Finding the best rum for a Pina Colada is easier than you think. I compare five options against the standard Bacardi choice.
We are looking for the right spirit to elevate your classic tropical drinks. This comparison focuses on finding a superior alternative to the standard Bacardi base, testing five distinct rums to see how they perform in a Pina Colada. Whether you are a home bartender or just enjoy mixing easy rum drinks, this breakdown helps you select a bottle that balances flavour and quality without unnecessary complexity.
Taste is subjective, but comparing specific profiles helps identify what works best in a cocktail tasting. We evaluate each rum to see if it stands up to the cream and pineapple, ensuring your next round of cocktails is a step above the rest. By focusing on these best white rum selections, you can refine your home bar setup for better results.
✅ 100+ Rum Cocktail Recipes (and growing weekly) 🎓 Rum Education 🥃 Easy to understand Rum Categories 🍌 Flavour pairings 📰 Weekly News from the world of Rum 📔 Monthly Cocktail deepdives ⚠️ DISCOUNTS CODES AND OFFERS ⚠️ ABOUT ME
I’ll love creating new fun & unique simple(ish) Rum Cocktail Recipes. My mantra is Faff Free, Fun & Easy Cocktails. No Mixology. No Geekery. If you have to spend more than 30 seconds making an ingredient… it’s too much hassle! So whether you make Cocktails at home, or you’re a Bartender looking for more fun Classic Cocktail recipes, my easy drinks should suit you perfectly!
===========================================
TIMESTAMPS
00:00:00 - Can You Improve on a Bacardi Piña Colada? 00:02:11 - Ingredients and the Saline Solution Trick 00:02:43 - Fifth Place: Diplomático Planas 00:03:28 - Fourth Place: Planteray Three Stars 00:04:05 - Third Place: Pampero Especial 00:05:10 - Second Place: Chairman's Reserve 00:05:54 - First Place: Angostura 7 00:06:53 - Why Appleton 8 Didn't Make the List
Video Summary
AI Generated
The video explores how to elevate a Pina Colada by upgrading the base rum from standard Bacardi to more flavorful alternatives. The creator shares five rum recommendations under £30 that enhance the cocktail's depth without making it overly complex, while also sharing a simple ingredient trick to amplify the tropical flavors.
Let's get this statement out of the way right at the top of this video.
A Bacardi Pina Colada. Is it any good or should you avoid it?
I'm going to be honest here. It makes a perfectly good Pina Colada.
If a Bacardi Pina Colada was all I would have,
I would be more than happy for that. However,
there's more than happy, there's settling.
Is that where we're at these days or can we do better?
So today in this video,
I've lined up five different rums that I think will take the Pina Colada to
completely new heights without making the drink more complicated or
without making it cost too much extra money.
Now when it comes to making the Pina Colada,
I've also got another little trick that's actually pretty inexpensive,
but amps up the flavours so much. So if you are sticking to the Bacardi,
then this little trick coming up in a second might help you.
Now, as I briefly mentioned at the top,
I think when it comes to upgrading the Pina Colada,
we don't need to go too crazy on rums. For example,
I would never in a million years think about putting a funky Jamaican rum in the
Pina Colada. Yes, it will have some fans,
but it would be in the minority. At the end of the day, the Pina Colada,
it's just light. It's fun. It's tropical,
but that doesn't mean to say we can't elevate it slightly.
The only criteria I really had was yes,
I am spending more money than a bottle of Bacardi,
but I wanted to keep it to 30 pounds or under.
I think when it comes to things like this,
my mentality is always mass market,
but I always want that reaction, that catch all.
It was like they've had a Pina Colada before. They like a Pina Colada,
but when they taste something I make, I want them to go, Oh,
I want them to have that reaction that makes them think it's better than what
they would normally have at home.
My fascination with the Pina Colada started when I went down the rum journey a
few years back. And I'd always done light white rums, whether it was Don Q,
whether it was Havana Especial, whether it was Bacardi.
My first different rum in a Pina Colada was actually the Bacardi four year old.
And I was instantly hit by, Oh my God, that is so much better than normal Bacardi.
So to make this, this is just simply three ingredients.
And you can see by the color of these, there is different rums at play here.
But the three ingredients is the base rum, my go-to coconut,
which is always Real cream of coconut.
And then I've just got my a hundred percent pressed pineapple juice that we can
get from every supermarket here in the UK.
But I did mention a little trick to make these even better.
