Contains strong language and discussions of sexual assault that may be upsetting.
Online groups that help UK women find out the truth about the men they are dating are growing. Are they a force for good? Or do they spread lies with harmful real-world consequences?
First shown: 24 Nov 2025
00:00 Intro 02:24 Are we dating the same guy? 04:39 Jess' story 08:44 The police response 09:41 New stories pouring in 11:34 Meeting the expert 13:54 In-person dating night 15:57 Group moderator 18:19 The men getting outed 20:58 Telegram chats 23:56 Outro
SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/c/Channel4Doc... About #4Docs: Welcome to Channel 4 Documentaries, the home of cutting-edge factual content, from the award-winning 24 Hours In Police Custody and Dispatches to provocative and powerful original true stories.
From shocking crimes to ground-breaking investigations, follow detectives unravelling real-life murder cases, step into the shadows of hidden subcultures and witness the shocking realities of romance fraud.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video examines the \"Are we dating the same guy?\" Facebook groups in the UK, which function as community-driven safety nets for women to expose cheaters and predators. While providing vital warnings where legal systems fail, the groups also face criticism for lacking due process, leading to defamation and retaliatory criminal behavior by men in similar private forums.
I'm Mary Manderfield, presenter, broadcaster, and yeah, single.
And honestly, dating right now, it is chaos.
Ghosting, love bombing, catfishing, been there, I've seen it all.
But look, I've heard about these private women-only Facebook groups,
and they're causing a stir.
If you're not part of the group, this is your sign to go and join it.
You guys must have seen this Facebook page going viral.
The most talked about page in the whole of the UK right now.
Are we dating the same guy?
Are we dating the same guy?
Are we dating the same guy?
The idea is simple.
Post a picture of a guy that you're dating or chatting to
to check if he's seeing anyone else.
And ask the standard question, any tea or red flags?
And it is juicy.
Already this morning, I've seen three men get caught
in the comment section by their girlfriends.
Cheating.
In one day he slept with not one, not two, but three girls.
The group started in the US in 2022 and went viral.
Basically every major city has one.
Across just the UK, over one million women have joined.
But these groups aren't just about catching fuckboys and cheaters.
I've discovered something way more disturbing.
I'm about to spill some tea on the dark side.
Women are using them to alert others to sexual predators.
He'd spiked me.
Exposed himself and put his fingers down my throat.
He was arrested for attempted murder.
Only 4.2% of sexual offences in the UK end with a charge.
And with the vast majority of these being against women,
are these online communities replacing a system
that is failing to bring women justice?
Conviction rates are really low
when it comes to like assault or harassment.
I don't really trust the police very much
when it comes to experiences like this.
I want to know if these groups are a force for good
or are some spreading lies about men with real world consequences.
There's rumours being spread about guys that isn't true.
Toxic women slagging men.
Guys have gone way too ******* far.
You're potentially gambling with somebody's life there.
Where's the line between protecting women and publicly shaming men?
I'm entering this murky world to find out.
I've seen one picture, guys, just give them a chance.
Every single time.
I haven't dated for a while, and I'm not gonna lie,
it all seems like a bit of a minefield.
Okay.
Okay, one more.
I'm intrigued already.
Born in Germany, raised in Barbados.
So I'm dipping my toe back into online dating,
with the help of my mates, Charlie and Chelsea.
There is much more of a throwaway culture nowadays
that's just churn people out constantly.
But do you feel like...
There is this fear within dating apps
that you just don't really know who you're dealing with.
Totally. People can really deceive you.
It's so easy for them to treat you bad and just disappear.
I've heard about these Facebook groups.
Are we dating the same guy?
Yes, wild.
Have I seen them? Have I used them?
Honey, I've used it myself and let me tell you,
I found out things about guys that, yeah.
Look at this post.
It goes by the name of David, Matt or Dan,
compulsive liar, cheater, knowingly spreading incurable STD.
STD.
What's happening?
This guy's married?
This guy's using a fake name?
This is ridiculous.
Okay, I'm hooked.
There's just thousands of people.
Every area of the UK seems to be covered.
The groups are private, so before I can see the posts,
my profile needs to be vetted by a moderator.
You know, to make sure I'm legit and not a man.
And, wow, OK, there are a lot of rules.
Everything from not posting anything outside the group
to no last names, don't share any personal information.
It's about protecting women, not judging men,
no false information about anyone, be civil.
The discussion is constant.
There are over 250 posts a day in that big London group
and thousands of posts daily across all other cities in the UK.
One post jumps out and the comments are going off.
The story? Basically my worst nightmare.
I need to know more.
The woman who made the original post agrees to meet up where her
are we dating the same guy journey begins at Crazy Golf.
For legal reasons we can't reveal
her identity.
So we're calling her Jess.
Lovely to meet you.
