In this episode - listen to us discuss some retinol alternatives, address the recent concerns surrounding Aquaphor, and provide some insights on the acquisition of Aesop.
Hit that subscribe button to never miss an episode!
*Affiliate Links Generate Revenue for the Channel*
Disclaimer: This video is not intended to provide diagnosis, treatment, or medical advice. Content provided in this video is for educational purposes only. Please consult with a physician regarding any health-related diagnosis or treatment.
What's up, everyone? Welcome back to Doctorly Unhinged. I don't know what our intro... Do I
do an intro part here? I feel like it's all you. We don't have an intro. We don't have an intro.
What's up, everyone? We're back. What's up, everyone? Welcome back to Doctorly Unhinged,
where we talk about all things related to skincare and beyond health, relationship advice,
all things. And we're going to jump right in today, and we're going to be talking about
retinol alternatives. It seems as if every article needs to lead with,
this is your alternative to retinol, or is this better to retinol, or is this the new retinol?
How about retinol is the retinol? It's like Botox is the Botox. That's it.
Oh, that's a good point. So, there's another thing, right, where everyone's like, this is
like Botox, or Botox-like effect. And it's like, no, Botox is Botox, unless you're juveau.
Unless you're juveau. Yeah. Oh, there's so much behind that. There's so much dirt there.
For those of you who don't know, Botox is a neuromodulator that's injected in the muscle,
and it basically stops muscle contractions. There are competitors that are also injectables,
like juveau, like dysport. But juveau was actually sued by Botox founder, creator Allergan,
or Abbey, for basically infringing upon their patent. And so, unless you're juveau,
and you infringe on patents, then you're not Botox, ultimately, is what we're saying. So,
all these ingredients that claim to be like Botox are not really like that. Though I would say
argyroline would be the ingredient that's closest to that. Right. And I was really high on argyroline.
So, argyroline is another topical. We're getting in the weeds, but let's go there. So,
argyroline is a topical that is actually modeled after kind of the whole complex,
to target the whole same complex that Botox is. It's topical, looked really promising in studies.
I was hyped. It's a very inexpensive ingredient. The products are inexpensive. How well does it
work in the real world? It's modest. It's just one of those things. It doesn't seem to be nearly
as effective at decreasing muscle weakness. It has other benefits as well. So, I still think
that ingredient stays. I think it's a good Botox additional, but it certainly did not succeed at
replacing Botox. Right. I think it can be added to your skincare routine to supplement
your other ingredients that are doing other things, right? So, like when you're looking
at anti-aging, you know, speaking of retinol, retinol acts on the retinoic acid receptor.
It increases collagen production, increases hyaluronic acid production, thickens the skin.
So, it acts on these receptors to have an actual effect on the skin, but it's not affecting muscle
contraction, right? So, Argireline plus retinol, they work by different mechanisms to fight off
the signs of aging. And so, can be used together. So, I look at it as like not going to be leading
your skincare routine, but certainly could be an alternative to your already existing,
well-thought-out skincare routine to fight aging. Right. And now, like Dr. Shah said,
retinol covers so many bases for photoaging, if not all of the bases. So, why would you even
want an alternative? I mean, so it could be irritating. It can't be used in pregnancy.
It can be broken down by the sun. And I feel like that's almost all that's against it.
The efficacy, you may be able to increase it with prescription ingredients, but that's
questionable too. There's a little debate about that. But if we're looking for a retinol alternative,
let's run through this list and see which ones are good, which ones are bad.
What's the new latest and greatest option? Yeah. So, you tell me. I'll list them. You tell me if
you think that they're the retinol alternative or not. All right, let's do it. Okay. According
to this article, here are the best retinol alternatives. Move over retinol, it says.
