Mysticism, Spirit and the Shadow' - Jordan Peterson interview part 1

Rebel Wisdom
9 followers
12 Video Views·Nov 15, 2022
I've always been surprised that I've been able to teach what I've been teaching in the universities.
Because I've always regarded it as crazily radical in a sense, you know.
It's crazily radical in a conservative way.
I don't know what to make of that.
Your teaching is crazily radical?
In a conservative way, yeah.
I mean it's in a conservative way because I think that the past not only has value,
we cannot live without the integration of the past.
No more than you can live as an individual without integrating your past.
I mean we're historical creatures, right?
And if we're not united consciously with the past,
then we're divided internally and socially.
And that has consequences.
So some of them are playing themselves out in the political divisions in the current world.
But the consequences can be fatal.
So, you know, what's the saying?
A house divided amongst itself cannot stand.
Right, exactly.
And the house is a very, very...
To the degree that any symbol is universal,
the house is a pretty universal symbol for the structure of the psyche.
So, yeah.
Flowing on from that, it's interesting to hear you call it radical conservatism.
Because there's a few quotes that I've transcribed from the Ideology, Logos and Belief lecture,
which I remember having a kind of hair stand up on the back of my neck at the moment when I heard you say this.
I don't know what happens to a person if they bring themselves completely into alignment.
I've had intimations of what that might mean.
We don't understand the world very well.
We don't understand how the world could be mastered if it was mastered completely.
We don't know how an individual might manage that.
We don't know what transformations that might make possible.
That's mysticism rather than religion, is it not?
Well, I don't know if you can...
You could draw a distinction between those two things to some degree.
Because you could say that in a religious system, there's two components.
And people are temperamentally inclined to align with one or the other.
There's a dogmatic component, so the conservatives are more likely to align with that.
And there's an active mystical component, which updates the conservative component, but also threatens it.
Which is what creative thought does in general.
And so I would say that the mystical element of that is religious, but it's more on the transformative side.
But I also think that figures like the Buddha, he's an exemplar of the possibilities of that alignment.
And the exercises, the yogic exercises, for example, are attempts to bring that alignment into being.
It's very centered on the body, which is quite interesting, even though it's a spiritual tradition.
It's very, very centered on the body.
And I suppose that's related to the idea of the Christian idea, and the Jewish idea for that matter.
But the Christian idea, more particularly, of the sacredness of the body.
And also the Christian insistence that in the universal resurrection, the body will also be resurrected.
And you know, people are cynical about that idea.
Because they think about it as simplistic, and archaic, and superstitious, and all of that.
And they're missing the point.
The point is that that system doesn't denigrate the body.
It says there's something about the body that's integral to being, and cannot merely be disposed of.
And so if there's an eternality to existence, then it's an embodied eternality.
That's not, especially given what we know now about the manner in which intelligence operates,
it's not really possible to have a disembodied being.
It's not possible, really.
When you say you have intimations of what that might mean, can you explain what you mean by that?
Well, I've had experiences where everything came together.
And they're very, very powerful experiences.
And they're also characterized by...
It's like everything turns into a musical symphony, where each part is exactly appropriate for that moment.
And I think music actually expresses that.
Which is partly why music produces transcendent experiences.
When people are dancing to something profound, and they're really into it, let's say,
the music and the person are the same thing.
And then if things really get going, you see this sometimes in a rock concert or a musical concert,
where everyone is in the same place.
The band kicks into high gear, and they're way out beyond where they usually go.
You don't see that that often in a concert, even a great concert.
But now and then you really see it.
The whole place is one thing.
It's just pulsing.
That's an amazing experience.
And I think it is an intimation of paradise.
It's something like that.
And you can think about that psychologically.
Because it also makes sense psychologically that your optimal experiences are going to occur
when you're most united with yourself.
But I don't know what...
See, we don't exactly understand the relationship between our consciousness and the world.
The materialistic notion is that everything is deterministically causal, essentially.
It's a Newtonian view.
It's also not true.
But we know that it's factually not true.
But apart from that, or...
I shouldn't say that exactly.
But at the very base of things, determinism isn't the operative mechanism.
And I think things are too complex, actually, to be strictly determined.
And it does look to me like we negotiate through that complexity.
But we're at our best when we're integrated completely.
And there's an effect of that integration, in principle, on what we would normally regard as external reality.
Because external reality can line up with that integration as well.
And so-called external reality.
And I think people probably experience that when they have peak sexual experiences with someone.
You know, where there's real intimacy.
