500 Years of Lace History (ft. Elena Kanagy-Loux)

Threads Through Time
2 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 28, 2026
In this episode, I interview textile and lace historian Elena Kanagy-Loux, on 500 Years of Lace History, an incredibly exciting and fascinating topic! Elena moves from the 1400s until the 1900s, explaining how lace and lacemaking have evolved and developed throughout the world during those time frames. It was such a pleasure to facilitate this conversation, and I learned so much from listening to Elena and her incredible knowledge about historical fashion and lacemaking.
So today I have lace and textile historian here, Elena Kanegi-Lauks, who is going to be giving a
presentation on 500 years of lace making. It's so lovely to have you because I'm a massive fan of
your work and I've been like looking forward to this interview for months now. Thank you so much,
Vasi. It's so wonderful to be here and I'm so excited to share this with your audience. I love
your 500 year series, so I'm really excited to be able to talk about lace. And I will just start by
saying that lace is really a massive category. I think people don't realize like how many
global regions and techniques that it encompasses throughout history, so this is really just a
taster, a highlight reel, if you will, of 500 years of lace history. But I'm trying to squeeze as much
into it as I can. So what was going on in the 1400s when it comes to lace? If you take a broader
definition of lace, as I do, I look at lace as a textile in which the pattern is defined by the
spaces between the threads. Then you will find different kinds of lace outside of the sort of
Western European focus definition of needle and bobbin lace in the early modern period from 1500-ish
to 1800-ish. And you will find lace techniques, for example, in ancient Peru. So in the 1400s,
one of the techniques that you will find is shanke gauze, which can be made two different ways.
This is either woven on a loom and then in a sort of gauze technique and then embroidered back into
with darning stitches, or it can be made by knotting. And in fact, there are relatives to
this technique in Europe during the Renaissance as well. So these don't appear until a little bit
later, but in Italy, for example, you have the technique burrato, which is also a woven gauze
that's darned back into, often with different colorful silk threads, to create a lace textile.
And burrato is actually one of the earliest forms of lace making that you see in pattern books,
the first one being from 1527, and it's called burrato. The other way that shanke gauze could
be made is by knotted netting. And this is a technique that we call lacisse in English.
These sort of square knots also have a general name of belay. It was the French name. These
ancient square knotting techniques go back millennia, but they were being used in Peru
in the shanke civilization to create these gauzes using knotted square netting. And then
you start to see this technique in Europe around the same time period as well. And knotting is
really a global technique. Everyone figured out how to make knots and square knots for fishing
nets, for example. You see this in Sicily. You also see knotted laces in the Mediterranean,
in Turkey and Armenia that start to appear a little bit later. If you enjoy learning about
the history of fashion and more, then you'll love the sponsor of today's video, History Hit.
History Hit brings you the stories that shape the world through their award-winning podcast network
and online history channel. It's like Netflix, but all history. Recently, I watched a fabulous
documentary on a topic that has always fascinated me, mudlarking. Mudlarking is essentially combing
the foreshore of a river to find various items of value, which generally means historical value
in this day and age. It's a popular activity amongst history lovers who live close to the
River Thames. In this incredible video, historian Dan Snow joins author and mudlark expert Lara
Makelim for a spot of mudlarking. And every one of their discoveries are captivating for various
reasons. And now, I never run out of entertaining educational content to indulge in while sewing,
as they have hundreds of hours of original history documentaries brought to you by expert
historians such as Dan Snow, Professor Susanna Lipscomb, Dan Jones, and more. Plus, they add
two more documentaries every week. To find out what Dan and Lara found whilst mudlarking and get
50% off your first three months of History Hit, be sure to use the link below and enter code
VBIRCHWOOD at checkout. Thank you so much to History Hit for sponsoring this video. Now back
to 500 years of lace. The other lace technique that you start to see early on is macrame. And
many people think of this as sort of the 1970s hanging plant holder type of technique that's a
little bit kitsch. But actually, macrame has an ancient history. And again, it is related to a
knotting technique. It comes from the Turkish word for towel. So essentially, it was a decorative
edging that you would use on woven towels with the warp left fringed. And you could make these
like decorative and elaborate motifs with them. So this is something that you start to see coming
from the ancient Near East. And you start to see macrame in the Renaissance in Italy in the 1500s
as well. The other technique that I just want to briefly mention that was being made in the 1400s
is sprang. And again, like knotting and woven gauze, this has an ancient history and sprang
you will find all the way back to in ancient Egypt to make hair nets. It was also used in
the 15th century in Europe to make hair nets, as well as military sashes and leggings in party
color. So it can be an openwork technique, but it can also be sort of a precursor to knitted
garments. So what was going on then by the 1500s? Now I'm guessing that needle lace was starting to
become developed. Absolutely. Yeah. So it's not until the early 1500s that you start to see the
development of needle lace and bobbin lace around northern Italy and quickly spread through other
regions. So needle lace actually develops out of cutwork and drawnwork embroidery, wherein the
pattern is marked onto plain weave linen fabric and threads are cut and pulled out of the design.
And then buttonhole stitches are worked back into the voided areas. And this becomes increasingly
cut away and more elaborate until you get this technique called reticello, which also means
little net, where you essentially only have a skeleton of the warp and weft framework left.
