6.2 Intra-empathy Mismatch

Irrational Behaviors
3 followers
3 Video Views·May 17, 2023
So if you think about this issue of what happens when you're under an emotional state and you're
trying to predict how you would feel and how you would behave and what kind of decision you would
make when you're not in an emotional state, we call this an intra-empathy problem. Because what
you're trying to understand is how you would be under an emotional state. Usually when we think
about empathy it's about how you understand somebody else, but in this case it's about your
own state. So you can think about what happens when you're in emotional state, you're angry with
somebody and you say to yourself how would I behave later when I'm not angry and you probably
mispredict your anger. You think that your later self would be as angry and the same thing is when
you're in a cold state right now. You're not hot, you're not aroused and so on and you ask yourself
how would I behave later when I'm aroused or angry and so on. And there's lots of examples for that.
One of them is a beautiful example about movies. When you ask people about what movies they think
they should watch, people often think that kind of high-class French movies without subtitles
and black and white and maybe things like Schindler's List and so on, these are good
movies they should watch in principle. And sometimes when they have Netflix they put those
in a high place in their queue because they basically think that they should be the kind
of people who watch these movies. But what happens when people basically go to watch a movie,
now they're in a different state. It's not in principle for later, it's for now. And what
happens is that people end up renting way too often things like Rambo. Nothing bad about Rambo,
but instead of renting the things that are good for us in principle, we rent the kind of things
would fulfill our desires tonight. And these are often much simpler movies in languages we
understand, not so black and white and not so high-class movies. Another example is another
experiment by George Loewenstein and his colleagues. And in this experiment they got
people in the gym to figure out how important are water-related causes in the world. How much money
would you give? How much effort? Would you join a charity dinner? Would you donate your time,
your money into those charities? And they basically got people either when they just
started exercising, so they were not very thirsty, or they waited a while and they got them when
they were thirsty. And what happened? The moment people became thirsty, all of a sudden they had
higher empathy with other people who might be thirsty as well. And they were willing to
contribute more money, more time. They thought that charities were more important. Now when
you became more thirsty, food-related causes did not become more interesting for you, just
water-related causes. Now if you think about it, there's a question of how do you create a charity
dinner? Many charity dinners you bring people in, they eat well, they drink well, and then somebody
comes on stage and tries to ask them for money, tell them what a good charity it is. I think a
much better approach is not to give them any food and not to give them any drinks. In fact, you want
to tell them in advance to come prepared for a wonderful meal, and maybe not to eat the whole day,
and then you get them to sit there. And maybe you even get the smells from the kitchen to
come in, and they have plates and forks and so on, but the food is not there yet. And now you tell
them how important it is, and now you get them to have higher empathy to these causes, what it feels
like to be hungry and thirsty and so on. And my prediction is that now they would give much more
money.
