Jordan Peterson - Masculinity is not toxic: part 2 of interview

Rebel Wisdom
9 followers
11 Video Views·Nov 15, 2022
Especially in the interview with Camille Paglia, I think you said that you fear that men checking
out could be a fatal situation for Western culture.
Oh, it's definitely fatal for Western culture. One of the things that struck me over the
last year, well even last night at the lecture, at last night's lecture, 85% of the people
were men. Now in the 12-part series that preceded that, more and more women came, and then there
was this gap, but the vast majority of the audience was men, and men of all sorts. Like
every sort of man was represented there. Young, old, rough, civilized, the whole range. And
they're coming from quite a long distance, many of them. They come up and say, well I
drove from New York City, or I drove from Michigan, and it's like, well you could watch
it on YouTube. It's like, no, they're not doing that. And that's very promising to
me, because, well, this Logos, the West will die without the rebirth of the Logos. Because
the West is that. So, with that gone, it's gone, and we've seen what's arisen to replace
it. Well, there's fascism, there's communism, and then there's the New Age mess, because
it's a mess. And most of it's wish fulfillment and fantasy, and inability to... There's creativity
in it, but there's no capacity to edit whatsoever. There's no coherence. And so, that stuff's
so weak that anyone with any commitment can just push it aside. And there's no justification
for the Marxism, or for the fascism. It's like, we already had that experiment.
Could you describe what you mean by the rebirth of the Logos, then, in that context?
Well, it's the... Part of it is taking voluntary responsibility for the appalling conditions
of your life, essentially. That you're a suffering creature that's mortal, right? And that you're
the locus of evil. Both of those things. And that it's your response, that your life is
about responsibility, and it's your responsibility to voluntarily accept that, and then to do
what you can about it. Even though it's, in some sense... You know, it's an enterprise
doomed to failure, in some sense, because you're going to die, and the world is a carnage,
a place of carnage. But that... You can accept that. And if you can't accept it, then what
that means is that you're not integrated enough. Because if you're integrated enough, then
you can accept it. It's like the test of the integration. So your character isn't forged
sufficiently if you cannot tolerate that. And it's not like it's an easy thing to tolerate.
Often what people do is they just don't think about it. They just push it out of their mind.
And no wonder. But they pay for that with shallowness, and with self-contempt, and with
the inability to bear suffering nobly, let's say. And that's... There's nothing in that
that's good for people. So, the rebirth of the Logos, as far as I'm concerned, is, well,
it's this willingness to take responsibility for the shaping of destiny. That's it. I mean,
the old Mesopotamian god Marduk, when he became the pinnacle god by election, basically, one
of his demands from the other gods was that he be in control of the tablet of destiny.
And so, the old idea among the Mesopotamians was that the highest god was he who was in
control of destiny. It's like, well, to the degree that you align yourself properly, then
you take responsibility for destiny. And that's a concentric set of circles with no end, you
know, because you can straighten up yourself, and then you can straighten up your family.
And if you do that properly, you're simultaneously strengthening the community. And then you're
a model for your peers, and so that starts to spread. And we don't have any idea what we would
be like if we all got our acts together. Like, we're pretty amazing as it is, human beings.
And, you know, we're probably devoting who knows what it is in terms of percentage. I mean,
Tao Te Ching suggests, you know, that 30% of people are working to make things better,
and 30% of people are neutral, and 30% are trying to make things worse. So,
it's obviously a metaphor, but there's some truth in it. We don't know what it would be like,
what we would be like if we put our effort to making things better, devoted our effort to
making things better, wherever we went. And it would be interesting to find out.
How would you summarize why men are in crisis now?
I think it's because in a deep level, the West has lost faith in the idea of masculinity.
That's no different than the death of God. It's the same thing. And Nietzsche knew what the
consequence of that would be. I mean, that's most of what he wrote about. And so you'd say,
well, the divine symbol of masculinity has been obliterated. Well, so then what do you expect?
What's going to happen? That means masculinity is going to become weak.
And especially if the symbol is also denigrated, which it definitely is.
So, what that means is that the ideal that man could aspire to is denigrated.
And well, then with your ideal, it tatters. You're weak. That's definitional.