And it's mostly filled in with these buttonhole stitches. And of course, if you think about it,
this is a time period when just to have plain weave linen, you have to grow acres of flax. You
have to process and ret the flax and go through all these processes to make it ready to spin into
thread. And then you have to take the thread and dress it on a loom. And then you have to weave
the fabric. So if you're throwing most of it away and stitching back into it, this is incredibly
wasteful. So what happens is someone has the brilliant idea to do away with the base fabric
entirely and work these stitches directly onto a pattern base. And they use different things for
the pattern, such as parchment paper and things like that. And essentially you would have the
pattern drawn onto the parchment base and you would lay couching threads around the outline
of the motifs, meaning you would lay a thread down and then you would stitch through the base
just on the outline threads. And that would enable you to work the same buttonhole stitches that you
filled in the reticella with by working back and forth inside those couched threads without
piercing the base. So only the couched outline threads are piercing the base. And this is referred
to in Italy as punto in aria, the earliest needle lace, which means stitches in air because you're
literally stitching in the air. So when you finish your needle lace design many, many hours later,
you can flip over your pattern and then you just have to clip out and tweeze out these little
couched threads to release your lace. And that's how needle lace is made.
Wow, that's so cool. So it's just like releasing the dragon in a way. It's just like pulling them
out and there you have your whole design. I make it sound so easy, but I know needle lacers will
tell you that there's so much work in tweezing. The finishing itself takes so long. Then we have,
of course, bobbin lace is the other category. And although these laces are talked about sort of
in tandem, they really are technically totally different. And bobbin lace develops out of
braiding techniques similar to passimentary, which is its whole own category of textile.
Passimentary braids are sort of, if you think of in military uniforms, the gold braids that they
have on the edges of the seams or the really beautiful Victorian couches with elaborate
trims and tassels, those are all passimentary braids. There's another earlier braiding technique
called loop braiding that also existed in the 1400s in Europe, and perhaps even earlier,
that you will find that was creating sort of little braided trims as well. And this is
using loops around your fingers. And in fact, two people would work together to produce this.
It's also related to techniques in East Asia, such as kumihimo in Japan. So again,
braiding has really a global history. You see this in the Andes as well.
Bobbin lace essentially is a technique that developed out of really elaborate braiding.
So it got to a point where you're working with so many different threads that it became necessary
to wind the individual threads around wooden or bone, or in some cases, lead bobbins to keep them
organized. So the bobbins are just for thread management, essentially. And essentially what
you're doing is you have a firm pillow base. Bobbin lace is also called pillow lace for that reason.
And you have your pattern card or pricking card, although some early laces are worked freeform.
But essentially you hang pins at the start of your pattern, you hang pairs of threads
on your bobbins, on those pins, and then you cross, which is left over right, or twist,
which is right over left, to follow the pattern below. And eventually you, when you need to,
when you finish your stitches, you insert a pin. And the pins are sort of like scaffolding to hold
the tension and to hold your lace in place. And once you're finished, you can knot off or finish
your ends of the threads, and you just pull the pins out and your lace is free. Someone referred
to bobbin lace as cursive braiding, and I think that's a really accurate way to describe it.
One thing I didn't mention is that Elena is an amazing lace maker. I did forget to say that,
not just a lace historian, but also an amazing lace maker. Honestly, your work is like,
I just drool over it, it's so beautiful. Thank you so much! So in my own practice, I've been making
lace, as I mentioned, for over 10 years. It took me many years to get the confidence to design my
own patterns, and the first pattern that I ever designed was actually a commission for Justice
Ruth Bader Ginsburg in 2018. So that was a white cotton and silk collar set with little 25s in the
to celebrate her 25th anniversary of her investiture to the Supreme Court.
And then following that, I did a project for Refashioning the Renaissance, which was a
research project funded by the EU out of Aalto University in Finland, and they were looking at
working in artisan class dress, so trying to figure out what not the aristocracy would have
been wearing during the Renaissance. I did a project for them reproducing four bobbin lace
handkerchief edgings that spanned 100 years of history in northern Italy to showcase the
different variety of techniques and materials that were being used in that time period, which I
published my research that will come out later this year. We can link to those below when they
come out. And then most recently, I was commissioned by the Bard Graduate Center Gallery to create a
piece of lace to open their exhibition Threads of Power, which was on from September 16 to January
1st. It ended in January 1st, 2023, unfortunately, although they do have a great website, exhibition
website online with more coming, so definitely check that out. There's lots of images and
learning resources there. And I decided to take inspiration from one of my favorite piece in the
St. Gallen textile museum collection, which was what the exhibition was showcasing, which depicts
the story of Judith and Holofernes. So I made a red silk bobbin lace collar with five lobes and
sort of a Genoese 1630s-ish style, each with different motifs on the inside. So one is Judith
holding the head of Holofernes and the sword, one is Abra, her maidservant, holding out a bag for
the head, and then one is headless Holofernes in his tent curtains. And this was what opened the
exhibition. It took me 200 hours. The Ginsberg collar took me 300 hours. So I shaved a little
time off for my most recent collar commission. Your work is just exquisite. Everybody who gets
a chance to see it is probably so lucky. Honestly, I wish I could see this collar in person. I bet
it's just absolutely gorgeous to see all the details. Well, now it's in the collection of the
textile museum in St. Gallen. So maybe they'll put it on view again someday. How did these techniques
spread across Europe? Because of course, Italy is not the only region where bobbin lace is known.
It's known all across Europe and today around the world. One of the big factors in the development
of bobbin lace and needle lace in Europe in this time period is pattern books. And of course,
you're probably familiar with in 1450s, the Gutenberg press was invented in Europe. So the
first movable type and printed books in Europe. And this led to, you know, a mass explosion of
printing books. And one of these types of books was pattern books. I mentioned earlier that
one of the earliest pattern books in 1527 was on Burato, approximately, and this was by Paganini.
