6.6 The Surprising Way Disgust Shapes Our Thinking - David Pizarro- Cornell University

Irrational Behaviors
3 followers
1 Video View·May 21, 2023
Hi, my name is David Pizarro.
I'm a psychologist at Cornell University,
and I study emotions, especially emotions
and how they influence judgment.
Today, I want to talk to you about one of those emotions,
the emotion of disgust, and how it might influence
your thinking in surprising ways.
For a long time, psychologists have pointed
to the power of emotions.
In fact, emotions are those things
that motivate us toward action.
Many times, these emotions are things
that motivate us toward actions that would keep us alive.
For instance, our strongest emotions,
emotions like fear, are ones that keep us
from getting close to natural predators.
There's a reason why we're afraid naturally
of things like lions and snakes and spiders.
But emotions don't only motivate us
to behave in certain ways, like avoiding predators.
They also seem to change the way we think about the world.
That is, when you're fearful,
not only do you want to run from the lion,
but you're more likely to think
that there are lions everywhere.
And this influence on judgment has some interesting effects.
What I want to talk to you about today
is the power that the emotion of disgust
might have on the way we make our judgment,
and how a very natural emotion that keeps us away
from things that might contaminate us or give us diseases
also changes the way we think about our social,
moral, political, and even our consumer decisions.
Now, the insight that emotions
could even be studied systematically
probably first came from Charles Darwin,
who wrote a book in the late 1800s
systematically documenting the universal nature
of many human emotions.
Psychologists in the 60s picked up
this original project of Darwin's
and documented that across the world
there appeared to be a set of universal basic emotions.
And these, as I said, are the kinds of emotions
that are around and universal
because they help us adapt to our natural environment.
So for instance, we have fear, surprise, disgust, anger.
All of these are there in the human system,
in the human mind, in the human body
because they give us a certain kind of survival advantage.
Disgust is one of these basic universal emotions.
That is, no matter where you look,
no matter what culture you look to,
some people seem to have this natural,
aversive response to things that are growth,
things that might contaminate us or give us diseases.
This is a good emotion.
It keeps our bodies clean, right?
Disease is something that we've had to deal with
throughout most of human history.
So avoiding disease with this natural program
of disease avoidance that we might call disgust
is a very good thing.
You can see the origins of this even early in infancy.
If you take a bitter liquid or a sour liquid
and you put it into the mouth of an infant, a newborn,
what you'll see is something very much
like the full-blown adult disgust face.
They'll wrinkle up their nose.
They'll even protrude their tongue
trying to get that thing out of their mouth.
In fact, when we make a disgust response,
even though we can't see that we're sticking out our tongue,
we're often actually moving our tongue in that same way.
So one of the things that's very interesting about disgust,
and actually one of the reasons I started studying it,
was because it's very, very easy to make people disgusted.
Some of the other emotions are hard to influence
in the laboratory.
That is, we can bring people in the lab
and we can try to make them angry.
We can try to make them afraid with various methods.
But disgust, we don't have to try very hard.
I'm just gonna give you one example of a disgusting image.
I'll just prepare you in advance
and I'm about to show you something disgusting.
Some of you might actually show that same emotion face
that I just showed you where you wrinkle up your nose.
Right, this is something that we might see
in any day in our lives,
but it's something that probably has a profound ability
to make you feel disgust.
Some of you might feel it more than others.
In fact, when we look at the sorts of things
that make us feel disgusted across cultures,
we see a very common pattern.
As I said, these are things that tend to make us sick
if we touch them or come into contact with them.
So things like feces, urine, blood, vomit,
rotten flesh, pus, all of those things
are universally listed as disgust.
That is to say, although we can override them sometimes,
no matter where you look,
people seem to respond with the same reaction.
And it makes sense.
These things are also things
that might actually make us sick.
They're signs of disease.
Now, when Darwin was investigating the emotions,
he wrote something that I think was very insightful.