So, I think the reason that men have been responding positively to my thinking,
let's say, is that I don't buy any of that. I like the masculine spirit. It's necessary.
And it's not fundamentally carnage and pillaging. It's not fundamentally rape culture.
It's not fundamentally world-destroying. And all of those aspersions have been cast upon it.
That's partly the guilt of Western society for technological progress, even.
And those are reasonable challenges to be set before men. But they're not reasonable
accusations to swallow without criticism.
If it's not that, what is it? What is the masculinity we can aspire to?
Well, it's responsibility, fundamentally. And to put it symbolically is that your
responsibility is to incarnate the spirit of the logos. That's your responsibility. That's your
role in life. And that is independent to some degree in whether or not you accept the idea
of a transcendent and eternal reality. Now, I'm not making a case for that or against that.
Those things are beyond human understanding. But we know what happens if people act poorly,
if men act badly. We know what happens. We know that the world turns into something that's so
close to hell that the difference is trivial. We know that. That's the story of the 20th century.
So we should learn that lesson. And what that lesson is, is pick up the world on your shoulders
and walk forward. Pick up the world with all of its trouble, with all of its suffering,
with all of its evil, and move forward with it. And in bearing that burden, learn that you're
the sort of creature that can bear that burden, and therefore deserving of respect.
That's identification with the logos. I've never encountered an idea that's better than that,
because it's so not naive. It's the opposite of naive. There's terrible evil, and there's
bottomless. But the human spirit is capable of voluntarily taking that on as a challenge.
Well, it's worth a try. Yes, exactly. That's the positive meaning. That's the positive meaning.
That's the world-affirming meaning. That's self-esteem, let's say, which is very poorly
characterized. It's very shallowly characterized, because it usually doesn't involve any sense of
responsibility. But it's obvious in some ways. If you look at the people that other people
spontaneously respect, unless they become unbelievably cynical, it's the people who
adopt responsibility and deal with it competently. So it's not a mystery that that would be
what you could aspire to. Now, it gets undermined if you feel that that force of responsibility is
the raping and pillaging patriarchal culture that's despoiling the natural environment and
that's equivalent to a cancer. Well, no, I don't buy that. I assume that you're skeptical of the
description of gender as a spectrum. No, I'm suspicious of the motives for putting that idea
forward. And I also think it's an imprecise definition. It's not a spectrum, because a
spectrum is equally represented at each point in the distribution. So that's wrong. And it's wrong
in the way that you would expect it to be wrong, given its ideological basis. Now, you know, there's
male and female and masculine and feminine are not exactly the same thing. And that's a
reasonable claim. And you could also make a case that too much masculinity without an admixture
of femininity is a form of excess, and that too much femininity without an admixture of masculinity
is an excess, or is a failure. It's an extreme. But the obliteration of the distinction between
male and female or masculine and feminine is a psychological catastrophe, not least because
those are arguably the most basic cognitive axioms. They're deeper than that. They're axioms
on which our entire cognitive structure is predicated. Yin-yang. Yes, exactly, exactly,
exactly. Well, and I think that that's a consequence of our biological heritage,
like the reality of sex. Sex is very, very, very old. It's a fundamental issue. And sex is
fundamentally about female and male. And there's no getting around that. Now, as I said, you can
distinguish masculine and feminine from that, and you can speak about the psychological components
of sex as well as the physiological components. But the real radicals deny the physiological
components. It's like, that's okay, except when they force other people to do the same kind of
denial. People are entitled to their opinion, but they're not entitled to put it in the law. And so
that's why I was opposed not to transgender rights or to transgender people. I mean,
that's a sideshow in many ways. I'm not trying to trivialize it, but it's not the main event.
It's emblematic of something else. Otherwise, no one would have cared. And I just see it as
fundamentally oriented towards destabilization and destruction. I think my... I'll just sort of
complete that question, because I think it speaks to what you just said. Because I think some people
who are not motivated by the same things that are motivating the sort of extreme postmodernists
are somehow persuaded by their claims that gender is a spectrum. Because there is something in,
as Jung talked about, the anima animus, there is something about the inner masculine,
the inner feminine in all of us. And there is a complexity there that is more than just a sort of
straightforward masculine, feminine, and binary, which is where I think that we might be able to
get out of this.