Bakuchiol. What are your thoughts? This one has a decent amount of studies. So,
does it do the same thing as retinol? It's thought to have a lot of the same clinical benefits. It's
thought to work in a different way, but have kind of a similar endpoint, both on a cellular level
and then clinically as well. This one is also thought to be safe in pregnancy. I feel like I'm
saying this. It's thought to do this. It probably does this. It does that. The pregnancy thing is
kind of the prime example of this ingredient. There's no real studies on pregnancy. It's just
thought to be safe in pregnancy. I do believe it is an acceptable alternative to Botox. I think it
can have similar benefits. Or Botox. Oh my gosh. I'm still where we were. It's thought to have
similar benefits to retinol. I think it actually does have similar benefits to retinol in the real
world. I think it's a good alternative, but it's like, why? This is another one though. Why not
use both? Why not like Argerolene? You can use both of these together. They don't quite work
the same way. I don't think it would substitute for retinol entirely. I don't think the evidence
is there. My personal opinion is that it's probably not quite as effective, but for someone who can't
tolerate retinol from irritation or from being pregnant, I think this is actually a pretty good
substitute. Yeah, I think I completely agree with that. It's interesting when people compare
everything to retinol, it almost makes it as if retinol is the gold standard, which I think is
true, but I still think that people will hype up these other ingredients and say they are retinol
like and then choose that over retinol, which to me is interesting because if you're comparing it
to retinol, then you're admitting that retinol is the gold standard for an anti-aging treatment,
right? And Bakuchiol saying that it is safe in pregnancy is basically saying that it hasn't been
shown to not be safe in pregnancy essentially because they've never tested it in pregnancy,
right? So, I've made that mistake myself saying that Bakuchiol is safe in pregnancy while retinol
is not safe in pregnancy, is that we know that retinol can, if you had high levels of
absorption of retinol into the body, have embryotoxic effects in pregnancy, whereas we
don't know about Bakuchiol, and so due to our lack of knowledge on the subject, we say that Bakuchiol
is safe in pregnancy, but we can't say for sure that it's safe in pregnancy, like something like
azelaic acid which has been tested in pregnancy is safe in pregnancy. Yeah, I think that that's
a super fair, and that's a common theme we're going to keep coming across too, is that the
safe in pregnancy thing, we will do a dedicated, we'll definitely do a dedicated video on this
because that's going to be the, I think the future of this thing going forward is that things are not
studied now in pregnancy, which is, you know, reasonable, so most things are kind of like
assumed, especially newer things like is it safe in pregnancy, is it not, who knows, probably for
things like peptides, Bakuchiol, niacinamide, vitamin c, etc. Right, so, all right, so we're
saying Bakuchiol has retinol-like benefits to the skin, but is certainly not the same as retinol,
and it doesn't act on the retinoic acid receptors, so it doesn't even have the same
mechanism as retinol does. So then the next one they have is rosehip oil. What are your thoughts
on rosehip oil? Oh, that's so interesting. I haven't heard about rosehip oil in so long. This
is a 2020 ingredient, 2020 ingredient. So, rosehip oil is, I used to love skin oils, I kind of still
do. We used to talk about it. This one's high in linoleic acid, linoleic acid, sorry, which we know
can be good for the skin barrier. There's supposed to be like a minuscule, if I remember right,
there's supposed to be a minuscule amount of actually retinol in this. I can actually find
this out. I've deep studied this extensively. That's correct, yeah.
Natural tretinoin. It has some retinoic acid in it.
Concentration varies with extraction, found to be as high as 0.0357 milligrams per liter
or 0.000357, so basically it has a minuscule amount of a tretinoin or retinoic acid.
The question then is, okay, so if you're going to use this as a retinoic acid or as a retinoid
and you're going to be extracting it, you're basically just using and creating a synthetic
retinoid anyway. To get this to be effective like a retinoid, I think you have to extract it
and create a retinoid out of it personally. So, I don't think you're going to get a retinol-like
effect from it. I do think it's a great oil. I think it's a great oil for your skin for multiple
reasons, but if you're looking for this to replace that retinol, I don't think it delivers just as a
plant oil. Acetylglucosamine. You got one I don't know much about.
So, you know, actually what's really interesting about an acetylglucosamine or acetylglucosamine
in general, I think this technology was pioneered by Neostrata, the skincare brand. It's owned by
J&J, so it's under the same umbrella as Neutrogena. So, you'll see an acetylglucosamine in a lot of
Neutrogena products, but that's because they were acquired by the same company that Neostrata
was acquired by. But the interesting thing about an acetylglucosamine to me is that it probably is
functionally the most similar to retinol and its benefits to the skin. It's been shown to
increase hyaluronic acid production. It's been shown to increase collagen production. It's been
shown to sort of have exfoliating benefits on the skin. It also has been shown to help with
pigmentation. So, a lot of the things that retinol is doing, to say an ingredient is retinol-like to
means that it needs to function similarly to retinol and the benefits of the skin,
which is increased collagen production, increased hyaluronic acid production,
thickening of the skin, minor exfoliating or increased cell turnover, and also tyrosinase
blockage. The reason why it helps in photoaging more than just increasing collagen and wrinkle
formation is it actually helps with the pigmentation and uneven skin tone, which is a
major contributor to the appearance of the aging face. And so, retinol has those benefits as well.