And you.
How are you doing?
Not bad.
Not bad.
How are you?
We're not bad.
We're not bad.
Well done.
Jess tells me about a guy that she matched with on Tinder.
We'll call him Jamie.
Tall.
Good looking.
He seemed like a real catch.
Yeah.
We like the same kind of music.
We're both into sports.
He was good with his communication, like talk all day,
every day, to the point where I could
see that this was going to be a relationship,
but then there was a moment when it just changed.
He ghosted me.
He blocked me.
I just thought he was mad.
i remember going out one time with my little sister
and she was like just put his face in
the group you'll know what he's up to i posted
his picture from tinder just asking if anyone
had any tea then i got a private inbox
on facebook yeah it was from a girl she was like
he's been going out with my best friend
for four years oh my god his name wasn't jamie
he didn't live in upminster he lived with his girlfriend
You're literally leading a double life.
It's insane, but you just don't think
it's going to happen to you, do you?
No.
The groups are full of stories like Jess's.
Guys cheating left, right and centre.
Out of nowhere he ghosts you, and not just that he'd lied to you,
but he was a complete different person to what he'd said.
If I hadn't posted in that group,
none of us would have known about what happened.
You potentially saved this woman from starting
a family with someone who she thought she could
trust and she clearly couldn't.
Yeah, I mean she also saved me a lot of stress and pain
and gave me a lot of closure. But Jess's story isn't finished.
We head somewhere more private
where she can share a much darker story about a guy
who we'll call Marcus. So I met another guy
shortly after meeting Jamie, actually on an app called Field.
I just let him meet up with
up with me for one drink outside the pub
while my mates were inside the pub.
He was just very pushy, quite demanding.
No, I really want to kiss you, is what he said.
But I don't want to do it here.
And then led me down an alleyway.
As soon as we got somewhere far enough away,
he pushed me up against a wall
and, like, exposed himself and put his fingers down my throat.
I'm sorry. That's just so grim.
I managed to make my excuses
and walk back down towards the pub again,
back where my friends were.
So I assume you told your friends?
Yeah, absolutely, I told my friends.
I even reported him, actually, to the app.
And then what? What did Field do?
They responded to me, I think, just acknowledging my message.
But I also don't know what's happened with what I have said.
So he could still be there.
Field's policy doesn't say if it discloses
the outcome of investigations to the reporting party.
So Jess doesn't know if Marcus is still on the app or not.
Do you think someone like Marcus is using other dating sites?
I know that from what I have seen and what I've heard from other girls.
We investigated how easy it is for banned users to hop to new dating apps
or just make a fresh profile and turns out it's simple.
A quick Google pulls up endless forums showing you how.
So Marcus could easily be bouncing from app to app.
So what did you do next?
I put his face in the group just I guess as a warning.
And it was incredible the amount of people that commented on that post,
saying that he'd done similar things and worse things.
How many people came forwards?
Over ten girls.
Ten?
After the assault, Jess also reported Marcus to the police,
but they said they didn't have enough info to pursue her claim,
and the case was closed.
Do you feel like there's almost more power in Facebook groups like this
than you might get from the police?
Yeah, 100%. It's quicker.
It's less intimidating, you can be anonymous, there's a support system.
It felt good to be able to have a platform to share that information
so people are aware.
I used to read some of these posts on the Facebook groups
and think it's just gossip,
but look I've just spoken to Jess and it's serious.
You know she's told me that she was sexually assaulted
by someone and that without this
network on the group she wouldn't have found out
that she wasn't the only victim.
Some of these allegations posted,
they're more than just cheating or gossip.
They're really serious.
I've decided to get in touch with the other women
who commented on Jess's post.
Two women respond and agree to speak with me anonymously.
They tell me they both matched with Marcus on different apps
and alleged they were sexually assaulted by him.
Neither went to the police.
Instead, they shared their stories about Marcus on the group
to warn others.
Jess's was just one post about one guy on one
of the dozens of Facebook groups in the UK.
How many other stories are out there?
I need to find out. So I'm going to hit record.
The more I've been talking to people,
the more I've realised there are some really
crazy stories. People's lives are being completely impacted by this.
So if you've got your own personal experience
or you know someone, let me know.
I'm overwhelmed with how many stories start pouring in.
I went on a date with a guy that I'd met on Hinge.
I felt like something was wrong.
I would never have gotten that drunk off of a few pints.
I sort of remember him on top of me.
He'd spiked me.
I was like, is there anything I can do to the police?
And they're like, no, not really.
And I was like, but I'm the third person
that he's done this to, like, what's it take?
I am so grateful for this group.
It really was that thing of,
I don't have to hold this on my own.
I don't really trust the police very much
when it comes to experiences like this.
When I told him to stop, he wouldn't.