Later in the 16th century, you start to see even more. There are early bobbin lace pattern books,
the first one being La Pompe Opera Nova, which was published by the Sessa brothers in Venice in
1557. And that has very simple braided edgings all the way up to slightly more elaborate figural
things. The second bobbin lace pattern book was published in Switzerland by a woman who we only
know her initials as RM. It's called New Model Book. And she describes this technique as having
come to Switzerland, where she is in Zurich, in 1536. So we know that it's been around for a
little while. And hers are, again, quite simple braided edgings. Many of these were meant to be
applied on the surface of your garments and made in metallic threads, not just in white linen,
which is what primarily survives, but it was made in a variety of fibers. And there were, of course,
many pattern books for needle lace as well. So in fact, there are many more of them because it's
easier to illustrate needle lace and embroidery patterns. It's easier to illustrate diagrams for
them. Because essentially, in needle lace, you're working with one thread at a time, and in embroidery
as well. So you can essentially draw just about anything and stitch it. Whereas in bobbin lace,
the threads that you're using all have to follow a particular diagram, kind of like working on a
circuit board. So you have to make sure that all of the motifs connect. And this is not always
successful in early pattern books. Reticella or cutwork and drawnwork is also complicated because
you're working with the warp and weft. So it's a little trickier to depict. There are many, many
more pattern books for needle lace and embroidery for that reason. There's another famous pattern
book designer, one of the rare named women, in fact, the only named woman that I know of, who
was a pattern book designer in Europe in the 16th and 17th century, Isabella Catanea Parasole.
And I'm a big fan of her. She produced books throughout her lifetime. She started out as a
botanical illustrator for a scientist. So she not only did her own drawings, but also her own
engraving. And she actually married an engraver husband who took her name in marriage, which was
a really, really big deal. This is unheard of in Rome at the time. And she went on to
publish a number of really wonderful books of designs. Many of them have sort of
dedications to noble ladies. So a lot of pattern books were called like, you know,
designs for virtuous and noble matrons and things like that. They were very flowery
language and they often were dedicated to patronesses like Catherine de Medici and things
like this. What's nice is all these pattern books are out of copyright. So they're available online.
You can still find them and use them. If you'd like to see some pattern books, they are in the
description box down below. One of the most iconic lace accessories in history, of course,
is the ruff. These giant cartwheel or millstone lace gathered ruffs that, you know, we've seen in
Elizabethan portraiture and in many really fabulous paintings. And I just wanted to talk
a little bit about them because they are so iconic. You're probably most familiar with seeing
them in portraits of Queen Elizabeth I. And hers are so dramatic that it looks like her head is
almost like floating above her body. And this is actually by design. In fact, she passed sumptuary
legislation, meaning laws against certain fashion that denoted what different classes could wear,
to prevent other people from wearing lace as elaborate as her own, including an enforcement
that she passed in 1580 that dictated, quote, neither also should any person use or wear such
great and excessive ruffs in or about the uppermost part of their necks. And this Her Majesty
commanded to be observed upon pain of indignation, unquote. Unfortunately, these century laws were
not very successful. We do have some records of gentlemen, one gentleman in England who was
walking around in lace boot tops that were too long for the sumptuary legislation. And so those
got chopped off by, I think, some, you know, royal policemen, unfortunately. And the other thing that
I think is really interesting about ruffs is that they were actually widely criticized at the time.
So the way that people today say, oh, these young people in their wacky fashions, people were saying
that about ruffs in the 1500s. You can see this great caricature image of a ruff goffering shop.
Goffering is the name for the particular type of figure eight ironing that laundresses, specialized
laundresses would set their ruffs into these figure eights. And so there's a caricature of
these very vain people in a ruff shop having their ruffs washed and reset. Another favorite
quote of mine comes from the religious critic Philip Stubbs in his great book, Anatomy of Abuses,
which basically is like the get off my lawn of the 1500s, where he condemns ruffs as, quote,
cartwheels of the devil's chariot of pride, leading the direct way to the dungeon of hell, unquote.
So they elicited a lot of feelings. The other thing that I wanted to talk about ruffs is in
terms of their construction. Like I mentioned, they had specialized laundresses that goffered
them. But for the lace makers, ruffs were really just long strips of lace, like yards and yards
long. So it wasn't a patterned garment the same way, a structured garment the way that we think
of other accessories. It wasn't made to any sort of particular shape. You would just buy many,
many yards of lace, and then have it gathered. And you can have it starched in different colors.
So we read about pink and blue and yellow being popular lace starching colors, and these would
be washed out and reset by your laundress the next time you wore them. And just to give an idea how
much lace that took, there is this recreation of a ruff from the St. Gallen Textile Museum
collection in Switzerland, where they actually, one of their conservators took about four feet of
some lace from the 1500s and gathered it into a figure eight like a ruff and set it into this
large ruff for an exhibition at the Bard Graduate Center last year. And all four feet of the ruff
only came out, of the lace only came out to about this much ruff. So it's really, you know,
it's really a vast quantity of lace that you're using to produce these giant collars.
And immensely expensive, I'm guessing, since lace is super expensive when it's done by hand.
Absolutely, really expensive and really time consuming.
So what's going on then now by the 1600s?
By the 1600s, we're seeing shifts in fashion. Ruffs are still around, but we're also seeing
these great standing band collars like the one you see here. I particularly love this portrait of
Elizabeth, Queen of Bohemia from 1613, because she has little figures in her lace. We often see
lace, eggstant lace with figures and pattern books with little figures like animals and people in
them. But it's rare that we see them depicted in paintings actually being worn. So this is
a really wonderful example of what that looks like. And these were made to shape unlike a ruff.