Well, that's a reasonable point. One way of conceptualizing that is in terms of, let's say,
in terms of the archetypes. Well, we use the Christian archetypes for illustration. So you
could say, well, for the male, generally speaking, the logos is the primary image. And so that would
be partly associated with the word that creates order out of chaos, and also with the sacrificial
crucifixion and that sort of thing, the voluntary acceptance of suffering. But the divine mother and
child is behind that, because human males are actually quite maternal. We do participate in
raising children, even if they're not our own. You're much more likely to be abused by a stepfather.
I think the risk is 100 times greater. So it's not trivial. But still, the fact that it happens
at all is a biological miracle. So human being males are very maternal for male mammals, or for
males, period. And then females are pretty masculine. But you can kind of see the difference
to which the sexes differ by looking at the difference in their physiological configuration.
You know, men are bigger and stronger than women, and not a tremendous amount, although
upper body strength is a tremendous difference. But that's approximately how different they are.
And they're more the same than they are different. But the differences aren't trivial. And the thing
is, is that differences that are small at the average can be huge at the extremes. So you might
say, well, if you took the most agreeable people, say, the most compassionate people out of a hundred
and segregated them, they would all be women, all of them. And if you took the least agreeable people,
and those would often be people who have a criminal bent, they would all be men. And often
the cultural force is driven by the extremes, not by the middle. And so you don't need huge
differences in the average to produce relatively large differences in cultural manifestation.
That's why there are so many men in prison compared to women. You know, that's a big deal.
And it's not the sexism of society that does that, although it might be to some degree,
because like male judges give female criminals lighter sentences, for example, than female judges
give female criminals. But no one ever talks about that. So yes, it's reasonable to
note the psychological components of masculine and feminine, let's say it at a psychological
and symbolic level. But to do that at the same time that you're denying biological reality and
playing an anti-patriarchal game behind the scenes, and perhaps masking your Marxist anti-capitalism
at the same time, it contaminates all of it so badly that you can't have a reasonable discussion.
And so even the transgender issue that arose in Canada is so contaminated by the underlying
ideology. Well, first of all, people would have just ignored it if that wasn't the case.
But it's so contaminated by the underlying ideology that you can't trust the
legislation, not a bit. And that was my point. You can have equality, but then difference is
also essential within that. Yeah, unless you want sterile uniformity, which is something that
only a tyrant wants. I mean, that's what the tyrant wants is sterile uniformity. And the
sterile is not only ideational sterility, but actual physiological sterility. And that's no
recipe for the continuation of a culture. And you can be cynical about that and say, well,
one culture is as good as the next, and you don't have any responsibility to continue your culture.
But it depends on how you want to construe your life. One of the things that's so interesting
about the biblical stories is that these ancient people had a sense of the continuity of life
across generations that we really don't have. And maybe that's a consequence of, I don't know,
a too narrow individualism, something like that, or maybe it's a present-centered hedonism.
But they're always acting under guidance from God, let's say, as if the consequences of their
personal actions echo down the centuries, you know, indefinitely, which they actually do.
And then with regards to the issue of what... So you need men and women to play the role in that,
and they have to play their masculine and feminine roles, fundamentally,
even though male and female and masculine and feminine are not exactly the same idea.
There's no reason to not have the differentiation. It should be encouraged differentiation.
I feel like there's so much in the Maps of Meaning and the biblical lectures that I really want to
integrate into what we're teaching, because I think it's essential stuff. For orienting
yourself in the world, it just seems to be completely essential.
You can't do without it. That's right, absolutely. You're adrift without it. You have to
have a conscious relationship with the archetypes. There's no way... If you don't,
then you're susceptible to possession, or to despair. And no wonder.
Well, you've got to have axioms, so the right axioms are the archetypes.
Yes, that's why they exist.
So do you see archetypes as biological structures?
