A Seismometer Found Something Hidden Inside Wyoming’s Devils Tower — What It Revealed Is Terrifying

Archaeology Explained
5 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedResearchers discovered that Devil's Tower is not a static monolith but a vibrating structure that sways and twists. By analyzing natural resonance, scientists found the tower is seven times \"softer\" than solid stone, revealing internal instability caused by its composition of individual columns rather than a unified mass.
867 feet of solid stone rising out of the Wyoming plains.
America's first national monument.
You know this rock. It looks like the most permanent thing on earth.
But in October 2024,
a team of climbers hauled a seismometer to the summit,
covered it with a bucket,
and left it there for 21 hours.
What it heard was not silence. The tower never stops moving.
It sways and twists about once every second,
day and night, wind or no wind.
Then scientists built a digital copy of the tower,
and it only behaved correctly
when they made it about seven times softer than its own rock.
Something hidden inside is not as tight as it looks,
and 200 feet up the south face,
an 80,000 pound column rests on a single edge. Remember that bucket?
Because nothing here is standing still.
To understand what that bucket was doing up there,
you need to start somewhere else.
Utah.
The 4th of August, 2008.
In Arches National Park,
a stone span called Wall Arch stood beside a busy hiking trail,
71 feet long.
It had stood for thousands of years.
Then, sometime in the middle of a calm summer night, it simply fell.
No storm, no earthquake, no warning.
That collapse stayed with a geologist named Jeff Moore
and his team at the University of Utah.
They later said it was one of the main reasons
their research exists,
because it raised a simple and uncomfortable question.
If a rock that has stood for thousands of years
can fall on a quiet night with no sign at all,
how would anyone ever know which one is next?
Moore's answer was to listen.
Here is the idea. Nothing on earth is ever truly still.
Wind pushes against every cliff.
Earthquakes on the far side
of the planet send waves through the ground.
Ocean swells crash against distant coastlines
and the energy rolls inland through solid rock. The whole planet hums
quietly,
constantly. And anything tall that stands on top
of that hum picks it up and starts to ring at its own natural rhythm.
A skyscraper does it, a bridge does it, and so does a tower of stone.
Measure that rhythm carefully
and you can learn what the structure is like on the inside
without drilling a single hole.
The team tested the idea on arches and natural bridges across Utah,
then on something bigger.
In 2018, climbers carried a seismometer to the top of Castleton Tower,
A sandstone spire about 400 feet tall above Castle Valley.
It turned out to sway roughly as fast as a human heartbeat.
Later, Moore worked on a study of the Matterhorn in the Alps
and found that even that giant was
being shaken by earthquakes and by the energy of the oceans.
So eventually, they set their sights
on the most famous rock tower in America.
You cannot drive to the top of Devil's Tower.
You cannot walk there.
The walls rise almost straight up for hundreds of feet.
Getting anything onto that summit has always been a struggle.
In October 1941,
a stunt parachutist named George Hopkins tried a shortcut.
He jumped from a plane and landed right on top to win a bet.
Then, he discovered he had no way down.
He was stuck up there for six days.
Around 7,000 people came to watch.
The rescue was finally led by a young climber named Jack Durrance.
Remember that name?
it will come back.
83 years later, the scientists had to do it the hard way.
On the 12th of October
2024, with a permit from the National Park Service,
a team of climbers began hauling
the equipment up the columns.
One of them was Katherine Vollinger, a climber who had already
carried a seismometer up Castleton Tower.
To make this work, she would have to climb Devil's Tower
twice in two days.
Once to set the instrument up, once to bring it down.
On the summit, they found a spot on the north side.
Bare rock.
They fixed the seismometer to the stone with putty,
then covered it with a bucket to keep the wind off.
The battery went under a tarp.
Down below, two identical instruments were waiting.
One sat on bedrock at the foot of the south wall.
The other sat on a boulder more than 600 feet away.
Three instruments, all listening at the same time.
If the summit heard something the ground did not,
then it could only be one thing. The tower
itself was moving. 21 hours later,
the climbers lifted the bucket off the summit. What it had
heard was waiting in the data.
When the team laid the three recordings side by side, the difference
jumped out immediately.
The two instruments on the ground heard the ordinary hum of the planet.
The one on the summit heard something more.
Steady and repeating.
The ground was not making it. The tower was.
In fact, there were two rhythms, almost on top of
each other. One at about 1.1 times every second.
The other at about 1.2. Both were the whole tower
swaying from its base to its summit.
One roughly east to west, the other roughly north to south.
Like a giant metronome ticking in two directions at once.
Why two? Because Devil's Tower is not
Not perfectly round.
From above, it is slightly slimmer from east to west
and slightly thicker from north to south,
so it sways at a slightly different speed in each direction.
And over those 21 hours, something odd
happened. The two rhythms kept trading places.
