We orbit the Sun, Sun orbits the center of the Milky Way, but what does the Milky Way orbit? Can we still catch up with Oumuamua? Is the Big Crunch a ruled-out theory? And in Q&A+, have we seen a phenomenon we can't yet explain?
00:00 Intro 00:26 [@jonathanchamberlain6260] What does the Milky Way orbit? 04:21 [@paulwilson1529] Could we still catch up with Oumuamua? 08:28 [@bakkos_bakkos] Is The Big Crunch a ruled out theory? 13:35 [@kamleshpatel6817] Why can't gravitational waves travel faster than light? 16:16 Final thoughts
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video covers a diverse range of topics, from the gravitational dynamics of the Milky Way and the acceleration of the universe's expansion to the technical challenges of intercepting interstellar objects. It also explores the physics of gravitational waves and concludes with the speaker's personal reviews of various science fiction and comedy television series.
We orbit the Sun. The Sun orbits the centre of the Milky Way, but what does the Milky Way orbit?
Could we still catch up with Oumuamua? Why can't gravity be faster than the speed of light?
And in Q&A+, have we seen a phenomenon that we can't yet explain?
All this and more in this question show.
It's time for the question show, your questions, my answers. As always, wherever you are,
across my channel, if a question pops into your brain, just write it down, I'll gather them up,
and I will answer them here. Alright, let's get into the questions.
Jonathan Chamberlain. So the Moon orbits the Earth, the Earth orbits the Sun,
the Sun and the solar system orbit the Milky Way. Does it go further than this?
What does the Milky Way orbit, and does it still exist in the universe?
Yeah, it orbits all the way down. The Moon orbits the Earth. Satellites are orbiting the Moon,
the Moon is orbiting the Earth, the Earth is orbiting the Sun, the Sun is orbiting the
The Milky Way is collected into a dynamic with a bunch of other galaxies and dwarf galaxies
in our vicinity. It's called the local group. And all of these galaxies are gravitationally
bound to each other. And so they are not orbiting each other, they are orbiting essentially the
common center of mass of all of these galaxies. You've got Andromeda, you've got Milky Way,
you've got M33, the galaxy in Triangulum, those are the three big galaxies in the local group.
And then you've got several hundred dwarf galaxies that are all buzzing around this whole thing.
And that, you know, depending on which model you like, either all of these galaxies wind up in one
large giant elliptical galaxy, or maybe Andromeda will just miss and spin out and head off into deep
space. But that is sort of the sum of what they are all doing. So imagine it's more like a globular
star cluster where you've got these objects that are all buzzing around each other. But the local
group, the galaxies in the local group, are gravitationally influenced by larger structures
that are in our vicinity. And so the next one is the Virgo cluster. And this is a collection of
galaxies. When you look out, when you see pictures of galaxies, most of these are within that kind of
range. So they're in the, say, 5 to 100 million light years away from us. And on the one hand,
we are not gravitationally locked to those galaxies. We are gravitationally interacting
with them. And we are like slightly moving towards them. But at the same time, the expansion
of space is carrying them away from us. And in the future, they will fall over the cosmic horizon and
they will be gone to us. But for now, you can sort of imagine this giant, large scale structure of
the universe that has all of these galaxies that are kind of gravitationally interacting with each
other as the universe is kind of tearing itself farther and farther apart. And then there's an
even larger structure called the Laniakea supercluster. And that is, now we're talking
about a structure that is like a billion light years on a side. And that all of these galaxies
are gravitationally influenced to each other. Again, not gravitationally bound. They will not
turn into one giant super galaxy because they're moving away from each other. It's just too fast.
