CMI is proprietary index from the Cromford report. It measures supply and demand and is a forward-looking indicator. A number over 100 is considered favorable to sellers. 80 shifts to a buyers market where the negotiating power belongs to the buyer. 👉👉Get a zip code market report: https://rickhelps.barrettre.com/data-store
Rick McHone
cell:602-361-9834 Email:[email protected] ✅Website: https//www.Rickhelps.com Realtor Lic# SA645991000 Barrett Real Estate Lic LC701376000 ✔️Broker: Barrett Real Estate Lic LC701376000
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The real estate market has shifted significantly toward a buyer's market following recent interest rate hikes. Data from the Cromford Market Index (CMI) shows a widespread decline in seller favorability across various cities, with a sharp drop in contracts and an increase in price cuts, signaling a slow and challenging period for sellers heading into the winter.
Welcome, welcome to the Birdcastle Real Estate Show.
And the numbers are out for the first week of October.
And boy, what a difference does it make when rates go up.
Let me show you what I'm talking about here.
Those of you that know about the Cromford Market Index
that we use here, you can see,
especially you can see better
when I use my handy-dandy magnifying glass, right here.
Look at Scottsdale.
The CMI, anything over 100 is considered a seller's market.
This is a measurement of supply and demand.
And it's red, they're all red, and it went down by 1%.
Not bad.
But look at Paradise Valley and Fountain Hills.
They're 146, 136, they went down 30%.
Now, most of that, if not all of it,
is because it's such a small sampling size.
But if you continue to look,
you see that Chandler went down 11.
Also see Cave Creek went down six.
Down across the board here,
let me get rid of this handy-dandy magnifying glass.
There we go.
All across the board, you can see that everybody was down.
Tempe down 20%, Surprise down 15%.
The average CMI is down 11.2 from last month.
This is much less favorable for sellers
than the last week's 7.8% decline.
So what does that mean?
Well, I'm looking at my seven-day moving average
and it's down to 2,200 contracts.
I don't see those kind of numbers
until you start getting into holiday weeks.
So it has grinded to a halt.
We're sitting here at about almost 7 3⁄4 as of today.
And if you look here,
another measurement of supply and demand that I really like,
and again, I'm gonna pull out my magnifying glass,
is I'm gonna show you right here.
They've really messed this thing up.
See how the blue line's going up
and the red line's going down?
The blue line is supply.
The red line is contracts.
The wider that gap gets,
the more we're going to see pricing pressure
on the downside.
We're not seeing a lot of that yet.
The median prices are kind of hanging on for the moment,
down maybe single digit, and I'll show you that
in one of our last slides here.
Here's one that really puts the month into perspective.
What happened in September with this rate hike?
Look at the Cromford Market Index.
This is a forward-looking indicator.
Down, down, down.
It's way down here in total at 74.9,
indicating not a balanced market, but a buyer's market.
So it's tougher for sellers.
Now, it varies by city, but this is our overall market,
and it is rough, my friends.
Now, if you look here at the Cromford Market Index
on a different type of chart,
with the blue line being balanced,
we're down again, way into the buyer's market.
Check here for the number of price changes.
Well, that's where it's showing up, folks.
Look at the number of price cuts that are coming up.
These are gonna increase the closer
that we get to the holidays.
Now, I don't do a whole lot of predicting
because I can't think of any agency,
Zillow, Redfin, Rocket, they've all been wrong.
Title companies, real estate agents,
remember four to six rate cuts this year?
Spring was gonna be a hot market.
It's hot, it's hot outside, but it ain't hot sales-wise,
not at 2,200 contracts a week.
It's pretty dismal, pretty slow.
We've kind of got three buckets of buyers.
One is buyers that can afford it.
Two is buyers that just can't afford it,
and they're waiting.
And three that just say, I give up, I'm gonna rent,
I give up.
And so the ones that are supporting the market
are the ones that can't afford it,
and right now, they're negotiating aggressively
and chasing deals.
Remember in 2010, nobody wanted to buy.
They go, this is terrible, don't buy real estate.
Well, the people that can buy right now
are going out there and saying,
okay, well, here's what I'm offering,
and here's what I would like on concessions,
and buyers are, sellers are cutting their asking price.
What's gonna happen is that we're gonna have
a whole lot of cancellations and expires
in November and December.
People are saying, I'm out.
