Laura the Biologist and Father Fish discuss the contents of water in the aquarium. The difference between water and what is in the water is an exciting insight. Their conclusion, "Don't throw the baby out with the bath!" Do not get rid of water filled with beneficial material. Chapters 0:00 What's in the Water? 2:20 Nitrates are Non-Issue 5:40 Why Nitrites increase? 6:28 Water becomes a Solution 11:58 Nature comes through your front door! 12:59 Conclusion 13:47 Visit Discord and Website
THE FATHER FISH SHOAL on Discord is a wonderful way to meet and make new fishy friends as well as get the help you need. Join us at Father Fish Server an Checkout our store! You can buy plants, soil supplement, & more: https://father-fish-aquarium.myshopify.com/
24/7 live on Discord: https://discord.gg/ZDADR5KnQu This is a wonderful way to meet and make new fishy friends as well as get the help you need. Join us at Father Fish Server on DISCORD!
All clips used in the video are for representation or visual beauty and there's intention of maligning anyone. We always use clips contributed to us directly on discord or clips released under the Creative Commons license on YouTube or other platforms.
All footage is used for illustration purpose only.
Hello! Come right on in. You're at Father Fish.
Water. We're talking about what's in the water.
I've been struggling with the difference between water and what's in water.
Yeah.
Because water is... water is two gases that combine somehow to form something that's not a gas.
However in the world that happens.
Hydrogen and oxygen can exist as a gas, as a liquid, and as a solid like anything else.
Same as water itself can exist as a gas, a liquid, and a solid.
So, you know, it's really just bonding of the atoms that creates a molecule of water.
Is it then legitimate to distinguish, as I said, between water and what's in the water?
Yeah, I think so.
You know, for example, with the ammonia, let's say ammonia in your fish tank,
I don't think the water is like per se bonded to the ammonia molecules.
Okay.
You know, for example, the ammonia is separate from the water.
This we can filter it out.
What's in the water is not changing the water molecule to another compound.
In theory, no, I wouldn't think so.
I would not expect that that's happening on, you know, in your fish tank.
Otherwise, you wouldn't have water in there.
You would have something else entirely.
Exactly.
Right.
Okay.
But again, I'm speaking off the top of my head, not having, you know, like a major chemistry
background.
So this is important though, because people change the water in their tank because they
believe something is wrong with the water.
I think, you know, they're thinking that you have to change the water in order to remove,
you know, just using that example, ammonia.
Right.
When we know that we can add floating plants.
And that gets rid of the ammonia.
So the issue is then to deal not with the water.
Yeah, you need to deal deep.
And everything else.
Deal with what's in the water.
While we're on that, is that comparable to nitrates in the water?
Nitrates?
So it's nitrogen and oxygen.
So it's bonding oxygen.
And it's soluble in water.
So it can form a solution in water.
So it's not bonding to the water, but it's able to form a solution.
Right.
It's not bonding to the water.
It is in the water.
Yeah.
So Stephen, the biologist, his laboratory researched specifically the levels at which
nitrates had a negative impact on fish.
They discovered that while there were some fish that were affected at a level of 450 ppm,
it wasn't until it reached 500 ppm nitrate that there was any distinguishable effect on fish.
Yeah.
Now, they had to create that 500 ppm in a laboratory environment.
Ostensibly, it cannot exist in a natural environment because it would be such an
attractant to all forms of algae that the algae would expand when it hit the water and draw it
out.
So it would prevent the buildup to ever reach that level.
Yeah, that's interesting.
So basically, you almost couldn't get to that point.
There was like almost a natural check in place.
Yeah, exactly.
So the issue of nitrate being a problem, you know, this has been taught for years to the
point where everybody believes it.
Everybody believes that nitrates are dangerous, and they're frankly not.
Yeah, at least not under normal conditions.
I mean, I would assume under some kind of bizarre conditions, maybe you could get nitrate
that would be too high.
But the point is, you'd probably have to work at it.
Yeah, probably if the temperature were 200 degrees or something.
I mean, who knows?
At which point you would have foiled fish anyhow.
Right, exactly.
The nitrates would be the least of your problems.
Really.
It's an example of a...
I don't even know what to call it.
It's something beyond false.
It's a myth.
It's an alternative reality that's used to sell product.
And I don't think it's that deliberate.
I think it's simply that there has not been a real understanding of the nature of nitrates
in order not to be able to be afraid of them.
Yeah, I would say in a planted tank, I mean, based off what you just said, I don't think
you would have to worry about nitrates at all.
The non-issue.
Yeah.
If anything, they're a nutrient for plants.
Yeah, that's what actually...
The higher the nitrates, the more plants you can have in your tank.
The more plants you can have in your tank, the more fish you can have in your tank.
I know nitrites can get to be a problem potentially, but I don't know what the condition really
is.
That's true.
But even with nitrites, if nitrates are going up, it's because the nitrifying bacteria are
not there in adequate quantity, which means either there is a pH that's too low for the
bacteria to be active, or like 6.0 or below, or there's something rotten in the state of
Denmark.
I mean, there's something decaying in the tank that's creating such a tremendous amount
of ammonia that the bacteria are not keeping up with it.