Because they're in the same place at the same time, and everything comes together for that moment.
Maybe literally.
Yes, yes, literally. Right.
And I also don't think that that linguistic usage is chance.
Right, because I think that's a place where that experience is a brief intimation of heaven.
That might be a way of thinking about it.
Well, through listening to you, it started to make sense of a lot of what I've been doing over the last few years.
I've done quite a lot of deep transformational practices.
A lot of shadow work, so integrating the shadow.
And actually feeling that real sense of becoming more in alignment with myself.
Feeling these different parts of myself coming together and feeling more embodied and more present in the world.
But it was through listening to you that I made this connection with the Logos.
With the idea that this is actually a deep principle of Western culture, which gave it another real interesting perspective.
It's the principle of the incarnation.
Because the incarnation is at least a symbolic representation of the idea that the spirit has to fully inhabit the body.
And that's also a remarkable idea.
Especially because the spirit, so to speak, the psyche, if you want, flees from the body in terror.
Because the body is the place of mortality and suffering.
And so people are disembodied.
One way of looking at it is because they're too afraid to become fully embodied.
And it's no wonder they're afraid.
There's a reason to be afraid.
But the question is, well, what would you be like if you had the courage to be fully embodied?
And that's fully incarnate.
That's another way of thinking about that.
And the idea, the Christian idea, is that the fully incarnate human being is the Messiah.
That's the idea.
That's a hell of an idea.
But it means embracing the horrors of the world.
That's what it means.
And that's not only the horrors of the world, but the evil of the world.
So there's this idea that Christ took...
Absolutely.
Those are not different.
And there's this idea that not only was Christ the incarnate spirit, so fully descended into the body, let's say,
but that he also took the sins of the world onto himself.
And what that means is that, psychologically speaking,
is that part of spiritual development is to recognize the satanic tendencies that characterize you
and to fully wrestle with them and to integrate them.
That's the thing.
It's not so much to cast them away.
It's to transmute them.
And you can see the difference between people who've done that and people who haven't, at least to some degree,
because people who haven't integrated the shadow at all are naive.
And you can tell that when you look at them.
And you can tell that when you talk to them.
And because they're naive, they're often resentful as well, because they get taken advantage of.
And someone who's integrated that more, they're dangerous in the martial arts sort of way,
which is they're dangerous, but they don't have to use it, because their presence radiates...
What would you say?
It doesn't radiate threat, exactly.
Well, certainly strength, but it's the potential for havoc.
That's the right way of thinking about it.
There's an implicit potential for havoc, and that's really necessary.
It's one of the things that gives people self-respect.
This is an interesting thing about the integration of the shadow,
because recognizing yourself as the locus of evil, let's say,
actually, in some sense, gives you far more respect for yourself, strangely enough,
because the same respect that you might have for a wild animal or even a monster,
so then maybe you learn to treat yourself differently.
I think this is particularly true with regards to the discipline of children.
If you know that you're a monster, and that that will manifest itself in your life,
consciously or unconsciously, and if it's unconsciously, it's not good,
then you become better at disciplining children.
And the reason for that is that you don't want to expose them to your dark side.
And so if they behave and don't provoke you, which means they'll also behave for other people,
then the monstrous part can stay in abeyance, and then that's great.
But if you don't understand yourself as capable of wreaking havoc,
and that can be the kind of havoc that unfolds over decades,
because if you're going to abuse a child, the primitive form of abuse is the physical abuse.
The sophisticated form of abuse is the continual undermining of the child's courage
across perhaps their entire life.
And there's a terribly monstrous element to that.
And if you're not respected properly by the child, say,
you will absolutely take revenge on them.
And in some sense, that's the whole Freudian psychoanalytic story.
It's not all of it, but it's a huge part of it.
It's interesting that you say that you have to accept the fact that you're dangerous, or become dangerous.
Because I'd also say that if you haven't done that kind of shadow work,
if you haven't made friends with your anger, if you haven't integrated it,
you're actually more dangerous.
Yes, definitely.
Because then things will happen that will come out in a way that you don't expect.
Right, it comes out disintegrated.
So it comes out as an autonomous spirit, right, under no one's control.
And that's like a burst of rage, let's say.
When you hear about a mother who's done something terrible to one of her children,
that's the reason is that maybe she's just been laid off,
maybe she went out and had too much to drink,
maybe she's hung over, she's angry and lonesome,
and she's overwhelmed by the responsibility of the children,
and she has a child who's testing.
And she doesn't know how to limit it.
