Workplace incivility costs employers billions as workers seek political neutrality

Fox - 5 DC
28 followers
Oct 29, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis discussion features Carolyn Johnson, president of the SHRM Center for Inclusion and Diversity, who examines the impact of political discourse and incivility in the workplace. The conversation highlights a significant gap between employees' desire for a neutral professional environment and the reality of increasing workplace tension and managerial inaction.
And as you know, talking politics can be fraught,
especially in the workplace.
So let's talk more about what we'll encounter and how we can
get around it and how we can coexist in the workplace better.
Carolyn Johnson is president of the SHRM
Center for Inclusion and Diversity.
She's up late with me tonight here on The Final Five.
Hi, Carolyn. Welcome.
Good evening. How are you?
I'm good. So, look, I know that they say what we
we were probably both raised to say you never discuss religion
and politics at the dinner table.
The workplace, especially over the last couple of years,
it has certainly changed.
It's evolved. And for a lot of people, it can be a very,
a very fraught situation when people want
to discuss politics around you when you're trying to get your job done.
This is very true. And I couldn't agree with more
and more with the changes that we're seeing from a research perspective
in the workplace, specifically as it relates to civility or incivility.
So I agree with you 100 percent.
You put out the Civility Index and explain what that is and how
you go about determining what what what entails the Civility Index.
Sure. So the Civility Index is a quarterly pulse
and we survey U.S. workers on their experience with how they're treated
and what they see happening potentially to others in the workplace.
And we started doing this because, you know,
going into next week around elections and around politics,
the impact on productivity that incivility has
is something that we needed to be able to put a number on.
And so our research found that due to incivility, your organizations
are losing about two point six billion dollars a day.
Right. And absenteeism and lost productivity as a result of incivility
and incivility defined or ways in which you could look at it are are
people being treated differently because of their political beliefs.
Or as you talked about at the top of this around
the dinner table, religious beliefs.
And then what is management or what are leaders doing
to ensure that the workplace is a place where folks can come,
feel respected, be respected and get their work done?
In terms of respect in the workplace, I think we've had these national
conversations time and time again over over the last several decades.
And we look at it, treating people with respect, with dignity,
making sure that they're free from harassment of all sorts.
But when it comes to politics,
you have gauged a number in the survey where people say
that they want their workplaces to stay politically neutral.
Yep, that's right. So let's talk about two numbers.
So just last month, Jim, 74 percent of workers saw
or experienced incivility just last month, while 87 percent
of them said they want their employers to remain neutral.
So this for the data that we're seeing is truly a manager gap.
And while we're sticking to the numbers, 35 percent of workers say
their managers ignore incivility and ignoring incivility can
be anything like, you know, not having the same consequences
for performers just because they are producing at a different level.
It can be silence or it can also be not modeling the behavior
that should, quite frankly, be part of your code of conduct.
So we're hearing we're seeing one thing happen to folks.
We're hearing them say that they're OK having
a workplace where politics are not discussed.
But that's not what's actually happening.
It also comes down to a generational gap,
too, between younger and older workers.
Yes, it does. And when we talk about the generational differences,
For the first time, generational differences was talked about
as a bigger issue in the workplace than politics to the tune of 37.
