Senator Josh Hawley is demanding answers about where taxpayer dollars are going, pressing officials in a tense Senate hearing on transparency and accountability. The discussion centres on whether federal funds are being properly allocated, tracked, and used effectively to serve the public. Hawley challenged officials on spending practices, highlighting concerns about waste, mismanagement, and the lack of clarity on where billions in taxpayer money are ending up. #JoshHawley#economictimes#SenateHearing
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This hearing discusses the staggering scale of government fraud, estimated at $1 trillion annually. Testimony highlights how stolen tax dollars fund terrorism, child trafficking, and luxury lifestyles. Using Minnesota as a case study, the discussion reveals systemic failures in oversight, the use of \"hawala\" cash smuggling via airports, and the urgent need for national coordination and modernized identity verification.
About a trillion dollars you think is lost in fraud every year.
Where's this money going?
It goes to terrorism.
It goes to child trafficking.
It goes to drugs.
It goes to terrorism.
And then it's used to purchase luxury items, cars, purses.
Holmes, you're telling me that the electrician who goes to work every
day, his tax money is being used to buy other people luxury items,
a trillion dollars a year on this stuff, $115 million an hour.
Thank you, Senator Johnson.
Senator Corrin, let me just come back to you.
I want to get a handle here on just
the scale of the fraud in Minnesota.
We talked about the dark money groups funding much
of what's going on on the ground,
but let's just get a handle here on the scale of the fraud.
You are a member, I want to get this right,
of the legislative, the office of the legislative auditor.
So.
I'm sorry, go ahead.
Mr. Chair, of the Legislative Audit Commission.
Audit Commission, got it.
You oversee the Office of the Legislative Auditor.
Okay, got it.
So you've got access to all of this information.
Give me your best estimate based
on the information you've seen, the audits you've seen.
How many of the agencies, 20 or so agencies,
I think in the state of Minnesota, public agencies,
how many have rampant fraud?
All of them are wrapped up in some sort of an issue.
There's 20 primary state agencies in state law.
The largest, or 10 of our largest primary agencies,
many of the non-profits receive
grants and funding from all 10 agencies.
If you had to put a number on it,
based on what you've seen, your work, your investigations,
the audits that you've seen, what do you think
the total losses are to Minnesotans in terms
of fraud?
I think the conservative number is what
our federal investigators have determined of just
the 14 Medicaid programs,
that half of all of it would be about $9 billion.
And I don't think that's...
And I think the reason I believe that's true
is in each audit that the legislative auditor
produces, we measure, right,
the level and the samples of what they have done, now 20
to 80 percent of each one of them,
they're unable to prove that the dollars were actually
gone, have gone to the programs in which they're indicated.
Nine billion dollars.
How much of this money has left Minnesota for overseas?
Well, I arrived in 2017. The child care assistance program fraud,
for which the program, I believe,
is $130 million, the whistleblowers showed us
that they believe $100 million of that was fraudulent.
We had a whistleblower come forward, actually publicly.
And at that time, we also discovered something new to me,
which is the hawala process of the movement of cash
through our airports in Minneapolis-St. Paul.
And what I've learned, come to learn,
and that year it was just coincidentally $100 million in fraud,
suspected fraud, and $100 million went out in cash
through the Minneapolis-St. Paul airport.
I've learned that...
Tell us how that worked.
$100 million in cash through the airport.
In suitcases.
Back then, it was a million at a crack.
And so I've learned that in the year before, it was about $74 million.
Secretary Besant just, I've tried for two
and a half years to get that number
because I wanted to get a view of how many excess dollars are sent out
from the community that's sending them.
And in the last two years, it was $340 million each year.
And so if you look at it,
it's about a 25% increase over this period from 2017.
That's $1.8 billion in cash.
And I don't think the average citizen whose works
for their money understands how complicated
it is to ship
or to obtain $6 to $7 million of cash every single week of the year.
That's.
And our federal government certainly must have
been aware of it and has done nothing
to look at it.
But that's just...
All but about $130 million, I think, is originated out of Minnesota.
You know, but what every American taxpayer
absolutely understands is their federal tax
money being taken on suitcases out
of this country to go heaven knows where.
I mean, if that's not infuriating, I don't know what is.
And the fact that it is systemic in Minnesota,
and probably to your testimony, Mr. Tucker,
probably systemic in a lot of other places.
I mean, millions of dollars in suitcases out of an airport,
and that's just one means of shipping this money around.
I mean, it's absolutely unbelievable.
I want to come back to you, Mr. Talco.
You testified that about a trillion dollars,
you think, is lost in fraud every year.
Where is this money going?
I mean, we know where some of it's going in Minnesota.
It went overseas. It went to Somalia. It went to NGO fronts.
We know where it's gone in some other states.
California gave away billions of dollars to a pro-Hamas NGO.
But a trillion dollars nationally, where's this money going to?
