Did America walk into Beijing’s trap? What if the Jensen Huang scandal was never just about a personal relationship or access to Nvidia’s AI chips? In this episode, I examine a provocative theory: how Beijing could exploit America’s own legal system, media, corporate governance, and financial markets to undermine its most powerful AI company. From Alice Huang’s unusually public behavior to the ancient Chinese strategy of “Kill with a Borrowed Knife,” discover what may be at stake for Nvidia, TSMC, Taiwan’s silicon shield, and America’s technological leadership. Was Jensen Huang the real target in a much bigger US–China AI war?
Is Jensen Huang's resignation simply the end of an extraordinary career
or a turning point in the
U.S.-China AI war? And something else caught my attention.
That's Beijing's reaction. Or rather,
Apparent lack of censorship.
Now, why hasn't China tried harder to suppress the Alice Huang scandal?
Remember Christine Fang or Fang Fang,
the Chinese woman linked to congressman
or former congressman Eric Swalwell from California?
When that story broke,
information about Christine Fang was heavily censored
on China's internet, and then she disappeared.
But this time, something very different is happening.
Chinese netizens are digging into Alice's past,
uncovering old pictures,
and then also they're sharing details about her personal story
or history online.
And much of that material remains accessible.
But here's what I find intriguing.
A scandal that might ordinarily be suppressed
is instead being widely discussed and mocked.
So is Beijing simply allowing the story to spread
or does it see a strategic advantage
in keeping the scandal alive?
Now, there's something about this entire affair
that has bothered me from the very beginning.
That is Alice Huang's high profile.
How to say, she was simply too visible.
If she had been professionally trained
by Chinese intelligence,
wouldn't she have been much more discreet?
Instead, she openly displayed her relationship
with Jensen Huang.
Posting intimate photos
and appearing with him in public in front of cameras
and showing the body language that would attract attention.
That's hardly how we imagine a professional spy would behave.
But what if Alice's mission was never to remain hidden?
What if her assignment was to attract attention?
So now I'm going to present you
a theory discussed among some China observers.
I'm not saying that this theory is the truth,
but it's an important concept that needs examination.
What if the mission wasn't to infiltrate, but to detonate?
Think about it.
If an intelligence service wanted to exploit
a romantic relationship over many years,
it would normally try to keep the relationship secret.
So why leave so many photos, personal connections,
and public appearances for investigators to discover?
Unless those traces were meant to be found,
perhaps someone wanted American authorities
to uncover or to discover these traces
or to uncover their relationship themselves and
believe they had discovered it entirely on their own.
That's the theory.
What if the real objective wasn't the relationship or even the chips,
but the removal of the
man at the center of America's AI industry?
So to understand why that would matter,
consider the competition between China and the U.S. in AI.
Now, AI competition has three major components.
First, data.
And China has enormous data resources,
and its political system gives authorized access
or gives Beijing broader or more powers to collect and use data.
Second is AI models.
The U.S. and China are competing intensely,
and the gap varies depending on which models
and capabilities we're comparing.
But the third component is hardware,
and this is where the U.S. has held a particularly important advantage.
Advanced GPUs are essential for training
and running powerful AI systems,
and NVIDIA dominates much of that market.
So Jensen Huang wasn't just another successful tech executive.
He led a company at the heart of America's AI leadership.
In military strategy, there's a concept called decapitation strike.
Could something similar have been attempted here?
Instead of attacking America's AI hardware advantage directly,
which is almost impossible,
Beijing could have targeted the individuals.
In this case, the individual most closely associated with it.
Could an outside power exploit America's own institutions
to damage one of its most important technology companies?
And this idea has a parallel in Chinese political thinking.
You have heard about this man, Wang Huning.
In 1988, he was a professor teaching political theories.
at Fudan University. He is now one of Xi Jinping's top aides.
He spent several months studying
in the U.S. as a visiting scholar.
That was in 1988. And then three years later,
after returning to China,
he published a book called America Against America.
Wang examined the contradictions within American society.
From his perspective,
What are those contradictions?
There's the separation of powers, strict legal procedures,
a free press, political competition.