And actually, acetylglucosamine has been shown to actually hit many of those things. And so,
in its benefits, actually, I think acetylglucosamine is probably one of the
more underrated ingredients in skincare.
Yeah, maybe we'll see a lot more of that. I feel like I never see it highlighted in an
ingredient list because the thing I had bookmarked for that ingredient was just,
now it's highlighted. Now we're going to see a lot more, just like niacinamide was moved.
But yeah, I think it's promising.
What about niacinamide moving in? Niacinamide, what do you think about that as a retinol alternative?
If you look at the list of benefits with niacinamide, it not only looks like a retinol
alternative, it actually looks like a retinol superior, in my opinion, because it has benefits
like increasing ceramide production, decreasing transepidermal water loss in studies with eczema
that retinol doesn't bring to the table. My knock on niacinamide is always not the lack of benefits,
because it also helps with hyperpigmentation, acne, collagen, elasticity, salivary skin,
photoaging, as an antioxidant to reproduce NADPH, similar to some other ingredients out there.
But it's the effectiveness. I believe that niacinamide has a low ceiling. I think it's
a supporting ingredient at heart and will always be. I think it's a perfect complement for that
retinol. I think it is a suitable alternative, again, for that person who can't use retinol,
but I would not expect the world of it at any point.
Yeah, there's definitely a ceiling for it. And I actually like niacinamide plus retinol together.
I think that they're awesome complementing ingredients. And you can also use niacinamide
plus bakuchiol, why not, right? So I actually think that skincare, and we kind of mentioned
this when we talked about ozempic face, about how to reverse ozempic face or the weight loss
that occurs in the face when you lose weight rapidly, and how that leads to this sort of loss
of elasticity in the skin, and extra skin folds and all this kind of stuff, how we would treat
that by using multiple modalities to treat it so it's not just one thing. And I think that skincare
is sort of the same thing there. Everyone's looking for the Occam's razor ingredient to do
everything, but it's really the combination. It's the routine. The magic is in the routine
or in the stacking of ingredients that can target multiple things to improve the skin.
So it's not like you have to rest on one ingredient, really. And I think that there
is a move in the skinimalism world away from these single ingredient products to,
even if you're going to use single ingredient products, stacking them to achieve the best
benefit on the skin I think has become much more popular than just focusing on one product or one
ingredient as the skincare market has become more mature over the last few years. And the
users that were the adopters of the Ordinary and the Inkey List early on are now looking for more
streamlined routines. Yeah, absolutely.
So moving on to the next subject here, let's talk about lip plumping really quickly because
we talked about lip plumping in a video. And if you want to learn more about lip plumping,
you can watch our full YouTube video on the subject. But there is a trending article right
now, and the purpose of this podcast is also to stay as topical as possible, but Buzzfeed article
on Aquaphor causing lip plumping. The reason why I bring this up is because it's also sunburn season
right now, and we would be remiss as dermatologists not to bring up the risk of sunburn. But basically
this Buzzfeed article is saying, people on TikTok are warning others not to wear Aquaphor in the sun.
We ask experts if lip sunburns are a thing. And basically the couple videos that I've seen on
TikTok, and there are more than one, is basically people saying, don't go out in the sun if you're
wearing Aquaphor on your lips because it will cause your lips to swell up massively. And we're
So why are people getting sunburns on their lips when they're using Aquaphor? And should people be
wearing an SPF on their lips? That's a follow-up question. What are your thoughts? So the first
part of that is actually the question the article posed, and that's, can you get a sunburn on your
lips? The answer to that is yes, absolutely. If you've ever, you know who gets this a lot is
actually snowboarders and skiers. I see this more with them than I do the surfers. And yes,
so absolutely you can. Should you be wearing sunscreen on your lips? You should. I think,
especially if you're going to be outside for a long period, that whole outdoors, 10 and 2,
active person, you should really be cognizant of that. Because I would do a lot of surgeries on
lips. They're very extensive. I see them being very aggressive. Squamous cell carcinomas on
actually have a high risk of metastasis as well. So yes, protect your lips. And then the last part
of this, tying it all together, we've talked about Aquaphor before, and I think in the setting of
lips, when we've talked about dry lips, and is it a good chapstick? I think it is. It has a high
petrolatum concentration. It is pretty nourishing. People use it. I don't, but other people,
other surgeons I know do use it postoperatively for wound care because there's not a whole lot
of ingredients. The only ingredient that I've known that has the potential to be problematic
in it is the lanolin. And I know there's some controversy with that too, but that's the only
ingredient I was on the fence about. Overall, I think it's a good product, good chapstick.
