The speaker challenges the notion that 2026 will be the \"last normal year,\" arguing instead that 2016 was the actual turning point. He posits that the shift toward algorithmic feeds and mobile internet fundamentally altered human attention, trust in institutions, and our perception of reality, creating a \"dumpster fire\" effect that persists today.
Good morning, John.
So I've now seen several video essays and tweets
and YouTube thumbnails telling me that
2026 will be the last normal year.
Now, this does not surprise me for reasons
that we will get into, however, I also don't
think it's true.
First, of course, I don't think
that there have ever been any normal years.
Every time is an unprecedented time.
In my mind, the most normal year was around 1996,
but, like, of course it was.
I was 16 and if you were also 16 in 1996 and you're thinking, yeah, but
But, like, it really was the most normal year,
look, we can feel that way while recognizing
that everybody thinks that their teenage years were the good
and pure times before everything
got so complicated.
Though, I actually do not think that people
who were teenagers in, say, 2016, feel this
way.
In fact, I would like to make the case, though,
John, I'm sure that you will refute it,
that 2016 was, in fact,
The last normal year.
And look, we didn't even get all
the way through 2016 before it stopped being a normal year,
but we got most of the way through it.
Quick preface though, John.
I know that you're gonna say I'm wrong.
And in fact, I have pitched you this video idea
and you rolled your eyes at me.
But feel free to disagree, you'll be here on Tuesday.
But let us cast our minds back ten, yes, ten years to 2016.
You can see him clearly holding the boy between his legs.
There's a Vaporeon that's falling right there.
Back at it again with the white van.
That's a very surprising move.
But it was a mistake.
And minimizing job loss for fossil power plant workers.
And then, you know, Pizzagate.
And Donald Trump was elected president just days after my son was born.
It was weird.
And I remember we had a shirt at DFTBA that was,
like, a dumpster on fire with 2016 written
on it, because 2016 was the dumpster fire year.
David Bowie and Prince and Alan Rickman
and Muhammad Ali and Carrie Fisher and George
Michael all died.
Dumpster fire was the American Dialect Society's 2016 word of the year.
And I really do believe that the reason we thought 2016
was the worst year ever and ever
Every subsequent year was even worse,
is all because of a switch that flipped in 2016.
2016 was the first year
when online advertising outpaced TV ads in the US.
It was the first year when mobile internet
outpaced desktop internet worldwide.
2016 was the year that Twitter
and Instagram switched to algorithmic feeds, and in that
That same year.
Google published a little paper all about
how YouTube recommendations were now being
done by deep neural networks.
In 2015, the number of Americans over 65
who were online and on Facebook was 48%.
In 2016, it was 62%.
The last demographic to join the internet was piling on,
and they were experiencing
the feed.
In the beginning of 2016,
when things were relatively normal, mainstream news outlets'
top election content was by far outperforming misinformation.
After the election, the top-performing fake election stories
on Facebook from hoax sites
and hyper-partisan blogs were being viewed more
and shared more and commented on more
than top stories from major news outlets.
That study basically says the beginning of 2016 was pretty normal.
The end was pretty not normal.
And this also is not an American phenomenon.
It didn't happen in 2016 everywhere,
but as people poured onto the internet all over
over the world, and as feeds became algorithmic at the same time,
institutions lost attention
Lost attention, lost respect, lost trust,
and upstarts, myself included, in collaboration
with those algorithms,
warred with each other and existing systems of media to find new
ways to gather and hold attention.
And one of the best ways to do that is to make people scared
and to show them the bad
news.
And so just as a little callback to the beginning
of the video, I think that the reason
That I keep seeing things that are like 2016 is the last normal year
is because that's a great frame for how to capture someone's attention
and be like, what do you mean?
In what ways? I should watch this video. I am unsettled.
Perhaps there will be some safety on the other side of this click
or if I continue watching this TikTok.
Because the result of this change has been a new world.
And also, I think a new sort of human vibe toward the world.
New systems for granting power to marginalized people
and also those same new systems are
good at granting power to terrible, inhuman ideas.
But more than anything,
what we got was an explosion in innovation for new ways to hold
attention.
Which is just a thing that, like,
kinda happened, and I don't think we noticed.
And I think this is gonna be a little loopy,
but I think that there's two pieces of
Of why things have gotten worse since 2016.
One, our media environment is worse
and that is resulting in us making worse decisions.