Now, these institutions are among America's greatest strength.
That's how we see it.
But the Chinese scholar, Wang, saw them differently.
He saw vulnerabilities.
He examined how they could generate internal conflict
and institutional friction.
Now considering another concept from traditional Chinese strategy,
Mao Zedong emphasized exploiting
divisions among opponents, turn people against each other.
And one of the ancient Chinese
stratagem is called kill with a borrowed knife.
The idea is very simple.
Why attack your opponent directly
when you can't get someone else to do it for you?
Okay, right?
That's called kill with a borrowed knife.
借刀杀人
So let's now apply that idea to Jensen Huang's affair.
Imagine the following chain of events.
American intelligence investigates suspected export control violations.
The findings reached senior government officials.
Congress demands answers and schedules closed-door briefings.
The media investigates the personal scandal
and possible national security implications.
Amadeus Board hires outside lawyers to investigate its founder.
Shareholders question whether
the company had adequately disclosed risks.
Investors then lose confidence.
Wall Street starts selling.
And suddenly the entire system is moving against one
of America's most important tech executives.
Here's the remarkable part.
Every American institution may
be doing exactly what it's supposed to do, right?
Investigators are enforcing the law.
Congress is exercising oversight.
Journalists are reporting the news.
Directors are protecting shareholders.
Investors are managing risk.
Yet the combined effect
It's devastating, and they're taking down one of their own.
So if you really think about it,
it's almost like an autoimmune disorder.
The immune system is designed to protect the body,
but sometimes it mistakenly attacks the body's own organs.
In the same way, America's defensive
institutions could potentially be manipulated
into producing consequences that weaken the country itself.
And I tell you, the CCP has done extensive studies in this area.
They are very knowledgeable about how American institutions work,
how American democratic process function.
So they have studied that closely.
And now they used the country's defensive institutions and manipulated.
into producing the consequences that we've seen.
And that's the essence of the borrowed knife theory,
which is that an outside adversary doesn't have
to deliver the final blow.
It only has to create the circumstances that trigger the reaction.
And if that was the strategy behind the Jensen Huang affair,
then Alice's high-profile behavior takes
on an entirely different meaning.
Her visibility wasn't necessarily a mistake.
It may have been part of the plan.
So let me talk about what does Beijing really want, right?
You might, what do they want?
Now, for years, Beijing has been trying
to reduce China's dependence on Amadea.
Chinese regulators have raised security concerns
about foreign technology, including allegations
about backdoors in Amadea chips.
I mean, China publicly stated this,
and Amadea has faced antitrust investigations in China.
I know.
So.
Beijing has encouraged domestic companies
to adopt homegrown semiconductors, particularly
those developed by Huawei.
And Janssen himself has repeatedly warned about
the dramatic decline in Amadea's Chinese
market share.
So let's look at the big picture.
China doesn't simply want to remain an Amadea customer,
at least not for the long term,
but it wants to bring down Amadea and eventually replace it.
With its own technology.
So the CCP's mentality is,
okay, I don't trust Amadea.
I don't want to use it in the long run.
But I do not want other people to have access to it either.
You know, when I destroy Amadea,
then everyone will be forced to use my alternative.
That's the CCP's mindset.
So now here's the contradiction.
If Beijing is determined to reduce its dependence on Amadea,
why would it invest so much effort
in cultivating Alice's relationship with Janssen
just to obtain more Amadea chips?
Or was Alice's relationship wasn't just about obtaining chips?
Perhaps the chips were only part of the goal
or part of the initial goal.
But never the ultimate goal.
Perhaps Jensen Huang himself was the target.
Let's reconsider the exposure of Alice's relationship with Jensen.
Under this theory, Alice's mission could have had three stages.
First, obtain access to restricted chips for China.
Second, influence Jensen Huang
and possibly persuade him to cooperate with Beijing's interests.
And third, if those efforts go nowhere or are about to fail,
then exposing the relationship
and create a scandal could undermine the target's leadership
and reputation and also damage
the company he founded.
So this interpretation leads to a rather surprising possibility.
