They Replaced the Avon Lady. Now Influencers Sell You Everything
1 Video View·Nov 11, 2026
It is late and you're lying in bed with your phone
and in front of your face watching a woman
you have never met do her makeup in a bathroom you could describe
from memory. You know the titles,
you know the light, you know the way she leans
into the mirror before she says the words you
have heard a hundred times in a hundred voices from a hundred faces.
This is the one. So you
buy it. A few days later a parcel arrives
and you open it alone on the edge of your bed and
the shade is wrong. Not dramatically wrong, just wrong enough.
In the light of your own room,
To remind you that she never saw your face, you return it,
or you put it in a drawer with the others and scroll to the next woman.
And the woman who sold it to you will never know,
never ask, and never have to answer for it.
But there was a time when the woman
who sold you your lipstick had to come back.
In the first years of the 20th century, a training manual printed
for the saleswoman of the California Perfume Company,
The company that would one day become Avon gave
its readers instructions that read less
Less like a sales guide than a set of stage directions.
Prepare your outfit.
Make it as clean, as attractive as possible.
With firm tread, step to the door and ring.
And then comes the instruction I have not been able
to stop thinking about since I first read it.
Under no circumstances open your case on the stoop,
in the yard or on the street,
or anywhere but inside your prospective customer's home.
Anywhere but inside.
Hold on that rule because by the end of the essay,
you will see that it has been perfectly reversed.
There are three ways for beauty to reach a woman.
The face on the screen, the woman at the door, the feet in their hand.
We tend to tell the history of beauty as the history of the first one.
The stars, the studios, the close-ups.
But for most of the 20th century,
for millions of women in ordinary houses, beauty did not
arrive by a projector.
It arrived on foot.
It rang the bell, waited to be invited in,
and opened its case on the carpet.
And the woman who carried it very often lived a few streets away.
So why does the feed, which has inherited her job,
feel so close and so cold at the same time?
Why does the most intimate way beauty was ever sold
survive only as a joke about a doorbell?
And if the feed has taken her place inside your house,
what exactly did it leave behind on the step?
And hello everyone, my name is Laura and welcome
back to my channel. And if you're new here,
this channel is about beauty, Hollywood, and what we
lost. Essays that use the past
as a set of receipts against
the present. Chapter one.
sold out in minutes. On the 13th of November,
2015, an 18-year-old named Kylie Jenner released
three shades of liquid lipstick, Candy K, Dolce K,
and True Brown K. When she announced them,
Vanity Fair noted she had about 43.6 million followers
on Instagram alone. So many people
tried to buy it once that the website crashed.
And once the technical problems were worked out,
the kits sold out within minutes.
I want to begin here in the present because I think
Launch is one of the clearest pictures we have
of how beauty is sold to us now.
The lip kit did not reach its buyers through
a magazine page or a shop window.
It reached them through a phone, in their bedrooms, in their own hands,
from a face that had spent years narrating
its own life directly to the people watching it.
They had seen her kitchen, her bathroom,
her morning routine, the inside of her car.
By the time she said the word lipstick, she was not a stranger.
She was something close to a neighbor.
And yet the structure underneath that closeness is much
Much older and much colder.
One face, millions of viewers,
and no way for one of them to sit across from her and
tell her what the product actually did.
Multiply that by every creator, every haul,
every get ready with me, and you arrive at
the feed as most of us know it.
So who rings the bell now?
Everyone does, constantly, and nobody stays.
Thousands of faces will tell you in the privacy
of your own bedroom late at night that this is
the foundation, this is the lip, this is the one.
Some of them are honest and careful and clearly
uneasy about exactly what I'm describing.
But not one of them will be sitting on your sofa
when you discover it was wrong.
You return the parcel, you scroll to the next face. The mistake
belongs to you alone. We tend to talk about this as though it were new.
A strange side effect of
the smartphone. I don't think it's new at all.
I think the feed is two very old machines welded together
One that sold beauty from a great distance
and one that sold it from a few streets away.
If we want to understand what it kept and what it quietly threw away,
we have to take it apart. The first machine was built in Hollywood.