I'm happy that I'm not murdered.
He was arrested for attempted murder
and I never would have known that
if it wasn't for the group.
Over the course of this investigation,
we spoke to 18 women who'd used the group
to warn others of potentially dangerous men.
Most of them hadn't gone to the police.
Hearing all these stories, it feels like the system is broken.
Are these groups filling a gap and stepping in to protect women?
I'm talking with Rebecca Hitchin,
a campaigner at the End Violence Against Women Coalition.
Nice to see you, come on in.
Thank you so much.
They've been working to end abuse against women and girls,
on and offline, since 2005.
I've spoken to some women
who say that they have been sexually assaulted on a date but they've
decided to not report it to the police.
Statistics say that roughly five in six women who are raped
won't report to the police. Yeah that's quite shocking really.
It can take a long time when
you report to the police that can
be really stressful it can be re-traumatizing and that
the statistics sort of speak for themselves.
The rates of charging are very low and very few cases
is actually end up in court.
The stats are pretty grim.
It takes on average 306 days to get
a decision for a charge on a rape case.
And on average, a victim will be waiting over two years,
from reporting to a verdict in court.
If someone is convicted of rape, the average sentence is 10 years.
Women have told me that they don't trust dating apps
to protect them online.
Do you think enough is being done to kind
of keep women safe in these spaces?
Dating apps could and should be taking the safety of women
and girls a lot more seriously.
And one of the reasons why they don't is they don't have to.
The current product, the way it works,
yes it causes harm to women and girls,
but it's profitable and that's essentially the bottom line for them.
And then there are these groups where it's very likely
that you'll just be believed and be heard
and that's really important for survivors as well.
They're clearly feeling a need
and there's a reason why they are so popular.
I'm discovering women feel neither the apps
nor the justice system are keeping them safe.
So they're turning to these online communities.
But can these groups sometimes get it wrong?
The repercussions of the page being used
in the wrong way is really, really massive.
Just had a lot of big, big impact on my mental health.
I just felt completely alone.
In South London.
I don't know why
I feel nervous.
I'm digging into the world of are we dating the same guy
and heading to meet some other singles
at an in-person dating night called Thursday.
One snake and one heart,
because look, I'm open to love,
but I also know what we're looking out for.
I think it'll be interesting to find out from all these singles
who are actively dating, do they know about the group?
Are they in the group?
And basically see what their thoughts are on it.
I know the Facebook group, I'll be dating
the same guy, you know about it.
I've seen so many people posting it.
A dating profile, you could be like catfished so easily.
I love to just read all the comments.
You want some validation that they're actually a normal person.
It's like having girls' backs.
It really holds a mirror up to like,
there's a reason why we feel we need to do this,
because we feel like it's safer and more comfortable.
The women I've spoken to tonight totally agree with the groups,
but the guys I meet make me realise maybe it's not so simple.
It's a sad sign of the times that these groups that you mention exist.
The fact that it's anonymous I think is quite bad.
Yeah.
Anyone can say anything.
It's like a murder song.
You can literally say that because they're anonymous.
You can say whatever the **** you want and there's no consequences,
but there's loads of consequences for the guy.
So the singles night was interesting last night.
I did have a lot of fun.
I think up until this point,
I've seen the groups as these amazing tools for women,
but the conversations I had with people
made me realize that they've grown,
they've gotten quite messy.
I think I want to peer behind the curtain of these groups,
see who's controlling them,
who decides what gets posted and what doesn't.
I've found that each group is run by a moderator
in charge of making sure all members follow the rules.
But the first rule of the group is don't talk about them.
We've been spending ages basically just like knocking
on the doors of moderators
from loads of different groups
and no one wants to speak to us until now.
This moderator runs a smaller Facebook group
of 10,000 members in Manchester
and she's letting us in on how her group works.
I'm curious, what was the reason for you to start your own group?
The last time I ever used a dating app,
the man turned out to be aggressive
and very passionate about warning other women
of someone who's dangerous.
As a moderator, you're sort of like sheriff,
judge and jury in all of this.
Yeah.
Do you feel like the kind of moderating space that you're in,
it replaces parts of the justice system?
The thing is, you can't ring the police every time
a man's gaslighting you.
Yeah.
Or, you know, driving you mentally, you know,
having a toll on your mental health.
If they can go in the group and just be like,
I just wanted to let you know, like,
just if anyone was thinking about going out with him.
Is there kind of one question you ask yourself
before you press approve?
If I think that I would read that post and think,
oh, my God, then I know I need proof.
But even when you have evidence,
there's still things that people can make up or they can twist things.
What happens if you feel like you've got it wrong?
Maybe you've put a post up or you've let a post through
that you feel like actually on reflection was the wrong thing to do.
People do post maliciously.