So you're making them with this dramatic corner, and they would be stood up behind you not only
with starch, but also with a wire sort of frame or support toss. These were used with ruffs too,
they were so giant that they had a wire frame underneath. And the same is true of falling bands
that there's or upstanding bands that you have these these big wire structures holding them up.
As you mentioned, lace making is really time consuming. And one of the things that
comes up for me a lot in my research is who were the people that were actually making this lace?
So often, even in books on lace history, you're mostly hearing about wealthy people who wore
lace and looking at examples of lace and museum collections or lace painted into portraits,
but so rarely do we hear about the anonymous makers. But we do know about them. And that's
the kind of thing that I tried to uncover in my work. As I mentioned, needle and bobbin lace sort
of developed in tandem in northern Italy. And this was particularly around Venice in convents,
because there were in Venice in the 16th century, I believe they were the highest number of convents
and nuns per capita in Europe. Thanks to in part, this practice of what was called involuntary nuns,
or essentially younger daughters of even wealthy and aristocratic families, they couldn't afford
the dowry to pay for marriage for all of their daughters, they would send them to convents. So
there were many, many nuns in Venice in this time period. And they did a lot of work doing embroidery
and making these elaborate and innovating these elaborate techniques like lace making.
We don't really have that many sources for what this work would have been like for them.
However, there there is a famous and my personal favorite nun from 1600s in Venice is Archangela
Tarabotti. She was born to an aristocratic family in 1604. And she was placed in a convent by her
family when she was only 11, probably because she was believed to have been disabled, which was a
very sad and unfortunate practice of the time period. However, she was totally undeterred. And
even though nuns were not necessarily taught to read and write in this time period,
she taught herself and ended up becoming a great literary scholar and thinker of her time period.
She corresponded with scientists and philosophers, and she published five books under pseudonyms
that we know that she wrote, including such titles as paternal tyranny, and monastic hell,
which I will read you a quote from in a bit. So you can, you can sort of get a sense of how
she felt about being forced to work in a convent and produce lace for many hours a day. So in
monastic hell, she discusses the sort of the undergarments of the women destined for an earthly
husband, she describes them as the richest embroidery and gold laces and silk and they have
they get to wear all of this jewelry and ornament themselves. However, in contrast,
she describes, quote, the woman condemned to the grave of the convent who has to cover her legs
with ragged, coarsely woven wool. And most telling is that she describes that the nuns are, quote,
forced by nature to take up a wretched needle or bobbin, unquote. So they were making both these
kind of lace in convents. And the other type of organization in Venice that they had that were
responsible for a lot of lace production were hospitalli, or these charitable organizations
or hospitals that were primarily homes for orphan or young women without stable home environments.
One such institution was the Pia Casa delle Sidele, which is in Giudica. It's just an island
next to Venice. And it was founded in 1559 to give a home to, quote, beautiful young girls
to protect them from succumbing to sinful behavior. So they were then kept in the hospitalli where
they made lace all day. But they were allowed, unlike the nuns who were paid very little,
they were allowed to keep one third of their income and work for many years to save money
for their own dowry. So then when they were old enough, they could choose either to join the
convent, or they could use their dowry and get married, or they could go into service and work
as a maid. But for many years in the interim, they would be lace makers, essentially.
Would you say that the majority of lace makers in history were, like,
involuntary lace makers in a way?
That's a good question. And it's really hard to say. I think there's a lot of literature from
these time periods in different regions that talk about how hard it is to find young women to work
in agriculture these days, because everyone wants to make lace. So compared to other occupations
available to young women, lace making was definitely preferable. It was indoors. It had
to be in these very clean environments. Your hands had to be clean. And, you know, you were
working all day, but you were seated, and you were protected from the harsh elements. So it
was definitely considered preferable work. And prior to industrialization, there were areas where
you could make pretty good money as a lace maker, especially if you worked up the ranks and became a
master lace maker who created designs and trained apprentices. This was actually a way for a woman
to earn some income. There's this image of lace makers as being sort of a domestic product,
like a housewife at home, just making a little lace for extra money. And it's not to say that
that didn't happen, but it's sort of a mythology. And it's a problem that we have this image that
women didn't work throughout history. That's one of the greatest myths that I always try to bust.
The only women who didn't work globally throughout history were the wealthiest
aristocratic ladies. Everyone else had to earn an income. There was not really this idea of
division between work for the men and women, because everyone had to bring in money.
But just to talk about what kind of lace that these Venetian nuns were making, that was taking
them so many, many hours. Venice during the 1600s is known for what is now known as
or Venetian raised point needle lace. And this was sort of considered the pinnacle of needle
lace throughout history. It's really, really incredible and exquisite. It can be up to
6,000 stitches per square inch, according to the lace historian Pat Earnshaw, who's written many
books on lace identification that I recommend. And it is really so iconic of the Baroque era.
You see these cravats with the raised ornamented work, even carved in wood or in marble bus,
because it's so iconic. So this is the type of work that nuns were spending years making.
