Xi Jinping leaves the United States—and Taiwan’s first new F-16Vs in more than three decades begin their final journey home. At almost the same time, Taiwan’s Coast Guard uses water cannons to force a Chinese fishing vessel out of restricted waters near Dongsha Island. Were these simply separate events, or signs of a more assertive Taiwan after the Trump-Xi summit? We look at the confrontation at sea, the arrival of Taiwan’s new F-16V fighters, and the changing balance across the Taiwan Strait.
On October 1st, China's National Day, something happened near Taiwan that immediately blew up
across the Chinese-speaking internet. Taiwan's Coast Guard and Chinese fishing vessels had a
direct confrontation, and this time, Taiwan fought back. Here's what happened. Taiwan's Coast Guard
discovered two Chinese fishing boats near Dongsha Island, also known as the Prata Island. Now,
there were about 27 nautical miles east of the island and roughly eight miles inside Taiwan's
restricted waters. And according to Taiwan's Coast Guard, both vessels had dropped anchor
and were illegally fishing inside the restricted zone. So Taiwan's Coast Guard vessel called
Yunlin immediately issued an audio warning, ordering both boats to leave. And so one complied,
one left, but the other one called Jinsha refused. After three warnings, when unanswered,
the Taiwan Coast Guard vessel Yunlin moved to about 200 meters away and fired its water cannon
into the air for roughly 30 seconds. Now, the remaining Chinese vessel still did not move.
So the Yunlin moved closer. Then what the Taiwanese Coast Guard did was they moved closer
and directed the high pressure water cannon at the Chinese vessel, at the vessel's wheelhouse for
about 90 seconds. And then the Taiwanese said the action followed its standard procedures for low
lethality weapons, and that it deliberately avoided crew members standing on deck. And then
that was when the Chinese fishing boat finally began to leave. But shortly after, the vessel
lost power and became disabled. Taiwan then sent personnel aboard and made sure that the crew was
safe. And the Taiwanese even provided 35 hot meals that evening to the Chinese crew, and later towed
the Chinese vessel outside the restricted area. And then at 6 o'clock, 6.15 the next morning,
it was handed over to the Chinese work boat or a Chinese work boat. So why does this incident
matter? Well, it matters not simply because Taiwan used a water cannon. The bigger issue is that
Taiwan moved from verbal warning to physical enforcement. This is the first time Taiwan used
water cannons to enforce or to force Chinese fishing boats or quasi-Chinese fishing boats
out of Taiwan's territorial waters. Dongsha Island sits far out in the South China Sea
and is much more exposed than waters immediately around Taiwan proper. The surrounding area has
also become a frequent point of friction. So from January through August this year,
Taiwan recorded 411 cases involving Chinese fishing boats or Coast Guard vessels entering
restricted waters around the island for fishing or other activities. That is more than 50 incidents
a month. So this was not an isolated case. And that matters because gray zone pressure often
works through repetition. You enter once, then again, then again. Each time you watch how the
other side responds. If there are only warnings and no consequences, your presence gradually
becomes normalized. The line begins to move. This time, Taiwan showed that repeated incursions are
met with consequences. But the response was also carefully calibrated. So someone might ask,
well, what if these are indeed fishing vessels? Well, we cannot prove from public information that
these fishing boats are not part of an organized maritime militia operation. But Chinese vessels
repeatedly enter sensitive waters ignoring warnings and test enforcement limits. And
this type of vessels don't behave like ordinary commercial fishing boats because ordinary Chinese
fishermen dare not create a political or diplomatic confrontation here around Taiwan.
And it's known that Beijing has been using these civilian or quasi-civilian vessels as part of its
gray zone strategy to probe boundaries, to create pressure, and to test how far the other side is
willing to go without crossing into open military conflict. Now here's an interesting detail.
After the Chinese vessel Jinsha lost power, the second one, the one that initially refused to
leave. So after it lost power, its crew members posted distress messages on Chinese social media
accusing Taiwan of attacking them. Interestingly, those messages were then quickly deleted.
And that raised an obvious question. If Beijing insists these waters are open to Chinese fishermen,
why suppress the story when one of its own vessels actually was asking for help?
Well, gray zone tactics work best when things remain ambiguous. Once an incident becomes too
public, people start asking uncomfortable questions. Who sent the vessel there? Why did
it refuse repeated orders to leave? Was it simply fishing? And why did Beijing suddenly become so
reluctant to talk about it? So the real significance of this incident was not
the water cannon itself. It was that Taiwan began to demonstrate willingness to physically enforce
a boundary that Chinese vessels have repeatedly tested. And the timing is sensitive. It's
immediately after the Xi Jinping-Donald Trump summit. It also came amid a broader effort by
Taiwan to strengthen the Coast Guard as part of its response to Chinese pressure. Just one day
earlier, Taiwan had reportedly transferred a senior naval commander into the Coast Guard
to improve coordination and strengthen what is increasingly being treated as a kind of second
navy. So that's development number one from Taiwan. Now development number two from Taiwan
came at the same time. And this time, Taiwan received a message from the United States.
Because while Taiwan was becoming more assertive at sea, its military capability in the air was
also getting a boost. On October 2nd, the first two newly built F-16Vs or F-16V fighter jets
purchased by Taiwan arrived at an airbase in Taichung. And the aircraft are the first two
from a total order of 66 new F-16Vs. They originally departed from Texas on August 17th,
stopped in Hawaii, and remained there for nearly a month and a half. And on October 1st,
they finally moved from Hawaii to Guam. And then from Guam, they continued toward Taiwan.
The aircraft were still being flown by American pilots during the delivery flight and were
formally handed over to Taiwan after landing. The remaining 64 aircraft are still being produced in
the US. And Taiwan's defense minister, Wellington Koo, said in an interview that more are expected
to arrive later this year, although the exact schedule still needs to be coordinated with
Washington. This purchase is part of Taiwan's Phoenix Soaring project. It was approved by the
State Department in August 2019 during Trump's first term. The package, including 66 latest
generation of F-16 aircraft, along with parts, equipment, training, and support, and total value
is roughly US$8 billion. Historically, this is important because the last time
the United States sold Taiwan a large batch of newly built F-16s was in 1992. So this is Taiwan's
first major acquisition of newly manufactured F-16s in more than three decades. Taiwan had
originally wanted to buy the F-35Bs, largely because of its short takeoff and vertical
landing capability, but Washington did not approve an F-35B sale. Instead, Taiwan received the newest
version of the F-16. Now there's also an interesting political detail about the timing.
The first aircraft had been expected to reach Taiwan earlier, but the program was delayed
by a production line relocation, supply chain issues, and software problems. These two fighter
jets had remained in Hawaii for more than a month, right before the September summit between Xi
Jinping and Donald Trump. And then shortly after Xi Jinping left the US, the aircraft resumed their
journey from Hawaii to Guam, and then from Guam to Taiwan. Whether that timing was deliberately
political is something we cannot establish from public information, but the optics are hard to
miss. Xi Jinping leaves, the F-16Vs arrive. And almost at the same time, Taiwan has just used
a water cannon to drive two Chinese vessels out of restricted waters near Dongsha Island.
Taken together, the two events send different messages, but they point in the same direction.
At sea, Taiwan is showing a greater willingness to enforce its own
lines. And in the air, its ability to defend those lines is continuing to grow.