Chapter two, nine out of ten screen stars.
Consider Lux. Lever Brothers created it at the
end of the 19th century as a laundry product
and for more than 20 years that is largely what it was
until a contest in the 1920s revealed that women
were already using it on their faces. The company
The company changed the product, changed the message,
and then made a decision that would
reshape advertising.
It went to the movies.
In 1929, its advertising featured 26
of the biggest American female stars of the day.
Under a slogan you may have seen on old magazine pages,
9 out of 10 screen stars use Lux.
The campaign is often credited with pioneering
the celebrity endorsement as we know it.
And Unilever, which still owns the brand,
counts Marilyn Monroe among the stars who later advertised it.
Picture the page for a moment.
Marilyn lit by a crew of professionals, retouched, luminous,
and beneath her, a bar of soap you could buy on an ordinary errand.
The promise is not really about the soap.
It's about the distance, about the possibility
that the space between her bathroom and yours might
be closed by something small enough to hold in one hand.
You cannot ask her whether it worked.
You cannot ask whether she uses it at all.
Or whether 9 out of 10 is a number anyone actually counted.
The authority of the cam comes entirely from the fact
that she is up there and you are down here.
And that she will never come back down to check.
Consider too Max Factor.
By 1933, the company was claiming that its professional makeup
was used by 96% of the film studios in the world.
The studios among them, Paramount, MGM,
20th Century Fox, Columbia and Warner Brothers
contracted their actresses to appear in Max Factor ads
Advertisements for a nominal fee of $1 in return
for Max Factor promoting those actresses
and their latest pictures.
The stars were paid a dollar.
The real currency was publicity,
flowing in both directions between two companies,
and the woman at the center of the advertisement
barely a party to the deal.
And the system behind the slogan was,
if anything, even more methodical.
When the company reopened its makeup studio
on North Highland Avenue in November 1935,
visitors passed through an oval reception room
into four separate salons,
one for each of the Max Factor types,
blondes, brunettes, redheads, and brownettes,
Each decorated in its own color scheme.
On the company's consumer product list from 1930 to 2,
its ordinary lipstick came in three shades, light, medium, and dark.
Three shades, hold that number besides the lip kits.
Four types of women, three shades of lip.
That is what a beauty standard looks like
when it is drawn up at a distance
by people who will never see your face.
A set of categories broad enough to sell to millions
and an invitation to find yourself somewhere inside them.
I don't want to be unfair to Hollywood
because it gave women something real.
The star system offered a dream large enough
to step into two hours on a Saturday night.
Max Factor's pancake makeup was developed
for Technicolor film.
First used on screen in 1937,
then adapted for ordinary women and it sold so well that it
outstripped the rest of the company's cosmetics combined.
But notice what the dream could never do.
It could not come to your house.
It could not see what the light in your own bathroom did
to its idea of a brunette.
It spoke to everyone and so it answered to no one. That is the first
machine inside the feed. The face you will never meet.
The second had been knocking on doors for
for more than 40 years before the first star ever held up a bar.
of soap and it was built on the opposite principle entirely.
Chapter three, the perfume was the free gift.
The story begins as so many beauty stories do
with something that was supposed to be beside the point.
David McConnell was a farm boy from upstate New York
who started out at 19 selling books door to door
to persuade the women who were home in the afternoons
to listen to his pitch.
He offered them a small free gift of perfume
and he soon noticed that they were far more interested
in the gift than in the books.
So in September of 1886,
from a small office on Chambers Street in Manhattan, he stopped
selling literature and started selling a scent.
And I love the origin because it's so unglamorous.
Nobody sat down in 1886 and designed a beauty empire.
A man noticed what women in their own homes actually reached
for when nobody was performing
for anybody, and he followed it.
The demand was already there.
Behind the door, he was simply the first
to stop pretending he had come about the books.
But the person who decided what this business would come...
was a woman in Winchester, New Hampshire, named Albie,
whose life in 1886 had just fallen apart.
According to the local history of Winchester,
her husband, an attorney, and a treasurer of the local
savings bank had been charged with embezzling thousands
of dollars from it and sent to state
prison. She was 50 years old with a variety store,
a family name that had just been badly damaged in
a small town, and no obvious way to make a living.