Can it cause sunburns on the lips? Why would that be? Yeah, so I want to dive into this a
little bit here actually. So first, a spokesperson for Aquaphor told BuzzFeed's News about the
thought on this TikTok trend. They said,
So what I want to say about this is that the regular Aquaphor that you're describing,
which is generally safe for people, fragrance-free product, has an ingredient called lanolin that can
and we debated this on our last podcast when we discussed allergen of the year,
which was in fact lanolin. So lanolin was the allergen of the year. But why is there a difference
between going out in the sun and wearing Aquaphor and wearing Aquaphor just in your home? Like,
why are they only getting this reaction in the sun? And I would propose, and I can't confirm
what everyone in this video did, but Aquaphor specifically has a lip product that is actually
And this lip sunscreen contains an ingredient called oxybenzone, which is a sunscreen ingredient.
It's on the FDA monograph for sunscreen, right? So oxybenzone, well-known sunscreen ingredient,
is being removed actually from most sunscreen products because they faced backlash for many
reasons beyond what I'm going to talk about right now. But the most compelling reason not to use
oxybenzone in your sunscreen is it is actually the most common photoallergen in skincare products.
A photoallergen is basically when an ingredient becomes allergic when exposed to the sun.
So oxybenzone as a sunscreen ingredient, to me this seems like the worst idea possible,
is that you have a sunscreen filter that is a risk of a photoallergen. So this is a product
that's specifically made to be used in the sun, but is the highest risk ingredient for
photoallergen reactions. To me, that's a compelling reason not to use oxybenzone. Forget every other
reason that you hear out there. So this ingredient from the lip repair ingredient from Aquaphor
contains oxybenzone in it. So if I had to suspect why these people are suddenly getting their lips
exploding and then getting peeling and itchiness on the lips, it's because of the oxybenzone and
not because of the underlying base of Aquaphor that's in your traditional Aquaphor repair ointment.
Nice. That is amazing. I love it. I love it. So I don't know. That's a quick, quiet deep dive
that he needs to throw a... If we had animations on this, he'd have a Sherlock hat on
and I would be his little Watson. I'm a skincare sleuth. All right. Let's
talk about lip... Okay. So basically, yes, don't actually buy this product. It's been a long time
since I've told people not to purchase a product, but don't buy this lip SPF from Aquaphor. This is
not the best product you should be using to protect your lips in the sun. There are other
lip SPFs out there. Do you have any preferred ones, Dr. Maxfield? The problem I have with... So yes and
no. Elta MD has a lip SPF. Let me just make sure there's no oxybenzone in this. I'm pretty positive
there's not. They're very conscious. The kicker I have with most lip balms and even lip SPFs
is that they still have this propensity to put in camphor and menthol. It drives me nuts
because it really aggravates a lot of perioral conditions like perioral dermatitis. But typically,
yes, Elta MD lip balm is the one that I usually would recommend. Yes. They don't... It's just
octanoxate and zinc. I find that they can be a little casty. You know how sometimes your lips
look chapped. You get that residue on the lip. I find that lip sunscreens tend to do that,
which can be a little bit frustrating. I believe that Supergoop has a pure chemical sunscreen
that's also pretty good. There's a few others out there. I've definitely tried the Elta MD one.
I liked it quite a bit, but it was a little... It did leave a little bit of a white cast because
of the zinc. Paula's Choice also has one that's pretty affordable. I think it's like $10. It's
a lip SPF that I've tried that I also liked. I like quite a bit too. I wonder for the people
who are concerned about chemical sunscreens, which I'm not one of those people that's concerned about
every ingredient except for oxybenzone, which I've clearly highlighted here today.
