Panera Bread - The Rise and Fall?

Business, Lending & Investing
2 followers
The once pioneering fast casual concept has been struggling lately. This video identifies some of the biggest reasons behind the trouble.
#GJWbusiness #BusinessAnalysis #MergersAndAcquisitions #Investing #FastCasual #PaneraBread #CorporateStrategy #PrivateEquity #Shrinkflation
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedPanera Bread is struggling with a significant decline in public perception and sales compared to fast-casual competitors. Once a beloved bakery-cafe, the brand is now facing a \"death by a thousand cuts\" caused by profit-driven decisions following its acquisition by JAB Holding Company, leading to diminished quality and a lost identity.
We'll
Panera Bread has been having a difficult time, to say the least.
be
It is almost hard to believe
just how much the public's perception of it has changed.
right
About a decade ago, it was mostly
considered a beloved chain of bakeries slash cafes
that served various breads, bagels, soups,
sandwiches, salads, things like that.
It had a loyal customer base that had very few bad things
back.
to say about it, and now it seems like people only have bad things
to say about it. In 2022,
I made a video about the success of Panera Bread.
There were already issues brewing,
But it was more of a comprehensive overview
of how the company grew to over 2,000 locations.
Well, I have noticed that the comments under that video have
been becoming more and more negative over time,
to a point where they are now almost entirely negative.
I think it is safe to say that people are upset with this restaurant.
Panera Bread was one of the few companies
that pioneered the now popular fast-casual category,
you know, the middle ground between fast food
and casual dining in the 1980s and 1990s,
and really helped popularize it in the 2000s alongside Joe.
Chipotle and Panda Express.
I always think of them as the big three fast casual restaurants,
and if we compare their sales over the past decade,
it is not looking good for Panera Bread.
They have remained comparatively flat,
while the other two have grown significantly.
Over that time, it has gone from the biggest
of the three to the smallest.
Zeroing in on the past three years,
the other two have grown while Panera Bread has shrunk,
falling back below that $6 billion mark.
Now they're in the middle of an aggressive comeback plan,
cleverly named
Panera Rise, with the goal of reaching
an all-time high $7 billion in sales by 2028.
Which, looking over everything, feels ambitious,
and even if they somehow pull it off, it would
likely still leave them behind the other two,
so we can see how not only the public's perception
has changed, but how they have been losing
their position within their industry.
Obviously, this is a complex issue with multiple components,
but the simplified explanation
behind these struggles, I think, goes back to 2017,
when Panera Bread was acquired by
investment firm called JAB Holding Company.
It was a $7.5 billion deal reported as one of the
highest prices ever paid for a restaurant company at the time.
In the years leading up to that deal,
they had also acquired similar coffee
or bakery chains including Pete's Coffee, Caribou Coffee,
and Krispy Kreme. Under their control,
the big criticism, as you might expect, is that they had
been way too concerned about profits,
making noticeable sacrifices to the food or the
the customer's experience in order to save money.
A lot of it has been small or subtle,
but when you put it all together, it has resulted
in a restaurant that has lost a lot of the aspects that made it
so unique and appealing
in the first place.
Their current CEO is referred to it as Death by a Thousand Paper Cuts,
so that is the overall
idea.
Keep all of it in mind as I go into a little more detail
with what I believe to be five
of the main reasons behind their recent struggles.
Starting out the list with the departure of Ron Shaich,
easily the most impactful
behind the scenes throughout the history of the company.
He co-founded it back in the 1980s and
led it for the next 36 years.
Anything you liked or disliked about Panera Bread during that time
could likely be traced back to him in one way or another.
Well, just a few months after JAB took
over, it was announced that he would be stepping down
from his longtime CEO position but remain
involved as chairman of the board.
But he is no longer chairman of the board and his involvement
His involvement with Panera Bread seems
to be diminishing as he turns his attention
toward other efforts, like the restaurant chain Cava,
where he is the chairman of the board.
Over the past decade, Panera Bread has had
numerous executive changes, including five
different CEOs that have attempted various turnaround plans
that have generally backfired.
The one that stands out to me was in 2024,
when they had their biggest menu transformation in
brand history, where they took a bunch of items off the menu,
including flatbread pizzas, and
added nine new menu items like bacon, mac,
and cheese, while enhancing the recipe for 12 classics
It was a bold effort,
but in the end most of the new menu items failed to gain traction
while people missed a lot of the old items.
Sales continued to fall, and I'm just going
to say it was not the big turnaround that
they were hoping for.
My point here is that Ron Shaich is the guy
who gave Panera Bread its identity, and
without him there, they have been slowly losing that identity.
Next up on my list is going to be...
Frozen bread, alright that is a wild way to put it,
but 10 years ago, all the bread and bagels and other bakery items
at Panera were exclusively baked in the restaurants.
They had a system of 24 fresh dough facilities that would make
the dough and then ship it to the restaurants each morning,
and they have already shut down f***ing everything.
15 of those facilities
and are in the process of shutting down the remaining 9.
Today, as I understand it,
the dough is made at third-party bakeries who partially bake it
and then freeze it before shipping it
to the restaurants. On the positive end,
it makes the end product more consistent,
they are less likely to run out of it before the end
of the day, and it allows them to expand into new areas
that those fresh dough facilities may have
had a hard time reaching.