So you hear about people spending years waiting for just a pair of lace cups. And this is the
work that they were doing. It was very, very skilled. The other major center for lace making
in Europe during this time period in the 1600s was Flanders, which is now Belgium. They were known
from very, very early for really exquisitely fine bobbin lace. So although Venice and Flanders
both made needle and bobbin lace, and this is true across Northern Italy as well, Venice ended up
more known for this Baroque needle lace, whereas Flanders was more known for these really fine
bobbin laces. And that's in part because their linen production was so incredibly fine. They're
known for these really incredibly fine hand-spun linen threads, which are finer than any machine
can spin today. It's very hard for people to believe me when I say that, but I mean it because
we have processed flax plants to the point where they are much more fragile and breakable and
rougher than they used to be hundreds of years ago. If you look at ancient Egyptian linen,
there was even finer quality than in 18th century Flanders. So unfortunately, that has changed over
time. And machines just don't have the sensitivity to pull these really fine threads in such a
delicate fiber. They can do it with synthetics. They can make it as fine as, you know, a nanofiber.
For linen, it's very delicate. So it's really only by hand that we can spin so fine. Sadly,
not anymore, but there are people working to bring that back. So fingers crossed. But I wanted
to talk a little bit also about the lace makers that were working in Flanders during this time.
And I mentioned, we talked about earlier, you were asking about sort of lace makers and
domesticity. And, you know, we have this image of this mother in the home, like I said, making lace
and that it was more of a, not a professional system, but this was somehow being made just by
women independently in their homes. And, you know, if you look at the vast quantity of lace
that exists in museum collections, that exists in paintings, there's just no way that a woman
with kids and a household to run working at home could produce something that took that many
hundreds of hours. I mean, we're talking even months or even years to produce some of these
pieces of lace working 10 plus hour days. So that's just not the kind of thing that you can do.
There were certainly women doing these types of things in their home or people who hired
linen laundresses to make like fine edgings, but it's the large scale, I would argue, was really
happening or was really able to happen only because of the practice of these big convents
or schools or charitable organizations that taught lace making to mostly girls and young
women. One of these lace making centers that is today a museum is the Magden House in Antwerp.
This means maiden's house, and it was essentially an orphanage. And this was established in 1530
as a home for impoverished girls to educate them and train them in domestic skills to eventually
work as maids in wealthy households. But as lace making developed into the most valuable industry
in Flanders, lace making became the sole focus of their work. So there's this really heartbreaking
but rare and wonderful painting that we have that is now on view as part of a triptych at the Magden
House in Antwerp called the Orphan Girls at Work. And this shows us an image from the 1600s of what
their lace making community looked like in the school. There's even a family bringing their
young daughter, so not an orphan, but just a poor family who can't afford to feed their daughter,
bringing them to the wealthy owners of the orphanage to take them in. One of the ways that I
hope to honor these women through my work is just by talking about the realities of their lives.
And it's really not so different than a lot of, you know, the garment factories, the exploitative
sweatshops that we still use today, unfortunately. Yeah, you're right about that. In Flanders, I
mentioned they were known for this really, really fine linen thread and really fine bobbin lace.
And by the later in the 1600s, the sort of fashion for these big standing collars and the big starched
ruffs started to look kind of dated, and they started to wear these falling bands or what were
known as Van Dyck collars after the painter. And these were made in these really beautiful, fine
linen in these more stylized patterns that were coming out of Flanders, like Pot and Cont was a
flower pot lace, or they also refer to the cauliflower motifs. And these were bobbin lace
techniques that required many hundreds of bobbins to produce. And they were made in continuous strips
often, so you would have one set of bobbins that you would work straight down your pillow,
essentially, or going a little bit zigzagging back and forth like this, depending on the technique.
Maybe you've noticed that we haven't talked about France yet. And that's because France actually
sort of got into lace manufacturing on a large scale pretty late in the game. You're probably
familiar with the fashions of Louis XIV. He's very well known for sort of establishing France
as a really a powerhouse in fashion and style within Europe. Previously, it had been sort of
more Italy. But then starting under Louis XIV, people really looked to France to get their
fashion advice and see what the latest styles were. But in the first half of the 1600s, there
was no major lace manufacturing in France. And under Louis XIII, there were many sumptuary
laws passed, like Elizabeth I had done, to ban importing lace because all of the French
courtiers were spending all of their money importing Flemish and Italian lace. Louis XIV
tried very hard to do this as well. In 1660, Louis XIV once again tried to ban the import of foreign
lace in France. But it was a flop, and people were just smuggling and stealing and doing anything
that they could to get their hands on the latest lace fashions. Louis XIV and his
Comptroller General of Finance, Jean-Baptiste Colbert, decided, if you can't beat them,
join them. So they issued a royal decree stating the establishment of a royal French
manufactory in 1665. And essentially what they did was they invited lace makers and
designers from Venice and from Flanders to move to France and set up lace making regions in a bunch
of small villages like Arras, Sedan, and Alençon, some of which are still producing lace today or
have lace museums. This worked very well, and they started producing beautiful lace. But unfortunately
for the Venetians, this meant that their lace became a little bit less popular after 1665.
And the Venetian Republic considered this espionage. So they actually issued a royal decree
that if any artist or handicraftsman from Venice was found in a foreign land working to the
detriment of the Republic, that they would essentially imprison their family and or execute
them. So it was really, this was a really big deal. I mean, these were wealthy international empires
that were making lots of money off of lace production. The French style became very popular
in the very, very tail end of the 1600s. And the new style that they created was called
Pointe de France. And this is very different, you'll see, than the sort of Baroque Venetian
needle lace, which is very three-dimensional and has these big scrolling sort of vining designs.
Pointe de France was, the motifs are much more miniature and ornamental. There are lots of little
figures. It's very flat, and it's also very symmetrical. The designs were inspired in part
by this French artist, Berand. It has a different look and a much more French look that allowed for
more ruffling and the sort of laces that would lead into the Rococo period in the 1700s.
Time for the 1700s?
