#permaculture#regenerativeagriculture#soilfertility In this Q&A, Geoff unpacks the difference between short-term financial profit and long-term ecological profit, arguing that a farmer’s real bank account is the soil.
This video is taken from Geoff’s 2021 Online Permaculture Design Course, which includes weekly Q&A sessions where he answers student questions. Learn more about Geoff’s courses at: https://www.discoverpermaculture.com
Key Takeaways:
00:00:04 - 00:00:31: Angelina asks whether Geoff’s money-in versus money-out statement is about energy accounting rather than normal dollars and cents. 00:00:31 - 00:01:34: Geoff says the real bank account is soil; chemical or biocide farming can produce fast cash while withdrawing fertility, structure and soil quality. 00:01:34 - 00:02:44: An energy audit exposes hidden losses through low-quality food, processing, machinery, imported inputs and degraded landscapes. 00:02:44 - 00:04:14: True profit must be measured over generations; even organic systems can be extractive if they depend on distant compost, heavy irrigation or excessive machinery.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This discussion explores the discrepancy between short-term financial profit and long-term ecological loss in industrial farming. While farmers using biocide cocktails may see immediate monetary gains, they do so by depleting soil fertility and energy reserves, essentially \"spending\" the land's natural capital for quick profit before the ecosystem collapses.
Angeline has a question here
and she says I'm not convinced that the money coming out is less than
money going in for farmers employing biocide cocktails
on their farms otherwise they'd be
doing the numbers and stopping already wouldn't they?
Nobody farms losing money each year right?
Is this statement meant to imply that this situation
is true from an energy audit perspective,
but not a dollars and cents accounting?
Am I missing something in my thought process?
No, you're spot on, Angelina.
Angeline, it's all about...
Your bank account being the soil,
if you're really a farmer, you're banking in your soil
quality and your soil fertility.
As you apply the biocide cocktail, you're making fast money,
you're making fast bucks, sure, at the expense of the soil.
You're losing fertility in that soil,
you're losing structure in that soil,
you're losing soil quality, you're definitely not
building soil. So over a period of time, you're losing completely.
Now there's a point when you're making money
and you need to pull out and drop the land onto
somebody else and maybe you can sell it for a profit as well,
but that's really pretty corrupt.
So you've disadvantaged the land,
you've made money at the expense of the fertility and soil
condition, and then you dropped it
on somebody else on the real estate game
and gone out with your money. So yeah, they're making money.
All right.
But the energy, if you truly did the energy audit,
what is the energy cost for the energy in to the energy out?
Now, you know, you.
You're running a complete loss.
But we are convinced that we need agriculture
and we need that very low quality food.
We don't even know it's low quality food.
We need it processed to even less quality food.
All costing energy.
So yes, at an energy point,
You're losing all the way.
And the money point, yeah, you might be making money quick,
but you're getting out before it all falls apart.
And that's the thing that you have to realize.
You just have to look at the records of agriculture
and the way it goes over time.
And it's not that large a period of time.
Might be in a human life, it's a considerable amount of time.
But in an ecological time period, it's just a blink of an eye.
And we've destroyed the landscape.
We've destroyed the soil.
We've destroyed the soil life.
And everything above it, it's destroyed with that.
So that's whole environmental ecologies.
And you might be doing it to grow vegetarian or vegan food
and not accepting the death rate that's happening from...
The vast cropping, even organically, of course,
it can be just as destructive organically
and just as much energy consumption.
You can be shipping in hundreds of tons
of compost from hundreds of kilometers away.
You can be using massive amounts of machinery.
You can use massive amounts of slave labor at low wages cost.
You can be pumping massive amounts of water
and grow an organic crop and make everybody
think, oh, well, this is all great.
This is all regenerative, maybe agriculture.
But the reality is, can you do the energy audit
and come out on top?
And what's the consequence over time?
It's the consequence over time.
If you really have to stick with that land
for a few hundred years or a few generations,
somebody down the line is going to go completely broke
and you're going to have to change your practices.
And we need to be less foolish about the timescale
of where we are actually in true profit
or not profit, making a loss.
That's the analysis that needs to be done.
So I think you're on track, Angeline,
but it needs to be voiced the right way
so the general public understand this,
because it's crucial.
It's absolutely crucial.