And it was then, the story goes, that McConnell
walked into her store and hired her.
What she carried at first was a single box set,
a little dot perfume set with five single
note fragrances, violet, white rose,
hyacinth, lily of the valley, and heliotrope.
By the end of the first year, there were 20 fragrances.
Later came shampoo cream and witch hazel cream,
almond cream balm, and tooth powder, and then
in the same catalog as the beauty spot remover,
machine oil, mending cement, and carpet cleaner.
Violet perfume beside carpet cleaner, almond cream beside machine oil.
It is the opposite of everything Hollywood
would later teach us to believe about beauty.
Not a fantasy set apart from the household.
But one more thing the household needed,
carried by a woman whose job depended on knowing what
the house was short of.
And Albie understood something that would shape the company for
more than a century. The best way to sell a woman,
she realized, was through other women.
And the best place for these women to sell
was their own neighborhoods. She traveled by horse
and buggy and by train, recruiting as she went.
And by the end of her career, she had trained
more than 5,000 reps. Of the work itself, she said,
I know of no other line of work so lucrative,
pleasant, and satisfactory as this. Notice the order of her words.
Lucrative comes first,
and I don't want to sentimentalize Mrs. Albee into a saint of
sisterhood, because the record suggests something more interesting.
A woman who needed money at an
age when the world had very few uses for her,
found work she could do on her own guard, and
built a network of other women who could do the same.
That is not a fairy tale, it is an economy,
but it is an economy with a very particular shape,
and that shape is an argument of the entire essay.
The saleswoman was local, and the woman who sold you your perfume
Was someone you were going to see again?
Albie died in December 1914.
That same year, her company began
sailing across the border. In Montreal
and in 1939,
the California Perfume Company finally
renamed itself after the label
it had been using since 1928,
Avon. Chapter 4.
Anywhere but inside. So what
exactly did those 5,000
women learn? Experts survived from the
company's training manuals of 1907
and 1916
and read closely. They are among
One of the most revealing documents I know
about how beauty used to move through the
world.
They are, first of all, intensely physical.
Prepare your outfit with firm tread step to the door.
Do not conceal your case.
Do not carry it too conspicuously.
And set it quietly to one side of the door while you knock.
Because as the manual explains,
some people are prejudiced against agents
until they know what line you represent.
It is choreography of approach.
Written for a woman who knew she would be judged
in the few seconds between the knock and the opening of the door.
And then the rule.
Only after receiving permission to show the line of goods
inside the home and nowhere else do you thank her kindly.
Finally, open your case and begin what the manual calls the canvas.
Why would a company care so much about where a case was opened?
Part of the answer is simple salesmanship.
A woman on a porch can close the door.
A woman sitting in her own parlor with a guest case
open on the rug is in a conversation.
But I think the rule also encodes something deeper,
something the company may only half have intended.
It meant that the beauty in the system
was always handled indoors, smelled and tested
and discarded in the room where it would exactly be used,
away from the street, away from the neighbors,
away from anyone who was not part of the exchange.
Hold that against the way beauty
was being sold almost everywhere else.
The department store counter was public. The
salon was a room full of other women.
The magazine page was printed for millions. The
canvas was one of few places where
a woman could look at a jar of cream and hesitate
and ask a question that might reveal her age
or her worries or her budget and nobody but
the woman opposite her would ever know she had asked.
The manuals are more candid than
nostalgia would like. They advise a little sympathy
and in their own words yes a little
flattery, at times works wonders on the fussy,
cranky, hard to sell customer.
Besides they add, her money is as good as any other.
So let's be clear, the woman on the step
was not your confidante, in some pure and
selfless sense.
She was trained, she had a memorized pitch,
and a total she was trying to reach.
But the same pages complicate the cynicism.
Don't make the mistake, they say,
of not calling at a certain home in the belief that
the people there are too poor or too wealthy.
Don't forget the little villages nearby or the
country because the farmers and their families are big buyers.
The studio sold beauty downward
from a great height. This system told its women
to knock on every door, including the ones a
glamorous brand would never have bothered with.