And that comes in the form of saline solution.
What's the saline, the saltiness is doing, it's not making the drink salty.
It's just amping the coconut and the pineapple flavors.
So let's start off with my fifth favorite Pina Colada.
And I'm actually going for Diplomatico Planas.
And it's this one here. It is lovely.
It's a higher ABV and I do get sort of subtle,
sort of like subtle, subtle chocolate notes. It isn't aged rum.
It's just been charcoal filtered.
And I just think it gives you a lovely sort of rounded,
deeper more oomph in a Pina Colada without taking it massively
away from that light tropical taste.
It's probably the one here that would stretch you the
most out of, if these were all mass markets, but I promise you,
it is absolutely delicious.
It just delivers in a way that none of these other four, well,
the other four do. And in fourth place,
I'm going for Plantaray Three Stars.
I just do not think you can beat it at the price point, at the rum.
It gives you the, it's this one over here.
It gives you that lovely sort of vanilla-y note.
And which Bacardi doesn't give you, obviously it is a three rum blend,
Jamaica, Barbados and Trinidad. So it does give you depth of flavour.
It is slightly stronger than Bacardi. Again, of course it is.
I just think it is a lovely and delicious Pina Colada.
For a lot of you, that would be the actual upgrade,
but I still think we can do better.
My third place pick actually does beat Bacardi Four Year Olds, again,
on price and actually on taste.
And that's Pampero Especial from Venezuela.
I think this is a delicious rum and coke, er, Pina Colada, sorry.
I think you can pick this up for sub £20 a bottle.
If you shop around here in the UK, it's extraordinary value for money.
It's a great mix in rum as well, rum and cokes and things like that.
And I just think to have it in a Pina Colada,
just to give it a slight depth of flavour over like the unaged Bacardi,
I just think it's fantastic.
And that leaves us with the final two and I'll be honest on a different day,
I'd put these around the other way.
I don't think I can crown an out and out favourite here because I love them both
equally. With all the rums,
and there are about four or five rums that I haven't tried that I've got behind
me in a Pina Colada,
I've never found rums that I would put in a Pina Colada that work
better. So I'm just going to say second and first,
these are both equal in my opinion, but in second,
it's behind me up here, Chairman's Reserve, the original,
the normal rum.
This is by far and away an amazing Pina Colada.
At the price point, quite often on offer in the UK in supermarkets,
it's outstanding for like, yes, again, five,
£6 more expensive than Bacardi, but I think it is so worth it.
It's such a great mixing rum.
It doesn't take the cocktail away from what it is. It's light, it's tropical,
it's fun, it's fruity,
but it just adds that little touch of caramelised depth of flavour to it.
It's just perfect. An absolute perfect Pina Colada.
But then the other one, as I mentioned, really did surprise me.
And it is a seven year old, as I've mentioned, and it is this,
the Angostura 7. I just think this rum is a belting.
It was a rum that I've mentioned in other videos recently that I just kind of
forgot about. I had a little bit left in a bottle. It was just like, yeah,
like that. But I've been testing rum and Cokes.
I've been testing cocktails and it just works.
It's a lighter column still rum. So it's got,
by that we kind of normally associate like Dominican Republic, Puerto Rico,
Cuba, those style of rums, like lighter Spanish origin rums.
But the Trinidad rums, because they are column still,
they still give you that lighter. And I love it. I love that style of rum.
And I think as much, I've got a soft spot for Chairman's Reserve.
I think I probably would just put the Angostura 7 in top place just,
but as I say on a different day, it could go another way. Now,
for regular viewers, there is one glaring omission here. Again,
it's what rum that I've coined the pound for pounds,
the best value rum on the market. And that is the Appleton 8 year old.
It's a great rum, but I'll be honest,
putting up against these five in a Pina Colada, I don't think it competes.
I think it's, I think it's just got a little bit too old. As an eight year old,
it's completely different to the seven year old Angostura because it has got
those pot still vibes for it. It makes it a slightly heavier rum.
I still think pound for pound is the best value rum in the market.
I just think I've got better rums behind me for a Pina Colada.
Drop your favourite Pina Colada rums in the comments below. No,
I didn't do flavoured rums.
I could have quite easily done the Plants vs Rats Stiggins Fancy or the Pineapple,
but I kept it to Blaine. Let me know your favourite rums for a Pina Colada.
I'm going to dive into the membership community now and give you some great
little riffs to take these to a different level.