But they are, you know, they're not ending up where they would if they weren't gravitationally
attracted to each other is sort of the way to think about it. An example is we were talking
about the great attractor, right? That the galaxies that are sort of above and below the
Milky Way seem to be sliding towards some object that is on the far side of the Milky Way. Now,
they're actually moving away from everywhere, moving away from each other, moving off into
deep space. But they're slightly moving towards this spot on the far side of the Milky Way. And
that is the center of gravity of all of those galaxies. So, you know, at a certain point,
I would say the last thing, the biggest thing that could be said is orbiting is the Milky Way
around the common center of gravity of the local group. Everything beyond that, these things are
not orbiting. They are just influencing each other while they're also flying apart. Paul Wilson,
could we still catch up with Oumuamua to photograph it if we wanted to? Yeah, theoretically,
we could still catch Oumuamua. We wouldn't be able to catch 3i Atlas. It's just going too fast. But
Oumuamua, we could catch. And there's a group of engineers that put out a paper called Project
Lira about four years ago, five years ago. And essentially, they described a plan for how you
could catch up with Oumuamua. It would involve building a very small spaceship, putting it on
top of a Falcon heavy rocket so you can launch it with an enormous amount of velocity. And then you
fly it towards the sun. And then as your spacecraft goes around the sun, you fire your engines. And
this gives you a boost in the sort of final velocity of your spacecraft, your sun diving.
They calculate that it would take about 50 years to chase down Oumuamua, but you would actually be
able to catch up with it and then start taking pictures of it. And that we could imagine even
more exotic propulsion systems, like say if we had a Hall effect thrust for like an ion engine
bolted to a fission reactor, then it's just the fission reaction producing electricity and the
ion engine is producing thrust and there's nothing else fancy. This thing is just a hot rod.
It could fly and catch up with Oumuamua, maybe even do a sample return from Oumuamua. These are
all still possible and will be possible probably for about another decade. And then it's really
just going too far too fast and we wouldn't be able to catch up with it. And just imagine the
science that we could do. Like if we could analyze a rock, a comet that came from another star
system, it would be such a boon for space science. But this is not in the works. You know,
nobody is going to spend the money to do this. The money is being set up in other ways. People
have other priorities, other telescopes, like would you like to catch Oumuamua or do you want
the Habitable Worlds Observatory? Do you want a Mars sample return mission? Do you want to have
humans on the moon? Like there's a lot of things that people are focusing their efforts and energy
on. Which, you know, I understand. But if you can't go and actually chase down one of these
known interstellar objects, then could you see the next one? And the answer is absolutely. This
is how you do it on the cheap, is that you instead wait for the next one. And thanks to Vera Rubin,
we should be finding a half dozen to ten interstellar objects passing through the
solar system every single year. And so you just have to be in the right position, right place,
right time. And so the European Space Agency is planning on launching their Comet Interceptor
mission. And that this is a spacecraft that will go out to the Earth-Sun L2 Lagrange point,
the same place where James Webb and Guy and all these missions were at, and Loiter in this orbit
that's like right at the edge between falling back to the Earth or heading off into orbit around the
Sun. When the telescopes have found an object that is on the right velocity, then this thing
will kick on its engines and do an intercept trajectory to get as close to this interstellar
object as it can. And it'll be kind of like, say, the flyby of New Horizons with Pluto. Like it
didn't go into orbit, but it did a flyby and it got really close. And so we can imagine this
interceptor spacecraft doing a flyby of some object that is making its way through the inner
solar system and happens to be on the right trajectory that is reachable with the engine
on this thing. And it would be incredible. So this is a serious idea. The Europeans probably
will have this launched in 2031 and that then it's really just open season on interstellar objects.
It's time to shout out all the new $5 patrons and above. Michael House, Jim Murphy, Michael Purcell,
Barry Greenway, Chris Foran, Howard, Robin McIntyre, Fred, Muzz, and Ryland Felna.
Join the club at patreon.com slash universe today.
Backos, backos. So the Universe is expanding all the time. What about the Big Collapse? Is it
ruled out theory? It is a mostly ruled out theory. It's been mostly ruled out for about 30 years.
And so let's say about 30 years ago, astronomers wanted to ask this fundamental question, which is
what is the future of the Universe? We know the Universe is expanding today. When we look out,
all of the galaxies that we see in all directions are moving away from us.