I appreciate that question because most people don't ask that question.
It goes to terrorism.
It goes to child trafficking.
It goes to drugs.
It goes to terrorism.
And then it's used to purchase luxury items, cars, purses, homes.
That's all funded by people like me that pay taxes.
So, you're telling me that the electrician
who goes to work every day and clocks in and
works his butt off
and tries to earn just enough to be able to make his rent, maybe
have a kid or two, put food on the table,
his tax money is being used to buy other people
luxury items, cars, yachts, whatever else,
and is going to fund terrorism and child trafficking?
Yes, sir.
A trillion dollars a year on this stuff?
$115 million an hour.
$115 million an hour.
How do they get their hands on it?
What are we talking about here?
Trends, national organizations, criminal networks,
how do they get their hands on this money?
They take advantage of antiquated government systems and processes.
They go into programs that they know
elected and appointed officials won't touch.
And they can steal at scale.
And what happened really was during the pandemic between the PPP loans
and the unemployment insurance, they learned a really valuable lesson.
Government never runs out of money.
And the probability of getting caught is virtually zero.
I have it at one-tenth of one percent.
So come back to the recommendations
that you mentioned in your opening statement.
What do we need to do?
To put a stop to this hemorrhaging of people's hard-earned money
going overseas to finance child trafficking and luxury yachts.
What needs to happen here?
It's really simple.
It's used every single day in the commercial sector.
Front-end identity verification.
You just don't get to say, I am who I say I am.
Second, recertification of all the recipients.
There is so much fraud right now in the benefit programs
all across the country.
We need to get a baseline.
Third, is this notion of a third party independent audit.
And finally, is involving federal law enforcement
like the Secret Service to investigate it.
The thing that people don't understand.
Is that most of these beneficiaries, Senator, they're not real.
They're fake.
They're someone's stolen identity
that is getting used in all 50 states.
Incredible.
Senator Kim, do you have anything for me?
Thank you.
Thank you, Chairman.
Look, what you just laid out there, Mr. Talco,
I mean, it should piss off every single American.
And this is absolutely atrocious, and it just,
I'm just furious, honestly, Chairman.
And, like, I think that there is something here,
as we've tried in other hearings, too,
where we can work in a bipartisan way to be able to address this.
You know, my job today, I'm not trying to defend any single state.
I'm just saying that we can't look at it just through that lens.
I mean, Mr. Talco, you were talking about this,
saying the criminals are looking at this nationally.
Is that right?
I think that was your quote.
Yes, sir.
Then we need to make sure we're looking at this nationally,
too, because it's not something
that any single state is going to be able to handle on their own.
Is that right, Mr. Talco?
Like, no single state in our country has
the capacity on their own to be able to address
this.
You don't see the connections when you're looking at it within a state.
You have to look at it nationally to find the connections.
Yeah, and so, you know, I think just...
Our best opportunity here going forward
to really try to deliver for the American people
this is outrageous and should not continue on.
It's just not just the scale of the money,
but what it's being used for and what it's
going towards.
And I say that as someone who used
to work counterterrorism, you know, at the Pentagon
before, like, I can't stand this.
But we need to make sure we're focusing in on the criminals
and thinking through, you
know, what you were saying about federal
law enforcement and other efforts.
So, look, you know, Mr. Chairman, again, I just think that there's
an opportunity here for us to come up with a comprehensive set,
a menu of actions that we can take and think through what
is it that we can work with this administration on,
what is it that we can work through Congress on,
what is it that we can empower the states to be able to step up
and to be able to handle on that front.
And, you know, Mr. Hedler-Gaudet,
I just wanted to just follow up with you because...
You know, we were talking through this about just the challenges,
for instance, on the data side.
You know, I had seen, you know, different reports about,
for instance, USAspending.gov, right?
But it seems...
From my appearance, wholly inadequate right now
in terms of being able to really rise
to the level of the detail.
I mean, I think it's admirable.
We're trying to have that transparency.
But would you agree that this is something,
if we're really serious about this, need to
make sure that we're taking the tools that we have,
investing in them to have a greater
level of detail and the fidelity to really be able to try to track?
Does that make sense to you?
Yeah, it makes perfect sense. And I would just note
that we're actually at a kind of an interesting moment right now.
We're 20 years, 20 year anniversary of the passage
of the Federal Funding Accountability and Transparency Act, which
was the piece of legislation bipartisan co-led by Senator Tom Coburn
and then Senator Barack Obama, by the way, that created USAspending.gov
and really tried to begin the process of bringing federal funding
and the tracking of federal funding into the 21st century.
We have obviously not kept up, and as I mentioned
in my opening testimony, we have a long way to go to really reflect.
21st century sort of technological capabilities
when it comes to how we track, monitor, and
assess federal spending, but it's, you know, it's something we can do.
It's not hard.
You know, the statute is there.
We have the reforms.
We have the fixes.
We just need to do it.