Why Canada's Perfect Island Isn't Its Own Province
3 Video Views·Sep 24, 2026
This is Victoria, the capital city of the Canadian province of British Columbia.
It's a major political hub, and it's home to nearly 400,000 people in this metro region alone.
And by all measures, this looks and feels like a capital city.
But there's a geographic quirk to this place.
It's not actually connected to the rest of British Columbia.
We're on an island called Vancouver Island, home to more than 860,000 people,
a thriving economy, and multiple cities.
So all of this begs the question,
why isn't Vancouver Island its own Canadian province?
Obviously, this building right behind me, that's the actual Parliament of British Columbia.
I don't know about you guys, but it is way more elaborate than
most federal buildings I know inside the United States.
It's like up there with the Capitol building in Washington, D.C.
It is just so ornate and elaborate.
And again, I think this just lends itself to the idea that this is a major political hub
with all of the pomp and circumstance that that building right there suggests.
Very beautiful.
So here's the weird thing.
Vancouver Island is huge.
It is nearly the size of Taiwan, which Jeff and I drove around last year.
And it's larger than nine U.S. states.
It also has a larger population than three Canadian provinces.
Prince Edward Island, New Finland and Labrador, and New Brunswick.
And honestly, its population is not that far away from
Manitoba, Nova Scotia, and Saskatchewan.
It has its own unique climate from the mainland.
It has its own mountain ranges and its own independent culture.
Also, one other thing to show you while we're here in downtown Victoria,
this is the Empress Hotel.
And for a long time, the actual Queen of England would still come here,
I think, annually to do high tea.
I think all that's to say it just shows that there's a little bit more political
gravitas to Victoria and Vancouver Island than perhaps most people would expect.
OK, so with that said, we are going to travel all across Vancouver Island today.
We are not just sticking around here in Victoria.
In fact, we're going to leave here, the political capital of Vancouver Island,
to go to another city in the north called Nanaimo.
And then we're going to head over to the west coast to see, well, what that looks like.
But before we leave, there's one other thing that I want to show you guys.
But to do that, we actually need to walk a little ways to get to the Strait of Juan de Fuca.
Let's go.
OK, we have made it to the Strait of Juan de Fuca,
which means we should probably talk specifics about where Vancouver Island is actually located.
So Vancouver Island stretches approximately 290 miles from south to north,
which means if you drop this island on the east coast of the United States,
it would stretch from New York City all the way down to about North Carolina.
And all told, the island covers a little more than 12,000 square miles.
That makes it the largest island on the west side of the Americas.
Yes, North and South America included.
So all this is to say Vancouver Island is a little unusual compared to the rest of Canada,
especially because the island itself dips below the 49th parallel.
And you'd be forgiven if you didn't know what that exact line was.
But let me tell you, that's the line that makes up the US-Canada border
from about the Great Lakes all the way to the Strait of Georgia in the west.
But here in Victoria, where I'm actually standing right now,
we're about 40 miles south of that line.
And if you look right behind me, that's Washington State.
That's the Olympic Peninsula.
This means that in terms of physical proximity,
the capital of British Columbia is closer to Washington State
than it is to mainland British Columbia.
It's an interesting geographic oddity,
and if history had gone a little bit differently,
this whole area might have been part of the United States.
All of this is to say that this physical separation from mainland British Columbia
has had a very profound impact on the way Vancouver Island specifically has developed.
Which brings us to the history of how this island lost its independence in the first place.
Because it wasn't always part of British Columbia.
But to tell that story, I think it's time we actually left Victoria behind
and traveled north to a city known as Nanaimo.
After a kind of long drive, we have finally made it to Nanaimo,
which is also known as the Hub City.
It's known as the Hub City because if you look at the original design of the streets,
it kind of looks like the spokes of a wheel.
But also, it's just a really central location.
Nanaimo is on the east coast of Vancouver Island along the Strait of Georgia.
It's one of the main gateways to get to other parts of Vancouver Island,
but also to a bunch of other islands that are nearby.
And as a central hub, it is the perfect place to talk about
the kind of crazy history of Vancouver Island.
But we need to get a little bit closer to talk about that.