But for lip SPFs, if you're worried about absorption through the skin transdermally,
are you worried about a chemical sunscreen on the lip even more then?
Oh, yeah. You have to be. You absorb everything through mucosa. That's the highest absorption
on the body. Some say the scrotum. That's also competing for top spot. But the mucosal lip,
are they in a competition that we need to... We don't know.
Is scrotum versus lip competition? We need to settle this debate.
The thinnest skin on the body. Remember that debate we had for the longest time? Is the
scrotum or the under eye the thinnest skin on the body? And we had a two-hour debate on this
when we were in residency. Never settled. We still haven't settled yet. I just need a biopsy
of your scrotum and then we can solve this problem once and for all. He won't give it to me.
All right. I think that we have a good conclusion here. One, avoid the Aquaphor
lip repair sunscreen on the lips. That's number one. Number two, if you're going out in the sun
during sunburn season, you should be wearing an SPF on your lips. Find one that you like.
The one from Elta MD is nice. It does leave a little bit of a white cast. The one from
Supergoop is a pure chemical sunscreen, no white cast. But if you're concerned about chemical
sunscreens, which I'm not, you could try that one out. That's my final stance.
You could just put sunscreen on your lips. Is there any reason you just can't put sunscreen
on your lips? You could. Yeah, you could.
The question is, do you ingest it? Yeah, why not? Just take your favorite
sunscreen and put it on your lips. Why not? That's kind of reasonable.
Vehicle-wise, would you then apply your normal, let's say that you're using Vaseline. I have my
little mini tub of Vaseline, which by the way, I think they do sell these. I love them. So,
you take these little mini tubs of Vaseline, you apply it to your lips. Then you take your
sunscreen and then you apply your sunscreen over that, and I'm calling that hack the SPF
lip basting hack. You heard it here first. I like it. I love the hack.
You heard it here first. And if you see it in the Wall Street Journal, just know that it started on
Dr. Lee Unhinged. It's good. It'll also decrease absorption for those of you who are worried.
Oh, there we go. And it's functional. All right. So, next up, because we're venturing a little bit
outside of just like skincare specifically and getting into the business side of skincare,
which is actually a very fascinating topic to me and is a personal passion of mine. And since
it's a personal passion of mine, you will all now be subjected to it. So, Aesop, a skincare
brand, a skincare, beauty, body, hand skincare brand was recently acquired by L'Oreal in its
biggest acquisition ever for $2.5 billion. Do you know anything about Aesop, Dr. Maxfield?
No, which is the craziest thing because to be worth that much, right? To be a newer brand,
to be worth that much, I would think you would have to be exceptional. You'd have to have a
huge share of the market. I feel like I'm fairly well-versed in skincare. I've tried thousands of
products. I spend a huge portion of my free time just looking at skincare. And I don't know about
this brand. To my detriment, I'm sure, but tell me about it. Well, I mean, I don't think it's
to your detriment. I think it serves a different type of niche than we're familiar with. We're
obviously very familiar with the dermal cosmetic space. We're very familiar with active ingredients.
This is more of a lifestyle brand. So, Aesop, the largest part of their portfolio is actually
hand and body. So, their hand soaps, hand moisturizers are their biggest category. So,
they have these very fragrant products that come in this very specific brown packaging with black
and white label on it. So, it's very distinguished. You see a lot at high-end hotels. You see it a lot
at high-end spas. And you see it in people who like to spend $30 to $40 on hand soap.
So, that's not the niche you live in, Dr. Maxfield. You, I know because I've been to your
house, are in the, you buy like the Walmart brand of hand soap. So, you're not the target
customer for Aesop. And that's why you don't know what Aesop is. And I'm also, to be clear to the
listener, I'm also not at the target. I am also not the target customer. And in case anyone thinks
I'm the bougie one, I am also not the target customer of Aesop, just to be clear. But they
were acquired for $2.5 billion, which just shows how quickly the categories like the body category,
the hand category, the hair category, the face categories are growing so quickly. And this adds
to a spree of acquisitions by L'Oreal in general. So, for those of you who don't know what the
skincare community looks like from a bird's eye view, L'Oreal pretty much owns everything.
