"That Was a Lie, Mr. Smith": We Checked Hawley's Receipts
1 Video View·Nov 15, 2026
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video analyzes a hearing where Senator Josh Hawley questioned Special Counsel Jack Smith. The analysis fact-checks Hawley's claims regarding the timing of indictments, internal DOJ advice, and allegations that Smith lied to Congress about obtaining text messages from members of Congress.
You told them you'd never gotten messages.
You'd never requested messages
from any member of Congress. That was a lie.
That's Senator Josh Hawley accusing Jack Smith under oath
of not telling Congress the truth.
In the same 10 minutes, Hawley gets two dates wrong.
You'll see every charge checked against
the record and the last one is the hardest to call, so stay for it.
This is part two of three
of the Jack Smith hearing checked. Part one was the wrong Hawks.
Senator Hawley is a Missouri Republican
and he had the last questions of a four-hour hearing.
He opens with the big claim.
Smith's whole case, he says, was about the 2024 election. Then he gets
specific with two numbers. Round one. Listen for both.
And that's exactly what you were doing.
Twice indicted the president during the election,
tried to get his first trial set for during the primaries.
In fact, I think the first trial date you requested
was like three days before the Iowa caucuses.
When all of that failed, you then filed a superseding indictment,
a whole nother indictment, on October the 2nd,
I believe, 2024, five weeks before Election Day.
Number one, like three days before the Iowa caucuses.
Smith's team did ask for an early trial starting January 2nd, 2024.
The Iowa caucuses were January 15th. That's 13 days, not three.
Hawley did hedge. He said, I think and like.
And his bigger point that Smith wanted a trial
early in the primary season is fair,
but the number is wrong. Number two is bigger.
October the 2nd, five weeks before election day.
That's not when it happened. Smith's team filed
the superseding indictment on August 27, 2024.
That's 70 days before the election, about 10
weeks, not five. So what happened on October 2nd?
Judge Tanya Chutkan unsealed a long brief
from Smith's team about immunity.
A filing in the case, not a new indictment.
Smith corrects this himself at the very end, and we'll play it.
Round two, Hawley says the Justice Department's own public integrity
section told Smith not to file, and he says he has the notes.
And you did it anyway.
That's incorrect.
You filed the indictment, and indeed,
the Public Integrity Division told you not to do it.
I've got it right here. I've got your notes
from the meeting. Let's have a look.
They said to you.
These are your notes.
Call with your team's notes.
Call with the Public Integrity Division.
August 17, 2024.
They said a large segment of the population would see
this as motivated bipartisan purposes
and would not understand why
the department could not wait to supersede.
They said public integrity has no precedent it could cite
to seek to support a superseding
indictment under these circumstances.
They said it's their advice.
You wait to file the superseding indictment if you do it at all.
Oh, but you did it anyway, because you were desperate to stop Donald J. Trump
Here's the honest answer.
We couldn't find those notes anywhere public, so we can't check them.
Hawley read from them on camera.
Smith says the section ultimately agreed his team followed the
election year policy. Both could be true
at different points in the same process. Without
the document, we score neither man on this one.
Then Hawley turns to Smith's deputy.
And then.
Your top deputy went out
and ran for Congress as a Democrat, boasting about it.
What was his name? J.P. Cooney? Do you remember him?
Your deputy, right? He was your deputy, J.P. Cooney?
Yes, he was. Right. Let's just take a look at his campaign poster.
Running for Congress as a Democrat, boasting about the fact
that he went after Donald Trump during an election.
Here he is, J.P. Cooney, candidate for Congress as a Democrat.
That one checks out. J.P. Cooney was a lead prosecutor
on both Trump cases in Smith's office.
He was fired in January 2025, and now he's running
for Congress in Virginia as a Democrat, according to NBC News.
Smith confirms he was his deputy, but notice what it proves.
It's a fact about Cooney's career
after the case. It says nothing about whether
the timing of the indictment was right.
Next come three minutes on phone records and a non-disclosure order.
Smith concedes one point.
Watch for it. You didn't tell the court you
were seeking subpoenas from the phone companies for
for members of Congress, did you?
You hid that from the court, isn't that correct?
We did not say who the subpoenas
were for when we sought a nondisclosure order.
That part is correct.
Yeah, exactly.
That part is correct.
Smith admits his team didn't tell
the court whose phone records the subpoenas were for
when it asked for a nondisclosure order.
That's the gag order fight, and it gets its own episode,
part three, with Senator Cruz.
Hold that thought, because this is where Hawley's ten minutes turn.
Round three is the charge in the headline.
Any time the law stood in your way,
any time the Constitution stood in your way,
you just ignored it.
Is that why you lied to the House under oath about getting member text
messages? I answered every question I was asked truthfully.
I'm proud of our investigation.
No, well, you shouldn't be. You should
be totally ashamed. Let me just ask you this.