They're at least that. Yeah, they're pre-existing categories of perception,
in the Kantian sense. That's a good way of thinking about it, is that the pure empiricist
thinks that you get all your information from the outside world. But that's not true,
because you bring an a priori interpretive framework to the world. And that's instantiated
biologically, but then it's also enculturated. So separating the archetype from the underlying
biological reality isn't easy. So you have the snake. You have the propensity to perceive
reptilian predators. The manner in which those things are represented in the culture
fill those holes, essentially.
In the same way as the language instinct fills them.
Yeah, that's right, exactly. It's the same thing. The archetypes are manifestations of
the universal grammar of emotion and motivation. That's a good way of thinking about it.
Now, they may be more than that, because life has been moving forward for three and a half
billion years, and it moves forward in these patterned manners, like the dominance hierarchy,
for example. So let's call that the masculine archetype. It's part of the masculine archetype.
In fact, Jung's proclamation was that the female representation of the male,
so that's the animus, is the dominance hierarchy. It's the patriarchy. So that's the unconscious
archetype, which I think is extremely interesting given what's happened, say, in the women's
movement, because that's what's projected onto men. And it can be projected in a very negative
way. It doesn't have to be, but it can be. And so an animus-possessed woman treats a man as if he's
a manifestation of the tyrannical patriarchy. He's a group. He's the group of men. The group
of bad men, actually. You spoke really well about incarnating the logos, and I found
often sharing, for example, in men's groups, speaking my truth, speaking honestly, being
vulnerable, being open, being available has been really important. I don't hear you talking so
much about the value of, say, vulnerability or the value of emotional honesty. But as a
psychologist, that must be something that you value. Well, it's more just the value of honesty
in general. You're trying to represent being as accurately as you can in your communication.
That's part of the logos process. That's the truth. It's truth oriented to love, I think,
is the right formula. And love is something like the desire for being to flourish rather than to
be eradicated. Those are the archetypal realities. Are you working for the flourishing of being or
for its eradication? And there's a credible case to be made for its eradication. But love, I think,
in the archetypal sense, is the desire for being to flourish. And then truth is the attempt to
represent your relationship with being in the most precise and accurate manner possible.
Because, well, you have to adapt to reality. So you can't adapt to something to whose existence
you will not admit. And so emotional honesty is part of that. But I don't think it's more
important than any of the other elements of honesty. The vulnerability issue is you're
modeling not so much your vulnerability, but your voluntary acceptance of that vulnerability.
Because to just model your vulnerability is not necessarily distinguishable from being a victim.
I'm hurt, and I'm saying that I'm hurt. That's not the whole story. The whole story is, well,
we're all hurt, some of us more than others, certainly. But it's possible to come to terms
with that. And with God's grace, let's say, and maybe some help from other people, to accept that
and then transcend it. And that's the hope. The hope is that you get beyond your hurt,
because otherwise you tend to distribute it and pay it forward. And that's not good, obviously.
What's your attitude to group work or to some of the psychological processing stuff that has
come out of, say, the 60s and 70s? I found it very, very useful, but I've not heard you speak
radical. Well, it can go terribly wrong. And that's part of the reason it did in some ways
die out in the 60s. It could go terribly wrong. The encounter groups were often very hard on people.
It can easily become tyrannical and totalitarian. And I've seen that happen very rapidly in group
situations. But, I mean, group work, it's part of the way that you integrate yourself into the
society. So it's necessary. It's obvious that group work would be prone to all those potential
catastrophes, because those are the catastrophes of groups. But it's necessary. And I would say
the lectures that I'm doing, for example, there's group work there, because there's an audience,
right, a crowd, and people like the live part of it. And there is a difference between speaking
to people live in a group and speaking to them, say, through electronic means. There's a
collective spirit, let's say, that manifests itself in the room. And that's a consequence
of everyone imitating everyone else unconsciously. And that's a very powerful thing and can also
provide direction, because maybe if you're fortunate, and things are coming together
properly in the room, it's the best part of the crowd that rises up. And then that rises up as a
kind of ideal. And then that sort of possesses each individual, because they can see that they're
supported in their journey forward, and that these things can be, and they can look around
and think, well, these other people are taking this seriously, and paying attention. And so
there's something to take serious here, seriously here, and to pay attention to. And so that's all
good. But you have to be very aware that of the pitfalls. And so you have to beat yourself with
a stick so that you mean, you retain the proper humility. And the humility idea is a very
complicated one. And I think what that is, in essence, is that you have to remember all the
time, that what you don't know is more important than what you know. You have to remember that as
if your life depends on it, because it does. I mean, even technically, because there's so much
you don't know, you don't know enough, like you're prone to catastrophe. So you don't know enough,
by definition. And if you know that and understand that, then that can reduce the temptation to
act in a manner that would be totalitarian or tyrannical, and that can facilitate the group work.
