DoctorOz: Casey Anthony's Former Roommates Speak Out After Acquittal | Oz True Crime

DoctorOz
7 followers
1 Video View·Nov 15, 2026
This is a face America will never forget.
Named the most hated mom in America, Casey Anthony
was acquitted for killing her two-year-old daughter, Kaylee.
Many say she got away with murder.
But today, more than six years after one
of the country's biggest murder trials,
two people who say they know the real Casey Anthony are here.
These men lived with her before and after her daughter's murder.
Today, they are here, opening up in an exclusive interview,
speaking out together for the first time since taking the stand.
Retracing the days leading up to Kaylee's disappearance
and revealing what they say she was really like at home.
Crime correspondent Melissa Moore has the story.
Thank you, Corey.
It's been called the social media trial of the century
and Casey Anthony,
the most notorious and hated mother in modern memory.
Accused of murdering her two-year-old daughter, Kaylee,
On July 15, 2008, Casey's own mother called police
to report her granddaughter had been missing for 31 days
and she fears a foul odor in Casey's car is from a dead body.
Casey Anthony is arrested for suspected child abuse the next day
and initially claims Kaylee was abducted by her nanny,
then later that the toddler had drowned in her grandparents' pool.
Five months later, authorities announced
remains identified as Kaylee Anthony
had been found in a wooded area near the family home.
During the murder trial, roommates of Casey's then-boyfriend
would paint a picture far from a doting mother.
She seemed like a fun party girl.
Claiming Casey became their roommate,
too, after little Kaylee went missing.
Did there come a time where
the defendant started spending more time at your apartment?
After just 33 days in court,
the jury returned a stunning verdict.
As to the charge of aggravated manslaughter of a child,
we the jury find the defendant not guilty.
Anthony would be sentenced to just four years
in prison for lying to authorities.
She is now a free woman.
Today, many feel justice was not served
and that Casey Anthony got away with murder.
Crime correspondent Melissa Moore joins us.
So what is it about this case that still has people
so fascinated and has them so angry?
Well, one, that Kaylee's murder has never been convicted.
And second, that her mother was never remorseful.
Yeah, Casey didn't feel badly.
In fact, Casey didn't even bring it
to the police's attention initially.
It was actually her mother, the grandmother of Cynthia Anthony, that...
She brought it up to the attention
that Casey kept telling her that she's being babysat.
And she was resolved to find out where her little granddaughter was.
Has Casey been remorseful at all?
Absolutely not.
In fact, she's given interviews where she said, I sleep well at night.
And I've spoken with many family members that have children that have
been murdered or went missing and they never sleep well at night.
But also, she was only convicted of lying to police.
So she got she got sentenced for four years.
And since the trial took so long as she was in jail,
she got a year off her good behavior and served three years.
All right. So you've spoken to a lot of folks
because of your background and you're always brave to acknowledge.
That your father was a serial killer.
People trust you because they know you've been there.
So you've spoken to a lot of folks who were close to Casey Anthony.
What are they saying about her?
How do they describe her?
Yeah, so Dr. Oz, when it comes to crime stories,
what really interests me is that there's what you see in the media
and then there's always a story behind the headline.
And in this case, I wanted to find out...
from the people that knew her really well, that lived with her.
And so I contacted the roommates.
And one thing that I have in common with them
is that when my father was arrested,
it was a giant media circus.
And unlike them, they were innocent bystanders.
I was innocent too.
You know, I was a family member when my father was arrested.
However, they were just college guys.
And so how they would describe her is very different than how
her mother would describe her.
So they talk about her being a party, a party girl.
They talk about her.
self-serving. It was always about her.
She's, you know, gargarious and bubbly and selfish and
selfish. Absolutely. So there's two men we're about to meet.
Their names are Nate and Clint.
You're going to get to know them pretty well.
They witnessed Casey's behavior before and after
Keely's disappearance. So what can they offer us
that's unique that no one else will be able to
share?
They met Kaylee. They babysat Kaylee.
So you're going to hear from them,
their personal interaction with Kaylee.
And Clint, I know, has made a Kaylee's Law,
which he'll talk about today.
But I'm just, it's rare that you meet,
you know, innocent bystanders that take a cause
and really try to keep Kaylee's memory in the forefront.
Up next, Casey Anthony's roommates are here,
reunited for the first time since taking the stand.
And they're revealing what happened behind closed doors. Stay with us.
Casey Anthony has been called the most notorious
and hated mother in modern memory,
accused of murdering her two-year-old daughter, Kaylee.
During the murder trial,
roommates of Casey's then-boyfriend would paint
a picture far from a doting mother.
She seemed like a fun party girl.
Claiming Casey became their roommate,
too, after little Kaylee went missing.
Did there come a time where
the defendant started spending more time at your apartment?
Yes, sir.
Did there come a time when she basically stayed every day?
Yes, sir.
