When will we see the surfaces of exoplanets? What non-western telescopes should we expect? Where are all the big promised results from Vera Rubin? And in Q&A+, how to get in space journalism and is it worth it now?
00:00 Intro 00:33 [@theindianking3000] Will Roman see exoplanets better than JWST? 03:13 [@fwd79] Which non-western space telescopes are coming? 05:55 [@paulwilson1529] How packed is the asteroid belt? 07:35 [@GadZookz] Are there any calories on the Moon or Mars? 10:26 [@rilanfelnar2698] Results from Vera Rubin. When? 14:57 Final thoughts
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This Q&A session explores diverse astronomical topics, including the technical limits of exoplanet imaging, China's upcoming Xuntian telescope, and the actual sparsity of asteroid belts. It also addresses the challenges of space farming and the operational goals of the Vera Rubin Observatory, concluding with the speaker's personal travel experiences hiking in the UK.
When will we see the surfaces of exoplanets? What non-Western telescopes should we expect?
Where are all the big promised results from Vera Rubin? And including plus,
how to get into space journalism, and is it worth it now? All this and more in this question show.
It's time for the question show, your questions, my answers, as always, wherever you are across
my channel. If a question pops into your brain, just write it down, I'll gather them up and I
will answer them here. The second to last day of our Cotswold walk, I'll give you more information
at the very end of this episode. But let's get into the questions. The Indian King, how closely
and clearly can we see exoplanet surfaces with Nancy Grace? And does it have any disadvantage
compared to JWST? Even the best spacecraft, the best space telescopes that we have,
Nancy Grace Roman, James Webb, the upcoming Habitable Worlds Observatory,
the ultimate telescope that follows after the Habitable Worlds Observatory will only be able
to see one pixel of an exoplanet, nothing more. And that's just because the resolution of the
telescope and the size of the object, all you get is the light coming from that target. You're not
going to be able to get any kind of resolution on the surface of that world. But you can learn an
incredible amount from that single pixel. You can detect the chemicals in the atmosphere of the
planet. You can measure changes in brightness as the planet is going around its star. You can
measure changes in brightness of the planet as it's rotating. You could imagine detecting the glint
of the sunlight off the oceans as the planet is turning and then comparing that to the times when
you're measuring the sunlight bouncing off of say the continents or forests. You could be able to
the presence of vegetation on that world. There's very specific wavelengths of light that you're
going to get reflected off of plant life on some other world. It's called the red edge. It's a very
specific wavelength of infrared radiation. You could detect that. You could detect the presence
of chlorofluorocarbons, other industrial chemicals in the atmosphere of that world.
And so even though you're still just getting a single pixel, it's an incredibly useful pixel.
And astronomers are really good at stretching those single pixels to be able to pull out an
incredible amount of data out of them. It would be incredible to be able to go to the next level and
be able to see more pixels. But that takes a telescope at a much larger scale. You're looking
at hundreds of kilometers across. Imagine, you know, think about James Webb 6.5 meters across,
Nancy Grace Roman 2.4 meters across. You're going to need a telescope that is hundreds of kilometers
across before you could start to see multiple pixels on an exoplanet orbiting around some
other star. So for the foreseeable future, we're just going to get one pixel. But one pixel could
tell us if there's life, if there's advanced civilizations, if there's technology on that world,
we could tell from that one pixel. FWD 79. We hear about all western space telescopes.
Are there any Chinese space telescopes on the level or below Hubble? Yeah, there is actually
a Chinese space telescope that is in development right now and it's going to be launching in 2027
and that is called Shuntian. And this is a two meter telescope coming from the Chinese Space
Agency and that it's going to be a very similar class to Hubble. Of course, it's going to have a
telescope mirror that it's a little bit smaller than Hubble, but it's going to be able to have
all of the modern science instruments. So it's going to have great big CCDs on it. And the plan
for Shuntian is that it is going to fly in formation with the Chinese space station.