Nanaimo is a little bit of a hidden gem here in Vancouver Island and British Columbia at large.
The harbor just sort of opens up and you just get this amazing view of both the Strait of Georgia,
but also all of the islands surrounding it.
It's just very pleasant and I think Victoria steals a lot of the thunder.
But if you come here, stop in Nanaimo.
It's worth it, geographically, of course.
What about gastronomically within Nanaimo bar?
As I was saying, the history of Vancouver Island is kind of crazy.
And that all starts with the fact that it was its own separate political entity.
In 1846, the Oregon Treaty was signed,
ending the dispute between the Oregon Territory, between Britain and the United States.
In the treaty, land that was north of the 49th parallel became Britain's.
But they made a slight revision for Vancouver Island.
So the border had to go a little bit south.
A few years later, in 1849, the colony of Vancouver Island was established.
For almost 20 years, the colony of Vancouver Island
remained its own separate entity from the mainland colony.
As coal mining in Nanaimo and fur trade in Victoria expanded and really boomed,
all of the wealth and the power of the region was settled in Vancouver Island.
But then in 1858, everything changed.
The gold rush already had hit the Pacific Northwest.
But then gold was discovered on the mainland in the Fraser River.
With the news, tens of thousands of men rushed to British Columbia,
completely bypassing the island.
Instantly, the mainland had all the wealth and the population.
But fast forward to the 1960s.
Both the mainland and Vancouver Island were drowning in debt.
The British government became tired of having to pay the debts
of two separate colonies that were basically right next to each other.
So they forced a merger in 1866.
The colony of Vancouver Island was absorbed into British Columbia.
And five years later, they joined the new country of Canada as a package deal.
When you think about it, Vancouver Island didn't fail because of its size.
It failed because it was in so much debt.
Also, you may have noticed this building inside the background of Alexa talking.
That is something called the Bastion.
And it's one of Nanaimo's oldest buildings here.
And crazy enough, it was built to protect the coal mines of this region,
which is partly what made Vancouver Island so wealthy in the first place.
I couldn't find anything necessarily,
but I'm pretty sure it was built to protect it from the Americans,
who just a few short years earlier, as Alexa stated,
kind of wanted all of this land for themselves.
Anyways, it was built because you could kind of see all of the land and the ocean around.
So it was easy to see things.
Really quick, we want to give a big shout out to the sponsor of today's video,
Level8 and their amazing Hegent series luggage.
When we were packing for this quick weekend road trip down to Bend,
we wanted a compact luggage that was versatile, durable, and easy to grab and go.
And the Hegent series has been the perfect travel companion.
One of the standout features is its premium zipperless frame design.
Instead of dealing with the standard zippers that can get snagged or easily broken into,
it uses dual TSA approved locks,
which means it's very secure and gives the bag a really sleek, minimalist aesthetic.
Something I personally prefer in my luggage.
But also, this thing is ridiculously smooth.
It features Level8's visually iconic, ultra quiet yellow spinner wheels.
They're built with a steel dual bearing structure,
making them way quieter and more durable than other bags we've tested.
Plus, the aluminum trolley bar handle is not only sturdy, but also features four stages.
So it's perfect for users of various heights.
It also has a soft touch rubber handle that makes it a more compatible grip.
So whether you're taking a weekend road trip or flying out for a business conference,
the Hegent series nails that balance of style and function.
Check the link in the description below to upgrade your travel setup today
and use code GEALEX to get an extra special 12% discount.
Alexa and I are on our way to one of my very favorite parts of Vancouver Island.
We're heading to the very far west coast,
and that means we need to cross through, well, a very rough landscape.
And we're going to be making a few stops along the way,
and it should be a whole lot of fun.
I see a bunch of mountains right in front of me, which means time to go up.
We have at long last made it to one of my very favorite places here in Vancouver Island,
a lovely little provincial park called Sprout Lake.
Really quick, I misread the sign for this lake, and therefore I mispronounced it.
It's not Sprout Lake, it's Sprote Lake.
So just keep that in mind.
And you guys are going to see that in just a second.
But first, we did have plans to stop somewhere else.
We were going to go to Cathedral Grove, full of big, beautiful trees.
It was a little crowded.