After just 33 days in court, the jury returned a stunning verdict.
As to the charge of aggravated manslaughter of a child,
will the jury find the defendant not guilty?
It's unbelievable.
And that's been over six years since the jury acquitted Casey Anthony
of murdering her two-year-old daughter, Kaylee.
To this day, she maintains her innocence,
while many believe she got away with murder.
Nathan Lesnovich and Clint Howe say they knew the real Casey Anthony,
living with her and witnessing her behavior before
and after Kaylee's disappearance.
They both went on to testify in court
and are reunited here on our stage
for the first time since in an exclusive interview.
And I thank you both for coming here.
Thank you for revisiting what I know is a painful time in your lives.
So you're college students.
You're rooming with the boyfriend of Casey Anthony.
When you first met her,
Casey, what did you think about her as a mom?
I think she was a really great mom.
Thank you very much.
There was nothing that we saw
that would make us believe that she was a bad mom.
She never abused her.
We never saw her get angry at her.
We saw her use flashcards.
I mean, Kaylee was a very well-spoken,
articulate little two-year-old girl.
Share with us what started happening the last few times you saw Casey
And maybe walk us up to...
The bigger events, where she was actually confronted by her mother.
Well, I mean, she was over regularly for the first couple of weeks
that Tony and her started dating.
Kaylee was there regularly.
And then it seemed like it was all of a sudden
that Kaylee just stopped coming over.
We didn't see her anymore.
Would you ask...
Casey, where her daughter was?
Absolutely.
She would just say, oh, she's with the nanny,
or she's with my parents, or they're going to Disney World,
or they're going to the beach, or it just,
it became an excuse after excuse after excuse.
So I probably would have felt as you felt,
but after a month of hearing those excuses,
did you start to suspect something else was going on?
I don't know if we really suspected anything.
We had no real reason to suspect anything.
So recount for us that infamous day.
When Cindy, the mom, comes to Casey
and confronts her with the fact that this child seems to be missing.
Right, and see, like I said, at that point we didn't know,
and I remember that night very well.
Tony and I were sitting on the couch, we were playing a video game,
getting ready for the All-Star game to start that night,
the All-Star baseball game to start that night.
And I'd say early evening, there was a knock at the door.
Um, Casey had been just behind us. We were sitting on the couch.
Casey had just been behind us, uh, just doing little things.
I think throwing loads of laundry.
She was pretty happy, pretty normal?
Yes, absolutely.
Nothing?
There was no signs that something was...
Really off could be good or really really bad,
but we'll come back to that
So you're about to get ready for watch the baseball game
and there's a knock at the door
Tony and I turn around Casey answered the door
and it was her mother Cindy and her roommate Amy
Cindy was visibly upset about something. We just had no idea
What it was about. How did you find out that Kaylee was actually dead
and emotionally? How did this impact you?
We found out when everybody else did.
It wasn't until, I believe it was December of 2008,
whenever Kaylee's body was found a quarter
of a mile away from her grandparents' home.
Who did you think had killed her?
You guys have been pretty close to everybody.
My gut reaction at that point...
Went to Casey, and I don't even know why it went to Casey,
but that was the only person I'd ever seen interacting with Kaylee.
I'd never seen a nanny.
The only person I'd ever seen interact with Kaylee was Casey.
My gut went to Casey whenever she didn't report
a child missing for 31 days.
When Orange County told us that,
I remember that specifically when the police came over
and wanted to search our apartment real quick, when we had asked them,
okay, what is the gravity of the situation right now?
Like, what exactly is going on?
And the officers looked at us and said, we do not know where Kaylee is,
and apparently she has been missing for 30 days.
I mean, my heart sank.
I'm thinking, wait, 30 days?
What do you mean, 30 days?
Like, this isn't something that's just happening?
Nothing's been wrong. She's been over here. Nothing's been wrong.
Yes, Kaylee hasn't been here, but we thought with the nanny
or with the grandparents and now it's a punch in the gut
Yeah, it was it was a punch in the gut.
You were there both of you. Let me ask each of you
What do you think really happened?
when
when the story broke and
The nanny's name got dropped Xanny the nanny.
I stood up and said she was using Xanax to babysit her kid
Oh, Zanny Xanax.
Zanny is the street term for Xanax.
And that was immediately what I thought.
That's what I've told everybody whenever
they ask me what I think happened.
I think that Casey overdosed her with Xanax.
Oh, my.
See, without her showing up, when you go back and look at it,
now we had to start, when you look
at the whole situation after the fact,
now we were wondering, I mean,
was she coming over to our place to stay the night?
Leaving her in the car to sleep,
putting her to sleep with, as Clint said, with the Xanax,
leaving her in the car.
Maybe she accidentally overdosed, didn't know what to do.
I mean, that's honestly what I think.
I don't know that this, I don't think this was a premeditated thing.
I think it was probably an accident,
but she was doing something she probably shouldn't
have been doing that caused that accident.