And originally their idea was, well, let's just mount this telescope onto the space station. But
they realized the vibrations of the station were going to make observations really difficult. So
instead they fly this in formation and then when they need to do any servicing, they'll be able to
bring the telescope close to the station, dock it, grab it, grab onto it and hold onto it. And
then they can perform spacewalks and work with the telescope. And then they'll be able to release it
again and they can continue to fly in formation with the space station. So it's a very clever
idea to be able to do the ongoing servicing, which we saw was a big part of what made the
Hubble Space Telescope so amazing. This is sort of like the main flagship telescope that the Chinese
are working on. Like I said, it's going to launch in 2027. So like a year from now we should have
another Hubble class space telescope in the sky. And we should get first light from this telescope
and we should get a lot of press releases coming out of China. You know, they're going to be very
proud about this telescope and I think we're going to see a lot of really cool pictures coming from
this telescope. That is just sort of one telescope that the Chinese are working on. There's one
called the Einstein probe that was already launched. Actually this is in collaboration
with the European Space Agency and this has been doing some interesting science. And they are
working on some gravitational wave observatories and they're also going to be getting into the
extrasolar planet hunting game. And they're working on a telescope that is going to assist with
finding and categorizing extrasolar planets. So yeah, there's a lot of space telescopes that are
coming out of China. You know, they typically will tell us what they're doing over their sort
of five-year plans and so these are the ones that are in the works right now. The Xuntian,
that one is going to launch next year though. Paul Wilson, is the asteroid belt packed? How
far away is each from the next? The asteroid belt isn't packed and there's sort of this classic joke
that if you wanted to pass through the asteroid belt and you were worried about you crashing into
a random asteroid, you don't have to be. That they are potentially hundreds of thousands of
kilometers apart, even millions of kilometers apart. And so you have to go out of your way
to get yourself close to an object in the asteroid belt. And that it gets even worse once you're out
in the Kuiper belt. In the Kuiper belt you're looking at millions, tens of millions of kilometers
away. Once you're out in the Oort cloud, these objects can be astronomical units away from each
other. Hundreds of millions of kilometers away from each other. And so they don't collide very
often. This is the classic trope in science fiction, that you're going to pass through this
asteroid belt and you've got to maneuver your way around these asteroids that are really tightly
packed. And it's just not the case. A place that you might have to do something like that, if you
wanted to pass through say the rings of Saturn, the objects in the rings of Saturn are packed
pretty close together. And that if you actually tried to pass through the rings, you would be
ground down like a buzzsaw. So you might have to do some fancy flying to get through the rings
of Saturn. It's time to shout out all the new $5 patrons and above. Ross Daniels, Jeff Newhart,
Max, Mark Bitkofer, Don Steiner, Eccentric Diffractions, John Rubin-Bubar, Astral Walker,
Scott Toast, and Matthias Faust. Join the club at patreon.com slash universe today.
Gazoos, are there any calories on the Moon or Mars that could be harvested by self-sufficient
colonists from Earth? So currently, no. When you think about calories, you need food, you need
organic materials. And there's no life on the Moon or Mars. And so there's nothing to eat. But,
you know, humans being humans, if we do set up some kind of station on the Moon or station on Mars,
then we will figure out a way to grow food, because it's going to be incredibly expensive
for us to try and bring all of that food up from Earth. Like in the beginning,
when a new research station is set up on the Moon or a new station is set up on Mars,
then they will send a packaged food in the same way those packaged food sent up to the
International Space Station. But scientists are already working on every idea that they can think
of for these researchers to be, you know, being able to provide some of their calories locally.
And that we have seen incredible experiments. People have tested out whether or not crops can
grow in lunar regolith, and they can. Whether they can grow in Martian regolith, and they can.
But you will require organic material, will require compost, poop, potatoes. Think about
the Martian, right? So you will need to do some treatment of the regolith on Mars, the perchlorates.
But chances are they won't even bother growing in the regolith in the soil on these places.
They'll just do hydroponics. And NASA is like world leading in developing hydroponics systems.
And in fact, this is what they use on the International Space Station. They grow plants
in water and then they feed nutrients into the water to be able to grow the plants. And so they
don't have to send up the food, they just have to send up the nutrients. And the nutrients are the
kinds of things that can theoretically be harvested locally on the Moon or Mars. Things like carbon,
nitrogen, potassium. Now they're not very common on the Moon or Mars. And so it might be that for
the first few decades, they'll have to just send up bags of fertilizer to the stations for them to
be able to run their hydroponics systems. And if you're hoping like, oh, can you get a burger on,
you know, the Moon base? It's going to be pretty tricky for a long time for them to be able to
have any kind of source of protein that they can count on. You know, I've seen people talk about
mealworms, crickets, maybe tilapia, things like that. But for the longest time, if you're going
try to harvest your resources locally on a place like the Moon or Mars, it's going to be
hydroponically grown algae, various plants, salad greens, strawberries. Maybe you'll move into sort
of higher protein foods like soybeans, things like that. I thought there would be more results
for Vera Rubin. Is it ramping up or will it explode in announcements after X months or something?
Yeah, this is, you know, like maybe I'm at fault because I had been so excited about the operations
of Vera Rubin. And we got those initial science results, which were great. And then about two
weeks ago, we got one big announcement from Vera Rubin where they had essentially pointed Vera
Rubin at the same vicinity as the Cosmos survey in the constellation of Sextans. And this is a
well-worn chunk of the sky that all the big space telescopes go and look at and sort of do their
version, their cover of this region of the sky, because now you've got this sort of baseline.