So it's risky, but everything's risky. And just coming back to the idea of the
rebirth of the Logos, something that's been coming up quite a lot recently is the idea of initiation.
And there's a couple of organizations in the UK, one called Band of Brothers, which is using
men's work, initiation work of some description to take disadvantaged youths, and to give them a
sense of direction, give them a sense of purpose, give them a sense of dignity.
Well, that's part of what an initiation is for. Part of it is exposure to that which terrifies
you. That's part of it. But then in the state that that produces, you're supposed to be
inculcated with the cultural wisdom, and that partly is direction. I mean, that's what older
men have to provide. It's even the case with elephants. The young elephants, if a herd has
been decimated and the old guys are gone, the young guys basically go insane. They're uncontrollable.
And obviously that's the case with human beings. And so the purpose of mature men, or the
responsibility of mature men, is to give young men, is to be models, obviously, but mostly models of
direction. Yeah, well, you need direction. There has to be a rationale for aiming up,
because that's direction. You don't want to aim down. Why would you aim down unless you were angry
and bitter and resentful and full of hatred and all that? You aim up. But that has to be put
forward in a way that isn't this too-tight-corset, grandmotherly moralizing. Because anybody with
any sense who isn't overly domesticated is just going to reject that. So, you know, that's the
kind of morality that Nietzsche described as cowardice. He said most people's morality is
cowardice. It's they're afraid. They're afraid to be bad. And because they're afraid, they think
they're good. But they're not good. They're just afraid. And that's not morality. Morality is a
whole different issue. And it's partly aiming up, but it's also partly gathering your forces
together so that you aren't interfered with while you're moving upward. Because you will be.
People test it. Do you think the central problem of Western society is that we're intent
on slowing off responsibility at every level? Any society where people are shying away from
responsibility is a society that's self-crippling. Because the responsibility is to do the work
that's necessary to revitalize the culture, to rescue its fundamental axioms from the darkness,
to revitalize it, and to have it expand and grow. And if that isn't happening, then anything that
isn't growing dies. That's sort of a fundamental truth of life. And so I don't know if it's
precisely the central problem of the West, because it's not like there aren't people who
aren't taking responsibility in the rest of the world. But it's enough of a problem in the West
that it threatens us. And I think that's particularly felt by young men. I think the
reason for that, in part, is that the direction for young women, in some sense, is more obvious,
both culturally and biologically. Because young women are encouraged. If they're attempting to
manifest the logos, let's say, they're definitely encouraged in that. There's no doubt about it.
And then, as a backup, they have the divine mother and child. And so they're kind of set.
With men, it's more, this is perhaps why men have always undergone a ritual initiation,
because they need to be directed in a more articulate manner, in a more conscious manner.
They have to be inculcated with the culture in order to decide that adopting responsibility is
the appropriate thing to do. And they need a rationale for that, because
why the hell would you adopt responsibility without a rationale?
The default position is aimless, impulsive, pleasure-seeking, and inertia. Because all you
have to do to have that is do nothing. And that's easy. So then the immediate question is, well,
why not just do that? And one of the answers is, because you and the world will go to hell,
and very rapidly. And that's a pretty good answer. And it's actually true. Now, you know,
what that means in any eternal sense is not an easy thing to say, but the proximal sense is true
enough. So even inaction is not morally acceptable in the face of the unkempt, unfinished state of
being. I guess that's a reasonable way of thinking about it.
For our full-length documentary on Jordan Peterson, and more great content, check the Rebel
Wisdom website, where you'll also find details of some of the events we're running for men
to give a direct experience of some of what Jordan Peterson is talking about.
