Hawley Confronts YouTube Exec Over Rampant AI Sex Abuse Material Hosted On Video Platform
Senator Hawley, you're recognized for five minutes.
Thank you very much, Madam Chair.
Thanks to all of the witnesses for being here.
Ms. Carlos, if I could just start with you.
You're here on behalf of YouTube, is that right?
That is correct.
Can you tell me, why is it that YouTube
has monetized videos that teach people
how to generate pornographic deep fakes of women?
Why does that happen on your platform?
Thank you for the question.
Protecting our users is one of our top priorities.
My general expertise is in music policy,
so I'm not in the best position to answer that question,
but I'm happy to follow up with you.
Do you know how many such videos there are out there?
These are monetized videos now on YouTube.
I'm not aware of that number.
I can't say that our community policies
do not allow that type of content on our platform.
Well, Forbes Magazine just reported
that YouTube's, in fact, promoted
over 100 YouTube videos with millions of views
that showcase AI deep fake porn
and include tutorials on how to make deep fake porn,
particularly porn that targets young women.
Do you have any idea how much money
YouTube has made off of this monetization?
Thank you for bringing this to my attention.
I do not have detail on this specific news article.
I'm happy to follow up with you in the committee.
So you don't have any idea of how many ad dollars
YouTube has made off of this?
I do not.
Are you aware that one of these websites
that was promoted by YouTube in these videos
was later cited in a criminal prosecution
for AI sexual abuse material generating,
let me be more specific,
generating AI sexual abuse material involving children?
Thank you again for the question, Senator.
As we mentioned earlier, YouTube has endorsed
the Take It Down Act,
and we take these issues very seriously.
Again, I'll notify that I represent music policy
and do not have the information
to give you a fulsome response.
Well, so let me ask you this then.
If a teenage girl's face ends up
in an AI porn video on your platform,
what does YouTube do about it?
What's her recourse right now?
What can she do to get some recompense,
get some restitution?
After over a year ago, we updated our privacy policy
so that anybody who believes that their voice
or likeness is being used without their authorization
on our platform can submit a request for removal.
A request for removal.
Is there some policy in getting reimbursement
for any profits the company may have made,
again, if these videos are monetized?
I mean, does the victim get a share of anything?
I'm not aware of those policies.
I would have to follow up with you, Senator.
Why is it that the enforcement of YouTube's own policy here
seems to only happen after videos go viral?
Is there a reason for that?
I do not have the answer to that question to you.
Do you know how many AI-generated deepfake videos
or deepfake content is removed before a victim complains?
Does the victim have to complain before YouTube does anything?
Again, my specialty is in music policy.
I do understand that we use technology such as AI
to search for that content,
and when it is in violation of our policies,
we will remove it.
Let me ask you about this.
YouTube training data.
Has YouTube provided data for use in Google's Gemini
or other AI training programs?
YouTube does provide data in Google training data
in accordance with our agreements.
So if an artist uploads music to YouTube,
does the company use that music to train AI models?
As I mentioned, we do share data
in accordance with our agreements.
I can't speak to the specifics of any individual agreement.
Well, so how are people like Ms. McBride protected?
I mean, so if you're an artist
and you put any content on YouTube,
does that mean that it's just free range?
I mean, you can do whatever you want with it?
Again, it goes down to the terms of our agreement.
I will say that we have forged deep partnerships
with the music industry.
We came out of the gate with forming AI music principles
with the music industry
and are continuing to experiment with them
to see how AI can best benefit their creative process.
So are there privacy protections, you're telling me?
YouTube hasn't placed privacy protections for artists?
We, they apply to all individuals on our platform.
Oh, so is this, you have to,
this is the click wrap scenario.
This is in order to watch cute dog videos or whatever.
You've got to click the I consent and that wraps in.
You basically give consent for your stuff to be used?
There are all different types of various
agreements, but our terms of service
are included in that batch.
So where are, I guess my question is,
where are users told about their privacy protections
if they have any and where do they explicitly consent?
There are, they agree to our terms of service
and we also have our privacy policy available on the web.
Okay, so that's the click wrap.
So in other words, if you come onto YouTube,
you want to use it, you click, you got to click through.
So you click it and there you basically agreed
to allow YouTube to give your content to AI
and allow them to train it without any further consent.
Is that basically it?
Again, we implement our policies in terms of our agreement
are what govern what goes into our training.
Well, and I'm asking you the content of that agreement.
So in other words, if I'm an artist
and I upload something to YouTube,
and yeah, sure, I've clicked the button that says,
yeah, I want to be able to use YouTube.
Are you telling me that I don't have any further recourse?
If YouTube then goes and gives the information
to AI models and systems, there's nothing further I can do?
Or am I missing something?
It is, if it is in accordance with our agreements,
we will share that data.
Yeah, that seems like a big problem to me.
That seems like a huge, huge problem to me.
And the fact that YouTube is monetizing
these kinds of videos seems like a huge, huge problem to me.
I'm glad you're here today.
I wish there were more tech companies here today,
but we've got to do more.
I mean, YouTube, I'm sure is making billions
of dollars off of this.
The people who are losing are the artists
and the creators and the teenagers
whose lives are upended.
We've got to give individuals powerful enforceable rights
in their images, in their property,
and in their lives back again,
or this is just never going to stop.
Thank you, Madam Chair.

