Rock Tumbling Basics - Comparing 3 Final Polishes
5 Video Views·Oct 6, 2026
Have you ever wondered which type of final polish is the best? In the video I compare aluminum oxide, cerium oxide, and tin oxide in order to see which one creates the best shine.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video demonstrates a comparative experiment to determine the effectiveness of three different polishing agents—aluminum oxide, cerium oxide, and tin oxide—on various types of gemstones. By using a consistent preparation process and a unique reflection test, the creator evaluates whether the higher cost of premium polishes results in a noticeably superior finish.
Hello fellow rock tumblers. I think this will be a fun and informative video. What you see before you
Brazil agate, polychrome jasper, chevron amethyst, and Mozambique agate. So I have three examples
of each. What I'm going to do in this video is I'm going to get all of these tumbling like I
normally do. They're all going to go into the 60-90 grit for several weeks until they get nicely
rounded and smooth, all the flaws removed. And then I will start the normal eight-day
four-stage polishing cycle that I use in the vibratory tumbler. They'll go through the 220
grit silicon carbide, the 600 grit silicon carbide, the 1500 grit silicon carbide. But at that point
I'm going to stop and separate them like you see here. One row in the one example of each type
will go to aluminum oxide polish, one row will go to cerium oxide polish, and one row will go to
tin oxide polish. That way when it's all said and done we'll be able to see with very similar rocks
what difference it makes using those different types of vinyl polish. I think it should be
very interesting. I'm curious myself. I have no idea how this will turn out.
So stick around and let's see how it works. Our rocks are finally finished with the core stage.
Thank goodness, right? They're ready to move on so we can begin this polishing experiment. I'll
go ahead and get these started in the vibratory tumbler and go through the first three stages
and then we'll check them out again at that point. We'll take a closer look before we start this
final polish experiment. Okay, the rocks are finished with the 1500 grit. They went through
the 220, then the 600, then the 1500, which means these surfaces are ready for the final polish.
What I'm going to do now is take this bottom row and run it through the aluminum oxide polish,
take this middle row run it through the cerium oxide polish, and take this top row and run it
through the tin oxide polish. When it's all done we'll compare them. We'll see if there's really
a difference. Here you see the rocks after two days in the vibratory tumbler with the aluminum
oxide. I get all my grits from Kingsley North and I believe the aluminum oxide that I use is
1 micron. It sells for I think it's around $7 a pound. And here you can see the stones in the
cerium oxide. This I believe sells for around I think $17 a pound if memory serves. Anyway,
so the cerium oxide is definitely a little more expensive than the aluminum oxide.
And now you can see the rocks in the tin oxide polish. This one I believe was around $25 a pound.
It's definitely the most expensive of the three polishes. I also want to point out that I kept
reusing the other rocks in this batch over and over again you know to keep the load the same
in the tumbler. So these rocks these other rocks have been polished now three different times.
Well well well we're finished with this polishing experiment. Right off the top of the bat,
I cannot say for sure that I can see much of a difference just looking at them here on this table
under this light. They all have a nice shine. What I'm going to do is compare them individually
and we'll take a closer look. I'm going to try to come up with a way to make this a little more
objective and we'll see if with that we can see perhaps a slight change in the shine between the
different polishes. Let's begin with the Brazil agates. Can you see a difference between the
aluminum oxide, the cerium oxide, or the tin oxide? I don't see anything obvious but I have
a way of checking the reflection. What I have with me, let me show you, these are what are called
line pair phantoms. You see they're these very fine fine cuts in this piece of lead. We use this
in the x-ray industry to determine the resolution of the system. What I thought I would try is to
see what the reflection looks like and if maybe we can judge that. Let's see. When we look at this
one for example, can we really make out that fine, I think it's the six there, this one right here,
that's the finest one, six line pair per centimeter. Can we make out in this reflection with the light
just right? Can we see? Yeah, it looks like we can see that. Okay, that's the aluminum oxide polish
on a Brazil agate. How's it look with the cerium oxide? Let's see. Does it look better? Worse? What?
Let's find a good spot to reflect here. There we go.
What do you think? It looks pretty clear to me. I can see that.
I believe I'm able to see that delineation between those fine slits.