First one was stronger, then the other, back and
forth at random all night long.
Then there was a third motion, faster, about twice every second.
And this one was not a sway at all. It was a gentle twist.
The whole tower rotating a tiny amount around
its own center and back again.
The team was careful here.
They called this match tentative. The signal was faint.
But the pattern was exactly what their model predicted.
Two sways and a twist.
Jeff Moore compared it to something we build every day.
A skyscraper. Tall buildings sway in the wind in just the same way.
But he pointed out one big difference.
A skyscraper is mostly hollow steel.
It can sway enough to make the people inside feel sick.
Devil's Tower is solid rock, so its movements are tiny.
How tiny?
On a windy stretch, the summit moved about half a millionth of a meter,
less than a hundredth of the width of a single human hair.
When the air went calm, it was roughly 10 times smaller than that.
You could stand at the base and stare at the tower all day long
and never see it move. But it never
stops. That was the point Moore kept coming back to.
He said the tower is constantly bending and
twisting every second of every day.
When the wind blows harder, the shaking gets stronger.
And when the wind dies completely,
the motion still does not end, because the planet itself
keeps pushing. And there was one more signal
in the data that made this even stranger.
All three instruments picked up a slow, deep pulse.
Roughly one beep every six or seven seconds.
It was just as strong on the ground as on the summit.
It is called the ocean micro seism.
It comes from sea waves striking coastlines
and pressing against the seafloor.
That energy travels inland through the rock of the continent.
Now think about where this tower stands.
Wyoming, more than a thousand miles from the nearest ocean.
And yet the waves of distant seas are still arriving here,
still pressing on this rock.
Now do the arithmetic. About one sway every second.
60 a minute. Over three and a half thousand an hour.
Across a single year, that comes to something like 35 million sways.
Every single year,
without a break. But here is where
the result turned from fascinating to unsettling.
The team built a detailed digital copy of the tower from a laser scan.
They asked the computer how fast a tower that shape should ring,
and it matched almost perfectly.
1.1, 1.2, but only after they changed one number,
and that number told them something about what is going on inside.
To understand why it was
so strange, you first need to know what this tower actually is,
because it is not one rock.
Picture the tower the way most visitors see it.
One giant block of stone, solid, rising out of the pines
as if it had been carved from a single piece.
That is the picture on the postcards, and it is wrong.
Go back about 50 million years.
The Park Service puts the age at roughly that today.
Deep beneath what is now northeastern Wyoming,
a huge mass of molten rock pushed up from below and stopped.
Exactly how close it came to the surface is still argued over.
And slowly, it began to cool.
The rock it became has an unusual name, phonolite porphyry,
a gray stone scattered with pale crystals,
some of them more than half an inch long.
Crystals that size only grow when molten rock cools very slowly,
over a very long time.
And as it cooled, something else happened.
Hot rock takes up more space than cold rock,
so as this enormous mass lost its heat, it began to shrink.
And when rock shrinks, it cracks.
Not at random. The cracks spread through
the cooling mass in long straight lines
running from top to bottom, dividing it into columns.
Thousands of them.
Most have five or six sides, some have four,
some have seven, some run hundreds of feet tall.
Then, over millions of years, the softer rock that once buried all
of this was worn away by wind and rain and the Belfourch River,
and the columns were left standing alone in the open air.
So what you are really looking at is not one rock, it is a bundle.
An early Park Service description put it perfectly.
The columns stand bunched together like a bundle of matches,
and between every single column runs a crack from top to bottom.
Geologists call them joints.
From the trail, they look like neat dark lines,
like the grooves on a fluted pillar.
But each one is a real break in the stone,
a place where one column ends and the next begins.
So what holds it all together?
Not glue, not cement, mostly its own weight.
The columns are not perfectly upright.
They lean slightly inward toward the top,
a few degrees on the west side,
10 degrees or more on the east, each one pressing in against
its neighbors, like a crowd of people leaning
on each other to stay standing, and sometimes one of
them stops leaning. Walk the tower trail around the base
and you will cross a huge field of broken
boulders, some of them taller than a person.
Every one of those boulders came from the tower.
Pieces of Fallen Columns
Some geologists believe
the last really big column came down around 10,000 years ago,
but smaller pieces still fall.
The Park Service strongly recommends helmets
for anyone climbing the tower.
The reason it gives is simple, frequent rockfall.
And people do climb it, thousands every year,
somewhere between four and six thousand of them,
wedging their hands and feet
into those same cracks between the columns.
Meanwhile, more than half a million visitors walk
the trail around the base,
right beside that boulder field, looking up.
Which leaves one question nobody could answer
from the outside. From the trail,
the columns look locked tight, pressed together so hard you
could not slide a knife between them.
But is that really true deep inside the tower?
Or is it only true at the surface?