And one day, the child tests at exactly the wrong time,
and it's like mayhem.
And everybody goes, well, what happened?
It's like, well, seven terrible things came together at the same time
and produced this outburst of disintegrated rage.
And like, look the hell out when that happens, you know?
So, yeah, you want to have that.
You either have that or it has you.
Those are the options.
And you don't become safe by being castrated.
That's not the right move forward.
And it almost feels like having done that, I feel that as a physiological thing.
It is a physiological thing.
There's more tools at my disposal.
Exactly, it is a physiological thing.
I mean, you can actually see a change in people's faces
when that part of them is integrated.
I would say the rage circuit is integrated because their face is hardened.
Like, they no longer look like wide-eyed children.
They're no longer someone to whom things only happen.
They're someone who makes things happen.
And there isn't much difference between being dangerous and being indomitable.
They're the same thing looked at from two different perspectives.
And so, you know, in my new book I wrote a little bit about
there was an idea in the 80s that was reasonably popular among psychologists
that the way to regulate male aggression was to socialize little boys like little girls.
And that's a very, very bad idea.
So, because suppressing that aggressive, competitive urge,
which also characterizes many women, by the way,
although it's more common among men,
that isn't what you do.
You integrate it.
This is why I'm such a fan of Piaget.
You know, not as opposed to Freud,
but I think Piaget's developmental model is superior to Freud's developmental model
because for Piaget, the process of becoming civilized
is a process of continual integration,
including the integration of what Freud would consider the id.
You know, I mean, it's not as if Freud didn't know that
because he wanted people to incorporate the id,
but he, you know, he kind of conceptualized socialization
as the superego inhibiting the id, you know, or suppressing it.
That only happens when the socialization process is bad.
When it's good, like if you have a competitive child,
like my son was and is a competitive person,
you have them integrate that into the ethos of fair play.
And then it's a mark of character strength at that point.
Absolutely. There's no doubt about it.
Would you also say that that has to be balanced with compassion,
with a greater sort of openness as well at the same time?
Well, it has to be aimed, right?
You need an aim, and to put your integrated capabilities
to work at bringing everything together is the right aim,
and it's not a task for...
You know, one of the things about, I think,
and one of the things about the way morality is taught
is it's always taught like it's your two...
It's always taught as if it's your grandma and her corset is too tight.
You know, it's a hectoring sort of thing, that you should be good,
and the reason that you should be good is kind of for other people,
you know, and so it's a...
It's almost like the Freudian sense you talked about.
Yeah, that's the superego sense, exactly, that's right,
and that it's a bunch of restrictions on you,
and so you have to reduce yourself in order to be a good person,
and that's...
Well, you might say that that's a prerequisite to discipline,
because I think in some sense it is, you know,
that you do have to be molded and shaped.
You know, Nietzsche believed that a long period of unfreedom
had to precede a period of freedom,
and that's something like discipline,
but fundamentally that's not the proper orientation,
because making everything work better
is actually the most demanding task that you can take on,
and it's not a matter of reducing yourself to a domesticated moral being,
you know, like a...
Well, like a...
Like a fat pug dog, something like that, you know.
It's a task that takes everything that you've got,
and so you can use all of those darker forces, let's say,
to be indomitable as you move forward,
and you want a challenge,
because all of those forces are exactly the thing
that is there for the challenge,
and so it becomes a matter of...
Well, it's a conversion of something that can be very dark
into something that's a prerequisite for light.
I was thinking this on the plane,
linking to the thing I said before
about how connecting this personal growth
to the idea of the Logos was really powerful,
and reframing this,
and I've heard you speak about this in a certain way,
as almost like a heroic mission.
You take on ultimate responsibility for your words,
you take on responsibility for moving the world
either closer or further from chaos.
Yeah, you take on responsibility
for moving the world closer to heaven or hell.
And this...
I was thinking how powerful a doctrine of...
I've always thought,
I've made a few documentaries about ISIS before,
and how seductive a worldview that is.
Right, right.
You can either be a shelf-stacker in Wolverhampton,
or you're on the front line fighting for your culture
in an existential conflict for the future of the world.
Right.
So what I find powerful,
and I've only really thought this the last few days,
is your message almost allows you to reframe your own life
in that same heroic way.
And it feels like something like that is essential...
It is essential.
...for us to fight back against those kind of ideologies.
There's no doubt about that,
and it's for the reason that you just laid out.
It's like you take a tough 17-year-old kid,
who's rebellious enough not to fit well
into the extra-domesticated school systems
that we impose on our children.