Will this always be the case? We know that the initial momentum of all of this movement was
caused by the Big Bang 13.8 billion years ago. But what does the future hold? Is it like this
initial expansion and then the mutual gravity of all of the galaxies in the Universe, all the mass
is going to be pulling back at itself. And it's going to be slowing this expansion down until it
sort of either screeches to a halt at some point in an infinite amount of time or some finite amount
of time, or that the mutual gravity is going to slow the expansion of the Universe and then pull
it back down in on itself. And that was called the Big Crunch. And so astronomers set about trying
answer this question. And they did this by trying to measure the expansion rate of the Universe
over time. And you can sort of think about an experiment that you might do, which is that you
say throw a ball up into the air, and then you measure the speed that the ball is going
up into the air. And you know that the gravity is pulling the ball down. And so you will measure,
you know, throw the ball up and then a second ago the ball was moving this speed, two seconds ago
the ball was moving at that speed. And you can sort of tell now when the ball is going to stop
going up, and it's going to start coming back down again. And this was the question that the
astronomers asked. And so they figured out that there was the standard candle, these type 1a
supernovae, and that they would always explode with the same amount of energy. And so if you saw
one of these, you knew how intrinsically bright they were. And so they measured the amount of
these type 1a supernovae around them to try and figure out, you know, the equivalent of that ball,
right? Is the Universe slowing down? And is the rate that it's slowing down to the point that you
can detect when it'll stop expanding and then crunch back in on itself? Or is it going to slow
down at infinity? So just at the end of time, the Universe will stop expanding. So it won't have
time to collapse back down. Or is the Universe going to keep expanding forever? It's going to
be slowing down, but it will keep on expanding forever, right? Which of those three models is the
answer to the Universe? Because that makes three very different futures for the Universe, especially
the big crunch idea. And what is amazing was that they found a fourth answer, right? It was none of
the above. That in fact, what they found is that the expansion of the Universe is accelerating.
And so if you go back to that analogy, you're throwing the ball up, and the ball, you know,
slows down, reaches the top of its arc, and then comes back down. Well, what if it, you throw it up,
and it speeds off into space? You know, faster, faster, faster. That is the equivalent. That is
the thing that they found. That in fact, the Universe, the expansion of the Universe is
accelerating. Nobody ordered this. Nobody wanted this. Nobody expected this. And that it has taken
the astronomical community 30 years. Like this was discovered in 1997. Here I am in 2026,
right? Almost 30 years that the astronomical community has been wrestling with this. They
had to come up with new instruments, new missions, new technology to measure this stuff because
nobody was planning for this. And so now here we are today, we've got Nancy Grace Roman, we've got
Vera Rubin, we've got the Euclid mission, we've got the DESI survey, the DES survey. So there's
like five or six telescopes all trying to answer this question of like, what does the future hold
for the cosmos? And when dark energy was originally discovered, it was thought, okay,
this is some kind of constant, this cosmological constant. The more mass, the more space there is
in the Universe, the more of this dark energy appears in the Universe. But the indications
from these big surveys are actually, maybe the amount of dark energy coming into the Universe
has been fluctuating over time, that it might be decreasing over time, which is, again, what
nobody ordered. Like nobody ordered dark energy in the first place, but at least a sort of standard
amount of dark energy is something that is acceptably understandable. But for it to be
changing over time, that's madness. So yeah, it's a very surprising discovery that astronomers are
still digesting to this day. So no big crunch? Probably. Kimilish Patel, why can't gravitational
waves travel faster than light if there's no electron or particle as part of the wave?
The speed of light is the sort of the speed of the Universe, and this is just what has been
measured. So like, why is the speed of light the speed of both electromagnetic waves and gravity
in the Universe? I mean, that's a kind of a more fundamental question, but it just happens to be.
And that it would have been very surprising if gravitational waves moved at some speed
other than the speed of light. But, you know, back in, you know, hundreds of years ago,
dozens of years ago, 50 years ago, 100 years ago, astronomers weren't sure if gravity moved at the
speed of light or if gravity moved instantaneously. You know, this was an open question. If you
disappeared the Sun, would the planets continue to orbit around the Sun for eight minutes,
the amount of time it would take for the gravity to fully propagate out to the planets? Or would
the planets spin off into space immediately? And some people thought it would be immediately,
and other people thought it was going to take eight minutes. And it wasn't until fairly recent
that astronomers were able to actually detect or essentially measure a rough approximation of the
of gravity. I think they were looking at the transits of moons across the surface of Jupiter.