You cannot simply drill into the tower to find out.
More than 20 tribes hold this place sacred.
Many know it as Bear Lodge. And taking rock samples
here is tightly limited.
So for more than a century, the inside of the tower has been almost
impossible to examine directly.
But a seismometer does not need to see inside. It only needs to
listen. Because how fast something rings tells you how stiff it really
is. Think about a guitar string.
Tighten it and it rings high and fast.
Loosen it and the note drops.
The same rule works for almost anything that vibrates.
A stiff object rings quickly. A loose one rings slowly.
So, if you know exactly how big something is,
and how heavy it is, and how fast it rings,
you can work backwards.
You can calculate how stiff it really is.
That is exactly what the team did with Devil's Tower.
They already had the shape, a detailed laser scan of the whole tower.
They had a good estimate of the weight of the rock.
And now, thanks to the bucket on the summit, they had the ring.
About 1.1 times every second.
So they fed it all into their digital copy
and asked the computer one question.
How stiff does this tower have to be to sway at exactly that speed?
The answer came back as a single number.
Scientists measure stiffness on a scale called gigapascals.
To ring the way it really does,
the tower as a whole had to have a stiffness of about 8.
So the team went and got something to compare it with.
They took three small cores of rock,
each about an inch and a half across,
drilled from a boulder that had already fallen from the tower.
Then, in the laboratory, they loaded those cores
and measured how stiff the solid stone itself really was.
The cores came back at around 55.
The lowest was 48. The highest was 66.
Not one of them came anywhere even close to 8.
Read that again slowly. The rock the tower is
made of is around 55.
The tower built out of that rock behaves like 8. The scientists
put it plainly. The real stone
is about 7 times stiffer than the tower as a whole.
In other words, Devil's Tower behaves roughly
seven times softer than its own rock.
So where did all that stiffness go?
The answer is the thing hidden inside.
Remember the bundle of matches?
Remember the cracks between the columns?
A small core cut from one piece of solid stone has no cracks in it,
but the tower is full of them.
And the only way the numbers make sense
is if those cracks are not tight.
The joints between the columns are slightly open,
not just near the surface where you might expect weathering.
The study concluded they appear
to be opened up throughout the rock mass, even at depth.
Deep inside the tower where nobody has ever looked before.
Why would that be?
The authors suggest it may come down to the tower standing on its own.
Rock buried underground is squeezed from every side.
That pressure holds the cracks shut.
But a freestanding tower has nothing pressing in on it from the sides,
nothing holding the bundle tight. To see how unusual that is,
compare it with Utah.
When the same team measured sandstone arches the same way,
those arches came out between two
and five times softer than their solid rock. Devil's
Tower came out worse than all of them.
Now, in fairness, the scientists were careful.
This was one recording lasting 21 hours in a single season.
The lab tested just three cores,
and all three came from one fallen boulder.
The number 8 was worked out by fitting the model to the data,
not measured directly.
It is strong evidence, but it is not the final word.
Still, picture the bundle of matches one more time.
Only now the band around it has been loosened.
Every column is still standing,
every column just slightly free of the one beside it,
and the whole bundle flexing about once every second.
And on the south face of the tower,
there is one column where those open joints have already let go.
Remember Jack Durrance, the young climber
who led the rescue of the stranded parachutist in 1941?
Three years before that rescue, in 1938,
Durrance and his partner Harrison Butterworth
found their own way up the tower.
Their line became known as the Durrance Route.
Today, it is the easiest way to the summit,
and the most popular.
And the very first section of that route
goes straight up one particular column.
Climbers call it the Leaning Column.
Stand on the south side of the tower and look up,
and you can see it, about 200 feet above the base.
A column roughly 26 feet long, made of three stacked pieces,
each one about five feet across.
Together they weigh around 37 tons,
about 81,600 pounds, heavier than a fully loaded truck.
Now look closely at how it sits.
It is not standing straight on the column below it.
Its base is shifted about a foot to one side,
so instead of resting flat, it rests on the edge of
the column underneath, like a lever on a pivot.
It leans back against the tower at a slight angle,
and at the top, it touches its neighbor at just a single point.
For as long as anyone had been climbing it,
that column had seemed solid. It had not budged.
Then, in June 2005, climbers began reporting something new.
The column was moving. Park rangers went up and confirmed it.
That September, scientists from the
United States Geological Survey came to inspect it.
What they found was not reassuring. Right beneath
the spot where the column rests on that edge,
a flake of fresh rock had recently broken away.
Thin cracks were running down into the column below,
four to eight inches deep, and they looked new.
The weight of the column was pressing down
on a single narrow line of stone,
and that stone was starting to give.
They watched what happened when a climber moved at the top.
A quick shift of weight and the whole column began to rock,
about a fifth of an inch each way,
roughly twice every second.
