Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ramsey.solutions/vujbgh • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
Connect with our Sponsors: - If you want your car to keep going and going, trust Christian Brothers Automotive. Find a local shop and get an exclusive Ramsey discount of 10% (up to $250) off ⮕ https://www.cbac.com/ramsey - Learn more about Christian Healthcare Ministries. ⮕ https://www.chministries.org/budget - Get started today with Churchill Mortgage. Equal Housing Lender • NMLS ID 1591 • NMLSConsumerAccess.org ⮕ http://ChurchillMortgage.com/RamseyOffer ⮕ Churchill Certified Homebuyer program is available for qualifying borrowers and select loan types only. Ramsey Audience offer of up to a $500 credit applied at closing toward fees incurred for appraisals for a limited time and may be discontinued without notice. - Get 20% off when you join DeleteMe. ⮕ https://www.joindeleteme.com/Ramsey - Visit Zander Insurance or call 1-800-356-4282 for your free instant quote today. ⮕ https://www.zander.com/
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.
I'm getting married soon and we're negotiating a prenup. My fiance has over six figures in
student loan debt and the agreement would make me responsible for those loans once we're married,
even requiring me to continue paying the remaining balance if we were to divorce.
In exchange, we've agreed that the assets I bring into the marriage will remain completely separate.
Is this a fair trade-off? Should I be willing to take on her premarital debt in exchange for
protecting my premarital assets or are we setting up a marriage where we're keeping score instead
of truly becoming financial partners? Well, there's some self-awareness here, so that's good.
The last line is the most hopeful line.
Yeah, nothing about this sounds romantic. I mean, you're saying I'll pay off your debts.
I don't know what your assets are if we're talking millions and millions in real estate
or 50 grand in a checking account. So it's hard to know exactly where this trade-off is.
Or what the balance is on the student loan.
Yeah, it just says over six figures. But here's how I see it. Once you're married, it's our debt.
You pay off the debt. The assets are our assets. We build wealth from there.
That's how I've seen couples win with money.
I've never seen it where it's tit for tat and they go, well, this was mine from before,
so I'm keeping my house. I think that is a losing game in the long run unless there's
a huge discrepancy where you're coming in with millions and millions and she's got nothing.
Okay, let's use some pretend figures and try to address an actual tactical thing here, okay?
Let's pretend that he has $2 million in mutual funds and she has $100,000 in student loan debt.
If I were in that situation on either side, I would not have approached this as we are negotiating
a prenup. That's a bad phrase to use with your fiancee, okay? I want to design something that
makes us both feel great about our future. That's not negotiating a prenup. This is not a
business transaction. You've reduced it down to that with the phrasing you're using,
the words you're using are really scary. As you said in your last sentence, I'm keeping score.
So if I woke up in that situation, George, the prenup would simply read that I have $2 million
in mutual funds and if we get divorced, we split everything beyond $2 million and I get $2 million.
And the day we're married, I'm going to pay off the student loan, period. And then we don't have
to worry about it. That would be simpler. You're not on the hook for the student loan. If you have
substantial assets and she has well over $100,000 in student loan debt, you write a check the day
after the honeymoon and you pay cash, you pay off her student loan, it's done. So it doesn't need
to be part of the prenup. You can state that in the prenup if you want, but upon return from the
honeymoon, we will write a check a day and pay off the student loan. But that's just a practical
thing. And because when you took her on, dude, you took on $100,000 in student loan debt. And
if she's not worth that, then you're very transactional and you need to walk away from
the whole thing, period. That's the way I feel about it. What are you thinking when you're seeing
this? I mean, yeah, we've seen couples who go, hey, this is scary. And then we've seen the ones
who go, you know what? I loved her and I wanted to marry her regardless of how much debt it was.
And I knew there was going to be a little bit of a mountain to climb and it would take me back a
couple steps to use my savings to knock out the debt, but it was all worth it. Those are the
marriages that I see that will win. I go, that's a couple that's going to stick together. So it's
not to say that this marriage can't work, but I think starting off on this foot makes me go,
how much else are we going to keep separate? Yeah. Even requiring me to continue paying
the remaining balance if we were to divorce, which there would not be a remaining balance
in my scenario because you've got substantial assets and you don't pay off a student loan.
You don't keep it like it's a freaking pet. We destroy the thing immediately. Sally Mae is an
ugly old woman with a ward on her nose. Get her out of the house. You do not want her in your house.
You do not want a spare bedroom for this chick. She's not family and she's evil.
She's from the government and anybody that's from the government is not here to help.
So there you go. That this is, this is how this works. So yeah, I, but I think you guys have
deeper problems in your relationship based on the way this is written. Yeah. Regardless of the
numbers, the phrasing makes it seem really creepy. You're walking in with arms up with the shield up.
Yeah. If my daughter was on the receiving end of this, I would tell her to run
away from you because everything with you, not into your arms, everything is going to be a
transaction with you. Hudson is what it sounds like based on this letter. I may be overreading
it, but the way this is worded with no tone is creepy. Create your free every dollar budget today.
The simplest way to budget for your life.