A Senate hearing on the safety and regulation of abortion pills turned tense on Wednesday when Senator Josh Hawley repeatedly pressed Indian-origin obstetrician-gynecologist Dr. Nisha Verma on whether men can become pregnant. The exchange during the Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee session went viral on social media. The hearing was meant to focus on the safety of medication abortion using mifepristone, the first pill in a two-drug regimen, and concerns over coerced or unsafe use. #JoshHawley#economictimes#SenateHearing
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This transcript captures a heated congressional hearing featuring a confrontation between a Senator and Dr. Verma regarding biological definitions of gender and the safety of abortion medication. The exchange highlights a deep divide between a strict biological interpretation of sex and a medical approach that considers patient identity and complexity.
Can men get pregnant?
Again, the reason I paused there is I'm
not really sure what the goal of the question is.
The goal is just to establish a biological reality.
You just said a moment ago that science
and evidence should control, not politics.
So let's just test that proposition.
Can men get pregnant?
I take care of people with many identities,
but I take care of many women that can get pregnant.
I do take care of people that don't identify as women.
Can men get pregnant?
Do science and evidence tell us
that men can get pregnant, biological men?
Can they get pregnant?
I also think yes-no questions like this are a political tool.
No, yes-no questions are about the truth, doctor.
Let's not make a mockery of this proceeding.
This is about science and evidence, and I'm asking you.
That's a yes-or-no question.
It really is, I think.
I think you're trying to reduce the complexity of a lot of things.
I'm not.
It's not complex.
I'm trying to get to an answer,
and I'm trying to test, frankly, your veracity.
As a medical professional and as a scientist, can men get pregnant?
I think you're also conflating male and female with...
No, I'm not conflating male and female.
They're two different things.
There's biological men and there's biological women.
And I want to know, can men get pregnant?
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Since you bring it up, why don't we just start there.
Dr. Verma, I wasn't sure I understood
your answer to Senator Moody a moment ago.
Do you think that men can get pregnant?
I hesitated there because I wasn't sure where
the conversation was going or what the goal was.
I mean, I do take care of patients with different identities.
I take care of many women.
I take care of people with different identities.
And so that's where I paused.
I think I wasn't sure where you were going with that.
Well, the goal is just the truth.
So can men get pregnant?
Again, the reason I paused there is I'm
not really sure what the goal of the question is.
The goal is just to establish a biological reality.
You just said a moment ago that science
and evidence should control, not politics.
So let's just test that proposition.
Can men get pregnant?
I take care of people with many identities,
but I take care of many women that can get pregnant.
I do take care of people that don't identify as women.
Can men get pregnant?
Again, as I'm saying...
Let me just remind you what you testified to a moment ago.
Science and evidence should control, not politics.
So, can men get pregnant?
You're a doctor science and evidence should guide medicine.
I do science and evidence.
Tell us that men can get pregnant biological men
Can they get pregnant? I also think yes.
No questions like this are a political tool. No. Yes
No questions are about the truth doctor.
Let's not make a mockery of this proceeding
This is about science and evidence.
So I'm asking you, you know, the United States Supreme
Court just heard arguments yesterday at great lengths
On this question. This is not a hypothetical question.
This is not theoretical that affects real people
in their real lives.
And you're here as an expert,
called by the other side as an expert, and you've been telling
us that you follow, right, you're a doctor,
and you follow the science and the evidence.
So I just want to know, based on the science, can men get pregnant?
That's a yes or no question.
It really is, I think.
I think you're trying to reduce the complexity of a lot of...
I'm not.
I'm trying to get...
It's not complex.
I'm trying to get to an answer,
and I'm trying to test, frankly, your veracity.
As a medical professional and as a scientist, can men get pregnant?
I think you're also conflating male and female with...
No, I'm not conflating male and female.
They're two different things.
There's biological men and there's biological women.
And I want to know, can men get pregnant?
What you're talking about is biological...
You're not going to answer my question.
You're saying biological males...
This isn't hard, doctor.
Can men get pregnant?
Yes or no?
I can't...
I would be more than happy to have a conversation with you that is
not coming from a place of trying to be polarized and pushing people.
I'm not trying to be polarizing.
I'm trying to ask.
I think it is extraordinary that we are here
in a hearing about science and about women.
And for the record, it's women who get pregnant, not men.
We are here about the safety of women
and science that shows that this abortion drug.
...causes adverse health events in 11% of cases.
That's 22 times greater than the FDA label,
another fact you haven't acknowledged.
And yet you won't even acknowledge the basic reality.
That biological men don't get pregnant.
There's a difference between biological men and biological women.
I just, I don't know how we can take you seriously
and your claims to be a person of science
if you won't level with this on this basic issue.
I thought we were past all of this, frankly.
I can't believe we're still here talking about this.
I am a person of science and I'm also someone here who's...
Here to represent the complex experiences of my patients,
and I don't think polarized
languages, language or questions serve that goal.
I don't think they serve the American people.
It is not polarizing to say that there
is a scientific difference between men and women.
And I want this to be clear and for the record,
it is not polarizing to say that women are
a biological reality and should be treated and protected as such.
That is not polarizing. That is truth.
It is also, by the way, the United States Constitution,
which offers unique protections to women
in a variety of circumstances as women.
And your refusal to recognize women as women
and men as men is deeply corrosive to science,
to public trust, and yes,
to constitutional protections for women as women.
And I just, I think it's extraordinary.
That you would sit here and advance a political agenda
that has been thoroughly discredited
and rejected by the American people in this forum.
And I'm glad we had this exchange
because it is exceptionally clarifying and is also
in many ways quite depressing.
I see that my time has nearly expired.
I just want to thank the other witnesses for being here.
Thank you for protecting women and children.
Thank you for your valiant efforts.
Thank you for following the science.
And thank you, Mr. Chairman, for this hearing.
Senator also Brooks.
Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I would be remiss if I didn't start
by saying I heard my colleague very passionately talk about
the fact that this is about the safety of women.
I want to make it clear that this administration
and this secretary could care less about women, men, or children.
In fact, they don't care about humans.
And I want to be very clear, I could go down and delineate how
that is true, but that is not the subject of today's hearing.
But for the past year,
We have all watched Secretary Kennedy
and this administration peddle conspiracy theories
and junk science to dismantle public health structures in this country.
So I don't want anyone lecturing about the safety of women.
These people don't care about humans.
Last week, in fact,
we saw the latest example with Kennedy recklessly eliminating the CDC's
recommendation for a number of critical childhood vaccinations
and very alarmingly, including
Including the flu shot.
In the midst of a flu, basically a surge in a super flu,
this is the moment that this man decides to eliminate
the flu shot for children as a recommendation.
Just like with the pediatric vaccine schedule,
changing the rules on FDA approved drugs without scientific input,
legitimate evidence on safety risk or transparency will cause,
we know, unnecessary fear for patients.
RFK's same playbook is being used to target.
Mifepristone, a safe and effective medication
that has been approved by the FDA for over 25 years.
Now, take all of the fear-mongering
and mistruths that RFK spewed earlier last year about measles, mumps,
and rubella vaccines, and take the fact that RFK agreed to reopen
the case on Mifepristone this fall, conducting its own very fake review
of the evidence of safety and efficacy of this drug.
That review was based in part on a study released last summer
by the Ethics and Public Policy Center.
Dr. Verma, as a practicing physician,
I would imagine that you read peer-reviewed research
and journals fairly regularly. Is that correct?
Yes, I do.
And is the Ethics and Public Policy Center a peer-reviewed
or rigorous medical journal?
It is not. That is a policy paper that you are referring to.