There may be a bitter ex, there may just be somebody that just doesn't
like a guy and just thinks I'm going to cause some trouble for him.
I'll never know if that post was real about him, will I?
I'll never know.
I think she had really great intentions.
She seemed to really care about the people within the group.
But I think you can have the best intentions in the world
and still not get everything right all the time.
We're talking about information posted in these groups
that could change people's lives.
There's one side I haven't heard from yet.
The guy's actually getting outed on these groups.
After months of searching, I found a guy willing to chat.
Football coach Kyle says he went through a bad breakup.
They went their separate ways,
but a post about him appeared on his local
Are We Dating the Same Guy group on Facebook.
Then another, and another.
A friend had sent me it, you know, saying,
you know, you're on this website, do you know about it?
It was basically calling me different types of names.
He's a liar or a narcissist or, you know, a gaslighter.
Where I live, where I worked, what I'd done in my spare time,
everything was out there for maybe 50,000, 60,000 people to see.
You live in quite a small town,
so what was that like thinking maybe other people had seen it?
I remember going to the gym
Even a quick glance, you know, of somebody looking at you,
you're just constantly thinking, have they seen that post?
Following the claims made online, Kyle's employer was so concerned
they temporarily removed him from his coaching job
and launched an investigation.
It was devastating.
Football's my passion, and to have that taken away from me
until an investigation was pending, it was devastating.
You know, the loss of income, the stress and worry
about how I was going to pay, you know, my rent.
The roll-on impact of it is massive.
Things soon got pretty dark for Kyle.
I was petrified to go out.
The suspension was still ongoing.
I was having a lot of trouble mentally.
I just felt completely alone.
Around Christmas time, I tried to take my own life.
I'm so sorry to hear that.
Kyle was eventually cleared by his employer
and returned to coaching a different team.
He says the posts about him are untrue.
I'm not here to be the judge
but it's hard not to be moved by the impact that this has had on him.
I have made a lot of mistakes.
I can hand on heart and say that you know
I probably wasn't the best boyfriend
but it doesn't warrant putting you on a page, it can destroy your life.
What were your thoughts towards these kinds of groups
and has that changed now?
I think for people it's just entertainment, I really do.
You're potentially gambling with somebody's life there.
I've just seen someone whose life has been completely altered.
He's been through a lot.
It's like, I'm all for keeping women safe, it makes so much sense.
It's put me in a position now where I realise
this is bigger than I thought it was.
And now I've discovered some men have struck back,
creating their own group chats in retaliation.
Are we dating the same girl Telegram group chat?
This group chat got dark.
Are We Dating the Same Girl groups have
been cropping up on Telegram and messaging app,
renowned as a safe haven for secretive activity.
When does this actually become more of an escalated crime?
We've gained access to some of the comments on these private channels
and it gets ugly fast.
They've posted the girl and then shared her mobile number
and just encouraging people to spam her.
She's a slag, slut, slag.
We've identified loads of intimate images that don't look consensual.
The comments are relentless.
This girl looks like rape material.
So much talk about leaked videos and police can't get involved,
police can't do anything.
This has just gone to another level, like it's disgusting.
The Facebook groups of, are we dating the same guy,
Felt like this wild west where anything could be said
and some things took it too far.
But then these groups, so much of it's criminal.
I asked Rebecca what she made of the
are we dating the same girl telegram chats
that we've discovered.
These groups where men are coming together
to share images, sexualized images, intimate image abuse
of women who they may have dated or may have interacted with.
That is criminal behavior, that's illegal.
Intimate image abuse, or revenge porn,
is now a priority offence under the Online Safety Act,
carrying sentences of up to two years.
The origins of these men's groups seem to be rooted around
trying to find ways to embarrass, silence, humiliate women
or somehow increase their own standing within the groups.
They're not used in the same way, I guess, as the women's ones are.
The origins of those groups for women
were about their own sense of safety
and also sharing information about people
who have been harmful or dangerous.
The intention of the women's group is trying to solve something,
but there's so much to solve.
Criminal justice system should be much better
and work better for women and girls,
but there should be other avenues as well.
So like, yeah, being able to report it to the dating app
and know that it will be taken seriously
and know that there will be effective action
taken against the perpetrator.
I'll be real with you.
At the beginning of all this,
I thought it was just about gossip.
But it turns out for loads of these women that I've spoken to,
these groups are a lifeline.
But my word, are they messy.
Women need spaces where they feel comfort,
they feel community and where they know that their
stories are going to be believed.
And look we've had spaces like this throughout history and we
have them now on Facebook.
They're not perfect but they're so popular and I think that shows
they are needed. I'm actually going on a first date tonight
and I hope it's a guy I never have
to post in one of these groups.
Look they exist, they're like the last line of defense for a system
that has historically failed women and men.
So, what do we do? What do I do? Wish me luck.