Not a lot of places to park.
Here we are.
Sprout Lake.
And a little bit of bushwhacking, and then we reach Sprout Lake itself.
Two things.
One, camera's not really going to do it any justice.
Surrounding us are a bunch of mountains.
Very beautiful.
But two, if you look at it on a map, Sprout Lake is huge.
Sort of snakes its way all throughout the mountain range here on Vancouver Island.
Almost from the far east side to the far west side of the island.
Maybe not quite as that big, but it's very long and very cool.
And so with that, we are actually getting pretty close to
ancient rock carving petroglyph type thing.
So we're going to wander over there,
and that will lead into directly what we want to talk about next.
There's cougars here.
Like Alexa is so worried about falling in.
Because it's pretty steep, and then I'm like boop, boop, boop.
Behind me are petroglyphs sketched into this rock wall,
and they're easily over a thousand years old.
Maybe up to three thousand years old.
For thousands of years, this land was populated by three distinct indigenous groups.
The Coast Salish people to the east and the south,
the Nuu-chah-nulth on the west coast,
and the Kwakwaka'wakw on the north.
Now that we've established this important context,
let's hike around Sprout Lake a little bit more and talk about how Canada became Canada.
If you look closely, you can definitely see some animals.
That one kind of looks like a deer or something like that.
But then there's definitely some more marine or aquatic animals.
I think one of these two is supposed to be like an orca or killer whale.
Very cool that we still have access to seeing it.
What a little gem.
And now you guys can understand why Sprout Lake is one of my favorite provincial parks,
because you'll just stumble upon stuff like this,
and there's signs that point it out.
It's not overcrowded.
It's not like a million people are coming to try and see it.
We've only passed a couple on our way over here.
Kind of gives that hidden gem feel.
If you're ever in Vancouver Island, come to Sprout Lake.
It's a good place.
While we're hiking here around Sprout Lake, let's fast forward to 1867.
That's when the Dominion of Canada was established,
uniting the province of Canada, Nova Scotia,
and New Brunswick into a federal state under the British crown.
Under this new entity, Canada became a self-governing polity under Britain.
But you might have noticed one key area missing from that list.
British Columbia.
It wasn't until 1871 that British Columbia joined Canada.
And it's important to note that they did that
without signing treaties with a vast majority of the First Nations.
What that means for today is that Vancouver Island remains unceded territory.
So basically, the land still belongs to the Indigenous peoples
and was never signed legally to the government.
As fun as it is here in Sprout Lake, that lake actually is really warm.
We could go swimming here all day and have just a really lovely time.
Unfortunately, the episode waits for no person.
So we gotta hop back in the van, keep heading west.
We're gonna go check out a trail.
We pulled off along the highway.
Not so assuming place.
And then this is the trailhead that Jeff has me walking through.
What is this?
It's crazy.
Armenia vibes?
Yes.
Ow, I hit my head.
I do try and take you all and Alexa places a little off the beaten path.
Frankly, everywhere else has a bunch of people in it.
Everyone has already seen.
We are just going to duck our way through.
This is the Giant Cedar Trail.
In theory, we should see some giant cedars.
Ah, there we go.
A little bit easier to walk, but we'll see what we see.
All right.
Well, while we're walking along this trail,
let's talk about why it's probably a good thing
that Vancouver Island shares its resources with the mainland.
We're gonna do that by looking at the logistics of it.
If you didn't notice on the way over here,
we were driving through some very rough, rugged, mountainous topography.
In fact, we're in the middle of that right now.
So right now, this trail that we're walking through right now
is currently off something called Highway 4.
And if you look on a map,
this is really the only highway that connects
the east coast of Vancouver Island with the west coast.
There is another road down in the very far south
that will connect Victoria to a town called Port Renfrew.
That's Highway 14.
It does technically make it over to the west coast,
but just over in that very far southwest corner.
So it doesn't really count in my opinion.
And of course, there's a reason for that lack of infrastructure.
And it's this right here,
the Vancouver Ranges that we're currently hiking through.
This is a jagged, rugged edge of the North American continent.
Something that would look very similar to the Alaskan archipelago up north,
which makes traversing Vancouver Island practically impossible,
except for the lone road, Highway 4.