He says here,
in Tierra del Fuego, a native touched with his finger
some cold preserved meat while I was eating
and plainly showed disgust at its softness,
while I felt utter disgust at my food
being touched by a naked savage,
though his hands did not appear dirty.
So one of the things that Darwin is pointing out early on
is that the same disgust reaction that he has,
he saw in the savage.
This was an early documentation
of the universal nature of disgust.
But Darwin also points to something interesting,
that is that we not only feel disgust
for things that might contaminate us
by putting it in our mouth or maybe by touching it,
but we also feel disgust very easily at people,
other people, people that might be foreign from us.
And he also points to the fact that disgust,
one of the real important features of disgust
is that it works through contagion.
To give you an example,
if you stand next to a lion,
I might be afraid of the lion,
but I'm not now afraid of you.
Disgust doesn't work that way.
If you touch something disgusting,
now that thing has the property of disgust.
That is, through this association with the bad thing,
that has now been contaminated and I don't wanna touch it.
And if you think about it,
this is a very good thing
if what we're trying to avoid is disease.
So before we had an explicit theory
of how germs spread and cause disease,
the emotion of disgust was tracking contagion.
The power of contagion is it worked a lot
in the emotion of disgust,
especially as we navigate
our daily social, moral, political lives.
But also when we make our consumer decisions.
Let me give you an example from one study.
Researchers gave individuals a mug and asked them,
how much do you think this mug is worth?
This was compared to a group who were just asked,
how much do you think this mug is worth?
But were not given the mug.
And it turns out in general,
people think that their own things are worth more.
So if you say, how much would you sell this mug for?
How much is it worth?
If I've just given it to you,
you actually think that it's worth more.
But if I showed you disgusting images
like the one I just showed you before,
that effect goes away.
One of the most robust effects
that we like things and we value things that are our own
more than those things that belong to others
can be completely wiped out
if we are now feeling disgust
when evaluating the value of our own product.
In another set of studies,
if products that are disgusting
touched products that were not disgusting,
so in this case,
a product that has to come into close contact with the body,
they use tampons.
If tampons touched a bag of cookies,
mind you, both of them were closed
and they were clean tampons,
there was no chance of any contamination going on.
Just the fact that people were disgusted slightly
by the tampons made them value the cookies less.
Now, this property of contagion
that we can see in consumer decision
extends to what might be considered
a much more important domain.
That is, we can make you feel disgusted
not at cookies or a mug,
we can make you feel disgusted
about a person or an entire social group.
And this has been used quite effectively
and quite tragically in many cases.
One of the best cases comes from World War II propaganda
where the Germans were trying to convince people
that the Jews were filthy, disgusting individuals
in part to make it easier to kill them.
So this quote comes from a Nazi children's book
published in 1938,
trying to point the children
into the disgusting features of Jewish people.
It says, just look at these guys,
the louse infested beards,
the filthy protruding ears,
those stained fatty clothes.
Jews often have an unpleasant Swedish odor.
If you have a good nose, you can smell the Jews.
More recently, this very same tactic
has been used by people who want to convince us
that homosexuality is bad or immoral.
So this is taken from an anti-gay website.
Gays are worthy of death for their vile sex practices.
They're like dogs eating their own vomit
and sows wallowing in their own feces.
Again, these very low level disgust properties
pointing to human bodily products, for instance,
or specific descriptions of sexual acts
get the disgust reaction going.
And through the process of contagion,
we tag an individual or an entire social group.
And it gives us a very, very strong avoidance
and negative response to that.
Now, one of the questions that my colleagues
and I wanted to answer was,
are some people just more prone,
more susceptible to being convinced
by this process of contagion?
And so one of the things that we wanted to look at was,
well, maybe some people who are more easy
to disgust than others would be more likely
to have some kind of negative attitude
towards certain social groups.
And we were able to do that
by looking across the population
at simply put the levels of squeamishness
that individuals have.
Just as with many other basic universal emotions,
while we all have them,
some of them have them much stronger than others.