Hubble Space Telescope did it. James Webb is doing it. Vera Rubin did it. And so normally,
Vera Rubin, they just point it at a different spot in the sky every few minutes. And then after
every three days, it's imaged the entire night sky and then it moves on like it's moving in this
very automated fashion. But they're essentially building up this movie of night after night after
night, essentially a thousand frames of this video. They will have one thousand frames of
every spot in the sky. And then they're able to watch as things happen night after night after
night over the course of 10 years with Vera Rubin. But what they're really doing, when you think
about it, is just a series of exposures. If you want to take a nice image of a nebula, you're
going to do a bunch of exposures. You're going to expose your camera for 30 seconds and then do
another one and then another one. And then you stack up all of the images. And that's what Vera
Rubin is doing. They're doing a 15 second exposure on a spot in the sky. And instead of just exposing
the same spot in the sky right immediately after, they're doing their next exposure three days
later. And then three days later they're doing it again until the sun is obscuring their view and
they got to wait. And so they're getting a total of a thousand of these. But they have done some
experiments where they're just like, let's just point it at one spot in the sky and expose, expose,
expose. And this is why we got those really nice images. But why have we seen a lot of science
come out of this yet? I've seen a ton of science and we've reported on quite a bit of it on
Universe Today. It is not making it out into the mainstream press. I'm not seeing a lot of
press releases. But we got analysis of 3i Atlas from Vera Rubin. We got the discovery that there
are asteroids that are spinning really quickly because of Vera Rubin. Like they should be
tearing themselves apart but they're not. So they must be solid objects like blobs of metal that
are spinning. And there's been a bunch of other science work. And there's been a lot of like
supernova discoveries and analysis. And so if you go into archive and you do a search for Vera
Rubin you're going to find tons and tons and tons of papers. And we are just at the beginning stages
of this because Vera Rubin has only done like the first frame, the first couple of frames of those
thousand exposures that it's going to eventually do on everything. And it's really only until the
end when you've got those big long data series that you can actually start to do some of the
important science. So you're going to probably see this ramp up. So stay tuned. And you know,
I am specifically looking for stuff that is related to Vera Rubin. So stay tuned and I will
bring you as much as I can find. Did you know that you can watch the same video with no ads
and get a bonus question over on Patreon completely for free. We call it Q&A Plus. This week's bonus
question, how to get into space journalism and is it still worth it? I'll put a link down in the
show notes. All right. Those are all the questions that we had this episode. Thank you everyone who
asked your questions into the YouTube comments. Everybody who joined me for the live show. The
live shows are still happening while I've been on the road. So thank you everybody who is continuing
to participate in all of the fun. I'm going to thank the patrons and then sort of explain what
I'm doing here. Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andreas Pedretti, Balthazar Galactic Invader, Brian Bode,
Kerwin, Chuck Hawkins, Karina Bailack, David Gilton, David Matz, Evan Dot Pro, James Clark,
Jeremy Mattern, Jim Burke, Marcel Sitz, Michael Purcell, NASAOceanGuy, Nordspace,
OneStepAnimals.org, Wayler.Travel, please follow my nephew at vbrick699, Forward Ring, Kaido,
Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Team49, Telescopes Canada, Vlad Sheplin, Wolfgang Klotz, Zelda Fraser,
The Galaxy Isn't What Worries Me, who supports us at the master of the universe level, and all
our patrons. All your support means the universe to us. So if you're wondering what it is and where
I am, I am in the UK and my wife and I are doing the Cotswolds, which is a multi-day hike here in
the UK, which goes from Chipping Camden at the north to the city of Bath at the south. And it
takes you through the Cotswolds. And that is sort of a sort of a region with a bunch of cities that
are all connected. And mostly you just walk just on the outskirts of these fairly large cities
through woods and meadows and and farmer's fields. And it's totally different than anything
that we have back in Canada. You know, in Canada, we go on hikes. We have to carry all of our gear.
We have to carry all of our food. We're in the backcountry for multiple days. Bears, cougars,
things like that. It's very rugged here. We are staying at bed and breakfasts night after night
and it is luxurious. And the landscape is just beautiful. The hospitality has been amazing.
We've been running into a lot of people from a lot of different nations, a lot of Americans,
some Canadians, but people from around the world that are doing this hike. And so now here I am.
This is the second to last day. We finish the hike tomorrow as we wind up in Bath. And would
I recommend it? Absolutely. It is a lot of fun and I think you can do it. We're taking a bit
of a slower route. We're doing about about 10 miles a day, which is sort of how they break it
up. But you can go much faster. You get the whole thing done in six days. You can take longer. And
this is just one piece of the tons and tons of hikes you can do here in the UK. And man, it's
been so much fun. I want to do another one. All right. We'll see you next time.