PICA Dry automatic Pencil | Professional Review

Dave Does Carpentry
1 follower
1 Video View·Nov 19, 2026
This is a review on PICAs dry mechanical automatic pencil. This refillable pencil has a strong graphite lead that can mark on almost any surface, and even on wet surfaces. You can re fill the supplied lead. It has a hook so you can hook the pencil on to your belt and never worry about losing it again.
The lead is strong and can mark rough surfaces without breaking, and when you need to sharpen it, it only takes a few seconds to get a new sharp tip.
The pencil costs $22.95 and you can get a refill pack of 10 leads for $14.95 from total tools.
I've got myself one of the Picker Dry Pencils,
gave it a use, tried to see what all the fuss is about,
and I'm pretty happy with this thing.
So the Picker Dry Pencil, it's a mechanical pencil,
which means you can put new leads in it, you push down the top up here,
and that just pushes the lead out even further.
It's got this case housing which you can slide it into,
it fits in perfectly to any slots in your nail bags or tool bags,
but you can slot a normal pencil in too.
You've also got the little hook too, which I find...
To be awesome, to be able to clip onto a tops pocket
or put across a belt for when I'm working around without a nail belt.
That's one thing I always didn't like
when I was using carpenter's pencils.
I'd always put one down and have
to go around and find out where I put it.
You've got the sharpener in the bottom of the case here,
so you can put the pencil lead in.
Turn it around, sharpen it, and you've always got a nice, sharp pencil.
It's got a graphite 2B lead,
which makes it possible to mark on almost every surface.
Doesn't matter if it's wet, if it's dry,
if it's rusty, it can mark on most surfaces.
And it is stronger than your traditional pencil,
just your traditional 2B pencil,
but it would not be as strong as a carpenter's pencil, in my opinion.
Yet, I'm pushing down the tip with quite a bit of force,
and I can't snap it just like that.
You can get some good, hard,
solid marks without breaking the tip of the pencil.
Holding the pencil, it's got a nice, sturdy,
strong feel, but it does feel a slightest bit wobbly
with the lead not being completely tight in the pencil,
and I'm talking like minutely not tight.
I'm going from using a carpenter's pencil where obviously everything
is built in, you're not going to have
the lead moving on you at all, it's all solid there.
You've got the very slightest bit of play in the motion,
we're probably talking a fraction of a millimetre,
which I noticed straight away.
And it honestly, after using it for a day or two,
it didn't serve to be any issue.
It's just something that I noticed with the pencil.
I've used it so far doing floorboards.
It's a nice, neat, detailed, accurate job.
And I'm not going to be doing any rough, hard pencil markings.
Just very nice little delicate markings.
And I find this pencil is going to be good for when I'm doing that.
I always want to have a quickly sharpened pencil ready to go.
If I'm doing cabinetry,
even trims and anything that's going to be fine, detailed.
If I'm talking framing or doing any more rougher work,
I'm always going to go back to my traditional carpenter's pencil.
It's got a rougher lead, and it's just more durable and versatile.
This basically is, yeah,
just a refillable mechanical pencil with the sharpener included on it.
You've got the easy hook, as I said before.
It's just very practical to have with you,
and especially if you're going through a lot of carpenter's pencils,
you can get one of these in a pack of leads,
which don't set you back much at all.
So I got this mechanical case with a pencil for $23
and I can get a refill pack of 10
leads for $15 and it sounds a little bit more
to spend opposed to the traditional carpenter's
pencil but when you're paying $2 a pencil,
$1 a pencil and you're going through them,
you're sharpening them away.
I'm probably losing them whatever happens to these pencils,
they disappear and I don't know what happens to them
but you do end up spending a bit on those pencils
so I'm always going to have one of both with me ready to go depending
on the task but I am quite happy with this pencil especially
as I said for that nice little delicate easy work
and when I'm not using it now about perfect just even clip it onto
my top right now I can just have it here all day
and slide it straight out of the casing.
Put it back in the casing, it's going to stay there.
It does have a nice strong casing.
I can just slide the pencil in quite easily.
Not much force still there.
And that's staying in there.
I can shake it around, throw it around, try to get that to fall out.
It's not going to fall out.
And it's not a pull to get out either.
Just a little tug and it comes out easily.
So there is my review for this pencil.
I would actually recommend getting it if you
are doing more cabinetry work and some more fine detailed work.
