SHEIN and Temu conquered global e-commerce with ultra-low prices, Chinese supply chains, and relentless competition. But now the two retail giants are turning on each other—fighting over suppliers, copyrights, market access, and the very business model that made them successful. As regulators tighten the rules and overseas growth becomes harder, China’s cutthroat “involution” is going global. This is the story behind the SHEIN–Temu war—and what it reveals about China’s ultra-cheap retail machine.
This video analyzes the intense rivalry between Shein and Temu, two Chinese-born e-commerce giants. It explores their legal battles in the US and UK, their shared business model of extreme cost-cutting and supplier pressure, and the regulatory challenges they face as they expand globally and encounter stricter laws regarding consumer protection and trade.
Both these two companies were born in China.
Both became huge by selling
extremely cheap products overseas.
Both depend heavily on Chinese suppliers,
and both are now running into tougher regulation,
slowing growth and rising costs.
But instead of just fighting regulators
and competitions overseas,
they've also been fighting each other.
So let me first tell you about their legal battles.
It started, or I should say,
it goes all the way back to late 2022.
Shane struck first.
Now, shortly after Timu entered the U.S. market,
Shane sued in Illinois,
accusing Timu of copyright infringement
and creating fake accounts to steal traffic.
Then in July 2023, Timu hit back.
It sued Shane in Massachusetts,
accusing the company of monopolistic practices.
In that case, in that legal case,
Timu dropped a major allegation.
It alleged that Shane had forced 8,338 suppliers
to sign exclusive agreements,
effectively locking up 70 to 80%
of China's fast fashion production capacity.
And that allegation got a lot of attention.
But then a little later,
I think it's only three months later,
by the end of October that year,
both companies quietly dropped their lawsuits.
People assumed they had settled.
They hadn't.
Just weeks later, on December 14th,
Timu filed a new 100-page lawsuit in Washington, D.C.,
and this one was much more explosive.
Timu accused Shane of what it literally called
mafia-style intimidation.
What did that mean?
Well, according to Timu, Shane summoned suppliers
suspected of working with Timu to its offices,
in China, of course, kept them there for hours,
confiscated their phones, and interrogated them.
The message was allegedly very simple.
If you keep doing business with Timu,
you will be fined.
Timu also said that between January and October 2023,
63% of all copyright complaints
against the platform came from Shane.
So that case lasted until October 2025,
when a federal judge dismissed Timu's claims,
ruling that the alleged conduct took place outside the U.S.
and was beyond the reach of U.S. law.
So Shane won that round.
But that was only the American front.
Another battlefield soon opened up in London.
Okay, so in London, this time, Shane sued Timu,
accusing sellers on its platform
of copying Shane product photos on an industrial scale.
Now, the case went to trial in May this year.
Three months later, the court largely sided with Timu.
The judge said Timu was essentially a platform
for third-party sellers,
and could not automatically be held responsible
for every infringing image posted by merchants.
There was also another complication.
Timu's UK website was supported by servers in Ireland,
making part of Shane's copyright case
harder to pursue under British law.
Then Timu got another win.
Shane had previously forced Timu to remove products
it claimed were infringing its copyrights.
But the court later found that Shane
didn't actually own the copyrights to some of those images.
So Timu could now seek damages,
but the amount hasn't been decided.
So in this round, Timu won.
And this fight isn't over yet.
Timu has also accused Shane
of using exclusive supplier agreements
to shut out competitors.
And that competition case is scheduled for trial
in November 2026.
Now, you may be wondering,
these are two companies born in China.
So why are they fighting all these lawsuits
in America and Europe instead of China?
Well, the answer is pretty simple.
They were born in China,
but their businesses are overwhelmingly overseas.
Neither Shane nor Timu built its business
around selling to Chinese consumers.
Shane was founded in Nanjing in 2008.
Its original company was called Nanjing Dianwei.
It started by selling things like teapots and cell phones
before shifting into women's fashion.
Its original website was sheinside.com.
And then in 2015, they just dropped the side.
So it becomes shein or sheen, sheen.
That's where the name came from.
As the company grew,
its Nanjing entity was dissolved in 2021
and control shifted to a Singapore registered company
called Roget Business.
Around the same time,
its founder Xu Yangtian, who has an English name,
his name is Chris Xu.
Okay, so legally, this company effectively
became a Singapore-based company.
And then Timu is even more straightforward.
It launched in the US in September 2022.
And it was created by Pinduoduo Holdings or PDD Holdings,
the parent company of Pinduoduo,
specifically for overseas markets.
Its US operating company is called Wellco.
It's incorporated in Delaware and headquartered in Boston.
Well, I could tell you that if you lay out
the business models of these two companies side by side,
you'll see that they are not fighting
because they're too different.
They're fighting because they're too similar.
In fact, they're running almost
the exact same business model.
They're competing for the same suppliers.
They're squeezing the same margins.
To put it simply,
their lawsuits are basically
Chinese-style hostile competition,
or as the Chinese call it, involution.
It's that kind of hostile competition taken overseas
and turned into a full-blown street fight.
So let's talk about their business model.
Let's break it down.
Well, the biggest competitive advantage
for both companies is price.
They're cheap, very cheap.
Where does all that cost cutting come from?
Well, first and foremost from the suppliers.
Both companies squeeze the suppliers upstream.
They just do it in different ways.
Each has its own method
and each has its own ruthless side.
Okay, so Shane's method
is what you might call exclusive agreements.
And according to evidence Tianmu submitted in court,
Shane required roughly 8,338 manufacturers
to sign contracts,
promising not to supply Shane's competitors.