Are there organic material substances that occur, that develop, that mature, that are
created in the water that are beneficial to the environment of fish and plants and
microbiology?
Does the tank, as it matures, if we think in terms of process, as it's changing and
modifying continuously...
If you were talking about, like if we're looking at that tank sitting next to you right
now, I would expect, and again, being more of a soil person than a water person by training,
I would expect that there would be, like for example, plant exudates in that water, for
example.
Like secondary metabolites and things similar to...
Like if you think of soil as a substrate, you get those secondary metabolites basically
that occur and leach out into the soil.
I would expect that you also can think of water as kind of being a semi-substrate.
It's certainly a substrate if we're talking about, like say, floating plants.
It's a medium.
You know, it's their substrate.
Yeah, it's a medium.
And so I would expect that, yeah, there would be things like chemicals and stuff that the
plants are producing that are getting out there into the water, for instance.
Biological.
And certainly chemicals that are being produced by any fungi and bacteria in the water.
One of the things that impressed me about the research that you guys are doing is when
I discovered that plants release signals into the soil to cause the soil to create the very
compound they need in order to do what they're trying to do.
Yeah, they can influence...
I mean, they influence everything around them.
It's crazy.
Let me just kind of pull this together.
Yeah, yeah.
The water contains the influence of everything that's in it.
Of the plants, the fish, the dirt, the organics, the everything, the minerals, all of it.
To a greater or lesser degree, all of those things are soluble in one way or another in
the water.
But soluble, that simply means they're reduced to their smallest component in order to be
able to remain in that medium.
In chemistry, solubility is the ability of a substance, the solute, to form a solution
with another substance, the solvent.
Water is a solvent.
It's like the classic solvent.
It does not change in the process of doing that, of being a solvent.
If that's the case, then doesn't that mean that the older the water is,
the more it is in...
I don't want to use a value-laden word here, but it's kind of unavoidable in harmony with
what's living in it.
I think that would be a good way of wording it.
I don't even know that it's intrinsic to the water itself, but you have so many beneficial
things as well as detrimental things in the water.
People, when they change the water, they're looking to get rid of the detrimental solutes
The dirt on the bottom, or the urine from the fish, or the dead leaves.
But the problem is that when you change that, you're also getting rid of the beneficial
solutes, the solutes that are beneficial to your system, as well as the detrimental solutes,
like let's say the excessive levels of nitrate, trite, or whatever.
The detrimental things are beneficial anyway.
They simply are at a stage in the process of changing, of their progressing through
the biochemical system that's working in the tank.
It's not so much that they're detrimental, it's that they're out of balance.
They're out of whack.
There's too much of it in the solvent.
Or they're at a given stage in that process.
So when people are changing the water, they're looking to get rid of undesirable solutes.
And what are they actually doing?
They're getting rid of both beneficial and the undesirable solutes.
So they're removing...
They're literally throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
Ha ha, okay.
There we go.
They're removing a fundamental component of that living environment.
It's like grabbing a handful of plants and ripping them out.
It'd be the same difference in a tank with aged water as taking a volume of that water out.
Same thing.
Liken it to a garden.
In a garden, we don't throw things away.
Yeah.
We plow them under.
If your garden soil isn't performing well, you don't rip it out and put in new...
Well, most people don't rip it out.
You don't dig up your dirt, clean it, and put it back.
Yes.
I mean, again, to get back to the whole water-changing thing,
I think people kind of forget that we are part of nature.
And that even in your own house, you're part of nature.
Like your fish tank is still part of nature, even though it's a glass box in your house.
The water that you get from your tap that you ultimately are going to use in your fish tank,
it's coming from a natural source.
It's come up as groundwater, or maybe it's been pulled from a river or something like that.
And then it's basically everything you take out and you put down the drain,
it's going to go out and get recycled, ultimately,
and come out through someone else's tap.
We're always part of the water cycle.
That's really excellent.
I can't tell you how many people have said to me,
you can't keep a natural tank, as though nature...
There's no other kind of tank, even what we're calling sterile tanks or natural tanks.
As though nature does not come through the front door.
You know, again, water's a solvent.
So what you have in your tank right now, the tank next to you,
it's not just water, it's a solution of water plus...
Everything else.
For example, these plants, this plant right here is releasing compounds
and whatever else into the water that is in the water
that's affecting everything else in the tank.
And to take that water out is to reduce the ability
of that plant to have the effect it needs to have.
All right, I'm going to wrap it up here.
We've been at this for half an hour.
I appreciate your time.
We are delighted that you have chosen to get involved with the Father Fish channel
and watch his videos and participate on our Discord server.
There is so much going on right now, it's impossible to cover it all.
Do please find our website.
That's www.father.fish, rather unique.
And it is a very unique site.
We've got lots of things over there that you can purchase for your aquarium
that are really quite wonderful.
Join Discord, find out what's going on there and be a part of it.
We're writing a book, we're evaluating these videos.
The group over there is a substantial and important part of why suddenly
this channel is becoming successful.
So please join us, be a part of the show
and we will celebrate your presence among us.
Love you all.
Bye for now.