But it's, I don't know, it's just, it was, it was such a.
Weird thing. I mean, I think that's what honestly,
I think that's what happened
I think that she was like Clint said that she was putting
her to sleep using the Xanax to keep her in the car so that
She can come and enjoy her life with her boyfriends
And I honestly think that she thought that she would have more fun
It would be less stressful just to leave Kaylee in the car,
which is poor. I mean absolutely horrible
Well, did you ever tell prosecutors this idea?
No, cuz I didn't want to speculate
It wasn't my place to speculate.
It's going to be late.
When they asked what I thought happened,
I did tell them, like, I think she was overdosed.
But
I didn't, there was just really nothing that I could tell
because I don't know it for a fact.
Right.
We're probably never going to know.
And I'll tell you what, it's an interesting theory.
Interesting theory that Xanny the nanny was Xanax, right?
And it is used to sedate people.
And with a child, of course, it's very dangerous to do because
drugs like Xanax, it's a benzodiazepine, like the Valium family.
It's very difficult to measure how much to give you,
but I can tell you something,
that this should never be given, period,
without being prescribed, especially to a child.
Because in a case like a two-year-old like Kaylee,
a tiny little bit, like a milligram,
just one milligram can be dangerous.
So then the question becomes, what about the autopsy?
So I'm a doctor.
I got the autopsy report.
I don't know if you've seen it,
but it says that there's no drugs detected.
No drugs were detected.
But then I got to thinking.
It took about five months to find her body, right?
Which was completely decomposed.
In the Florida swamp.
In the Florida swamp.
Which means drugs are a lot more difficult to detect
because there's no blood sample, there's no urine sample.
So in the Florida swamp, who the heck knows what happens to that?
So we reached out to Casey Anthony's attorney
to get a statement from her about these claims.
She did not respond back to us in time for this taping.
Up next, I want Nate and Clint
to help reveal what still haunts them to this day
and how they think Kaylee's life could have been saved.
Stay with us.
We're back in an exclusive interview
with Nathan Lesnovich and Clint House.
Former roommates of Casey Anthony and her daughter, Kaylee.
They testified against Casey in court more than six years ago.
They are reunited today on this stage for the first time.
I'm so struck by the insights that you've offered.
I mean, priceless, I must say.
And I'm appreciative that you're willing to speak openly about what's,
I'm sure, a painful moment in your lives.
What haunts you still today, Clint?
Well, you know, Dr. Oz, I'm a father now.
I have a year and a half old son.
It's done.
About the same age.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Yeah, about the same age.
Oh, that's right.
You've been close together, that's right.
You know, the thing that really haunts me is thinking about that is
if I was on trial for the murder of my child and I was acquitted,
I wouldn't sleep another day until I found out who killed my kid.
The other painful thing to think about, too,
is was Kaylee in that trunk or was Kaylee in Casey's
car when we passed by it to go to school?
Every day.
Every day.
Down in the morning and cars parked there.
That's hard to think about.
Could we have saved her? Could we have gotten her out of the car?
If we would have known, was she there? Who knows?
We just, there are so many unanswered questions that him and I have
because we were so close to it, because we knew Kaylee.
We held Kaylee. We taught Kaylee words.
Thank you very much.
You know, that's really hard to think about.
How did she get acquitted?
Well, first of all, the prosecution went
for a first-degree murder, and to do that,
you had to have a lot of evidence.
They were, frankly, just ambitious. With Kaylee,
there was just bones left. There was not a lot of hard evidence.
There was no murder weapon
that they could find. So, essentially,
it's the charges that they brought forward
that really was the nail in the coffin of her being free.
Looking back, were there any signs, Nate,
that sort of tipped you off that maybe, only
in retrospect, might have clued you into this?
To what she would, you know, to what our theory is,
you know, what she did with Kaylee, there
was no signs whatsoever that she was a bad mother,
even, or capable of doing something
this extreme, you know, as not reporting her child missing for 30 days.
Although she seems unremorseful,
I suspect somewhere deep in there, she's processing this.
Clint, if she's watching you right now, speak to camera.
What would you have to say to her?
Why? What is going on? Did you do it?
Are you ever going to tell us?
I mean, that's really all I can say to her.
Are you ever going to tell us? Are you ever going
to be truthful about anything that happened to Kaylee?
Nate, like he said,
You can't completely push it.
As her mother, you can't completely push this out of your mind.
I've never met a parent on any of the shows that you see or anything
that has lost a child that sleeps well at night,
that isn't out there burning everything down they can
to find out who did it.
I mean, if she's innocent, she should be out there
looking for the murderer of your child.
So I want to thank you both very, very much.
Very thoughtful, insightful, and I wish you both the best.
God bless you.
Thank you, sir.
As always, wonderful insights.
Thank you for watching.
Don't forget to subscribe and turn on notifications
so you never miss out on new videos to live the good life.
