An exploration of what it is to grow food at a human scale using agroforestry techniques compared to mainstream farming. Looking in detail at productivity, diversity and resilience of the two different systems.
The video includes livestock, and references to meat.
Music by Tao (bouzouki and rav drum)
Special Thanks to Emma and Sean and T for being up for being involved.
All video and audio recordings from late August/ early September on our plot.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video showcases a successful agroforestry farm in Wales, contrasting its high productivity and ecological resilience with conventional monoculture sheep farming. By integrating trees, livestock, and diverse crops, the farm produces significantly more food and value while restoring soil health and biodiversity in the face of a changing climate.
Welcome to our farm. We grow a wide range of crops here using a variety of methods. For example,
here we have our orchard and we planted these apple trees 16 years ago and even though this
region is considered totally unsuitable for top fruit, you can see our trees are doing well.
We have been careful to create a supportive microclimate and to build soil fertility
and our geese help us manage this area keeping the grass down and creating a nice
under canopy airflow which keeps the trees healthy. We also have grazing fields in which
we raise goats. We have two milking nannies, Sunshine and Polly, and three kids who are five
months old. Plus, because it's nearly autumn and the nannies are coming into heat, we have a billy
visiting us. This year we have Primer, a two-year-old golden guernsey. You'll notice
that we've planted trees in the fields. They provide dappled shade in the summer,
lift the wind patterns in the spring and the autumn and fertilize the fields in the winter
when they drop their leaves. We also have vegetable gardens like this one. Some of the crops are still
growing. These are winter squash but many of the vegetables have already been harvested and
have been prepped for the winter storms. Things like onions, garlic and drying beans. Now this big
evergreen hedge around the edge of the garden, this is important for sheltering the beds from
the elements. Plus we have forest garden areas like this. Here we have cobnuts and autumn olive berries.
These tree crops are combined to complement each other. The autumn olive is a nitrogen fixer and
its roots will be feeding the soil, supporting these cobnuts to have a heavier crop. Having our harvest
in the canopy layer means that the soil is partially shaded from the sun, which enables
it to retain its water content and remain productive throughout the summer heatwave.
These growing systems all fit broadly within the category of agroforestry, literally combining
agriculture and forestry, so that we are able to harvest a range of crops at different levels
in a way in which the trees and the plants complement. This approach by its very nature
is more productive, more resilient and previously this seven and a half acres was one big field.
The farmer at the time kept cheap on it. According to industry figures you could keep approximately
15 ewes of this area of land producing around 19 lambs a year, worth an estimated two thousand
pounds in a good year. But this hasn't been a good year, it's been the hottest year on record
and a summer drought has meant that the grass barely grew at all and most livestock farmers
have already used their winter feed to keep their stock alive and now face a bleak winter
with very high feed costs. Bear in mind that when this land was dedicated to sheep there was
virtually no wildlife. The soil fertility was reducing every year and whenever it rained heavily
the water ran off the fields in shoots because there was so little life in the soil there was
no porosity. The topsoil had become compacted into a hard pan. These days the bounty of produce
is remarkable. Last year we grew 23 types of vegetables, 22 different fruits plus nuts,
eggs, milk and meat. Some of this went to feeding our family and our volunteers
and some was sold to the wider community. The last time I did the sums on what we harvest here
it came to roughly 12,000 pounds worth of food. That's six times as much as the same area would
produce under conventional sheep farming. On top of that we also grow biomass fuel for heating,
we harvest our own water, we harvest our own electricity plus it's teeming.
To be fair perhaps it's not appropriate to compare mainstream agriculture to agroforestry
homesteading. They are totally different systems after all. One is based on the economics of
providing food at scale, a national and international market. The model supports the
most efficient growing techniques and tends towards regional specialisation. Grain in the lowlands,
sheep on the upland. The strive towards efficiency inevitably leads to shortcuts
and the long-term costs that arise from ecological exploitation tend to be hidden
and are passed on to future generations. All this is supported by the government in the form of
subsidies and tax-free fuel for farmers. But here's the thing, the whole industry is based on the
premise of a stable climate in which to operate and that is no longer true. We live in a new age
of heat waves, droughts, storms and floods and monocrop fields don't perform well in those
conditions. We need to completely change how we look at the landscape. We need tree cover,
we need diversity, we need to move away from a system designed by economists to feed the markets
the one designed by ecologists to feed local communities.
The alternative is agroforestry and the thing about agroforestry is that it requires people.
It doesn't really lend itself to industrialisation and big machines. It works best when people are
living in the landscape able to form an intimate relationship with the natural world around them.
Fortunately here in Wales we have planning policies that enable people to establish
new agroforestry farms. Most notably the one planet development policy which in truth is
overly bureaucratic and onerous but does at least create the opportunity to move in the right
direction. In reality at the end of the day nature will decide. Nature will dictate what works and
what doesn't. The thing about unsustainable systems is that they either evolve or collapse
and the thing about sustainable systems is that they are nourishing and life-affirming.
Thank you for watching.