Time for the 1700s. So I focused a lot on the 1600s because this was a really big time
in European lace history. In the 1700s, of course, now we have the establishment of French lace making,
but we also see innovation in lace design in Flanders. And one of the most popular techniques
in bobbin lace in the 1700s is known as Brussels lace or also Pointe d'Angleterre. It's a little bit
funny that it's called basically English pointe because it is not an English lace. There's debate
of whether it's called that because it was exported to England or maybe they wanted to avoid
taxes by calling it English even though it wasn't. So it's kind of like unclear why it got this name,
but it is a part lace technique. So earlier we talked about the Flemish laces that are continuous
strips using hundreds of bobbins, and Pointe d'Angleterre is made in different parts. So it can
make an endless variety of really complicated and elaborate figural designs. So different lace makers
would work different motifs and then they would be assembled together. And the other story that I
think that is really important that comes out of the 1700s is that of the lace gown of Brussels
lace of Empress Maria Theresa of Austria. This is a rare, very, very rare, there's only a couple
known to ever have been made, example of a full gown or ensemble made of lace. So far we've only
talked about lace accessories and that's because it was so time-consuming and expensive that people
couldn't afford full garments of it. So even if they had, you know, many, many ensembles in their
wardrobe, if you look at wardrobe inventories, you'll find that people's lace is valued higher
than all of their clothing, even if they're only a few small accessories. So it's really
astronomically expensive. However, in the 1740s, as I understand it, the Ghent government in Belgium,
now Belgium, owed the Austrian Habsburgs a great debt, something around, I think a million dollars
now, don't quote me, but they couldn't afford to pay it. And so they offered instead to produce
an exquisite bobbin lace gown for Maria Theresa. And this was made over many months by many lace
makers. I've heard 50 lace makers over seven months. I've heard different figures. It would
have taken a very long time and a lot of labor to produce this gown. It was then sent to her
and two portraits were painted of Maria Theresa wearing this lace gown. One was sent back to Ghent,
which is still hangs there. And then one is in Vienna. And it's really just so exquisite to see
lace on this scale, because it looks like the patterns of these silks from the 1700s, these
Rococo silks, but it's actually all in lace. But unfortunately, the dress doesn't survive.
There's no record of her ever wearing it again. What historians think happened is that it was
probably taken apart and given away as royal gifts, because lace itself was a form of currency
during this time period. It was so valuable. So we think that it was really almost immediately,
you know, redistributed amongst the aristocracy. So unfortunately, it doesn't survive, but it's
still a wonderful story. That's so sad, though, that it doesn't exist anymore, because I can only
imagine it being in some museum where you could like go and look at it, you know, in a display,
that would be so cool. Well, one of the types of lace that we see, the sort of largest examples
of Pont d'Angleterre or Brussels lace is in benediction veils. And there are very few of
these, but they do exist in some museums around the world, particularly, of course, in Belgium.
And these were made in convents, they were used in ritual practices by the nuns, also made by the
nuns, depicting different saints and religious imagery. And these are quite large, rectangular
veils. We're not certain exactly how they were used. But they do show signs of where the ones
that survive. And these are some of the most incredibly detailed and exquisite pieces of
lace that you will ever see. I mean, it's they're just really breathtaking, that a human being
could have made some of these things. And even after 10 years of making lace myself, sometimes
I look at things like that. And I'm like, Oh, I give up. I can never do that. But I won't.
Yeah, definitely. I think if that's your like, standard for how good you have to be, that's
immense. I don't know how people can even physically make these things. Honestly,
it's like crafted by like something unnatural, almost like it looks like it's done by a machine
because it's so perfect. And the funny thing is, sometimes I'm able to identify machine made lace
because I'm so familiar with handmade, I can compare to what a hand lace maker would do.
And I find the machine making mistakes. So the way that I see it, not to say that all machines,
the machine lace can't be beautiful and wonderful. It's really just an imitation. It really for me,
it pales in comparison. But there are some really exquisite lace machines. And unfortunately,
even those are starting to disappear the earliest machine lace technology, but great prompt because
I was just about to move into the 1800s, which of course, is when we see the invention of the
earliest lace machines. It's not a surprise that lace machines were a top priority for inventors
in the Industrial Revolution because lace was so expensive. So there's so many different people
working on different types of machine you see already in the 1700s, these sort of like tool
being made on like, basically warp frames, but it runs unlike lace. So it's not really ideal.
Then in the early 1800s, you have the bobinette machine, which basically makes a tool ground
that lace makers can apply their lace motifs to. But it's not until the levers machine,
which uses Jacquard technology, which is the figural loom that uses sort of the earliest
binary code system that is now all computer technology is based on. That's a whole nother
lecture on textile history. Once they apply the Jacquard technology to the levers lace machine,
then they're able to create these gorgeous figural laces. And there are levers lace manufacturers
that still survive. In Calais, in France, they have become a really beautiful museum. And these
laces really represent some of the most exquisite laces that you, machine laces that you will find
in the world. And they really are very hard to tell apart from handmade lace. They're just
exquisite. So when I say that I'm looking for the opposite thing, it's just because I know
where a hand lace maker, where their threads will travel versus on a machine. It's just different.
So that's how I can tell the difference. But it takes many years of looking at lace to be able
to tell it apart. So don't worry if that isn't immediately apparent to you. I love this example.
It's from 1900. It was shown in the Paris Expo, which was an international exposition of
textiles and technology and basically all the newest inventions and innovations from around
the world. And leavers lace was considered one of them. So this is showing all the newest
technologies in lace. So you have steam engines, you have electricity, you have hot air balloons,
et cetera, et cetera. So it's like the iPhone of 1900. We're jumping ahead a little bit.