So in this class, there are many of you
who, when I showed that image,
had a very, very strong response.
Some of you weren't even bothered at all
and wondered why I bothered to put the picture up.
We can actually measure this level of squeamishness
using a scale called the disgust sensitivity scale
and plot people along the line
of how easily disgusted they are in everyday life
and how hard to disgust they are.
We do this by asking a series of questions.
Let me give you a couple of examples.
Imagine that you were asked this.
Even if I were hungry,
I would not drink a bowl of my favorite soup
if it had been stirred by a used
but thoroughly washed glass water.
How much do you agree or disagree with that statement?
Or while you're walking through a tunnel
under a railroad track, you smell urine.
Would you be very disgusted or not at all disgusted?
It turns out that I'm actually very, very disgusted.
So it's hard for me to do this research.
But we can plot a score given enough of these questions
that gives you an overall score
on how disgust sensitive you are, how squeamish you are.
One of the things that this can do
is predict your actual behavior.
So the researchers that came up with the scale
brought people into the laboratory
and asked them to do a variety of tasks
that were disgusting.
For instance, eat perfectly healthy,
in fact, very nutritious mealworms,
but nobody eats worms really in the United States,
so they were very disgusting.
Or something milder like eat a piece of chocolate
that's been baked to look like dog poop.
It turns out people who are very easily disgusted
are much less likely to do that
than people who are not easily disgusted.
So your score on this scale actually predicts
your actual disgust response and your behavior.
One of the first things we found was that
disgust sensitivity, that is level of squeamishness,
seemed to predict, of all things, political orientation.
That is, people who are more likely
to be politically conservative
were also more likely to say they were easily disgusted.
Another way of saying this, though,
is that people who report being more liberal
are less easy to disgust.
You might imagine why one way or the other
might make more sense.
But this is the general relationship.
And we found this over three, four, five
different data collections,
looking at different populations,
until we finally came to a very, very big data set,
at least when speaking about psychology.
We were able to look at nearly 30,000 respondents
in the United States.
What you see on this graph is that people
who are very conservative there on the right
are much more likely to report
that they are easily disgusted.
That's higher numbers there indicate
that they're more squeamish.
And on the other hand, people who are very liberal
are actually less likely to be easily disgusted.
We found this even though we were able
to statistically control for a variety of factors
that we know are related both to disgust sensitivity
and to political orientation like socioeconomic status,
income, education levels, religiosity,
even some of the big personality traits
that we know are associated with both.
No matter what, we still found a general relationship
between disgust sensitivity, how easily disgusted you are,
and your political beliefs.
And this actually predicted
not just how you respond on a one-to-seven scale
of how politically conservative you are or liberal,
but it also seemed to predict actual voting behavior.
That is, when we looked at state-by-state voting results
in the 2008 US presidential election,
what we found was that levels of disgust sensitivity
in a state predicted the margin of victory
of Obama over McCain.
That is, states that had, in general,
higher levels of disgust sensitivity
were states where McCain actually got more votes
compared to Obama.
Now, we were wondering whether this was maybe
just a feature of American politics,
so we looked across the world.
Across 121 different countries,
here you see collapsed into a number of geographical regions,
we asked the same kinds of political questions
and disgust sensitivity questions.
And what we were able to see was
these numbers indicate the strength of the relationship.
There's a correlation between disgust sensitivity
and political orientation.
What you see is no matter where you look across the world,
the same result emerges.
That is, by and large,
the more likely you are to be easily disgusted,
the more likely you are to be politically conservative.
Or again, you're liberal if you're not easily disgusted.
Now, this is a fairly small effect.
This accounts for a small part
of why we might have political beliefs,
but nonetheless, it's interesting
because most people might not think
that how easily disgusted they are
by things like unflushed toilets
or sipping on a stranger's soda
might actually predict who they vote for
in a presidential election.