On December 17, 2025, you told the House
That you had never gotten text messages from members of Congress.
Let's have a look.
Here's what you said to the House.
Did you seek a search warrant for the content
of any text messages of members?
You say, from members?
Yes.
You say, I don't recall.
It was, I don't recall that.
It was just toll records?
You say, correct.
Now, do you recall this exchange with the House on December 17th, 2025?
I see it there, yes.
Okay, good.
First, the quote is real.
It's in the deposition excerpt published
with Representative Jim Jordan's referral in July.
But listen to the exact question.
Did Smith seek a search warrant for the content
of text messages from members of Congress?
He said no, he didn't recall that.
It was toll records which list who contacted whom and when.
Now, Hawley's evidence.
But on June the 2nd, 2023, two full years earlier,
you demanded from the National Archives
records that included text messages from 44 United States senators
and members of Congress.
And indeed, you got all of those records. Isn't that correct?
Yes, and I'm happy to explain that if you'll give me the opportunity.
Oh, no, I understand that you got them.
We all understand, and we know it, not because you told us,
but because the Department of Justice disclosed it.
So two full years before this deposition,
you were in possession of text messages from 44 members of Congress
that you went and subpoenaed.
That holds up.
Justice Department records released in July.
By Chairman Grassley and Senator Ron Johnson,
Smith's team got text messages
involving 44 current and former members of Congress,
20 senators, 24 House members.
Hawley is one of them, but look where they came from.
The National Archives. From the phones of Trump White House officials.
Donald Trump, Mark Meadows,
Mike Pence. Not the members' own phones and not a search warrant.
A subpoena to the archives.
Smith offers to explain and Hawley doesn't let him.
Now pause and decide. Was Smith's
answer to the House false? A dodge or true but narrow?
Hold that and hear Hawley out.
You read them within 30 minutes,
the Department of Justice told this committee.
They said that within an hour of receiving those text messages,
your team was reading them.
And yet, not only did you not notify any member
of Congress whose text messages you obtained,
pursuant to your process, you told the House two full years later,
having read all 44 members' messages,
you told them you'd never gotten messages,
you'd never requested messages from any member of Congress.
That was a lie, Mr. Smith,
and you may try your lawyer your way out of it.
Well, it wasn't from the member, it was from the archives.
You knew exactly what you were being asked,
and you deliberately misled them.
Here's where we land.
Hawley's facts on the texts mostly hold.
44 members and Smith's team read them fast.
Reports on those records say within about an hour and a half.
Hawley says 30 minutes, then an hour.
Close enough for his point.
But his summary of the deposition is not what the transcript says.
In the exchange he read,
Smith was not asked whether he ever got members' texts.
He was asked about search warrants, and he answered that.
Hawley's argument is that Smith knew what the House meant.
That's a fair argument to make. It is not a finding.
Jordan referred Smith to the Justice Department in July.
Smith's lawyers say the referral doesn't even contest
the truthfulness of his answers.
No court and no official body has found
that Smith told Congress anything false.
Then, Hawley closes like this.
It's the worst abuse of prosecutorial power
in the history of the United States.
And all I have to say is, I'm glad you failed.
I don't know what our democracy would
be like if you had succeeded in your effort
to interfere in the workings of a presidential election.
If it were up to me, I'd charge you with perjury.
But you should certainly be disbarred.
And I can only pray that nothing like
this will ever happen again in the United States of America.
A senator saying he'd bring a charge,
with no charge and no finding behind it.
The ranking Democrat Dick Durbin then asks that Smith get to answer.
Here's his whole reply.
Mr. Smith, they have an opportunity to respond.
If there are any areas of questioning,
he didn't get an opportunity to respond.
There were several things
that Senator Hawley just said that are not accurate.
Uh, including, uh, among other things, uh,
the process we went about to get these, uh, records from NARA.
That was a request for White House phones. It was also inaccurate
to state that our indictment happened on October 2nd.
We indicted that case, uh, in August and, uh,
we consulted with the public integrity section during.
That process and the public integrity section ultimately concurred
that we had followed
the election year sensitivities policy. I just want that to be clear.
August, not October. On the dates, Smith is right twice over.
On the public integrity section,
we can't check either man.
And on the texts, the messages are real and the answer Hawley
calls a lie was narrow, but it matched the question in the transcript.
Here's the grill score.
Our real score and it's our opinion on our published rubric.
Jack Smith, 9.3. He answered
directly. He conceded the non-disclosure point
and every claim we could check held up. Senator
Hawley, 3.7. His facts on the text and on Cooney held.
But both of his dates were wrong. Most of
his questions were accusations
and he described Smith's deposition answer as something it wasn't.
A false answer or a narrow answer to a narrow question.
Tell me what you heard.
Part one, The Wrong Hawks, is on the left.
Part three is Senator Cruz and Smith's I Don't Recall.
Every source is in the description.
The tape, the receipts, the truth.