The other lace machine that is still more in use today than the leavers machine,
the leavers machine, we have a few factories, for example, Sophie Hallette in France, which was
bought by Chanel to keep them from closing. There's also Solstice in France, but there's very
few manufacturers of it left. Just to be clear, leavers lace is imitating bobbin lace. And the
other lace machine I'm about to talk about is imitating embroidery and needle lace. So even
within machines, there's a division in the technique. There was a really cool machine
invented in Switzerland, in Eastern Switzerland, around St. Gallen in 1824. It was the first
embroidery machine. And it was actually like this big hand crank. It's like this row of needles.
I got to see it in use, a historic one, at the St. Gallen Textile Museum, which is amazing.
They still have one lovely woman who operates it every week. And essentially it's a big hand
crank that sends needles all the way back and forth, rows of needles through fabric.
So you have to sort of move the needles back and forth with the machine. But in the 1860s,
the Schiffli embroidery machine was invented, which uses Singer sewing machine technology.
The needles don't go all the way through the fabric. There's two threads instead,
and the thread from the front catches the thread in the back, and that's how they're
doing this embroidery. That machine, as I mentioned, was invented in the 1860s and could do
really vast quantities of machine embroidery. And then in the 1880s, they discovered that if
they embroidered with cotton onto silk fabric base, the silk could be dissolved in, I think it was
chlorine or something like that. I forget the chemical. But that's the reason they call it
chemical lace, is because it's essentially embroidery where the base fabric is dissolved
in chemicals. Then they moved on to using acetate as a base, which was then dissolved in
acetone, but that's very toxic. So today it's still made, but it's using totally non-toxic
synthetic fiber base that can be dissolved in water. So this is called Schiffli or chemical
lace. And it has this sort of raised three-dimensionality. Is it my collar?
Yes, and it's your collar. So you're wearing Schiffli lace. And if you're ever in Eastern
Switzerland, the textile museum has an amazing collection of it. It's really stunning. And you
still find it in fabric stores today. So unlike the lever's lace machines, which are sort of
a little less common these days, this machine from the 1800s is still being updated and still
in use. So despite the introduction of lace machines in the 1800s, lace making by hand is
still prevalent. It sort of takes a dip for a while, but then in the late 1800s, there are all
of these revival industries and philanthropic organizations and schools opening, and there's
really a renaissance of lace making. People realize how precious handmade lace is. And even though
they really want the accessibility of machine-made lace, they still treasure the handmade. In England,
we have John Ruskin revives hand-spun cutwork linen techniques, which are known as Ruskin
lace. We have in Burano, famously, Burano Island outside of Venice, it's actually Queen Margarita
of Savoy is the patroness of the Burano Lace School, which essentially is founded after this
freezing winter when the fishermen in the community, it's a fishing community in Burano at
the time, can't earn any money, they can't go out to sea, the lagoon is frozen. So they revive the
lace making industry. They find one lady who still makes lace in Burano from centuries ago,
and they start a school, and that school is now a really wonderful museum. I haven't really talked
about Central, Eastern Europe, and Russia, but there is always, consistently over centuries,
lace making in these regions as well, and there are many revival industries that you'll see there
as well. In what is now the Czech Republic, there's really intense lace innovation happening,
even in the 1900s, that is still continues to this day. Also in Venice, you see Jezerum, who is an
antique lace dealer, but also works in making handmade lace that revives this polychrome style
or multicolored style of bobbin lace that's just stunning. And another favorite and famous
lace manufacturer during this time is in Vienna. This is the school run by the designer Joseph
Stork, I believe, and he designs these really, really exquisite imitations of the Venetian
gros pointe laces, but they're in a Victorian and then later Art Nouveau style. So using historical
techniques and designs, but bringing them into the sort of late 1800s fashion. So you see this
happening all over Europe, and even as we'll talk about around the world. We haven't gotten to some
of the other techniques that I think people are more familiar with these days, and that
are still very popular. So I also wanted to touch on crochet lace. A lot of people know it as Irish
lace, although I will point out that there are many kinds of lace making in Ireland, including
y'all and Kenmare needle laces, Carrick Macross, etc. And so they actually call Irish crocheted
clones lace, that's their name for it. And that is an industry that starts during the famine.
So it's introduced in the 1840s, ironically, by the English as a method for, you know, producing
something so that the women of Ireland have an income so that they don't starve. And Irish
crocheted lace is also sort of an imitation. At first, the three dimensional sort of Baroque
Venetian needle lace designs, but it becomes totally its own thing. And it's and it's really
exquisite, and still set made to this day. Like I said, there's also of course, tatting. I think
tatting in the US in particular, gets used as a sort of umbrella term for lace making in general.
And that's not really how it's used in the lace world, because it didn't really emerge until the
1840s. It's based on a knotting technique that was popular in the 1700s. You'll see these
ladies in portraits in the 1700s with these silver shuttles that look like tatting shuttles,
but they're actually knotting and making these little trims for their gowns. So it's not quite
tatting yet. The shuttles are also much bigger in the 1700s. But in around also in the 1840s,
just after these machines sort of take off, we start to see tatted lace, which is sort of like a
looped little knotted chain that you make in little round rings. This also takes off, I believe,
in England and Ireland, and then of course, in the US and is still made to this day. A friend
of mine has a theory that the reason why Americans use tatting as this general term for lace is
because of crossword puzzles, which is actually brilliant, because it's so true. If you do a lot
of New York Times crossword puzzles, as I do, they'll say to make lace, tat. But really,
tatting is just one of many ways to make lace. We need a better verb for lace making, though.