One of the questions that we had was
whether we could actually shift people's attitudes
towards social groups and moral and political attitudes,
and particularly by making them disgusted.
So what we did at Cornell in our lab
was bring participants into the lab
and ask them to fill out a series of questionnaires.
In this particular study,
we asked them to evaluate certain social groups.
We knew that there was a strong link
between homosexuality and disgust
because of the way that many people who are anti-homosexual
talk about the sex act and use disgust
in order to convince people.
So we wanted to see if making people disgusted
in a completely unrelated way,
that is, we weren't making them disgusted
about sex or anything like that,
we were making them disgusted with a foul odor.
Essentially, we sprayed the room
with a really nasty odor on every other day,
and we brought participants into the lab
and asked them what they thought
about certain social groups,
African Americans, the elderly, immigrants,
gay men, and lesbian women.
And what we found was that the foul odor
had a particularly strong effect.
In fact, the only effect we found
was that it made people negatively evaluate gay men more.
So that is, on the days when people had to evaluate gay men
where there was a foul smell in the room,
they were more likely to report greater negative attitudes.
Here, this is plotting on a feeling thermometer,
that is, from zero to 100,
how warmly or coldly do you feel toward gay men?
Other labs have also looked at these differences
using physiological measures.
You might wonder whether self-report,
that is, if I ask you how easily disgusted you are,
maybe you're not so accurate.
But if I hook you up to physiological measures,
measures of heartbeat and skin conductance
that we know are rough measures of arousal,
and show you disgusting images,
we find the same general effect.
People who report being greater conservative,
more likely to be politically conservative,
are more physiologically aroused
when presented with disgusting images.
Liberals are less physically aroused.
In particular, attitudes towards homosexuality and abortion
were the ones that predicted more, most,
whether or not people would be aroused by disgusting images
that had nothing to do with those issues, such as dog feces.
Well, there's another way to kick in this feeling
that there might be contamination in the environment.
So disgust is a particularly powerful way to do this.
But disgust, again, is in the service
of keeping us from getting sick.
You can show similar effects by just reminding people
that there is disease prevalent in the environment.
A number of researchers have used this disease avoidance
as a manipulation.
We thought, well, perhaps just reminding people
that there's contamination in the environment
might get them to change their political and moral attitude.
So we conducted a study where all we did was remind people
that the swine flu was prevalent in Cornell,
and that they should sanitize their hands.
In one case, we explicitly told them
that they should sanitize their hands
and asked them a number of questions
about their moral beliefs and their political beliefs.
In another case, we actually just asked them
to fill out a questionnaire,
either next to a hand sanitizing station or not.
And what we found was that a simple reminder
to wash your hands actually had a pretty strong effect
on your moral beliefs.
In this case, beliefs about sexually weird
but harmless practices.
I'll give you an example.
So we asked people, imagine that Joe
is house sitting for his grandmother,
and Joe invites his girlfriend over
and they have sex on his grandmother's bed.
Now, if I just reminded you that you should wash your hands
because of the swine flu,
you're more likely to find that to be morally wrong
than if I hadn't.
When we asked people to report their political orientation
in the same set of studies,
we also found this general effect
that simply reminding people to wash their hands
had a change in how conservative
they reported being, politically conservative.
So, again, a simple reminder of disgust
or of contamination can change our consumer decisions,
it can change our political decisions,
it can change our moral decisions.
This is a case in which disgust
is not simply preventing us from eating things
that might make us sick,
but it's having a fairly profound influence
on our social, political, moral judgments.
The question that I want to leave you with is,
now that we know this,
we can finally get to the point where we can ask,
when should emotions influence our thinking?
Science isn't particularly well suited
to answer this question.
All we can do is point out how emotions work,
how emotions can influence
the way we make decisions and judgments.
But we have to now ask the additional question,
now that we know that,
should disgust shape the way, for instance,
you vote, who you vote for in the political elections,
what you vote for about gay rights,
or what you buy at the grocery store?
Thank you very much.