I'm just gonna wait, and wait till the war's over,
gonna wait till gas prices come down,
hopefully interest rates come down,
and then maybe things will pick up.
Now, if interest rates get down in the low sixes,
obviously, things will pick up
because prices have come down,
but not enough for the majority of you folks out there,
and I've shared it before, but here's where we're at today
with our interest rates.
7.56% saying they're having a positive day.
In other words, the rate's coming down a little bit,
not by much, but that's a big bite
when we were sitting around 6.5.
Here is pending listings, and you can see
that they really dropped off last week.
They were following last year week by week,
like it was planned that way,
and all of a sudden now, boom, done.
This is the number I wanted to show you here.
See this?
This is the percentage of,
I'll creep this up here a little bit,
get rid of my magnifying glass for just a moment,
come up here and see.
This is annual change in monthly median sales price,
and if we look at today, we see this.
It's up.
That little green line you see there is up.
Why isn't it down?
Monthly median.
That means price is falling in the middle.
It's not down.
It was down at 1.4%, 1.1.
Way back here, it was down 46.3.
We all know why.
That was 2008, 2009, but right now, it's up.
Kind of odd, huh?
Kind of odd to figure out why that's going on.
I see a lot of waiting going on,
and another thing, and I don't make a lot of predictions,
but here's what I'm also reading and seeing,
and that is that builders have,
they're just gonna clear out their spec homes right now,
and they're only gonna do homes
that you ask them to build.
They're gonna pair back on their spec homes.
They're gonna have some fire sales here.
You can get homes like 3.5% mortgage there.
They're trying to get up underneath this inventory,
and there's not a whole lot of new permits coming out.
What does this do?
We're still building apartment complexes,
but that's kind of stopped
because the financing's been tough.
Most of those things reset after five years of the lending.
Renters are gonna rent.
There isn't gonna be enough supply
because everybody's backing out of the home buying process.
Rent's not gonna go down, folks.
It's gonna continue to go up,
so we're really in kind of a catch-22 situation,
and believe me, I know where you're at.
If you're a buyer, you want these prices to come down,
and I know if you're a seller,
you wanna try and capture as much as you can.
Don't be discouraged in some of these cities.
You can get your asking price
if your asking price is correct.
You can't price what it was three months ago.
You're gonna have to be aggressive,
and you're gonna have to realize
that that equity that you thought you had,
that price that you thought you had is no longer there.
It doesn't mean you're upside down.
You hear comments like, well, I don't wanna give it away.
Well, you're not giving it away
if you're up by $200,000 or $300,000,
so you just kind of have to swallow your pride a little bit
and realize that you can sell your home.
I've seen us get offers in a day, two days.
Someone in Sun Lakes get an offer in two days,
and they were asking $7.99.
I didn't think it would happen,
but lo and behold, they got it done,
so the market can be busy if you price it correctly.
Inventory's jumping up.
I need to take a peek at that and show you where we're at,
but it's climbing, but it's not climbing yet
by leaps and bounds.
Bear with me while I pull this up.
I'm gonna see here, Topic Active Listings.
Here we go.
Here's the weekly chart.
See, they haven't gone up much,
gone up just a little,
but I think they're gonna continue this climb.
And then as the holidays come,
we're gonna take our seasonal dip.
What's gonna happen in January?
I don't know.
All depends on where rates are.
All depends on where gas prices are.
So this is a very interesting turn of events.
Many of you have said this was coming,
but what you've said was we were gonna crash.
I'm not seeing a crash today.
Will it crash next week, next month?
I don't know.
I'm only showing you what I see today.
Now you'll see in the comments,
people are gonna say,
ah, Rick, you're just a FOMO.
You're just a cheerleader trying to sell out.
I'm just sharing the numbers with you folks.
And September was a bad month.
Everything turned.
Cromford Market Index is a forward-looking indicator.
This is gonna be a very tough fall
and a very tough winter if you're a seller,
because you're not gonna get that price
that you wish you could get.
Buyers, negotiating is on your side.
So go out, see what you can do,
or sit back and wait.
Now if you wait till everybody gets back in,
you're gonna have some competition.
So I don't really know where this is gonna land,
but if you wanna see what's going on in your zip code,
I've got that QR code up there on the top
and the link down bottom.
I'll send you a zip code report.
I was gone last week,
so a couple of people got it a little late.
Actually got it on Tuesday.
But if you have any questions, as always,
shoot me an email at rickatrickhealths.com.
Take care.