For lack of a better term,
Vancouver Island is essentially one gigantic mountain range.
And this harsh topography really means one thing.
Everything on this island, food, fuel, even things like Amazon packages,
these all rely on the BC ferry system.
To get here, we had to take a ferry.
And when we leave to head back home to Portland,
we'll have to take another ferry.
So suffice it to say,
this entire island is entirely dependent on the mainland.
But there's more to say on that.
But for now, I think we're getting close to some giant cedars.
Let's see if we can find them.
This is just such an incredibly lush area.
In a lot of ways, it feels much more natural than
even a lot of the forest in our home state of Oregon.
Beautiful though.
I am like 90% sure this guy right here is one of our giant cedars.
Look at this.
Oh, he's a big boy.
He's also leaning heavily over into this river that's behind.
So I would assume within 10 years, this guy's going to topple over.
That's going to be my assumption.
Before we head back, you might be wondering,
if the island is so big, populated, and economically important,
then why don't they just build a bridge from Vancouver Island to the mainland?
Because it's a nightmare.
Multiple studies have been done by the British Columbia government,
and each time it says the same thing.
It's just not feasible.
The thing is, is that the geography just doesn't add up for a bridge.
To start with, the Strait of Georgia is 1300 feet deep in some areas.
Let's add in the fact that this is one of the most
earthquake-prone or active areas really in the world.
And finally, there are just a large amount of ships
that like to come through the Strait of Georgia.
So with all of those factors, a bridge is just impossible.
And what that means for Vancouver Island,
they're just going to remain an island without a bridge.
Now, as much as I love these small and humongous trees
and this really weird trail that Jeff has taken me on,
I think it's time to get back in the van and continue our journey west.
At long last, we have finally made it to the far western coast of Vancouver Island.
And if you haven't picked up on it yet,
this visually and climatically feels a lot different from Victoria and Nanaimo.
Mostly because there are two things at play here.
If you look at a topographic map of Vancouver Island,
the first thing you're going to notice is that over on that eastern edge,
it's a lot flatter.
There's a large coastal plain that stretches almost from Victoria
all the way up to Nanaimo, maybe even a little bit beyond that.
Meanwhile, the west coast is more of this shattered, rugged maze of mountains.
The stuff that we just drove through.
But even more pronounced is the weather between the two sides.
The weather can be a lot different over here.
The reason for the extreme difference in climate
is a phenomenon we know as rain shadow.
As weather systems roll off the Pacific Ocean,
they hit the Vancouver Island ranges.
The same ranges we just drove through.
These mountains then force the clouds to rise,
causing them to dump huge amounts of rain,
sometimes up to 120 inches per year here on the west coast of Vancouver Island.
By the time these weather systems hit Victoria and Nanaimo,
they're much drier.
And that geographic divide means that this side of the island
is dominated by wild temperate rainforests and tiny isolated communities.
And both of those have to battle the elements just to exist.
So I can confirm the water is a little cold,
but I didn't think it was that bad.
Alexa, however, I don't think she enjoyed it very much.
So here we are at long last answer the question,
why is Vancouver Island not its own province?
It has the population.
It has the size.
It has the economy.
So what gives?
What do you think, Alexa?
I mean, I think the history tells a lot of the story.
They became bankrupt and were forced to merge with the mainland.
And at the end of the day,
most of this land was never formally ceded.
And most people who do live on Vancouver Island
don't live in most of Vancouver Island.
Kind of tucked away in a very small part of it.
Speaking of which, those parts of the island that people don't really live or go.
What are we doing next week?
We're exploring them.
We have obviously made it all the way here to the west coast of Vancouver Island.
And so next week, what we're going to do is we're going to explore this entire region
because you've only seen a very smidge of it
to kind of answer the question,
well, why don't more people live here?
West coast of California, of Washington, of Oregon and the states,
they all have tiny towns dotting all along their coast.
There's not really that same thing here on Vancouver Island.
So come back next week for another geographic adventure.
See you then.
Multiple studies have been done by the British.
The Dominion of Canada.
Keep walking, man.
Oh my God.
I don't know.
Spider webs.
They got webbed.

