from doing the 12 Steps, addicted or not. Imagine a world where Boris Johnson and
Vladimir Putin and Joseph Biden all did the 12 Steps, and did moral inventory on the stuff they
done to other people. We'd be living in a much better world. But what the 12 Step community,
by and large, doesn't recognize is the traumatic nature and origin of addiction. Therefore,
they can only take people so far. Some people they really works for. It could work for many
more people if they were to incorporate trauma awareness into their processes.
And the same thing is true. The medical profession, the average medical doctor
does not get a single lecture on trauma in all their years of training. If you can believe it,
they don't. So how are they to deal with them, with all the physical and emotional manifestations
of trauma, of which addiction is one? So they're just not trained for it. It's not part of their
perspective. So if you don't have the eyes to see, you're not going to see. And they don't
have the eyes to see. So those modalities that do incorporate some trauma awareness, like
internal family systems, like my compassionate inquiry approach, like genuine ayahuasca
experiences, psychedelic healing that is infused with the trauma perspective, like somatic
experiencing with Peter Levine, like sensory motor reprogramming, any number of modalities
that do have trauma awareness are essential aspects of any addiction healing program.
And even the word recovery itself, if you just meditate on that for a moment,
the essence of trauma is disconnection from the self. That's the essence of trauma.
And in my new book, which is called The Myth of Normal, out in September, I talk about that
in great detail. So the essence of trauma is disconnection from the self. When we talk about
recovery, what does the word recovery mean? It means to find something that you've lost,
so you recover. When you talk to people in recovery, what have you found? They'll say,
And so it's that search for the self, the full self, both in the physical, emotional,
and spiritual sense. That's the essence of recovery. And unless the addiction programs
incorporate how that self was lost in the first place, which is trauma, they're naturally going
to be inadequate. They're just going to manage behaviors, but they're not dealing with the
primary dynamic. Thank you. Just follow up. I'm kind of in a bubble of people who do the type of
work you're talking about, and it feels like it's growing, maybe not exponentially, but it's growing
quite a bit. But I guess the question I'm really trying to get at is, do you see that 5% of the
recovery world is kind of moving in your direction? Are we anywhere close to that? Is it expanding
in a way that you see that we're going to be better off? I don't know how to quantify that.
What I can tell you is that trauma awareness in society is growing. There's this book here
called What Happened To You by Dr. Bruce Ferry, written with Oprah, all about not what's wrong
with you, but what happened to you, all about childhood trauma and its manifestations.
There are my books published in 30 languages. The new one, which is out in the fall,
is already being bought in 21 languages around the world. Bessel van der Kolk's wonderful text,
or wonderful public book on trauma, The Body Keeps the Score,
international and New York Times number one bestseller for years upon years now.
This indicates a sea change in society's awareness of trauma. That sea change has
not penetrated the official institutions like the medical faculties and the academic
institutions so much, and certainly not government policy. But it is changing.
People are coming more on board, whether it's 5% or 7.5%. I don't have the means to quantify it.
What I can say is there's an encouraging awareness on the part of more and more people,
in the face of a lot of official resistance.
I was interested in that topic as well, Gawor, because it does feel like
there has been a big shift in the conversation, or there's a growing shift
in the direction of your work and your understanding. I think the book that came
out by Johan Hari was very much along those similar lines. It does feel to me like the
conversation is moving in that direction. I wonder whether you're seeing the same thing
from your perspective. It so happens I was speaking to Johan just this morning in another event.
As I say, the indications are that it's changing. The public interest is changing
on the part of a significant minority. I think it's going to take a long time.
I think it's going to take a long time, but it's very encouraging how far it's come in the last 10
years. Yeah, I want to say thank you to everybody. Beautiful sharings from everyone.
I'd say a special thank you to Karl. Karl, just before this, Karl is a friend of mine.
I'm going for a beer with after this. Karl, do you want to say something and you'll come up to
the front of everyone's screen? You're going to have to unmute yourself. Are we allowed to go
for a beer after? I'm not sure if that's the done thing, David. Just the one. Thank you, Karl,
because just before this, Karl is a very close friend who said, oh, I want to be there for you,
and that was really touching. Thank you, Karl, and thank you for being there for me over the
last years. Thank you for sharing it for me, Dave. You've been a wonderful friend and
you've made your journey something of use to other people, and I think that's a real gift
to be able to do. You're a good man. Yeah, and I want to acknowledge the support that I've had
that has been invaluable in the journey with my mother and everything that's unfolded over the
last years, which has been an insane amount to handle, but has actually been the most
incredible transformational process as well in my growth. So, yeah, thank you, Karl,
and other friends for being there. Genevieve, who's here somewhere as well, who's my ex-housemate,
and there she is. Can you unmute yourself, Genevieve, in my old kitchen? Oh, gosh, yeah,
I'm in 99, back in the old world. Yeah, that's the house I lived in for 12 years,
but we turned it into a pop-up restaurant and all sorts. Yeah, and also thank you to so many of the
previous members, like Adriana and Nick, coming back for this session, and I really feel the
emotional resonance of this topic, and yeah, I really feel the value of opening up these spaces,
and I would love to do more of this. It's a really heartful space, and yeah, most of all,
Gabor, thank you so much for being here. Thank you so much for all of the amazing work and the
dedication that you have to, I can see, and the dedication you have to others and helping others.
So, thank you so much. Thank you so much. If I may mention, for those of you that are in London or
near it, on June the 13th, I'll be in a public event on how we can transform trauma into wisdom,
and I don't have the website here, but you can look on my website or find it. It'll be
the evening of June the 13th in London somewhere. Yeah, I'll send that. I'll make sure I send that
out to our mailing list, Gabor. I'll send out a special message to our mailing list,
so if you just get in touch with me on email, I'll make sure that we share it.
And then I'll be back again in October when the book actually comes out and there'll be some
public events. So, listen, thank you. It's such a pleasure to work with you, David, and all of you
that shared so openly. It's always an honor to connect with real human beings. Thank you, Gabor.
And as we traditionally do at the end of these calls, if everyone would like to unmute themselves,
we'll just say thank you and goodbye until next time. Thank you.
