The Decline of Fazoli's...What Happened?

Business, Lending & Investing
2 followers
The largest chain of Italian fast-casual restaurants has been struggling. This video explores the history of Fazoli's while identifying five of the main reasons behind its decline.
#BusinessGrowth #Entrepreneurship #LendingStrategy #InvestingSecrets #BusinessMindset #WealthCreation #BusinessCaseStudy #Fazoli #FastCasual #PrivateEquity #CorporateBankruptcy #FatBrands #BusinessFailure
AI Generated·May contain errors
Fazoli's is a struggling chain of fast-casual slash quick-service Italian restaurants, mostly
known for serving unlimited breadsticks and a variety of pasta dishes at reasonable prices.
Effectively, I'm just gonna say it, it is a cheaper version of the Olive Garden. I'm talking
about spaghetti and meatballs, fettuccine alfredo, baked ziti, all the classics, in addition to pizzas,
sub-sandwiches, salads, all the Americanized versions of what we associate with Italian
cuisine. Maybe not a perfect comparison, but I think it is fair to say that what Chipotle is
for Mexican food and Panda Express is for Chinese food, Fazoli's is for Italian food. In fact, in
the early 2000s, those three chains were much more comparable in size. The whole fast-casual
category was gaining traction, and these were considered to be some of the fastest-growing,
most promising concepts within it. For a while there, McDonald's was trying to capitalize on it.
Early on, they became the majority owner of Chipotle and made a deal with Fazoli's to open up
to 30 new restaurants as a joint venture, with the option of eventually acquiring the entire concept.
But shortly after, McDonald's switched their strategy to focus more heavily on their own
McDonald's restaurant, so the relationship sort of fizzled out. From that point, Chipotle and
Panda Express went on to become sensations, opening up thousands of locations throughout
the country, while Fazoli's started closing locations. Currently down to 138, meaning only
about a third of them remain, compared to their peak in 2002 at just over 400. Not exactly living
up to the hype, 2026 has been particularly difficult, already closing dozens of locations,
either exiting or severely reducing their presence in select markets around the country.
Looking at this graph, we can see that Virginia, Oklahoma, North Carolina, Mississippi, and
California are all down to a single location. I hope that you are as interested in the story as I
am, because in this video, I want to talk about the history of Fazoli's, while highlighting what
I believe to be five of the main reasons behind its decline. In case you were wondering, Fazoli's
has no real meaning, it is not the name of the founder or anything like that, just a made-up
word that is meant to sound Italian. You might be surprised to learn that the concept was started
by Jericho, the company behind Long John Silver's. In 1989, following a massive leveraged buyout and
years of rising fish prices, they started experimenting with separate restaurant concepts
to try to stabilize the business and reduce the reliance on fish. Fazoli's was one of these
attempts. They opened five of them in Lexington, Kentucky, before selling it mostly to a diverse
Japanese company called Duskin, known for selling cleaning products and franchising Mr. Donut in
the country. And that is going to bring me to the first reason behind their decline, rapid expansion.
Not a surprising reason to be on a list like this, but you're going to want to hear this.
See, the 1990s were an unusual time when it comes to pasta, because many people viewed it as a health
food. It was allowed under most of the popular diets, maybe you remember the USDA created the
food pyramid that placed bread and grains at the bottom of it, recommending 6 to 11 servings of
them per day, whatever that means, but as a result, pasta became so much more popular. The Olive Garden,
of course, was the biggest casual dining chain to capitalize on it, just about tripling in size
throughout the decade, while multiple concepts were emerging to offer quicker and cheaper versions of
it. Notably, Pizza Hut experimented with a fast food pasta restaurant called Fastino's, and Little
Caesars did something similar with Little Caesars Italian Kitchen. Not to mention, this is when
Sbarro was hitting its peak, opening hundreds of them in shopping malls across the country, so you
could see the level of competition and the urgency Fazoli's must have felt to beat everyone else into
new markets. As a result, they started an aggressive franchising program and would focus on cheaper
real estate in smaller towns as ways to expand their footprint as quickly as possible. It is
hard to find information for every year, but by the end of that decade, those five restaurants had
turned into 330. The chain that was isolated to Lexington, Kentucky, could now be found throughout
half the country. I will admit some speculation here, but I'm going to guess that many of those
Fazoli's were fragile, relatively new, probably not in the best locations, and likely to struggle
if some unexpected obstacles were to come along, like the next reason on my list, economic factors.