On the negative end, it might not be as pleasant or fresh tasting,
They kind of lose that fresh bread smell throughout the restaurant.
And maybe more than anything else, it just sounds bad, right?
I mean, for a restaurant with bread in its name,
technically twice since Panera means bread basket,
it makes it sound like they are cutting corners
on their primary menu item.
The head of the company has called it one
of the worst communications they ever had.
My next reason behind their struggles
is related to the previous reason.
poor value. There are so many different ways to look at this,
but there have been countless
complaints regarding the price, quality,
and portion of the food they serve, which is a lot
of stuff to complain about.
The CEO has recently admitted, in some instances, we shrunk portions
so guests would walk into our cafe to buy
a sandwich that has gone up significantly in price
with lower quality ingredients in a smaller size.
There are, well, too many examples of this,
But maybe the most popular one is that in 2024,
They started replacing half of the romaine lettuce in their salads
with iceberg lettuce as yet another cost-saving measure.
As you could imagine, there was so much backlash against it
that the following year, they switched it back to 100% romaine.
Briefly, they also stopped slicing the avocados
and those cherry tomatoes in the salads to save on labor costs,
so clearly not devastating changes,
but little things like this can make a difference.
These are tiny opportunities where they could be making
the customer a little bit happier instead of saving a little bit of money
Lately, they have been trying to address
the concern with the Panera Rise comeback
plan where the I stands for Igniting Value.
They now offer some cheaper options and more promotions,
so for any long time Panera Bread
customers, I'm curious about your experience.
Has it become a worse value over time,
and have any of these comeback plans done a good
job at improving it?
Moving along, to my next reason behind
their struggles, health concerns.
This isn't exactly what you might expect,
because obviously there have always been menu
They're filled with fat or sugar or whatever else,
so it really depends on what you order.
But it has generally been promoted as a fresh
and healthy option, and as a result has a
fairly health-conscious customer base.
Famously, in 2015, they came out with what they called
a no-no list, a list of ingredients
that they refused to put in their food.
Well, in 2024, they took some key ingredients off of that list,
including phosphates, sorbic
acid, and maltodextrin,
all of it to save an estimated $21 million per year, and then
Around that time, the restaurants were instructed to remove signs
and artwork that included
such phrases as, no antibiotics ever, vegetarian fed,
animal welfare, or anything involving
hormones.
The headline here is that their standards
for this kind of thing are becoming less strict,
and that has been an issue for certain people.
Also, along the lines of health concerns,
I have to mention their charged lemonade energy
drinks, a terrible decision that directly led to four lawsuits,
two of which alleged
Wrongful deaths.
The most widely reported one that you may remember
was a 21 year old college student
with a heart condition named Sarah Katz.
She went into cardiac arrest
and died hours after drinking a charged lemonade from Panera
Bread.
It really is a tragic story.
Her parents said that she was unaware
of the high levels of caffeine in that drink, which
apparently was 390 milligrams for a large,
just under what the FDA says is safe to consume
in a day.
There could be a debate over whether
the caffeine content should have been more clearly labeled
I'm not sure if they should have been selling it at all,
but either way, it was more negative publicity.
I mean, this health-focused restaurant was selling
a drink that was allegedly killing people.
So now, not even factoring in the infamous charged lemonade,
the food at Panera Bread is considered by many
to be not only a worse value, but potentially less healthy.
Extra concerning, because I would argue that the restaurant
is more reliant on people liking the food than ever before,
leading me into my final reason.
The atmosphere.
Ronald Shaikh used to believe that the atmosphere
was essentially the most important part of the experience.
In 2009, he went so far as to say,
in many ways, we're renting space to people
and the food is the price of admission.
A different way to look at things,
most of them had fireplaces, friendly and helpful employees,
they were among the first to offer free Wi-Fi,
which was a big deal back in 2004,
all of it was designed to create a cozy and pleasant environment
that encouraged people to stick around and hang out.
Today, that no longer
feels like a top priority,
they have built many smaller locations that are less
likely to have that fireplace,
most of the ordering has been shifted toward kiosks when
you walk in, or the app which limits
your interaction with the employees, or delivery
or drive-thru which eliminates your need to even enter the restaurant.
It is all a little more typical,
and seemingly designed to get customers in and out of there
as quickly and efficiently as possible,
once again taking something that made them cool
and different, and reducing it in favor of profits.
Let me know in the comments, what are your thoughts about Panera Bread?
Is everything truly as bad as people
on the internet have made it out to be, or are there
still redeeming qualities that make it a great place to go for lunch?
Because this does seem to be more of a death
by a thousand cuts type situation, I would
be particularly interested in hearing
from the more loyal customers that have experienced
all these little changes over the past decade.
In your experience, have the quality
and the portions gone down while the prices have gone
up?
Does the bread taste different?
Does it feel less cozy and more rushed?
Really, what would you say
are the biggest differences compared to 10 years ago?
And finally, I guess the big question here is,
do you think they will be able to reverse
this trend and make a recovery, or will things continue to struggle?
And any other thoughts you have about Panera Bread,
leave them in the comments.
I'd like to hear what you have to say.
Thank you for watching.