Maybe even a little bit better. I'll let you be the judge.
Okay, so that's the cerium oxide polish. Let's look at the tin oxide polish
on this Brazil agate. Let's find a good spot to reflect here.
This is tricky to hold this the way I want to.
That's not very good. Let's see.
Oh, there we go.
How does that look? How does that reflection look? Are you able to make that out any better?
That even looks clearer to me. I gotta say with this little test, the tin oxide seems to have the
best reflection. But again, you be your own judge. But just to my eye, looking through this phone,
I think that one's a little bit sharper. Let's go back to the cerium oxide.
Cerium looks pretty good too.
So we're looking again for that delineation between those fine lines there.
And once again, the aluminum oxide. Let's see that one. I know it's not a fair comparison.
These rocks are different colors. That actually looks really good too.
They all look pretty darn good, and I think I can see the reflection in each one of them.
Just as clear as can be. Well, that's a pretty good reflection. Geez, now I'm thinking the
aluminum oxide might be the best. I don't know. I thought it was the tin oxide. I can't decide.
Okay, now let's look at the polychrome jasper. Here's the aluminum oxide. Looks pretty good.
Cerium oxide.
Also looks pretty good. And finally, the tin oxide. I gotta say, I think the tin oxide looks
the best of these three, just with the naked eye. Let's try that reflection test again.
Okay, so here's the reflection. Looking for that six again.
Don't really have a good angle here.
Okay, there we go. Clearly not as smooth as the Brazil agate.
I see some more distortion in there. Not bad. Now let's check the cerium oxide.
Oh, I think that just comes off much brighter.
What do you think? I think it's a brighter polish and sharper, I think.
And finally, the tin oxide. I'm trying to compare apples to apples here. It's very difficult, but
there's the resolution part. Looks pretty good. Yeah, that looks, hmm, it's between the tin and
the cerium, in my opinion. What do you think? Okay, now let's check out the chevron amethyst.
It's the aluminum oxide. Oh, it looks pretty good. The cerium oxide. Yeah, not a bad shine.
And finally, the tin oxide. Well, I gotta say, again, the tin oxide seems to have better eye
appeal, just with the naked eye. That's what I'm seeing. Let's try that reflection. Okay,
let's see if we can get this to reflect. Let's see, there we go. This is going to be tricky.
This may not work with this. Yeah, you can see it in there, but it's difficult to make it out
with all the different structures within this amethyst. You can sort of see through there.
That's the aluminum oxide. Let's check the cerium. Let me see if it's any better.
Yeah, it's the same sort of deal. It's tough to use this reflection test with this amethyst.
Now let's try the tin oxide.
That came right up. You see the lines in there on the six.
I think in this case, the tin oxide does the best job with the amethyst.
Of the three we've looked at so far, the three different stones, I think the amethyst
shows the greatest distinction in the polishing. What do you think?
And finally, we'll look at this Mozambique agate. Once again, with just the naked eye,
it's hard to really see much of a difference. They all look really good. Let's try that
reflection test. Once again, we're looking for that reflection. There's the six line pair.
You're able to make out those lines there. I think I can see them
pretty clearly. So that's the aluminum oxide. Aluminum oxide. This is a beautiful stone,
by the way. I like the way this one turned out. Here's the cerium oxide. How does that one look?
Okay, I can see it. And there we go. Oh yeah, so you can clearly see the
individual lines within that six line pair. So that's a good reflection.
Now for the tin oxide. Oh sure, no problem.
Look at the other side here. It's a little bit easier when it's a darker finish on the stone.
Oh yeah, that looks fine to me. What do you think? I would say with the Mozambique,
the cerium and the tin look a little bit better than the aluminum, but that's just my opinion.
You can decide for yourself. So there you have it. That is our little polish experiment.
I guess if I had to pick one, I would say that the tin oxide does the best job overall,
but it's so close. You're gonna get a good shine with any of these. You might as well save some
money and stick with the aluminum oxide. Maybe if it's something critical, you're in a contest or
something like that, you might want to go with the tin oxide or the cerium. But as you can see
from my little reflection test, they're all really good at polishing a rock. Thanks so much
for watching this video. I hope you enjoyed it. I hope you learned something. Be sure and check
my other videos for more like this.

