The rise and fall of the West's "New York" vision
Oct 1, 2026
I'm standing here at the very edge of the Quimper Peninsula here in Washington State.
And by all geographic logic, this should be a very small wooden sleepy fishing village.
But instead, there's actually a little city that almost became the major city of Washington State.
Welcome to Port Townsend, Washington.
In the late 1880s, this was the richest, fastest growing city in all of the Pacific Northwest.
Speculators poured millions of dollars to build, well,
all the buildings we see right behind me, which at the time would have been a major city.
Mostly because they were absolutely 100% sure that this
was going to be the New York City of the West.
But they made one catastrophic mistake.
How embarrassing.
They completely underestimated the brutal,
glacier carved geography of this part of the Puget Sound.
Honestly, an alternative hook for this could have been
Port Townsend, quite possibly the cutest town in America.
I'm Alexa.
And I'm Jack.
Together, we're exploring the history and geography of the world, one place at a time.
So if you know anything about the coastal areas of the Pacific Northwest,
you'll know that it's supposed to generally be dark, stormy, gray, rainy,
not that dissimilar from today.
But actually, Port Townsend has a little bit of a geographic cheat code in this regard.
Just to the southwest sit the Olympic Mountains.
As massive Pacific storms roll in, those large and dramatic mountains
catch almost all the moisture.
Port Townsend sits perfectly in the rain shadow of those peaks.
This is something we call orographic lift.
As the rain clouds move in,
they lose their moisture as they are forced up the west slope of the Olympic Mountains,
leaving almost nothing for the eastern side of the mountains
and any town that happens to be there.
This pays off well for Port Townsend.
So while a city on the west coast of Washington, like Aberdeen,
gets nearly 85 inches of rain a year and Seattle gets 37 inches,
Port Townsend only gets around 19.
This puts Port Townsend in a little bit of a geographic lucky spot
that is more similar to Los Angeles than almost any other place along the Puget Sound.
Speaking of being in a lucky spot,
we just happened to walk up to an amazing skeleton of a gray whale.
But what would be really cool is to see a real one, like live.
Apparently, March through April, you can see the North Pacific gray whales migrating up north.
It still feels pretty cold to me, but I don't know.
I'm not a whale.
That is brand new information!
I know they're not super visible from the camera,
but the Olympic Mountains are peeking through the clouds right now.
The camera's just not going to do it justice, but it's so incredibly beautiful.
This is an awesome area to visit.
If you're ever in Washington state, make the visit out to Port Townsend.
So I will say, even though Port Townsend isn't very grandiose, it's not a major city today,
you definitely see it in some of the buildings.
There is a distinct sort of turn of the century, late 1800s, early 1900s style
where you can almost feel the money that they were going to ply into this tiny town.
Like you can almost see what it would have been
had it just kept growing.
It's very cool.
Very pretty.
Alexa, when you see a statue like this, what do you think?
They're usually like fancy or like, I don't know, money?
Money.
Europe.
Yeah.
Very European.
Yeah, absolutely.
Another sign of wealth.
That was here.
Twelve seconds later.
Totally called it.
This statue, it looks like it was built in 1893.
It was a clear sign that there was money here in Port Townsend.
All right, we haven't been in Port Townsend that long and I can already tell you,
I love it here.
I've already texted some friends saying,
we are going to do a summer trip here because I got to come back.
And you might be wondering, are they sponsored by
Port Townsend Travel Association or whatever?
And I'm going to tell you, no, we are not.
I just love it here this much.
If y'all are listening, we would love to come back.
As we're trying to get views of the bay, we stumbled upon a bell tower
and this was built in 1890
and it's actually the last remaining wooden bell tower in the United States.
And you might be wondering, what is a wooden fire bell tower?
So basically, it is what it sounds like.
It was a bell tower that was used when there was fires.
It's not used anymore, but it does look pretty cool.
Right on the other side of the bell tower is just an awesome view.
A little downtown waterfront area.
See a little bit of the harbor.
And of course, the sound itself.
Windier, though.
Before we jump back to Port Townsend,
I want to take a second to talk about how we kept all our gear organized on the road.
Thanks to today's sponsor, Bellroy.
You might know Bellroy as the Australian brand
that set out how to show people how to slim your wallet.
And while their wallets are top tier,
I'm currently using the sleek Apex Slim Sleeve every day.
Their broad focus is really to help you carry better in every aspect of your life.
For this trip, my everyday carry was the Venture Sling.
It's the perfect size for exploring Port Townsend,
so that all of my essentials were in one place.
And I kept all my extra camera batteries and chargers organized inside their tech kit.
But what's really awesome is that all of Bellroy's main body fabrics
and linings are made from 100% recycled materials.
And when we go abroad, we're heading to Ireland very soon,
I rely on their travel folio to keep my passport
and all my travel documents in a single place.
It's crafted from premium leather,
sourced only from gold rated leather working group tanneries.