To keep it simple, all I'm going to say here is that the 1990s economy was much stronger than the
2000s economy. The dot-com bubble bursting in 9-11 were factors that led to lower consumer spending,
so Fazoli's had a harder time attracting customers. Also, skipping ahead for a second to recent times,
inflation combined with high labor and ingredient costs, specifically when it comes to tomatoes,
have complicated things. According to the National Restaurant Association, restaurant operating
expenses have jumped 36% over the past six years. But going back in time and back to the list,
the most significant obstacle they were facing was changing diets. Suddenly, pasta and breads
were no longer considered healthy, to a point where most of the new diet crazes, like Atkins
and the South Beach diet, were pushing people away from them. In 2005, that food pyramid was
redesigned into something called MyPyramid that made fruits and vegetables more important, and by
the way, a few years later, that was replaced by MyPlate, but I don't think people found any of
that useful. So now, Fazoli's was in all-out defensive mode. They advertised new menu items
that focused on vegetables and proteins, they eliminated trans fats from their famous bread
sticks and later from the rest of their menu, but none of it was very effective. There were
surface-level efforts trying to save a sinking ship. Simply put, a chain of restaurants centered
around pasta was not nearly as attractive as it was before, and that was bad news for Fazoli's.
Going right back to the list, low quality became a major issue. It looks like they became overly
concerned with offering a low price, to a point where they were significantly cutting costs and
lowering the food's quality and the overall guest experience to make it happen. As you might expect,
Fazoli's developed a bad reputation. No matter what the price is, it is difficult for a restaurant
to succeed without offering any tasty food. That is practically common sense, right? So in 2008,
they hired a new CEO, Carl Howard, who later said the focus on the brand was all wrong,
it was on speed and price. The guests were migrating from the business because the food
was terrible. That is a bad sign when the new head of the company calls the food terrible. He went on
to say that the Alfredo sauce was 90% water and the marinara sauce was produced in the cheapest
manner. He also said, the goal when I started was trying to keep the company out of insolvency,
so things were really teetering and I truly believe that his $3 million per year in food
quality improvements is what saved Fazoli's from disappearing entirely. In addition to investing
in other aspects to improve the overall experience, many of the buildings were remodeled,
he made it so that the employees would bring the food to the tables and even add parmesan
cheese to it if you requested, and they switched over to real plates and silverware. All of these
changes forced the average check to raise from $4 to $7, but it was still perceived as a better
value, their reputation was greatly improved, and at least some of the customers started returning.
Carl Howard remained in charge throughout the entirety of the 2010s, which I would describe
as their least eventful decade. The rise was in the 1990s, the fall was in the 2000s,
and the 2010s were mostly steady. They had been reduced to about half of their former size,
but were able to maintain that level until the last few years. Just recently, everything has
to look at here, but I do want to point out that in 2022, after 14 years,
Carl Howard retired from his CEO position, potentially having something to do with it.
My final reason behind the decline of Fazoli's is going to be neglectful owners. In 2006,
after it was already declining, Fazoli's was sold to Sun Capital Partners, a private equity firm
which might already be a potential red flag, but this particular firm was involved with a lot of
restaurants. The following year, they would acquire Boston Market and Friendly's. In 2015,
once they had declined even further, they were sold to Sentinel Capital Partners, another private
equity firm who had acquired Checkers and TGI Fridays the previous year. In 2021, they were
acquired by Fat Brands, who earlier that year had made bigger deals to acquire Twin Peaks and Global
Franchise Group, the owner of Hot Dog on a Stick and Round Table Pizza, among other brands.
So, do you see the pattern here? Going back to the very beginning over 35 years ago when it was
started by Long John Silver's, Fazoli's has never been owned by a company where it was the primary
focus. Throughout five separate owners, it has always been seen as an afterthought that was
competing for resources with other restaurants that were bigger and more important. Contrast
all of that with Chipotle, who has been its own company for the past 20 years, and Panda Express,
who is still owned by the original family who started it. It is my belief that if Fazoli's had
been given more care or attention at any point, it would have likely built a stronger presence.
Going back to their most recent owner for a minute, Fat Brands, they were on such an aggressive
acquisition spree that they accumulated $1.3 billion in debt that lenders demanded to be paid
immediately. When Fat Brands couldn't do it, they were forced into bankruptcy in early 2026 and the
whole thing has been a mess. The head of the company has been the target of numerous accusations
that I do not want to focus too much on in fear of derailing the video, but over the past few months,
all of these various brands that they have accumulated are being split up into different
pieces. As of right now, it looks like Fazoli's, along with 10 of the other chains, are going to
be owned by a group of lenders, maintaining its streak of owners that are probably going to
allocate more of their resources toward other restaurants that they own and look at Fazoli's
as a smaller part of their overall business plan. Let me know in the comments, what do you
think about Fazoli's? Like, what is your favorite food there? Have you ever tried the pasta or the
breadsticks and do you feel like it is a good value? I mean, I would say it is a strong concept
and even unique at this point, with very little direct competition remaining. Even at this reduced
size, it is still the biggest chain of fast casual Italian restaurants in the country.
So I guess that the big question here is, what do you see for the future, given the right people
and the right circumstances, does Fazoli's have a realistic chance at recovering and what
specifically would they need to do to make that happen? Finally, do you agree with my list of
reasons behind their decline or do you think something should be added or subtracted from it?
It is a complex issue without much public information and a lot of parts to it so,
based on your experience, tell me if you think I overlooked something. And any other thoughts you
have about Fazoli's or anything else in this video, leave them in the comments. I'd like to
hear what you have to say. Only at Fazoli's! Thank you for watching.