So what was she? A saleswoman with a script or a
neighbor with a case? A flatterer or a witness?
I think she was both and the second part had very
little to do with the character.
It was a matter of geography. She could flatter you with this
This month, but she was coming back next month to the same door.
In 1954,
Avon launched an
advertising campaign
that at its heart did
not sell perfume or
lipstick or cream.
It sold the knock.
Ding dong! Avon calling!
It rang until 1967, long enough to become one of the most memorable
slogans of its era, and long enough
that the phrase is now more famous than almost
anything Avon ever sold.
Think about what it means for a company to advertise an arrival.
In Mrs. Albee's day, the knock belonged to the woman.
Her firm tread, her case set quietly beside the door,
her face on the porch.
A national campaign about the doorbell moves
the trust from the woman to the brand.
Before she has ever reached your street,
the corporation has introduced her
in a voice you heard between your favorite programs as a friendly
and familiar event.
It solved the very problem
the manuals had named half a century earlier,
but it makes a turning point.
The relationship was still local, the reputation had gone national,
And one reputation can be manufactured
A company can begin
to wonder how much it really needs the woman at all.
Alongside the case came the brochure, and the printed brochure has
a quality we have almost forgotten in an age of endless scrolling.
It ends. It has a last page and a first page.
You could hold the whole of what was on offer in two hands,
turn it over and put it down.
Whatever else the mid-century standard was, it was finite.
And a standard you can finish is a standard you can,
at least in principle, meet.
Old Hollywood turned the star into a product.
Avon turned the neighbor into a jingle.
The door stopped opening and the reason was simpler
and far more human than...
any marketing failure.
Increasingly there was nobody standing behind it. The entire model from
Avon's free perfume onward assumed a house
a woman inside it during the working day and over
the second half of the century that assumption collapsed.
By the early 1990s business reporters
were writing that fewer doors opened when Avon ladies went calling.
In 2023 Avon's own
As its own chief executive said it plainly,
as reported by The Guardian,
at home in the past, but now they are going out to work,
and we have to follow them wherever they
spend their time. There were other forces too,
the drug store, the department store, the internet,
years of corporate trouble.
But the receipts they've followed are not a gentle fade. In 2015,
after 50 years, Avon was removed from the stock exchange.
In 2019, the Brazilian beauty group
Natura agreed to buy it.
In August 2024, Avon Products filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy
protection in an effort
to resolve lawsuits over talc-based products and
And in September 25, Natura announced it would sell Avon International
to an investment firm
for £1, the company that once sent
a 50-year-old woman across New England by horse and buggy
with five little bottles of perfume changed hands
for less than the price of a lipstick.
And yet the woman did not vanish.
In 2023, Fortune still put the number
of Avon reps worldwide at around 5 million.
And in 2021, according to The Guardian,
30% of Avon's sales contracts were being made
online, up from less than 10% before the pandemic.
The case is now at length. The Avon lady did not
disappear. She followed her customers out of the house
and onto the screen. And the question worth
asking is not where she went, but who had already got there before her.
Chapter six, 40 shades. Go
back to the lip kits.
Three shades, like the Max Factor list of 1932,
but look at how differently those three
shades traveled.
The Max Factor lipstick reached a woman through a magazine page,
from a face she would never
meet.
The lip kit reached her in her bedroom,
in her own hand, from a face that had spent years
speaking directly to her.
It had the reach of the luxe advertisement
and the intimacy of the woman on the sofa.
It came in every sense that once made the Avon lady matter,
inside the house.
And for the first time in this whole history, the star and the
neighbor were the same person.
That is why the feed feels the way it does. It took the closeness
of the front room and the scale of the silver screen
and from each it kept only the parts that
scale. The intimacy of the neighbor without her return visit.
The reach of the star with all of
her distance. Now there is a fair objection
and it deserves its full weight because the modern
system has done something neither Hollywood
nor the catalog ever managed. In September 2017 Rihanna
Beauty with the luxury group LVMH
in around 1,600 stores around 17 countries with 40 shades
of foundation. For customers who had spent years mixing products
or walking out of shops without a
match, that range answers a very old problem.