It's just lace making. So as I mentioned, the late 1800s, we see a lot of these revival
philanthropic industries in lace making. Many of these are in Europe. Some are in the US as well.
There's a Scuola d'Italiane in New York. Italian immigrant women are making lace here in Manhattan.
But one of the other lesser known industries is the Sybil Carter Indian Lace School. So Sybil
Carter was an Episcopalian missionary who basically, starting in Wisconsin and then
spread across indigenous communities in the US, was basically introducing lace making
to indigenous women as a way to, quote, civilize them. So unfortunately, really a
colonial industry of erasure. There's some telling quotes from her and her views on
the indigenous community, as well as the designs themselves, which often come from
very stereotypical images of Native Americans, such as this one you see with the teepee.
However, there were some indigenous women in the community who sort of rose up through
these schools and became teachers. And there are still traces of lace making
in some of these communities. However, as we know, there actually is a history of lace
in the Americas, which predates colonization. Little did Sybil Carter know. But I just think
it's important to point out that, you know, lace makers were not always the ones who were
sort of being oppressed in their situation, but they also, the roles were then later reversed
when they were interacting with women of color internationally. But lace making wasn't only
spread outside of Europe, at least bobbin and needle lace traditions, starting in the 1800s.
There are many regions around the world that have much longer traditions. For example,
in Sri Lanka, where bobbin lace was introduced first by the Portuguese, then the Dutch,
and then the British through colonization, and has become a treasured part of their local
tradition. So it's now known as Beerloo lace, and they have their own patterns and designs
and name for these designs that they still produce to this day. This is also true of Brazil,
where they have really a thriving lace tradition that is really unique. They have a very colorful
aesthetic compared to the sort of white European bobbin lace. They use lots of colors, they use
indigenous materials and tools. And this has, you know, started from the Portuguese and has become
really an important and treasured part of their own cultural heritage. Also throughout the Americas,
we see a technique that is known with several different names. One of them is Tenerife lace,
named for one of the islands in the Canary Islands. This kind of started as a cut and drawn
work technique in Spain, and is found in like ecclesiastical garments as early as like the 1600s.
But it really takes off in the Americas. So we see Tenerife lace all over South America,
we have Sol lace is the name of this technique, meaning the sun in Puerto Rico. And then in
Paraguay, it's called Nyanduti, which means spider's web in the Guarani language. And it's
also made in different ways. So it can be made on a pillow. It's worked in the round where you sort
of lay out spikes of lace, like spokes of a wheel kind of and then you needle weave around
through those spokes. It can be made on a little pillow, it can be made on a little kind of a
wooden loom with with little divots in the edges, or it can be made on a frame. That's how it's made
in Paraguay, where you're stitching actually onto a fabric base to create the base. So there are
still these many thriving communities of lace makers around the world. And I don't want to give
the impression that it's solely a European tradition. So if people want to start making
lace, and I'm sure probably some people watching this video will want to, what sort of resources
can they pursue? Or what is there available for them to learn? Well, I will say that when I set
out to learn to make lace back in like 2011, it was really difficult to find information about it
online. There weren't many websites associated with lace making communities, which isn't to
say that there weren't many lace makers, but they just weren't sort of online yet. But today,
I guess the silver lining of the pandemic has been that there are many
online resources for learning to make lace. So for example, the Lace Museum in California, which is
offers many different virtual classes. I'm taking one right now in Juan Degas Needle Lace, but they
offer beginner bobbin lace classes, Irish crochet, Turkish needle lace, all kinds of different
varieties of lace making. There's also in the US, the International Organization of Lace Inc., or
IOLI. They have a great virtual lecture series every month where you can learn from a different
historian or maker about a different technique. And I'm actually the host of the series, so you'll
get to see me interview them and talk to them at the end. There are also great Facebook groups.
Facebook is a really great source for lace makers, for beginning bobbin lace makers, and for free
materials and tools. And then of course, there's YouTube. There are different creators on YouTube
who have great channels in English and Spanish, at least, and probably many more that I'm less
familiar with. And I myself do teach. I have not been teaching online recently because I have been
so busy, but I hope to get back to it in the future. But I am teaching a class in person,
a week-long intensive in May of 2023, May to June. It's one week. And that is at the John C. Campbell
Folk School in North Carolina. So we'll take a really deep dive into bobbin lace making. And this
is a class for total beginners, no experience necessary. We're going to go through a series of
pattern. There will be some room for creativity. And we'll talk about lace history a little bit,
too, and look at some examples from my collection. So that's going to be really fun. It's the longest
class I've ever taught, so I'm really excited about it. The other organization that I would
recommend as one of the founders is Brooklyn Lace Guild. So we are an organization based in Brooklyn
that offers virtual meetings. We sometimes do in-person events. We don't teach classes for
the public, but sometimes we have internal classes for our members. And our membership
is very affordable. We also have collaborated with organizations such as the Yale Center for
British Art and the Bard Graduate Center to do pop-ups and artist residencies in their spaces,
as well as at the Textile Arts Center, where they offer some bobbin lace classes in person,
as well. So there's many different resources around New York, but also around the world,
for learning to make lace. Well, thank you so much. It's been such a pleasure to have you.
I'm sure everybody's going to get so much out of this interview. And I just really appreciate you
taking the time to educate us all on the realities of lace making. Thank you so much,
for having me. I hope I've inspired some people to go out and dive into lace making and lace
history because there's really so much there. It's impossible to fit it all into one conversation,
but I really tried to squeeze in as much as I could.