So those 8,000 suppliers represented roughly
70 to 80% of China's fast fashion production capacity.
So with these exclusive agreements,
Shane was essentially able to lock up
a huge part of the entire supply chain.
That's Shane.
And then Tianmu uses a different weapon.
What is it?
Fines.
In April 2024, Tianmu suddenly increased the penalties
it imposed on sellers.
If a customer complained or returned a product,
even when it wasn't the seller's fault,
an entire batch of goods
could be hit with collective penalties.
In some cases,
the fine could be as much as five times the sale price.
And on July 29th, 2024,
it was two years ago,
I remember reporting this in one of my programs back then.
So July, 2024, hundreds of suppliers
showed up at Tianmu's headquarters in Guangzhou
or I should say Pinduoduo's headquarters
or the parent company of Tianmu's headquarters,
the headquarters of Tianmu's parent company in Guangzhou
to protest and block the entrance.
And the Financial Times interviewed one seller
who was a woman,
and she had expected to be fined 110,000 yuan.
Instead, the bill came to 290,000 yuan,
which is about over 40,000 US dollars.
And the clothing,
the clothes she was selling
only cost 20 to 30 yuan each piece.
There was simply no way she could earn enough money
to pay that fine.
So you may ask,
well, why not just stop selling on Tianmu?
Well, another seller explained why.
He said, I cannot just walk away.
I have workers to pay.
I still have millions of yuan worth of inventory
sitting in the warehouse.
I really have no way out.
So whether it's using contracts to lock suppliers in
and shut out competitors
or using fines to squeeze suppliers dry,
the result is basically the same.
The suppliers who are supposed to be business partners
lose the freedom to leave.
Different methods, same goal.
And there are hardly the only companies that do that.
It reflects a prevailing business culture under the CCP.
Cutting prices so aggressively
that you drive out the competition
and eventually dominate the market.
I mean, that's what we have been seeing all these years,
not just in China, but also here.
But for this kind of system
to keep working over the long term,
you need two things.
First, you need suppliers who are willing
or forced to stay in the game.
They may have no real alternatives.
In a sense, they become hostages to the supply chain.
If they don't work with Pinduoduo, Tianmu, or Shenyin,
the next buyer may be just as tough.
The second thing you need is regulators
who don't interfere.
In other words, the government allows companies
considerable room to play rough,
squeeze out competitors, and consolidate market power
using any means possible.
And the regulators just look away.
And as long as those two conditions remain in place,
Chinese companies can keep getting bigger and stronger.
And that's the logic inside China.
It also fits Beijing's vision
of building large, powerful, national-level enterprises.
But once these companies go overseas,
those two conditions start to disappear.
First, suppliers can sue you.
They can protest outside your headquarters.
And then you have regulators, courts, journalists,
congressional hearings, one after another,
all coming after you.
Take the app itself.
You open Tianmu and immediately get a prize wheel.
Actually, Tianmu isn't the only one
that does the practices this.
Every time I open some kind of app
that asks me to play a game that shows a prize wheel,
I know it's run by some Chinese.
And then so once this prize wheel starts spinning,
there's a countdown clock ticking away.
You have to add more products to unlock a coupon.
And a German consumer protection group
published a study describing Tianmu's prize wheel
as a highly sticky, dark pattern.
In other words, it's a design meant
to encourage compulsive buying.
And European Union has already launched
a consumer protection investigation
into gamified shopping practices.
And the investigation is still ongoing.
And as we mentioned earlier, this May,
the EU imposed a fine of roughly 200 million euros on Tianmu.
And soon after that, the EU brought another case
against PDD Holdings, the parent company of Tianmu,
and its Irish subsidiary,
accusing them of deliberately obstructing an investigation
under the EU foreign subsidy rules.
And if that charge is upheld,
the next fine could be even larger than the first.
And it's not just in Europe.
The attorney general of Iowa has also sued PDD Holdings,
accusing the company of deceiving consumers
and transferring user data to China.
What's the impact on these two companies?
Well, in the old days, they shipped packages one by one
directly from China to individual customers overseas.
That allowed them to take advantage of duty-free treatment
for low value packages.
But now that loophole has been closed.
The beauty of their original business model
was that they didn't have to hold much inventory.
They could wait for the orders to come in,
then produce and ship accordingly.
That kept costs extremely low.
Now they're being forced to rent warehouses,
and they need local logistics teams,
and they have to predict demand
and keep inventory sitting in those warehouses.
And all of those costs have to be added back in.
So now let's go back to where we started the legal war
between Sheng and Timu.
On the surface, they're fighting over copied photos,
suppliers, and market access.
But I don't think that's what this battle is really about.
At its core, this is a clash between two companies
built on the same model of extreme competition.
They brought that model with them from China,
but once they went overseas,
they ran into something they were less used to,
regulators, lawsuits, public scrutiny,
and limits on how far they could push suppliers
and consumers in a totally different environment.
And when the room for growth started to shrink,
the competition became even more brutal
because these two companies don't just resemble each other.
They threaten each other because they're too similar.
They chase the same suppliers, the same customers,
the same low price advantage.
They adopt the same philosophy of extreme competition
or of extremely low prices.
So in a way, this legal war was almost inevitable
for companies built around beating the competition,
the most dangerous rival
is the one that looks exactly like you.
Thank you so much for watching.
If you're new here, please hit subscribe.
Don't forget to give my video a like.
If you want me to answer your questions directly,
please join my live every Tuesday, Thursday,
and Saturday at 9 p.m. Eastern time.
I'd love to chat with you there.