BBC reporting later estimates its sales at around
100 million dollars in its first 40 days
and the pressure it put on competitors came to be called
the Fenty effect. Set that aside,
four decorated rooms on North Highland Avenue. If your face did
To fit the categories, a studio makeup company had
drawn up. There was no salon for you,
and even the most attentive representative in the most
honest neighborhood could only sell what
was printed in her brochure. If your shade was not
on the page, her good intentions could not put it there.
It would be dishonest to make this essay a
simple lament. In terms of who is offered a product
that matches her skin, things have genuinely
improved, and that improvement came from the very scale I've
been criticizing. But look at how the
40 shades is a magnificent answer to a particular question.
How can a company serve millions
of different faces without ever needing to see one of them?
It is a range wide enough that you can find yourself
in it alone on a website with a shade
finder and a row of swatches photographed under someone else's light.
It is the most generous
version of the Max Factor logic ever made.
More categories, finer categories, fairer categories,
but categories all the same. What no range can do is the
thing built into Mrs. Albee's arrangement
by the simple accident of geography.
It cannot come back next month and look at you.
And let me know in the comments below
whether you have bought something like Matcher on the app
or it was the wrong shade.
Chapter seven, the case of the stoop. So what did we actually lose?
Not the products. They are everywhere.
More shades and textures than any representative
could have ever carried in a lifetime of cases.
Not the saleswoman. There are millions of them
still. And millions more
who sell beauty on their phones without ever calling it that.
And not even the intimacy.
If anything, the feed delivers more intimacy than Mrs. Albee
could have ever imagined. A stranger's bathroom.
A stranger's nightly routine. A stranger's voice
speaking to you as though you were the only person in the room.
What we lost was the return
visit. The structure that made a seller live
with the consequences of the sale. The woman
on the step could flatter you,
and the manuals told her to, but she could not disappear.
Her reputation lived on your street.
Among women who knew each other, the feed has every
advantage she lacked. The reach, the range, the data, the speed.
What it does not have is a next month,
and we lost something smaller, and I think stranger.
Remember the rule from the beginning.
Under no circumstances open your case anywhere
but inside the customer's home.
For most of the 20th century, beauty was handled behind a closed door,
tested on a wrist in front of a room, discussed in a lowered voice,
carried upstairs and set down
on a dressing table where nobody else would ever see it used.
Now think about how beauty is open today.
The haul, the unboxing, the first impressions video,
products unwrapped, tested and judged in front of an audience
on the stoop of the entire internet before they have ever reached
the room where they will be worn.
The rule has been perfectly reversed.
The case is opened everywhere except inside.
Is that a loss or a liberation?
Is it better that a woman no longer has to wait?
at home for beauty to find her or did
the closed door protect something we have only noticed now
that is gone the right to hesitate to ask
the embarrassing question to get it wrong without
anyone watching i think it can be both the world
that kept women at home in the afternoons is not
one i would want back and neither i suspect would most of the women
who lived in it but inside the
world almost by accident a woman
with a case built something worth remembering a way of selling beauty
at human scale.
on private ground between two people
who would have faced each other again.
Hollywood sold us a face we would never meet. The Avon
lady sold us a jar from a woman we would never see again.
The feed sells us both at once
and then it never comes back.
The algorithm learned everything the Avon lady knew about
which door to knock on and never learned the walk back up the path.
So thank you so much for watching.
I mean let me know in the comments below. I mean I personally
like buying beauty products in person
when I still don't know what shade I am if I want to like test
and swatch colors but once I know what I like,
I do buy things online because it is easier, but obviously
that human touch is nice.
I don't think I've ever bought anything
from an Avon lady coming to my door or anything like that,
but I do love the look of those vintage catalogs and the products.
But I think there was just less selection back
then and I think that's why Avon
was more lucrative and more popular because we had less to choose from.
But now there's just so many beauty products,
there's drugstore products,
and everything can be bought online
so it's just such a different world.
But it's interesting to look back and see how it all started.
So thank you for watching and let me know in the comments below.