80,000 pounds of rock rocking on an edge. The report concluded
that a climber could not push it over.
It would take far more force than any person can put out.
But it also warned that if more pieces keep breaking
from the edge underneath,
the column could become less and less stable until it topples.
So what would that look like?
The column would likely split into its three pieces as it fell.
They would bounce and gather speed down the face of the tower.
Fragments could hit the boulder field below at up to 75 miles an hour.
Pieces could bounce 200 feet or more and the boulder field they
would land in stretches about a thousand feet out from the tower.
toward the bench where the visitor center stands.
Anyone in that boulder field,
the report said, would be in extreme danger.
To make the point, they mentioned another place,
Sacred Falls in Hawaii,
where in 1999 a rockfall killed seven hikers.
So what can you do with a column like that?
Bolting it to the tower was ruled out, so was removing it.
Instead, the team sprayed paint across the place where it rests.
That way, any new break would show up as fresh, bare rock.
If new breaks appeared, they recommended thinking about closing
the route, and the ground below.
The honest truth is that nobody knows when it will fall.
The report said it may stay where it is for years, or even centuries.
And it is still there today, still on its edge,
still part of the most popular climb on the tower.
So now put the two discoveries side by side.
On their own, each finding sounds almost harmless.
A tower that sways less than the
width of a hair. A single column that has
been leaning for as long as anyone can remember.
But put them together
and the picture of Devil's Tower changes completely.
Here is what we now know. The tower is not one solid block.
It is a bundle of columns.
The cracks between those columns appear
to be slightly open all the way through, even deep inside
The whole bundle sways and twists about once every second,
something like 35 million times a year,
pushed by the Wyoming wind,
and by ocean waves breaking on coastlines more than a thousand miles
away. And 200 feet up the south face,
80,000 pounds of that rock is already resting on a single edge,
above a busy trail. That is not a frozen monument.
That is a structure in slow motion.
So why do scientists care so much about a movement nobody can see?
The short answer is earthquakes. Every tower has a natural rhythm,
and when the ground starts shaking near that rhythm, the tower can sway
far harder than the ground beneath it.
Moore and his colleagues have seen this before.
In their work on the Matterhorn,
they found that high peaks and ridges can amplify shaking.
Moore has pointed to the Haiti earthquake of 2010,
where rock on the ridges suffered
more damage than rock in the valleys.
That is why the Devil's Tower study matters.
The authors say this kind
of model could help assess damage caused by vibration,
and help predict which pieces might break loose in an earthquake.
Moore says the animations help show how
the tower might move if a big one ever struck,
and now we know it would be a bundle with open joints doing the moving.
There is a slower question too.
Years ago, Moore's team studied Rainbow Bridge in Utah,
a huge stone arch near Lake Powell.
They found that waves on the lake kept the arch vibrating
more strongly than it otherwise would,
and they suggested that constant tiny vibration
might, over a very long time, help tired cracks grow.
That was only ever a hypothesis,
and it was about a different rock,
but it is one reason scientists keep listening.
Now here's the part the headlines tend to leave out.
Jeff Moore himself does not think the tower
is in danger. He has said he knows of no risk from these movements,
and he is not even sure
there could be one. The motion is unimaginably small.
The volcanic activity that made this rock
ended a very long time ago,
and the tower has stood in the open air for millions of years.
Nothing in this study says it is about to fall.
So, what is the truly unsettling part?
It is not that the tower is collapsing,
it is that it was never as still as we believed.
For generations, people have looked at this rock
and seen the most permanent thing in
America.
In 1977, Hollywood landed an alien mothership on top of it,
because nothing seemed more
solid, more fixed, more eternal.
The instruments say the opposite.
The most permanent looking object in Wyoming
is the one that never stops moving, and perhaps that
would not surprise everyone.
More than 20 tribes hold this place sacred. Many know it as Bear Lodge.
For them, it has always been a living place rather than a dead stone.
Every June, the Park Service
asks climbers to stay off the tower voluntarily
so ceremonies can take place in peace.
Two very different ways of seeing the same rock,
and for once they do not seem so far apart.
Which brings us back to where all of this began,
to a bucket on a summit, and to what it heard.
So go back to that summit, a bucket, a little putty,
21 hours on bare rock. At first it looked like a routine measurement.
Now you know what it heard.
A tower swaying about once every second.
A tower that behaves seven times softer than the stone it is made of,
because the cracks running through it are not as tight as they look.
And 200 feet up the south face,
80,000 pounds of rock still resting on a single edge.
Every year, half a million people walk around the base of Devil's Tower
looking up at the most solid thing they have ever seen.
And the whole time the rock above them is moving.
If you've climbed it or walked that trail,
did it ever feel alive to you?
Tell us in the comments
because the next landmark we visit has been moving even longer.