Because Bellroy is a certified B Corp,
you know that they're actively limiting their environmental impact
and designing products meant to be used and loved for as long as possible.
So, if you want to upgrade your travel setup,
check out our unique link in the description below
or scan this QR code to receive 10% off anything on bellroy.com.
Now, let's get back out to exploring how Port Townsend
almost became a major city at the mouth of the Puget Sound.
Port Townsend's naturally deep harbor,
located along the Strait of Juan de Fuca and Admiralty Inlet,
was literally a captain's dream.
With relatively good weather and access to the Puget Sound region,
Port Townsend became vital in the shipping economy in the 1800s.
Since it was the very first port that ships had to hit
as they were coming into the Puget Sound,
they had to stop here to clear customs.
With so much maritime traffic,
the money and opportunity for growth seemed endless.
Investors from the East Coast saw this and went wild.
They built heavy, ornate masonry downtown
and towering extravagant Victorian mansions up on the bluff for the elite.
Now, for as good as the view was from our bell tower friend over here,
when we were down in downtown, I saw a massive building up here
and I think it's just up the road here because we like big buildings.
Turns out the super cool building is Port Townsend's
original U.S. Postal Office and Customs House,
and it was built in 1893.
With its Richardson Romanesque architectural style,
it was clearly signaling that Port Townsend was supposed to be
the next big city here on the West.
It's important to note that it wasn't just this building
that signaled that Port Townsend was going to be the next big city.
In fact, it was really all of downtown Port Townsend.
Investors from the East Coast saw Port Townsend's opportunity
as the next major port.
Right behind me, you can actually see a ferry with cars loading up.
But they knew that in order for Port Townsend to become
this great big strategic port,
they knew they needed to build a downtown with large masonry buildings
and you can see the evidence of that today.
Let's get back to downtown.
A few minutes later.
It's a deer!
What kind of deer is it?
It's a baby deer.
So we're like walking into downtown Port Townsend once again,
and just as we're walking down,
you sort of look over and you see all the buildings
and you see like the wide open sound.
It really looks and reminds me of Astoria,
which is kind of funny because Port Townsend shares a very similar story,
just about 50 years apart from each other.
That's kind of sweet. Twins!
Both should have been much bigger cities,
and of course, both failed.
So we decided to do a little intermission,
get some pizza.
Man, it comes with just the best view.
We've also got a little friend right over here.
He's hoping to become besties and it's not gonna happen.
Another example of definitely a building that was built
around the turn of the century,
and now it looks abandoned, unfortunately.
Which is a shame because it's really beautiful.
This car is a literal map of a city.
I would think maybe potentially Seattle.
Definitely one of the coolest cars I've ever seen.
To complete their empire, Port Townsend just needed one thing,
the transcontinental railroad.
If trains could reach these deep harbor docks,
they would control the entire Pacific trade.
The businessmen assumed that this would be easy.
This is where things get a little messy for Port Townsend.
You see, there were two distinct attempts to connect Port Townsend,
and both failed miserably.
One laid just one mile of track before going out of business.
The other made it as far as Mount Walker
before realizing that the geography of the region
just wasn't amenable to trains.
But there was one more speculative attempt
to connect Port Townsend by train.
Unfortunately, those speculators
forgot about one very important thing,
the Puget Lobe Glacier.
But to answer that, I actually want to drive down
to the Hood Canal.
So let's get in the van.
Now that we've explored a bit of its historic charm,
let's talk about exactly where Port Townsend
is located on the map.
Perched at the extreme northeastern tip
of the Olympic Peninsula,
this city acts as a gateway to the Puget Sound.
It's surrounded by water on three sides,
specifically at the crucial intersection
of the Strait of Juan de Fuca and Admiralty Inlet.
This strategic maritime geography
is exactly what made it such an ideal
deep water port in the 1800s.
And to top it off,
almost anywhere you stand in town
offers sweeping views of the Olympic Mountains
to the west.
All right, we're on the road
and we are heading to our next stop.
And I figured, Jeff, we have a little bit of time.
Should we do some geography trivia?
Absolutely.
We have been noticing some similarities
between Astoria and Port Townsend.
So I thought it would be fun if I give a fact
and you have to tell me,
is it Port Townsend or is it Astoria?
It's always gonna be Astoria, baby.
All right, is Port Townsend or Astoria
closer to the big city of their respective states?
That's a good question.
I know.
I'm gonna go with Port Townsend.
And you would be correct.
Port Townsend is only 58 miles away from Seattle,
but Astoria is like almost 100 from Portland.
Which city has a median age of 40?
I know they both trend older,
but I'm gonna go with Port Townsend again.
I've been seeing a lot of old people
since we've been wandering around.
Well, you are wrong.
It's actually Astoria.
Oh, really?
Port Townsend is 60.
Which city is known as the oldest American settlement
west of the Rocky Mountains?