What if this full-blown scandal with Alice actually suggests
that Jensen Huang's value to Beijing is over?
Beijing does not see Jensen Huang as having any value to them.
Or maybe Jensen wasn't cooperating.
Think about it.
A cooperative, ambitious CEO would
be far more valuable to Beijing than a formal CEO.
So why sacrifice such an influential relationship unless the effort
to secure, to get him to cooperate, has failed or had failed?
Now, there's no direct evidence that Jensen Huang was approached
for intelligence recruitment or refused to cooperate.
I'm not saying any of that, but it's a theory worth examining.
But once people begin questioning a prominent executive's loyalty,
the damage is done.
It can spread far beyond his reputation.
Management becomes distracted because they need to prove themselves.
Decisions become more complicated.
Research and development may slow.
Investor.
Investors lose confidence
because then you're dealing with a major reputation issue, right?
You need to rebuild your relations with government
and there's a reputation crisis.
And then uncertainty spreads throughout the industry.
Who would benefit in that scenario?
Think about it.
It's obviously China.
Beijing, but the consequences don't just stop at Amadea,
they might reach well beyond Amadea,
because there will be impact on Taiwan.
Remember, Amadea is one of TSMC,
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing
Corporation's most important customers,
and TSMC produces many
of the advanced chips powering Amadea's AI products.
So uncertainty at Nvidia can affect investor
sentiment toward Taiwan's chip industry.
And on November 5th, TSMC's U.S. listed shares fell nearly 11 percent.
Along with Nvidia,
I think Nvidia fell almost 10% and TSMC fell 11% on November 5th.
Although TSMC's stock later recovered in the following days,
but consider the potential
consequences of a prolonged Nvidia leadership crisis.
It could affect development schedules,
investment decisions,
and demand expectations throughout the supply chain.
And that matters because Taiwan's semiconductor industry
is often described as its silicon shield,
a source of enormous economic and strategic protection.
And also, I've heard people saying over and over
that Janssen Huang's relations with industry leaders in Taiwan
is irreplaceable.
I mean, semiconductor industry leaders in Taiwan is irreplaceable.
No one...
I think no one in his company
at this point can replace him in that capacity.
So a serious disruption to Nvidia could therefore create uncertainty,
not only for America's AI computing industry,
but also for Taiwan's chip sector
and potentially for the broader strategic
relationship between Washington and Taipei.
In other words, a scandal involving...
One executive could have repercussions across
an entire technological ecosystem.
So from this perspective,
Jensen Fong wouldn't necessarily be the ultimate target.
The bigger target could be the network of companies
and relationships that support America's advantage in AI.
So let's put the theory together.
Imagine an operation that accomplishes
Several objectives at once.
One, obtaining restricted AI chips for China.
Two, attempting to influence the leader
of America's dominant GPU company.
Three, creating a scandal that undermines his credibility.
Four, disrupting Nvidia's management and technological continuity.
Five, triggering market turmoil
and uncertainty throughout the semiconductor industry.
Most people will see these developments as separate events
or unattended consequences
as a result of a personal scandal.
That's what most analysts say.
But I'm telling you, what if they were part of a coordinated strategy?
And that's the possibility I want to examine.
Of course, it's only a theory.
I have no evidence supporting that.
But the theory illustrates how
an adversary might seek to exploit vulnerabilities.
At the intersection of personal relationships,
corporate governance, financial markets,
and national security.
And that's why I think we must examine the Janssen Huang affair from
a broader perspective.
Because the West has underestimated Beijing's ambition in the tech war.
It's, I'm saying that again, it's not about obtaining chips.
The ultimate goal of Beijing is to beat out all competitors,
and when they cannot do so technically.
They will do anything to bring their competitors down,
including its leaders.
This isn't a theory.
CCP has put it to practice many times before.
Thank you so much for watching.
If you're new here, please hit subscribe.
Don't forget to give my video a like.
If you want me to answer your questions directly,
please join my live every Tuesday, Thursday,
and Saturday at 9 p.m. Eastern Time.
I'd love to chat with you there.