I mean, also, like, there were just things that occurred.
Like, COVID was not caused.
By the algorithms.
It was perhaps made worse by the algorithms.
Certainly a pandemic in combination
with a media revolution has not been great for our
ability to trust in institutions.
But there's also the part where we experience the world as worse
because there is this very
intense competition for our attention.
And a really great way to hold someone's attention is moral outrage
or them feeling scared or
unsettled.
So that kind of content that makes you experience moral outrage,
that makes you unsettled, is
is just going to travel through the internet more easily
It's going to flow through the systems with less friction,
it's going to be more likely
to hit our eyeballs.
And from there, it seems likely
that those things would feed back into each other.
That if we are confronted more
and more with how terrible things and other people are,
we will have less trust in things and other people,
and that will result in...
In things being worse.
Like, there's great data showing
that when society loses trust in itself,
when people lose trust in each other,
trust in their government, things get worse.
And I think the last 10 years have been kind of a bad decade for trust.
I think it's really interesting
that it seems we're pretty aware of what's
happening with artificial intelligence.
We are walking into that revolution,
at least with our eyes open to the fact that it's happening,
even if we don't feel much agency.
And I think that might be in part
because we walked into the last revolution thinking it
Thinking it was going to be all about bottle flips and her.
Harambe and Pokemon Go.
But when machine learning algorithms were turned
on human attention, that, it just seemed
like a little thing, you know, just show me more stuff that I like.
But they don't always show you more stuff that you like.
Sometimes they show you more of whatever you will watch,
maybe because you're scared
or because you're angry.
Were there more celebrity deaths that year,
or were we just experiencing them in an entirely
new way?
Was 2016 a dumpster fire?
I mean, yeah, but not because Prince died.
2016 was a dumpster fire,
because we were entering a new world where anything that would
get watched would get made.
In the fullness of time, most news consumption would be feed-based.
That didn't happen in 2016,
but the switch had been flipped, and we simply had no idea.
And I think that most people watching
this will get this, but it's worth saying, our
attention is all we have.
And we already gave away a huge percentage
of it to machine learning algorithms ten years
ago, and we are living in an intensely different and,
I think, worse world because of it.
It's wild to me that we had no idea how big
of a deal this would be when saying it now
sounds so obvious.
AI controls what we see, you know?
That's what!
Not LLMs, though they are increasingly a part of the process.
But AI is in charge of whether you saw this YouTube thumbnail.
It's in charge of what's on your Threads feed,
or your Twitter feed, or your Facebook
feed, or your Instagram feed.
It decides what comes next when you're swiping.
There's this phrase, like, I built this for you,
Page Brick by Brick, this thing that
you say when, like, the feed gives you something
that's, like, perfect for you.
But hopefully we all know that that's an illusion.
We didn't build that For You page brick by brick.
To some extent, the For You page is building us.
We are made of and by the things we watch.
And it seems that when you give us opportunities
to let those recommendation systems be in charge,
the way that we do on short-form swipeable feeds, people prefer that.
Now, because of that change, we are in a media revolution,
which is never a particularly comfortable place to be.
And it feels to me like somewhere
in 2016 is where we entered that world.
Where we let the machine learning algorithms start to build us,
and thus start to build our world.
And we are now living in a world
that is constructed by us, and also by them.
And I'd also say that we still have a lot
of learning to do about how to live in that world.
John, I'll see you on Tuesday.
Two quick things.
One, the Focus Friends sale ends tomorrow, I think.
Or the day after tomorrow.
But also, importantly, you do not have
to pay us anything for Focus Friend to help you have
a little bit more control over your relationship with your phone.
I was just talking to the person who gave me pizza last night
at the pizza place about her Focus Friend, a little bean named Benson.
So check it out. It's called Focus Friend. There's a link
in the description. Lifetime Pro will never be this cheap again.
Also, too, to keep things simple and efficient and make inventory
make sense, the Awesome Socks Club is now open during just, like,
one or two windows a year, and the 2026 window is about to open.
It's opening on November 3rd, so four days from now.
So, if you're in the market for something lovely
to arrive in the mail, or you would
like to give that as a gift, and also, of course,
help fund the Maternal Center of Excellence
because everything a good Dutch store, all profit goes to charity.
And also, we have not raised prices
on the Awesome Socks Club since 2022, so technically
they're just getting cheaper.
Mark your calendars.
Okay.
That's, I think, it.