Most of my friends,
because I lived in a working-class town,
most of my friends dropped out of school before grade 10.
And I wouldn't say it was the least admirable kids
who dropped out.
These were guys who pretty much physically matured
at 15 or 16.
Some of them were pretty big and strong.
And they were done with putting up their hand
to go to the bathroom.
They were just done with that.
And the fact that they left school,
it was a bad long-term decision,
maybe for many of them.
I mean, a lot of them went and worked on the oil rigs
and made a fortune,
but they never kept any of it.
But they didn't drop out of school
only for weakness and failure.
And so there has to be a challenge put forward
to those people who are inclined
in that aggressive, competitive direction.
Or they will fall prey to,
well, you mentioned,
you know, why would people go fight for ISIS?
Well, you just said why.
And you can't really understand that
unless you can allow yourself to imagine
how you could be attracted to that.
And the shelf stacker versus the heroic desert warrior,
I mean, you know, it's an illusion.
And it's a dangerous one.
And it's being utilized in a very manipulative manner
by the people who are pushing this.
But you always have to give the devil his due.
And do you think we need a heroic story of our own
to combat it?
Well, what do you have otherwise?
You know, you have a life of pleasure-seeking.
You have no admiration for yourself
if you live a life like that, right?
There's contempt.
There's self-contempt that's going to build.
Or engagement in things at a trivial level,
which isn't useful.
Because in the final analysis,
whatever your life is, it's not trivial.
The suffering makes it not trivial as a baseline.
You're stuck.
You're stuck with a certain number of profound experiences.
And all of them can be negative if you don't...
All of them can be negative
if you let the default manifest itself.
But you don't get trivial
because you have to encounter your own death
and the death of everyone around you
and the horrors of the world.
And so, there's no trivial response
that doesn't subject you to that with no defense
and then embitter you.
So, yeah, it's...
I mean, there's a call to nobility
in the idea of imitation of the logos.
But it's more than that.
It's a call to something of...
Well, the hypothesis is
it's a call to something of cosmic significance.
And I don't think that we have any right
to assume that that idea is wrong.
We don't understand our place in the cosmos.
And, you know, if you base your analysis on size,
physical size,
well, there are bigger things than us.
But it's no...
That's no...
That's not a reasonable yardstick.
There isn't anything that's more complex than us.
Not that we know of.
So, why not use that as a marker?
And there is something.
There's an integral relationship
between consciousness and being.
And that isn't taken with sufficient seriousness
by the materialist community.
They keep...
People like Daniel Dennett, for example.
You know, he wrote a book on consciousness
which his critics...
It was called Explaining Consciousness.
And his critics called it Explaining Consciousness Away.
And I read the book.
And that is what he did, as far as I'm concerned.
And, you know, people like Sam Harris
have a real hard time with free will.
And so their proclivity is to deny it.
But they act out the proposition
that people have free will, including themselves.
Because otherwise they wouldn't be able to exist in society.
Because people aren't very happy
when you treat them like they're not
at least semi-autonomous agents.
And so I don't think that that's fluke.
I think that we are semi-autonomous agents.
Now, we don't understand how that can be possible.
But I'm not willing to say that it isn't the case
merely because I can't explain it.
Especially when I observe that
people accept it behaviorally
as an axiomatic proposition.
So they accept it as true.
They can say they don't believe it.
But it doesn't matter.
Well, it depends on what you think you mean
when you say believe.
And for me, you act out what you believe.
And your conscious, your cognitive,
your capacity for abstraction
can divorce itself from your embodied reality
and go wherever it wants.
It can even propose contradictory...
It can propose a worldview that
isn't in alignment with the manner of your embodiment at all.
That happens all the time.
It happens to everyone to some degree
because we're not transparent to ourselves.
But it isn't so straightforward
to determine what our place is in the world.
And the thing that really got me with regards to that
wasn't the good that we can do
but the harm that we can do.
Because you can debate about the good we can do.
But you cannot debate about the harm we can do.
That's done.
We know if we want to know.
And I think my experience was
when I took that seriously,
which meant understanding how that was about me,
that Auschwitz was about me,
and that the Stalinist camps were about me,
then while that reorients you,
that's a deep part of the shadow idea.
And I think that is part of the idea
of taking the sins of the world onto yourself.
It's like, you're a human being,
so you see what human beings do.
That's you.
And you might say, well, I'd never do that.
It's like, don't be so sure about that.
In fact, the probability that you're wrong
is extraordinarily high.
Well, that's yes.