But we got the best test of this with the Kilonova event in 2017, where astronomers
measured this collision between neutron stars. They detected both the gravitational waves of it,
as well as the electromagnetic radiation. So yeah, they were able to pin down that gravity does
for sure move at exactly the speed of light. Did you know that you can watch the same video with
no ads and get a bonus question over on Patreon, completely for free? We call that Q&A+. In this
week's bonus question, have we seen a phenomenon we can't yet explain? I'll put a link in the
show notes. Alright, those were all the questions we had this episode. Thank you everyone who asked
your questions into YouTube comments, everybody who joined me for the live show. I'm going to
let you know what TV shows we're watching, but first I'd like to thank our Patrons.
Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Pedretti, Balthazar Galactic Invader, Brian Bowdoin,
Caridin, Chuck Hawkins, Brandon Bailick, David Gilson, David Matts, Evan Dot Pro, James Clark,
Jeremy Madden, Jim Burke, Marcel Sitz, Michael Purcell, NASAOceanGuy, Nordospace,
OneStepRedEmotes.org, Weyla.Travel, please follow me on Instagram at vbrick6994,
Rankheide, Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Team49, TelescopesCanada, Vlad Sheplin,
Wolfgang Klotz, and Zelda Fraser of the Galaxy ismwhatworriesme who support us at the Master
of the Universe level. And all our Patrons, all your support means the universe to us.
So about once a month, I give you an update on all the shows that we're watching. And even though
we are still on the road, we still have access to our streaming services. And so we are able
to watch a bunch of shows. So the sci-fi stuff first, which is that we are now watching the
new season of Strange New Worlds. This show started really strong with the first couple
of seasons. This season has been not that entertaining for me. There's been like one
amazing episode and I thought a couple of like solid episodes and then a bunch of stinkers.
So, uh, unfortunately this show, which felt, you know, like a breath of fresh air is starting to
kind of fall into some, I can't say they're falling into some tropes. They're trying some
experiments and you've got to appreciate that if they're going to do a puppet episode or they're
going to do a musical, but still haven't loved this season as much. Watching the second season
of Dark Matter. It's a little better than the first season of Dark Matter. And I'm not a huge
Blake Crouch fan. I read one of his books, didn't love it, but you know, Apple TV tends to do some
pretty good shows. And so I was willing to watch the first season and it felt very formulaic.
This one, now that they've kind of gone beyond his original book, I think feels a little bit
and a little different. And there was like a really good episode that just aired and actually
was quite poignant and I really enjoyed it. And so, you know, it almost made the whole second
season worth watching. Continuing to watch Lanterns, which I consider to be excellent.
I'm going to wait and see how the whole thing turns out, but it might make its way to
one of my top shows of all time. We'll see. And of course we're watching the new season of Ted
Lasso, which I am like on the one hand, I love Ted Lasso. It's probably one of the greatest shows
ever made. On the other hand, it feels like it didn't need to happen like through popular demand.
They needed a new season of Ted Lasso, but it's sort of like the core premise of the show that
you can kind of win with kindness. Like they did it. They did, they told their story and now they're
coming back and telling new stories. Some of the episodes are good. Some of the jokes are funny,
but it just doesn't feel as sort of revelatory as it did the first time, the first seasons of Ted
Lasso, which kind of came out of nowhere. I don't want to give a pitch since I'm in the UK and we're
passing through all of these really amazing landscapes to encourage you to watch The
Detectorist, which I consider to be one of the finest television shows ever made. It hits that
same note as Ted Lasso. And it's about a couple of best friends who use metal detectors to search
for gold and other treasures in the UK while just kind of enjoying the landscape and their small town
politics. So check out The Detectorist as an alternative to Ted Lasso. All right, we'll see you next time.