I know that one's Astoria.
That is correct.
And for your last question,
which city receives the most visitors?
I'm actually gonna say Port Townsend on this one.
Port Townsend just has a little bit more
of the vacation flair.
And that is correct.
Wait, bonus question.
Which town is Alexa's favorite?
My heart says it's gonna be Astoria,
but my head says that you really love Port Townsend.
I love Port Townsend so much.
I am Port Townsend's like number one fan.
Onward to Hood Canal Bridge.
We have made it all the way down
to the Shine Tidewater State Park
to talk about this body of water right here,
which is basically the entrance to Hood Canal.
Now, 16,000 years ago,
a 3,000 foot tall sheet of ice
bulldozed this entire area.
And when it retreated,
it didn't just leave flat land.
It left these big, massive carved fjords and canals.
And so when the railroad engineers
finally surveyed the land,
they realized that building a train bridge
over an impossibly deep fjord
was basically impossible.
And so the tracks,
they went to Seattle instead.
Today, of course, there is a bridge here.
The Hood Canal Floating Bridge.
It's the third largest floating bridge in the world,
but it was only completed in 1961,
nearly 80 years after the initial train rush
to connect towns by rail.
During the late 1800s,
the technology to build a floating bridge
just wasn't available yet.
Even today, it's a remarkable piece of engineering.
I do know that it's not perfect
and it flooded and nearly collapsed entirely in 1979.
But now it's a highway.
There was never a train there.
Had there been a train there,
had they been able to put a railroad bridge there,
Port Townsend's fate might've been different.
I know, I bet you.
Oh, yeah, it would be a beat-up.
Pino's a big fan of Hood Canal Bridge.
Well, we gotta head back to Port Townsend.
And to do that,
we're gonna use our snap teleportation powers.
Alexa?
Ready.
And just like that, back in Port Townsend.
And now that we're back,
we should talk about how this all ended.
By the late 1800s,
the city of dreams was a well-known seaport.
But as the railroads were aggressively growing
across the country in the 1870s to 1890s,
Port Townsend was expected to be
the Northwest extension of the rail,
connecting to other key areas like Portland, Oregon.
But as news broke that the railroad wasn't coming,
it spread like wildfire.
The panic of 1893 marked the beginning
of economic instability in the Pacific Northwest.
In Port Townsend,
this meant that the city's hopes and dreams
of becoming the next big port were really crushed.
And the wealthy investors left the city
and its big, beautiful, elaborate buildings in the dust.
But there's one more thing we want to show you guys.
And that is one of those big, beautiful buildings.
The financial ruin in the wake of losing out
of the economic driver of a railroad
is exactly why Port Townsend looks the way it does today.
In large and prosperous cities like nearby Seattle,
old buildings are torn down to build new, bigger ones.
But here, the wealth left
and there wasn't money to tear anything down or remodel.
Now, the last piece of the puzzle is right behind me.
This is the Starlit House.
It's a hotel, so we're not going to go inside,
but it gives a good example
of the different Victorian-style homes
that you can find throughout Port Townsend.
Now, because the economy declined so quickly,
the town of Port Townsend was basically preserved
over the last 120 years.
Today, walking around Port Townsend
is like walking through a 19th century time capsule.
And the city has done a really good job
at preserving the charm of the city.
They do things like making sure that new businesses
follow the certain style, especially in the downtown core,
and preserve buildings like the one behind me.
And while Port Townsend never grew to be the big city
that it was meant to be,
this small but mighty community of about 10,000 people
have created quite the cute, picturesque town
here on the Washington Coast.
I will say, just as one added thing,
as a former city planner,
they've done a really good job
of preserving the Victorian homes,
but they've also done a really poor job
at adding more homes,
which is partly why all these houses are so expensive
and why Port Townsend is so old,
because young people tend to not be able to afford
to live here.
It's kind of a double-edged sword a little bit.
Totally.
All right, we're going to make one last voyage
into downtown Port Townsend.
Port Townsend is easily one of the most beautiful
and charming towns in Washington,
but it's more than that.
It shows that even the biggest dreams
can be crushed by unfortunate geography.
But Jeff, I have a question for you.
We talked a little bit about Astoria.
When we were last in Astoria, you asked me,
could you imagine this being a big city?
Could you imagine Port Townsend being a big city?
And how does it compare to Astoria?
It's a little harder to imagine for me.
Astoria had the Columbia River mouth,
which acted as a really large bay,
and bays tend to be a lot more sheltered.
Now, this one is within the Sound,
so I guess it has that.
It just doesn't seem to have as much land.
Next week, we are off to the Oregon Coast Mountain Range
to talk about one of the biggest wildfires in the state.
So come back next week.
For another adventure.
See you then.
How's that view?
Super pretty.
All right, but like...
Oh.
That's my beanie.
I don't want to say rocks.
Well, don't.
Sorry.
How's that?
Good.