It isn't self-evident that the default position
is heroism in the face of the advance of evil.
In fact, quite the contrary.
So it's highly probable that you would be
on the side of the weak
who are transformed into oppressors.
And that's a very terrifying realization
if you take it seriously,
which you should.
And I do believe that
if we don't take that with sufficient seriousness,
we are not going to survive
because we're too powerful to be naive.
And that was something that Jung insisted on,
especially after the invention
of the hydrogen bomb in particular.
It's like, if you're going to play with fire,
you'd better be a master of fire.
What are the prerequisites
for true knowledge and understanding?
Because it seems to me that
intelligence is only a small matter
of seeing and understanding properly,
and it takes a certain amount of moral courage.
It takes a certain amount of
having done the work of introspection,
having done the work of deep introspection.
What do you think the components are
for true knowledge and understanding?
Well, I think the motivation,
one of the best motivations,
is existential terror.
You know, I mean,
I don't remember where this is in the Old Testament,
but the line is,
the fear of God is the beginning of wisdom.
And that's definitely psychologically true.
But we could strip it, say,
of its transcendent implications,
and say, well, for me, anyways,
I wasn't motivated to be serious
until I knew what I was capable of
in the most negative way.
Because you don't take yourself seriously
until you know that you can be,
you are an evil monster.
And you don't take that seriously
until you know what that means.
And so, but once you know what that means,
especially if you do it,
if you find that out consciously, say,
then you're in a position
to start taking yourself seriously enough
so that you might be willing to
learn what you need to learn to become wise.
You have to see yourself as an Auschwitz camp guard.
And you have to see yourself enjoying it.
And that can't just be an exercise
in intellectual simulation, precisely.
It has to be a dramatic experience.
You have to feel that in your bones.
And then you have to decide.
And you have to give the devil his due.
There's something very attractive about predatory power.
And you might even say that it's
preferable to pathetic weakness.
Now, I'm not saying that,
but you could make a case that it is.
Because you could say that the person
who's pathetically weak
would like to be a predatory tyrant
but just doesn't have the ability.
And that's, well, that's a Nietzschean criticism
of standard morality, I would say.
But then, is there something higher
than predatory power?
Well, yes.
I mean, part of Christ's encounter
with Satan in the desert
is precisely that realization,
because he's offered the kingdom of the world.
And that means he's offered
the option of tyrannical power.
And his response to that is,
there's something better.
And that's wisdom.
There is something better.
And there's no reason not to go
for what is the best.
What else?
You don't have anything better to do
than that, by definition.
So why not work for the betterment of being?
And abandon your resentment
and your hatred of humanity
and your self-contempt.
And take on the responsibility
of the horrors and catastrophes
of human existence.
And do what you can to,
well, at least not make it worse,
but maybe to make it better.
You know you can.
You know you can make it worse and better.
You just don't know how much.
Find out.
It might be way more than you think.
I'm sure that's the case.
So there isn't any more
interesting adventure than that.
Find out how much good
you can do in the world.
And not in this moralistic
thou shalt not way,
but in a forthright,
noble, courageous,
eyes wide open,
articulate, embodied manner.
And then God only knows
where we could get.
So let's see.
Let's find out.
That would be good.
It's certainly better than the alternative.
I don't know if you saw the logo
that we've put together for Rebel Wisdom
and recognized the eye and the triangle.
Yep, perfect.
We were looking for an abstract kind of way
that didn't look too illuminati.
A little bit illuminati,
but not quite so much.
Yeah, well that's the thing.
It's the sun in the pyramid
that you worship,
not the pyramid.
Right.
Because the sun is the thing that,
in both senses,
that stops it from being
the patriarch.
So that's the thing that you can have
a relationship with.
That it sort of transcends
the dominance hierarchy itself.
Yeah, it is.
It's like in The Lion King.
There's that little bird, Zazu.
He flies above everything.
He sees everything.
That's the eye.
That's the Egyptian eye.
It's outside the structure.
It's the thing that moves up and down
the structure.
And it repairs it.
That's what consciousness does
in your body.
It moves up and down levels of reality,
let's say,
and alters them.
So it's outside the structure.
And it's also the thing that gives rise
to the structure.
But the structure also gives rise to it.
That's why there's Trinitarian ideas
in Christianity.
There's the Father and the Son,
and they're mutually causal.
You think, well, how can that be?
Well, the Son gives birth to the Father,
obviously, because boys turn into men.
But the Father also gives birth to the Son.
And so that's part of the reason
that those Trinitarian ideas exist.