So, L'Oreal, to give you an idea of what kind of brands are, they have a division called LDB,
which is their L'Oreal dermatologic beauty division, which houses SkinCeuticals,
SkinBetterScience, which was a recent acquisition, La Roche-Posay, CeraVe. And then you have their
Luxe division, which has Kiehl's, which just recently acquired Aesop. You have their consumer
division, which is L'Oreal Paris. And the list goes on and on and on and on. These are all under
the L'Oreal umbrella. And so, this Aesop acquisition to me is interesting. And I think it was, I don't
know, based on the financials of the deal, I think they were doing over $500 million in revenue,
which is a massive number, how it will do financially as it expands into new international
markets with a strategic like L'Oreal. But it just shows you that despite the fact that right
now you're seeing in the skincare, just in general, in the finance markets, you're seeing
tighter purse strings because the interest rates have gone up so much that you're still seeing
these big acquisitions in the skincare space. And so, brands like L'Oreal as a strategic is
seeing tremendous upside in the skincare space and are still continuing to bet on that,
bet big on that on brands like Aesop. And it just shows me, the interesting thing to me about this
whole Aesop acquisition, which is similar to me as the Tula acquisition, is that these are brands
that actually don't show up very often on Dr. Maxfield and ours radar, but still hold a large
portion of the skincare market. And so, it's interesting that despite the education on
products that's occurred over the last three years, that has shifted growth in the entire
skincare market in general, there are still huge penetrants of these brands that are not necessarily
science-based skincare brands or skincare brands that are rooted in efficacy, which just shows
that we think we're talking to everybody, but we're actually not talking to everybody.
And there's a huge space for the fragrant skincare world that we, in some ways,
neglect through our content. That's such an interesting point. You know what I've noticed
too in some of the things we've talked about and shot lately? I think you're becoming more
open-minded into the... No, not no. Well, yeah, no, maybe both. I don't know. To the experiential
side of it, you've always been really good about dedicating this product is for this
experiential skincare. This is for the treat yourself skincare routine. But maybe we need
to dedicate... Maybe we need to just dedicate the best experiential skincare. Maybe that should be
the thing, is just dedicate some time. Because people who are investing a lot of money into
these products, like the person who's buying these products or the person who's really going out
looking for the bougie, fragrant, this and that, this and that, they probably still deserve to know
what's working for them and what's not. They probably still, in their heart of hearts,
want a product that works. And so maybe we should just disregard the fragrance,
disregard the limonene and everything else and just say, okay, this product may be $200.
It may be fragrance to the moon. But is it doing anything for you?
Yeah. No, I think that there's a space to have that conversation. I think it needs to come with
a lot of disclaimers because the people that listen to our content or the community that we've
curated, and you guys can let us know in the comments, you want to see this science-based
content and you want to know what's not going to irritate your skin and cause allergies in the
skin. I will tell you that Aesop soaps, hand soaps, smell so good, right? But aren't there
other influencers to communicate that message to the world? Or do we need to also have that content
out there as well to tell you what the best smelling hand soap is?
Oh no, this is how we do it. I know how we do it. We go, Dr. Sean, Dr. Maxfield, go to the spa.
It's a series. We just go live it up at the spa.
Okay. Because there are other brands like Byredo. Have you seen Byredo stuff? Their stuff smells so
good too. We could do it. The best spa brand. That would be fun.
The best of the spa brand. But we have to put the disclaimer that these are not really clinical
brands because I think that's still why people come to us. But I think that pretty much wraps up
a very hodgepodge episode on retinol alternatives, lip plumping, the Aesop acquisition. If you've
used the Aesop products, let us know what your experience has been with them. I like the way
they smell, but they're not a clinical-based skincare brand in my opinion. It is Rosacea
Awareness Month. We want to shout out to anyone who's struggling with rosacea. We have to do a
follow-up video on it. Eventually, we will do a follow-up video on rosacea and some of
the advancements in rosacea, which actually are pretty interesting. Stay tuned for that.
For those of you who do have rosacea, just know that the sun is a major contributor to the
upregulation of blood vessels in rosacea. Wearing sunscreen is one of the most critical things you
can do to protect your skin from worsening rosacea. Thank you all so much for tuning in.
We appreciate you all as always. Thanks for being a part of this journey,
and we will see you next time. See you in the next one.