Witch's brew dessert recipe for a festive Halloween celebration

Bigger Bolder Baking with Gemma Stafford
2 followers
Oct 30, 2026
Hi Bold Bakers!
Halloween is a great time to get creative
with desserts and I have a lot of recipes
I want to share with you.
So I was excited when the folks
at Best Fiends reached out to me and asked me to create a
bonus video for you featuring
a Halloween themed dessert for their game.
Best Fiends is a free puzzle adventure game where you collect
and upgrade characters by
matching same colored blocks to defeat slugs.
My husband Kevin and I love playing, I'm a level 45
and Kevin is on 30 so he's got a bit of catching up to do.
For Halloween they have slugs
dressed up in costumes so it's a great time to start playing
and it's free to download.
And the slugs are back in their second game
in the trilogy, Best Fiends Forever,
an adventure clicker game you can now download for free.
Sticking with the theme of slugs and creepy
Creepy Crawlies, we are making a witch's brew. So let's get started.
So the base for our witches brew is tapioca.
It tastes really good once it's finished and
best of all it looks kind of like frog spawn,
it's all bubbly, it's perfect for Halloween.
Now I have tapioca here that I soaked overnight
and I'm just going to put it into a heavy
bottom saucepan. I don't recommend using quick cooking tapioca
for this recipe because it's
ground up too fine. Next ingredient is milk.
Now you can use dairy free milk, that will
work perfectly. And then lastly a pinch of salt
to add a little bit of flavor. Then what
Then what you want to do is turn the heat
Once it comes to a simmer,
on and just bring it to a simmer.
put on a lid and then turn the heat down to the very lowest
setting. Now what we're going to do is let this sit here for an hour
and very, very gently
cook away until it thickens up and it's really lovely.
Every few minutes you do want to go
in with your spatula and give it a bit of a stir
to make sure that the milk isn't sticking
to the bottom of the pot. The recipe for this pudding can
be found on my website, BiggerBolderBaking.com
and go there and check it out because I've got lots
of other Halloween desserts there too
Okay so it's been an hour and I want
to show you what the tapioca should look like.
It has plumped up and the tapioca has gone
transparent just like frog spawn so this is
what we want. So the next ingredient
in our pudding is egg yolks. Now these are used to
thicken it up and get it nice and stiff.
Now if you're vegetarian or you don't eat eggs you can
always use cornstarch or tapioca starch to thicken up your pudding.
Into the eggs we're going to add
in some sugar to sweeten up our pudding
and then just give that a quick whisk together. Now into
our egg yolks we're going to take some of our hot tapioca mix
and then add that in here.
And then just give it a mix around once you add it in.
This step is called tempering and what it does,
it introduces two ingredients that are
different temperature so they both become the same temperature.
It's really important when you're working with eggs.
Okay nice, these eggs have become a little bit warmer.
Now all you want to do is add them back
in to the rest of your tapioca and mix them all
together.
Now still over a very low heat,
I'm going to stand here and stir this for around 10
to 15 minutes until it thickens up.
So after a few minutes you'll notice
that your pudding has thickened up really well so I'm going
to go ahead and turn off the heat
and then we're going to add in our last few ingredients.
To give nice flavor to our tapioca pudding,
I'm going to add in some vanilla extract.
If you don't have it at home, you can always leave it out.
Now a witch's brew is always bubbling
when you see it, and that's where the tapioca
pudding comes in, but now we're going
to color it green, so I'm going to take a little
bit of food dye, and then just add in as much
as you want until you get your desired color.
Just look at that, it's kind of like sludgy and bubbly,
definitely what we're going
for for Halloween.
Now just like all of my big and bold desserts,
I want to make sure that this tastes great
too.
Oh yummy.
If you like puddings and rice pudding,
things like that, you are going to love this.
Now I'm going to set this aside
and we're going to start to build our Halloween dessert.
So I have a little cauldron but you can
also use any kind of black bowl.
And then I'm going to take some long pretzels,
just like these ones, and I'm going to place
them around the cauldron because these are going to be the logs.
So we've got our logs for our cauldron but now we need our fire.
So I've got a piping bag fitted with a star nozzle
and I've got some red food dye and
I'm just going to run it in lines inside the piping bag.
Now this is red but I'm also going to put orange
in here as well, this is gonna create
nice streaks.
Then into our piping bag I'm gonna put in some
buttercream that I colored with yellow
food dye.
So I'm gonna just push it down
and then we are going to pipe it in and around the logs.
Our next step is to add our frog spawn tapioca pudding.
I like to put it almost coming out over the edges
so it looks like it's like bubbling
up.
Now this is where it gets really fun,
we get to decorate it with lots of creepy crawly
ooey gooey bits for Halloween.
I'm going to place a skeleton in the middle.
And then I'm gonna put his limbs all around the bowl.
Next I have some gummy eyeballs,
you cannot have Halloween without gummy eyeballs.
Another must for Halloween are brains. Then of
course it would not be complete without adding
in some gummy slugs, just like in the game Best
Fiends. I'm gonna pop in a slug over here,
and then I'm gonna put another slug in over here.
Oh look at that, all you need was to make a pudding
and then have lots of ooey gooey bits
to put into your cauldron
and you end up with this amazing Halloween dessert.
Thanks again to Best Fiends for helping me
to bring you this video. The link for the
game is in the description box
and remember it is free to download. I'll see you back
here next week for more Bigger Bolder Baking.
